Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Breakdown of Bohr's Correspondence Principle

Bo Gao

Published Nov 22, 1999• 51 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Bohr's correspondence principle, i.e., the expectation that the semiclassical approximation works better for states with greater quantum numbers, is shown to break down in all quantum systems in which the asymptotic interaction between the fragments behaves as ${\ensuremath{-}C}_{n}/{r}^{n}$ with $n>2$.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.83.4225

Related papers

Three Puzzles about Bohr's Correspondence Principle

Alisa Bokulich

Niels Bohr’s “correspondence principle” is typically believed to be the requirement that in the limit of large quantum numbers (n→∞) there is a statistical agreement between the quantum and classical frequencies. A closer reading of Bohr’s writings on the correspondence principle, however, reveals that this interpretation is mistaken. Specifically, Bohr makes the following three puzzling claims: First, he claims that the correspondence principle applies to small quantum numbers as well as large (while the statistical agreement of frequencies is only for large n); second, he claims that the correspondence principle is a law of quantum theory; and third, Bohr argues that formal apparatus of matrix mechanics (the new quantum theory) can be thought of as a precise formulation of the correspondence principle. With further textual evidence, I offer an alternative interpretation of the correspondence principle in terms of what I call Bohr’s selection rule. I conclude by showing how this new interpretation of the correspondence principle readily makes sense of Bohr’s three puzzling claims.

•Aug 1, 2009•5 citations

Breakdown of quantum-classical Correspondence Principle when light interacts with fluctuating disorder

Hanan Herzig Sheinfux, Tal Kachman, Yaakov Lumer +2 more

We demonstrate a novel regime of light-disorder interactions, at which the quantum-classical Correspondence Principle breaks and quantum-behavior appears even at large quantum numbers. Our findings are supported numerically and an experiment-ready scheme is suggested.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Lecture 15: Semiclassical Limit; Coherent States; Metaplectic Group

Gianfausto Dell’Antonio

According to Bohr’s correspondence principle when the energy levels are very closely spaced the description of the emission and absorption processes in Quantum Mechanics should approach the one given in Classical Mechanics.

Atlantis studies in mathematical physics•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations

Bohr correspondence principle for large quantum numbers

Richard L. Liboff

Foundations of Physics•Jun 1, 1975•27 citations

Comment on “Breakdown of Bohr's Correspondence Principle”

Christopher Eltschka, Hanno Friedrich, M. J. Moritz

A Comment on the Letter by Bo Gao, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 4225 (1999).Received 29 November 1999DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.86.2693©2001 American Physical Society

Physical Review Letters•Mar 19, 2001•25 citations

Comment on “Breakdown of Bohr's Correspondence Principle”

Christophe Boisseau, E. Audouard, J. Vigué

A Comment on the Letter by Bo Gao, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 4225 (1999).Received 28 February 2000DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.86.2694©2001 American Physical Society

Physical Review Letters•Mar 19, 2001•19 citations
Bohr's correspondence principle, i.e., the expectation that the semiclassical approximation works better for states with greater quantum numbers, is shown to break down in all quantum systems in which the asymptotic interaction between the fragments behaves as \ensuremath−Cn/rn{\ensuremath{-}C}_{n}/{r}^{n}\ensuremath−Cn​/rn with n>2n>2n>2.
Niels Bohr’s “correspondence principle” is typically believed to be the requirement that in the limit of large quantum numbers (n→∞) there is a statistical agreement between the quantum and classical frequencies. A closer reading of Bohr’s writings on the correspondence principle, however, reveals that this interpretation is mistaken. Specifically, Bohr makes the following three puzzling claims: First, he claims that the correspondence principle applies to small quantum numbers as well as large (while the statistical agreement of frequencies is only for large n); second, he claims that the correspondence principle is a law of quantum theory; and third, Bohr argues that formal apparatus of matrix mechanics (the new quantum theory) can be thought of as a precise formulation of the correspondence principle. With further textual evidence, I offer an alternative interpretation of the correspondence principle in terms of what I call Bohr’s selection rule. I conclude by showing how this new interpretation of the correspondence principle readily makes sense of Bohr’s three puzzling claims.