Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity

Probing the Stability of HEB Mixers With Microwave Injection

Andrey Trifonov, Edward Tong, R. Blundell, Рябчун Сергей Александрович, Gregory N Gol'tsman

Published Nov 25, 2014• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Using a microwave probe as a tool, we have performed experiments aimed at understanding the origin of the output-power fluctuations in hot-electron-bolometer (HEB) mixers. We use a probe frequency of 1.5 GHz. The microwave probe picks up impedance changes of the HEB, which are examined upon demodulation of the reflected wave outside the cryostat. This study shows that the HEB mixer operates in two different regimes under a terahertz pump. At a low pumping level, strong pulse modulation is observed, as the device switches between the superconducting state and the normal state at a rate of a few megahertz. When pumped much harder, to approximate the low-noise mixer operating point, residual modulation can still be observed, showing that the HEB mixer is intrinsically unstable even in the resistive state. Based on these observations, we introduced a low-frequency termination to the HEB mixer. By terminating the device in a 50-Ω resistor in the megahertz frequency range, we have been able to improve the output-power Allan time of our HEB receiver by a factor of four to about 10 s for a detection bandwidth of 15 MHz, with a corresponding gain fluctuation of about 0.035%.

DOI
10.1109/tasc.2014.2374417

Related papers

Microwave Stabilization of a HEB Mixer in a Pulse-Tube Cryocooler

Alexander S. Shurakov, Edward Tong, R. Blundell +3 more

We report the results of our study of the stability of an 800 GHz hot electron bolometer (HEB) mixer cooled with a pulse-tube cryocooler. Pulse-tube cryocoolers introduce temperature fluctuations as well as mechanical vibrations at a frequency of$\sim$1 Hz, both of which can cause receiver gain fluctuations at that frequency. In our system, the motor of the cryocooler was separated from the cryostat to minimize mechanical vibrations, leaving thermal effects as the dominant source of the receiver gain fluctuations. We measured root mean square temperature variations of the 4 K stage of$\sim$7 mK. The HEB mixer was pumped by a solid state local oscillator at 810 GHz. The root mean square current fluctuations at the low noise operating point (1.50 mV, 56.5$\mu\hbox{A}$) were$\sim 0.12\ \mu\hbox{A}$, and were predominantly due to thermal fluctuations. To stabilize the bias current, microwave radiation was injected to the HEB mixer. The injected power level was set by a proportional-integral-derivative controller, which completely compensates for the bias current oscillations induced by the pulse-tube cryocooler. Significant improvement in the Allan variance of the receiver output power was obtained, and an Allan time of 5 s was measured.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Jan 21, 2013•4 citations

Stabilization Scheme for Hot-Electron Bolometer Receivers Using Microwave Radiation

Рябчун Сергей Александрович, Edward Tong, R. Blundell +1 more

We present the results of a stabilization scheme for terahertz receivers based on NbN hot-electron bolometer (HEB) mixers that uses microwave radiation with a frequency much lower than the gap frequency of NbN to compensate for mixer current fluctuations. A feedback control loop, which actively controls the power level of the injected microwave radiation, has successfully been implemented to stabilize the operating point of the HEB mixer. This allows us to increase the receiver Allan time to 10 s and also improve the temperature resolution of the receiver by about 30% in the total power mode of operation.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Dec 18, 2008•12 citations

Effect of microwave radiation on the stability of terahertz hot-electron bolometer mixers

Рябчун Сергей Александрович, Edward Tong, R. Blundell +2 more

We report our studies of the effect of microwave radiation, with a frequency much lower than that corresponding to the energy gap of the superconductor, on the performance of the NbN hot-electron bolometer (HEB) mixer incorporated into a THz heterodyne receiver. It is shown that exposing the HEB mixer to microwave radiation does not result in a significant rise of the receiver noise temperature and degradation of the mixer conversion gain so long as the level of microwave power is small compared to the local oscillator drive. Hence the injection of a small, but controlled amount of microwave radiation enables active compensation of local oscillator power and coupling fluctuations which can significantly degrade the stability of HEB mixer receivers.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Oct 18, 2006•2 citations

Microwave probing of relaxation oscillations related to terahertz power detection in superconducting hot electron bolometers

Runfeng Su, Y D Zhang, Xuecou Tu +8 more

Abstract Relaxation oscillations related to terahertz (THz) power detection in superconducting niobium nitride hot electron bolometers (HEBs) have been studied using microwaves as a probe. The reflected microwave signal, which is related to the impedance changes of the HEB irradiated by an incident THz signal, can be used to characterize relaxation oscillations. The frequency of relaxation oscillation switching between the superconducting and resistive states increases linearly with incident THz power but nonlinearly with bias voltage or bath temperature. The observed strong periodic pulse trains of relaxation oscillations have a maximum duty cycle of ∼50%. These strong switching pulses indicate that DC Joule heating, THz radiation or thermal energy is absorbed in the bi-stable region of the HEB intermittently. In addition to relaxation oscillations, we also see weaker oscillations when the device is in the resistive state, which we call intrinsic oscillations. These have a constant frequency at the order of 10 kHz which is independent of external stimuli. The weak periodic pulse trains at a constant frequency can be divided into mainly two types—one is the pulse train with a small duty cycle and the other is the quasi-square wave. Measurement of these oscillations in HEBs has some practical applications. Digital THz power measurement with frequencies below and above the gap frequency can be made based on the linearity between relaxation oscillation frequency and incident THz power. The relaxation oscillation frequency can be used to estimate the maximum speed of a THz direct detection system especially for a multi-pixel HEB array. In particular, extra noise induced by relaxation oscillations and intrinsic oscillations can be determined for the HEB operating as a THz direct detector.

