Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Perspectives in biology and medicine

The Story of Spin By Sin-Intro Tomonaga (review)

Voichira Nambu

Published Dec 1, 1999• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Story ofSpin. By Sin- Intro Tomonaga. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1998. Pp. 280. $50.00 Anyone who has been exposed to the rudiments of atomic physics and quantum mechanics knows that the elementary constituents of matter, like the electron and the proton, have a "spin." Just as they carry a unit of electric charge, they also carry a unit of angular momentum. It is as if we can draw a crude analogy between an atom and the solar system: The planets not only orbit around the sun, but also rotate around their own axes, as does the sun. This property of the electron and the proton has enormous practical consequences, too. Without it, permanent magnets would not exist, and MRI technology would not be possible. This book is a fascinating historical and expository narrative by a master narrator Sin-Itiro Tomonaga about important topics related to spin in the context of quantum mechanics. Tomonaga (1906-1979) is a celebratedJapanese theoretical physicist who had firsthand experience in the formative years of quantum mechanics and nuclear physics. The early part of this century was a truly revolutionary period in physics. The Einstein relativity changed our concept of space and time, replaced and extended the Newtonian mechanics to extreme regimes of scale and energy. Quantum mechanics , even more revolutionary than relativity, solved the mysteries of the atomic world and changed our concept of reality. After a quarter-century of groping for makeshift theories and models of quantum phenomena, it developed into the modern quantum mechanics in the latter half of the 1920s with a breathtaking speed, thanks to a handful of heroes who made this possible. Tomonaga was a student in Japan in this period, and he went on to study under Heisenberg, one of the heroes, in the mid-1930s. Together with Yoshio Nishina, his mentor, and Hideki Yukawa, his fellow student and rival-friend, they built the foundations of nuclear physics research inJapan. Both Yukawa and Tomonaga would receive the Nobel Prize later. Tomonaga was a delicate, mild-mannered man. In his private life, he was an oldfashioned Japanese. He relaxed at home wearing a kimono and sipping sake, and he frequented a neighborhood yose (a story-teller's theater). Like a maiden at a spinning wheel, he weaves the story of spin slowly and patiently. It is possible to imagine one's self sitting in a lecture room listening to Professor Tomonaga. He writes out equations and statements on the blackboard carefully and completely in a beautiful style, while he explains every detail in a patient voice, always mixing it with background stories of who discovered what and how, who failed and why, and how they fought each other. In his narrative, there are three true heroes and a supporting cast of a dozen or so. (He also sprinkles his stories with revealing photos of them.) The true heroes are P.A.M. Dirac, Wolfgang Pauli, and Werner Heisenberg. They were all born in this century, and were in their mid-1920s when they did their most celebrated work. Tomonaga's characterization of the heroes is very vivid. Dirac is a true genius, an acrobat, a deus ex machina; his thought process is beyond the comprehension of us mortals, Pauli, a fiercely intolerant perfectionist, applies his standard indiscrimately to himself and others, mincing no words to criticize anything less than perfect in his eyes, and in the process frequently commits the sin of throwing out somebody 's baby together with the water. Heisenberg is a brilliant, energetic, and downto -earth prime mover who excels in playing analogies; he discovered not only matrix 294 I Book Reviews quantum mechanics but also laid the foundations of nuclear physics and ferromagnetism . The book consists of 11 lectures, or let us say 11 stories. It starts with "Before the Dawn," the struggle to come up with a refined and consistent picture of the atom on the basis of the Bohr model of atoms and spectroscopic data. In the second lecture Tomonaga explains how physicists were gradually, and reluctantly, led to the idea of a spinning electron. In the third lecture he introduces Pauli's description of spin, which he had initially rejected...

DOI
10.1353/pbm.1999.0051

Related papers

The story of spin

振一郎 朝永

All atomic particles have a particular spin, analogous to the rotation of the Earth about its axis. Simple as spin may sound, the quantum mechanical reality underlying it is complex and still poorly understood. Yet this mysterious quality and the statistics associated with it have vast practical importance to topics as wide-ranging as the stability of atoms and stars and magnetic resonance imaging. Originally published in 1974, Sin-Itiro Tomonaga's The Story of Spin is an accessible treatment of the subject, now available in English translation. Tomonaga relates the story of the pioneers of physics and their difficult journey toward an understanding of the nature of spin and its relationship to statistics. His discussion of spin should interest advanced scientists studying the foundations of modern physics, while his description of the little-known history of the Japanese physics community from the 1920s to the 1940s should be a useful resource for historians and philosophers of science.

