Jean-Marc Lévy-Leblond
The reduction of the state vector is rightly held as one of the most puzzling aspects of quantum theory. Before adding a few more pages to the inflatory literature on the subject, I wish to voice a somewhat sobering remark. Namely, there is a striking contrast between the amount of theoretical discussions about the nature and significance of this notion, and its practical import. Indeed, the so-called "axiom" of reduction of the state vector has a rather limited use in the effective working of quantum theory. There are very few situations where we really need to assert that, after a measurement, the state vector has been reduced to the eigenvector of the physical property corresponding to the eigenvalue resulting from the measurement ("observed"). Most of the time, in effect, the system under investigation is forgotten or discarded after the measurement - or even destroyed by it (photons). We rarely make successive observations of the same system, so that we do not usually need to know what the state of a system is after a measurement. One might argue that the reduction of the state vector is operationally used mainly to describe the preparation of a system before acting upon it, that is, to ensure that we are indeed dealing with spin up electrons or velocity selected protons such as we wish to experiment about. Anyway, the statement of reduction is to be considered more as a kind of consistency condition to be required at the beginning or end of a theoretical analysis than as an effective tool of this analysis - such as, for instance, the statement of unitary evolution, which leads to the concrete construction of the evolution operator, hence the S-matrix, cross-sections, etc. In other words, the practical status of the state vector reduction, even if it is considered as an axiom of quantum theory, is different enough from that of the constructive axioms of the theory.
CRC Press eBooks•Oct 19, 2017•0 citations