Superconductor Science and Technology•Jul 9, 2019•6 citations

Study of the Effect of Microwave Radiation on the Operation of HEB Mixers in the Terahertz Frequency Range

Рябчун Сергей Александрович, Edward Tong, R. Blundell +2 more

We have investigated the effect of injecting microwave radiation, with a frequency much lower than that corresponding to the energy gap of the superconductor, on the performance of the hot-electron bolometer mixer incorporated into a THz heterodyne receiver. More specifically, we show that exposing the mixer to microwave radiation does not cause a significant rise of the receiver noise temperature and fall of the mixer conversion gain so long as the microwave power is a small fraction of local oscillator power. The injection of a small, but controlled amount of microwave power therefore enables active compensation of local oscillator power and coupling fluctuations which can significantly degrade the gain stability of hot electron bolometer mixer receivers.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Jun 1, 2007•3 citations

Aluminum hot-electron bolometer mixers at submillimeter wavelengths

Anders J. Skalare, William R. McGrath, P. M. Echternach +4 more

Diffusion-cooled aluminum hot-electron bolometer (HEB) mixers are of interest for low-noise high resolution THz-frequency spectroscopy within astrophysics. Al HEB mixers offer operation with an order of magnitude less local oscillator power, higher intermediate frequency bandwidth and potentially lower noise than competing devices made from other materials. We report on mixer experiments at 618 GHz with devices fabricated from films with sheet resistances in the range from about 55 /spl Omega/ down to about 9 /spl Omega/ per square. Intermediate frequency bandwidths of up to 3 GHz were measured (1 /spl mu/m long device), with absorbed local oscillator power levels of 0.5 to 6 nW and mixer conversion up to -21.5 dB. High input coupling efficiency implies that the electrons in the device are able to thermalize before escaping from the device. It was found that the long coherence length complicates mixer operations due to the proximity of the contact pads. Also, saturation at the IF frequency may be a concern for this type of device, and warrants further studies.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Mar 1, 2001•17 citations
Using a microwave probe as a tool, we have performed experiments aimed at understanding the origin of the output-power fluctuations in hot-electron-bolometer (HEB) mixers. We use a probe frequency of 1.5 GHz. The microwave probe picks up impedance changes of the HEB, which are examined upon demodulation of the reflected wave outside the cryostat. This study shows that the HEB mixer operates in two different regimes under a terahertz pump. At a low pumping level, strong pulse modulation is observed, as the device switches between the superconducting state and the normal state at a rate of a few megahertz. When pumped much harder, to approximate the low-noise mixer operating point, residual modulation can still be observed, showing that the HEB mixer is intrinsically unstable even in the resistive state. Based on these observations, we introduced a low-frequency termination to the HEB mixer. By terminating the device in a 50-Ω resistor in the megahertz frequency range, we have been able to improve the output-power Allan time of our HEB receiver by a factor of four to about 10 s for a detection bandwidth of 15 MHz, with a corresponding gain fluctuation of about 0.035%.
We report the results of our study of the stability of an 800 GHz hot electron bolometer (HEB) mixer cooled with a pulse-tube cryocooler. Pulse-tube cryocoolers introduce temperature fluctuations as well as mechanical vibrations at a frequency of$\sim1Hz,bothofwhichcancausereceivergainfluctuationsatthatfrequency.Inoursystem,themotorofthecryocoolerwasseparatedfromthecryostattominimizemechanicalvibrations,leavingthermaleffectsasthedominantsourceofthereceivergainfluctuations.Wemeasuredrootmeansquaretemperaturevariationsofthe4Kstageof1 Hz, both of which can cause receiver gain fluctuations at that frequency. In our system, the motor of the cryocooler was separated from the cryostat to minimize mechanical vibrations, leaving thermal effects as the dominant source of the receiver gain fluctuations. We measured root mean square temperature variations of the 4 K stage of1Hz,bothofwhichcancausereceivergainfluctuationsatthatfrequency.Inoursystem,themotorofthecryocoolerwasseparatedfromthecryostattominimizemechanicalvibrations,leavingthermaleffectsasthedominantsourceofthereceivergainfluctuations.Wemeasuredrootmeansquaretemperaturevariationsofthe4Kstageof\sim7mK.TheHEBmixerwaspumpedbyasolidstatelocaloscillatorat810GHz.Therootmeansquarecurrentfluctuationsatthelownoiseoperatingpoint(1.50mV,56.57 mK. The HEB mixer was pumped by a solid state local oscillator at 810 GHz. The root mean square current fluctuations at the low noise operating point (1.50 mV, 56.57mK.TheHEBmixerwaspumpedbyasolidstatelocaloscillatorat810GHz.Therootmeansquarecurrentfluctuationsatthelownoiseoperatingpoint(1.50mV,56.5\mu\hbox{A})were) were)were\sim 0.12\ \mu\hbox{A}$, and were predominantly due to thermal fluctuations. To stabilize the bias current, microwave radiation was injected to the HEB mixer. The injected power level was set by a proportional-integral-derivative controller, which completely compensates for the bias current oscillations induced by the pulse-tube cryocooler. Significant improvement in the Allan variance of the receiver output power was obtained, and an Allan time of 5 s was measured.