University of Chicago Press eBooks•Jan 1, 1997•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics

Leo Pincherle

Volume 2: New Quantum Theory S.I. Tomonaga Amsterdam: North Holland . 1966 Pp. xi + 474. Price £5. There is a recurring theme in this second volume of Professor Tomonaga's original and stimulating work: the dualism wave-particle. Throughout the development of wave and quantum mechanics the dilemma is never far in the background, until its final solution following the study of many-particle systems and quantized wave fields.

Physics Bulletin•Nov 1, 1966•0 citations

The Stern-Gerlach Experiment and the Electron Spin

Sandip Pakvasa

The full story of the Stern-Gerlach experiment and its reception, interpretation and final understanding has many unexpected surprises. Here, we review the history and the context of the proposal, the experiment, and the subsequent story of the aftermath. We also discuss the story of the possible Stern-Gerlach experiment for free electrons etc. Finally, we comment on the remarkable career of Otto Stern.

arXiv:1805.09412•May 23, 2018•22 citations

On an Approximate Solution of the Many Body Problem of Fermi-Dirac Particles

M. Nogami

Progress of Theoretical Physics Vol. 5 No. 4 (1950) pp. 544-569 Remarks on Bloch's Method of Sound Waves applied to Many-Fermion Problems Sin-itiro Tomonaga

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Feb 1, 1950•1 citation

Analysis on the Development of Quantum Spin

Zhang Zi-hui

Spin, still a concept or property not fully exploited, has already impacted the world in many ways with its many applications. The history of how spin came to light and how it was interpreted and developed as investigations were conducted is of particular interest with the many odd outcomes of experiments concerning this intrinsic property. This article will sort out the historical outline of how spin was first indicated in theories and how it was eventually embraced as a fundamental property of quantum particles in an attempt to holistically review the process of recognition of this remarkable concept. Through this review, it becomes apparent how the recognition and development of a concept involves the intellect of a broad range of physicists who are willing to view things from both classical and quantum perspectives particularly when it comes to new concepts as spin. How elements like luck and chance play a role will also be revealed. As it turns out, our intuitions about the world around us may not be the ultimate truth, especially when it comes to Quantum Mechanics. Space Quantization was once thought of as no more than a theoretical outcome, however, experiments anyway impose this reality on physicists requiring them to abandon stubborn biases. Admittedly, not every speculation was correct, the analogy of “Spin” was an unfortunate one. But this article shows that this is just how understanding the mysteries of the quantum world really unfolds.

International Forum on Electrical Engineering and Automation (IFEEA)•Sep 1, 2020•1 citation

Bohr the Innovator? Or Bohr the Intimidator?

Daniel M. Greenberger

Quantum Dialog The Making of a Revolution. Mara Beller. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1999. 381 pp. $35, £24.50. ISBN 0-226-04181-6. Beller argues that the success of the Copenhagen interpretation was due primarily to intimidation and abuse of authority by Bohr and his collaborators. Our reviewer believes the author's biases led her to overlook the important question of how so many people have convinced themselves that one viable interpretation was actually unique and unassailable.

