Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Science

Bohr the Innovator? Or Bohr the Intimidator?

Daniel M. Greenberger

Published Mar 24, 2000• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum Dialog The Making of a Revolution. Mara Beller. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1999. 381 pp. $35, £24.50. ISBN 0-226-04181-6. Beller argues that the success of the Copenhagen interpretation was due primarily to intimidation and abuse of authority by Bohr and his collaborators. Our reviewer believes the author's biases led her to overlook the important question of how so many people have convinced themselves that one viable interpretation was actually unique and unassailable.

DOI
10.1126/science.287.5461.2166

Related papers

Quantum Dialogue: The Making of a Revolution

Roland L. Omnes

`Science is rooted in conversations.' The word is from Heisenberg but it becomes with Mara Beller a thesis for reconsidering the philosophy and history of science: how conversations were a cradle for the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics is the main topic of this book. This `dialogical' approach is moreover assumed to be quite general and it is proposed as a guideline for future investigations in the history of science. This work will certainly be important among historians of science. Its most valuable content is a wealth of information picked up from many sources, including the correspondence between the actors and later registered commentaries by many witnesses. There will be also undoubtedly much discussion of its conclusions and theses. They are extremely strong since, to mention but a few, one is told that the success of the Copenhagen interpretation is the result of a `fierce' propaganda strategy, and that Bohr could not really master physics (because of a weakness in mathematics), while the idea of complementarity, after a long discussion, is dismissed as `mythology'. Such new ideas will certainly find an enthusiastic approval from the adeherents of `new is beautiful', and will give rise to much discussion. What is missing most, however, in this book is a consideration of recent intensive renewals of interpretation arising from advances in both experiments and theory. The resulting conclusions are clearly different from Beller's: now that there are demonstrative versions of interpretation, one can fully appreciate why it was so difficult to justify logically and philosophically the Copenhagen interpretation (accordingly Bohr's stature would be enhanced rather than slighted). Mara Beller's inclination towards excessive statements is finally crowned when she says that her philosophical analysis `demonstrates the possibility and the need of a viable alternative to the orthodox interpretation' (most probably Bohmian mechanics). To have such an Aristotelian confidence in the power of philosophy and to be so assertive in a book where neither the word or notion of `decoherence' is mentioned indicate in my opinion the real nature of that book: too provocative to be wise.

European Journal of Physics•Mar 1, 2000•65 citations

Mara Beller , Quantum Dialogue - The Making of a Revolution . Reviewed by

Ravi V. Gomatam

•Dec 1, 2000•1 citation

Tecnologias Quânticas: A inovação disruptiva como diferencial estratégico para a Defesa Nacional

F.M.A. Moreira, J. F. Galdino, Eliene B. Simão Silva +2 more

Em seu livro Quantum Dialogue - The Making of a Revolution[1], a escritora Mara Beller mostra que a ciência está enraizada não apenas na conversa (frase do Werner K. Heisenberg), mas na discordância, na dúvida e na incerteza. Ela argumenta que é justamente essa cultura de diálogo e polêmica dentro da comunidade científica que alimenta a criatividade. Beller extrai seu argumento de sua nova leitura radical da história da revolução quântica, especialmente o desenvolvimento da interpretação de Copenhague. Uma das várias abordagens concorrentes, esta versão teve sucesso em grande parte devido às habilidades retóricas de Niels Bohr e seus colegas. Usando uma extensa pesquisa de arquivo, Beller mostra como Bohr e outros comercializaram seus pontos de vista, deturpando e descartando seus oponentes como irracionais e defendendo sua própria posição nem sempre coerente ou bem apoiada como sendo inevitável. Na atual conjuntura de negociações entre os diferentes stakeholders relacionados com as tecnologias quânticas, as habilidades retóricas de Niels Bohr estão mais válidas do que nunca. A pergunta principal a ser respondida neste artigo é quem deve financiar, gerenciar e liderar no Brasil o desenvolvimento dessas tecnologias?

Seven Editora eBooks•Jun 16, 2023•0 citations

Bohr’s Quantum: 1926–

“How wonderful that we have met with a paradox. Now we have some hope of making progress,” said Niels Bohr with characteristic irony. The quantum view of the atom began with Bohr. Coming from Denmark, he worked with Rutherford, who although famously skeptical about theoreticians, supported him. Max Planck had previously introduced the idea of the quantum, and Einstein had extended it from matter to light, but Bohr’s proposal that electrons can adjust their orbits only by quantum leaps was revolutionary. The next revolution was Schrödinger’s description of electrons as waves instead of particles. This led to recognition of the wave–particle duality. The rest of the 20th century was marked by the realization that the apparently fundamental particles of the nucleus, the proton and the neutron, each actually consisted of a series of sub-particles. The wave–particle duality created a baffling series of paradoxes. Following revolutions tended to be driven by theoreticians, and massive team efforts were required to identify the sub-particles experimentally.