We present the results of a stabilization scheme for terahertz receivers based on NbN hot-electron bolometer (HEB) mixers that uses microwave radiation with a frequency much lower than the gap frequency of NbN to compensate for mixer current fluctuations. A feedback control loop, which actively controls the power level of the injected microwave radiation, has successfully been implemented to stabilize the operating point of the HEB mixer. This allows us to increase the receiver Allan time to 10 s and also improve the temperature resolution of the receiver by about 30% in the total power mode of operation.
We report our studies of the effect of microwave radiation, with a frequency much lower than that corresponding to the energy gap of the superconductor, on the performance of the NbN hot-electron bolometer (HEB) mixer incorporated into a THz heterodyne receiver. It is shown that exposing the HEB mixer to microwave radiation does not result in a significant rise of the receiver noise temperature and degradation of the mixer conversion gain so long as the level of microwave power is small compared to the local oscillator drive. Hence the injection of a small, but controlled amount of microwave radiation enables active compensation of local oscillator power and coupling fluctuations which can significantly degrade the stability of HEB mixer receivers.
Abstract Relaxation oscillations related to terahertz (THz) power detection in superconducting niobium nitride hot electron bolometers (HEBs) have been studied using microwaves as a probe. The reflected microwave signal, which is related to the impedance changes of the HEB irradiated by an incident THz signal, can be used to characterize relaxation oscillations. The frequency of relaxation oscillation switching between the superconducting and resistive states increases linearly with incident THz power but nonlinearly with bias voltage or bath temperature. The observed strong periodic pulse trains of relaxation oscillations have a maximum duty cycle of ∼50%. These strong switching pulses indicate that DC Joule heating, THz radiation or thermal energy is absorbed in the bi-stable region of the HEB intermittently. In addition to relaxation oscillations, we also see weaker oscillations when the device is in the resistive state, which we call intrinsic oscillations. These have a constant frequency at the order of 10 kHz which is independent of external stimuli. The weak periodic pulse trains at a constant frequency can be divided into mainly two types—one is the pulse train with a small duty cycle and the other is the quasi-square wave. Measurement of these oscillations in HEBs has some practical applications. Digital THz power measurement with frequencies below and above the gap frequency can be made based on the linearity between relaxation oscillation frequency and incident THz power. The relaxation oscillation frequency can be used to estimate the maximum speed of a THz direct detection system especially for a multi-pixel HEB array. In particular, extra noise induced by relaxation oscillations and intrinsic oscillations can be determined for the HEB operating as a THz direct detector.
We have investigated the effect of injecting microwave radiation, with a frequency much lower than that corresponding to the energy gap of the superconductor, on the performance of the hot-electron bolometer mixer incorporated into a THz heterodyne receiver. More specifically, we show that exposing the mixer to microwave radiation does not cause a significant rise of the receiver noise temperature and fall of the mixer conversion gain so long as the microwave power is a small fraction of local oscillator power. The injection of a small, but controlled amount of microwave power therefore enables active compensation of local oscillator power and coupling fluctuations which can significantly degrade the gain stability of hot electron bolometer mixer receivers.
Diffusion-cooled aluminum hot-electron bolometer (HEB) mixers are of interest for low-noise high resolution THz-frequency spectroscopy within astrophysics. Al HEB mixers offer operation with an order of magnitude less local oscillator power, higher intermediate frequency bandwidth and potentially lower noise than competing devices made from other materials. We report on mixer experiments at 618 GHz with devices fabricated from films with sheet resistances in the range from about 55 /spl Omega/ down to about 9 /spl Omega/ per square. Intermediate frequency bandwidths of up to 3 GHz were measured (1 /spl mu/m long device), with absorbed local oscillator power levels of 0.5 to 6 nW and mixer conversion up to -21.5 dB. High input coupling efficiency implies that the electrons in the device are able to thermalize before escaping from the device. It was found that the long coherence length complicates mixer operations due to the proximity of the contact pads. Also, saturation at the IF frequency may be a concern for this type of device, and warrants further studies.