Science•Mar 24, 2000•2 citations
The Story ofSpin. By Sin- Intro Tomonaga. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1998. Pp. 280. $50.00 Anyone who has been exposed to the rudiments of atomic physics and quantum mechanics knows that the elementary constituents of matter, like the electron and the proton, have a "spin." Just as they carry a unit of electric charge, they also carry a unit of angular momentum. It is as if we can draw a crude analogy between an atom and the solar system: The planets not only orbit around the sun, but also rotate around their own axes, as does the sun. This property of the electron and the proton has enormous practical consequences, too. Without it, permanent magnets would not exist, and MRI technology would not be possible. This book is a fascinating historical and expository narrative by a master narrator Sin-Itiro Tomonaga about important topics related to spin in the context of quantum mechanics. Tomonaga (1906-1979) is a celebratedJapanese theoretical physicist who had firsthand experience in the formative years of quantum mechanics and nuclear physics. The early part of this century was a truly revolutionary period in physics. The Einstein relativity changed our concept of space and time, replaced and extended the Newtonian mechanics to extreme regimes of scale and energy. Quantum mechanics , even more revolutionary than relativity, solved the mysteries of the atomic world and changed our concept of reality. After a quarter-century of groping for makeshift theories and models of quantum phenomena, it developed into the modern quantum mechanics in the latter half of the 1920s with a breathtaking speed, thanks to a handful of heroes who made this possible. Tomonaga was a student in Japan in this period, and he went on to study under Heisenberg, one of the heroes, in the mid-1930s. Together with Yoshio Nishina, his mentor, and Hideki Yukawa, his fellow student and rival-friend, they built the foundations of nuclear physics research inJapan. Both Yukawa and Tomonaga would receive the Nobel Prize later. Tomonaga was a delicate, mild-mannered man. In his private life, he was an oldfashioned Japanese. He relaxed at home wearing a kimono and sipping sake, and he frequented a neighborhood yose (a story-teller's theater). Like a maiden at a spinning wheel, he weaves the story of spin slowly and patiently. It is possible to imagine one's self sitting in a lecture room listening to Professor Tomonaga. He writes out equations and statements on the blackboard carefully and completely in a beautiful style, while he explains every detail in a patient voice, always mixing it with background stories of who discovered what and how, who failed and why, and how they fought each other. In his narrative, there are three true heroes and a supporting cast of a dozen or so. (He also sprinkles his stories with revealing photos of them.) The true heroes are P.A.M. Dirac, Wolfgang Pauli, and Werner Heisenberg. They were all born in this century, and were in their mid-1920s when they did their most celebrated work. Tomonaga's characterization of the heroes is very vivid. Dirac is a true genius, an acrobat, a deus ex machina; his thought process is beyond the comprehension of us mortals, Pauli, a fiercely intolerant perfectionist, applies his standard indiscrimately to himself and others, mincing no words to criticize anything less than perfect in his eyes, and in the process frequently commits the sin of throwing out somebody 's baby together with the water. Heisenberg is a brilliant, energetic, and downto -earth prime mover who excels in playing analogies; he discovered not only matrix 294 I Book Reviews quantum mechanics but also laid the foundations of nuclear physics and ferromagnetism . The book consists of 11 lectures, or let us say 11 stories. It starts with "Before the Dawn," the struggle to come up with a refined and consistent picture of the atom on the basis of the Bohr model of atoms and spectroscopic data. In the second lecture Tomonaga explains how physicists were gradually, and reluctantly, led to the idea of a spinning electron. In the third lecture he introduces Pauli's description of spin, which he had initially rejected...
All atomic particles have a particular spin, analogous to the rotation of the Earth about its axis. Simple as spin may sound, the quantum mechanical reality underlying it is complex and still poorly understood. Yet this mysterious quality and the statistics associated with it have vast practical importance to topics as wide-ranging as the stability of atoms and stars and magnetic resonance imaging. Originally published in 1974, Sin-Itiro Tomonaga's The Story of Spin is an accessible treatment of the subject, now available in English translation. Tomonaga relates the story of the pioneers of physics and their difficult journey toward an understanding of the nature of spin and its relationship to statistics. His discussion of spin should interest advanced scientists studying the foundations of modern physics, while his description of the little-known history of the Japanese physics community from the 1920s to the 1940s should be a useful resource for historians and philosophers of science.
Spin, still a concept or property not fully exploited, has already impacted the world in many ways with its many applications. The history of how spin came to light and how it was interpreted and developed as investigations were conducted is of particular interest with the many odd outcomes of experiments concerning this intrinsic property. This article will sort out the historical outline of how spin was first indicated in theories and how it was eventually embraced as a fundamental property of quantum particles in an attempt to holistically review the process of recognition of this remarkable concept. Through this review, it becomes apparent how the recognition and development of a concept involves the intellect of a broad range of physicists who are willing to view things from both classical and quantum perspectives particularly when it comes to new concepts as spin. How elements like luck and chance play a role will also be revealed. As it turns out, our intuitions about the world around us may not be the ultimate truth, especially when it comes to Quantum Mechanics. Space Quantization was once thought of as no more than a theoretical outcome, however, experiments anyway impose this reality on physicists requiring them to abandon stubborn biases. Admittedly, not every speculation was correct, the analogy of “Spin” was an unfortunate one. But this article shows that this is just how understanding the mysteries of the quantum world really unfolds.