Royal Society of Chemistry eBooks•Jan 12, 2026•0 citations

Niels Bohr – A Centenary Volume

R Schofield

A P French and P J Kennedy (eds) 1985 London: Harvard University Press 403 pp price £16.50 ISBN 0 674 62415 7 It should be said at the outset that this is a remarkable book – all that one could hope for in celebration of such an important occasion. Not only is it edited with great originality and flair but it has been splendidly produced.

Physics Bulletin•Jun 1, 1986•89 citations

Wheeler's world

Ian G. Moss

There was once a prolonged argument between Niels Bohr and Albert Einstein about the nature of quantum theory. The theory had proved invaluable for describing the atom and the nucleus but it challenged Einstein's ideas about the rest of the cosmos. Einstein repeatedly pressed Bohr to provide him with a better definition of quantum theory, but was never satisfied.

Physics World•Feb 1, 1989•0 citations
Quantum Dialog The Making of a Revolution. Mara Beller. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1999. 381 pp. $35, £24.50. ISBN 0-226-04181-6. Beller argues that the success of the Copenhagen interpretation was due primarily to intimidation and abuse of authority by Bohr and his collaborators. Our reviewer believes the author's biases led her to overlook the important question of how so many people have convinced themselves that one viable interpretation was actually unique and unassailable.
`Science is rooted in conversations.' The word is from Heisenberg but it becomes with Mara Beller a thesis for reconsidering the philosophy and history of science: how conversations were a cradle for the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics is the main topic of this book. This `dialogical' approach is moreover assumed to be quite general and it is proposed as a guideline for future investigations in the history of science. This work will certainly be important among historians of science. Its most valuable content is a wealth of information picked up from many sources, including the correspondence between the actors and later registered commentaries by many witnesses. There will be also undoubtedly much discussion of its conclusions and theses. They are extremely strong since, to mention but a few, one is told that the success of the Copenhagen interpretation is the result of a `fierce' propaganda strategy, and that Bohr could not really master physics (because of a weakness in mathematics), while the idea of complementarity, after a long discussion, is dismissed as `mythology'. Such new ideas will certainly find an enthusiastic approval from the adeherents of `new is beautiful', and will give rise to much discussion. What is missing most, however, in this book is a consideration of recent intensive renewals of interpretation arising from advances in both experiments and theory. The resulting conclusions are clearly different from Beller's: now that there are demonstrative versions of interpretation, one can fully appreciate why it was so difficult to justify logically and philosophically the Copenhagen interpretation (accordingly Bohr's stature would be enhanced rather than slighted). Mara Beller's inclination towards excessive statements is finally crowned when she says that her philosophical analysis `demonstrates the possibility and the need of a viable alternative to the orthodox interpretation' (most probably Bohmian mechanics). To have such an Aristotelian confidence in the power of philosophy and to be so assertive in a book where neither the word or notion of `decoherence' is mentioned indicate in my opinion the real nature of that book: too provocative to be wise.
Em seu livro Quantum Dialogue - The Making of a Revolution[1], a escritora Mara Beller mostra que a ciência está enraizada não apenas na conversa (frase do Werner K. Heisenberg), mas na discordância, na dúvida e na incerteza. Ela argumenta que é justamente essa cultura de diálogo e polêmica dentro da comunidade científica que alimenta a criatividade. Beller extrai seu argumento de sua nova leitura radical da história da revolução quântica, especialmente o desenvolvimento da interpretação de Copenhague. Uma das várias abordagens concorrentes, esta versão teve sucesso em grande parte devido às habilidades retóricas de Niels Bohr e seus colegas. Usando uma extensa pesquisa de arquivo, Beller mostra como Bohr e outros comercializaram seus pontos de vista, deturpando e descartando seus oponentes como irracionais e defendendo sua própria posição nem sempre coerente ou bem apoiada como sendo inevitável. Na atual conjuntura de negociações entre os diferentes stakeholders relacionados com as tecnologias quânticas, as habilidades retóricas de Niels Bohr estão mais válidas do que nunca. A pergunta principal a ser respondida neste artigo é quem deve financiar, gerenciar e liderar no Brasil o desenvolvimento dessas tecnologias?
“How wonderful that we have met with a paradox. Now we have some hope of making progress,” said Niels Bohr with characteristic irony. The quantum view of the atom began with Bohr. Coming from Denmark, he worked with Rutherford, who although famously skeptical about theoreticians, supported him. Max Planck had previously introduced the idea of the quantum, and Einstein had extended it from matter to light, but Bohr’s proposal that electrons can adjust their orbits only by quantum leaps was revolutionary. The next revolution was Schrödinger’s description of electrons as waves instead of particles. This led to recognition of the wave–particle duality. The rest of the 20th century was marked by the realization that the apparently fundamental particles of the nucleus, the proton and the neutron, each actually consisted of a series of sub-particles. The wave–particle duality created a baffling series of paradoxes. Following revolutions tended to be driven by theoreticians, and massive team efforts were required to identify the sub-particles experimentally.