Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.14432

Singular Asymptotics of SPADE in Quantum Source Discrimination

Natsuki Kariya

quant-phmath.STstat.MESubmitted May 14, 2026• Announced May 15, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Aug 14, 2026 (v3)
v1 · May 14, 2026v2 · May 31, 2026v3 · Aug 14, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study far-field discrimination between one and two incoherent point sources in the singular regime of weak and closely spaced emitters. Under ideal alignment, spatial-mode demultiplexing (SPADE) attains the quantum-optimal large-sample Stein exponent, but the finite-photon behavior near the one-source boundary and the effect of realistic imperfections remain less understood. Using singular learning theory, we analyze both the aligned and misaligned problems. In the aligned Gaussian case, for prior densities that are smooth and strictly positive in the physical $(ε,s)$ coordinates near the singularity of the aligned model, direct imaging and SPADE share the same real log canonical threshold $λ=1/2$ but have different multiplicities, yielding distinct Bayes free-energy asymptotics. A fixed nonzero misalignment removes the exact support mismatch of ideal SPADE: locally, the fixed-offset binary-SPADE Kullback--Leibler function has the normal-crossing form $K\asympε^2s^2$, giving $(λ,m)=(1/2,2)$ under the same prior class, as for direct imaging. The local separation scale nevertheless depends on the source-position convention. Moreover, full Hermite--Gaussian mode counting about an offset sorter axis has a reflection-induced KL-zero branch at $s^\ast=2θ$, where the two-source alternative becomes indistinguishable from the null. Pointwise finite-$n$ binary-SPADE calculations exhibit the corresponding power collapse. These results identify measurement support, nuisance geometry, prior weighting, and identifiability as structural ingredients that must be tracked in finite-photon quantum discrimination.

Comments
15 pages, 2 figures. v3: Clarified prior dependence and the distinction between fixed-parameter and prior-predictive discrimination; revised the misalignment analysis and KL-zero-set structure; expanded technical appendices

Related papers

Noise-robust discrimination of incoherent point sources with spatial-mode demultiplexing

Jian-Qiang Liu, Chao-Ning Hu, Jun Xin +1 more

We theoretically predict and experimentally demonstrate that a reduced spatial-mode demultiplexing (SPADE) measurement using only the two lowest-order Hermite-Gaussian modes exhibits remarkable robustness against background noise in discriminating between a single source and two incoherent point sources. We establish a theoretical framework incorporating uniform background noise and derive an analytical Chernoff exponent expression, showing that SPADE consistently outperforms direct imaging (DI) across all source separations. Experimental results confirm that SPADE-based hypothesis testing approaches the quantum limit even when the background-to-signal photon ratio per pixel is 0.11. This advantage stems from SPADE's ability to concentrate source information into minimal detection modes, reducing the cumulative background noise impact. Our findings provide a practical detection scheme for applications where background noise is inevitable, such as astronomical observations and quantum sensing.

quant-pharXiv:2608.01765•Optics Express•Aug 4, 2026•0 citations

Bayesian quantum estimation of the separation of two incoherent point sources

Boyu Zhou, Saikat Guha, Christos N. Gagatsos

We examine the problem of estimating the separation between two arbitrarily close incoherent point sources from a quantum Bayesian perspective—that is, assuming the availability of a prior probability distribution function (PDF) for the separation. In particular, we consider both non-displaced and displaced half-Gaussian prior PDFs to evaluate the performance of Hermite–Gauss spatial mode demultiplexing (HG-SPADE) and direct imaging (DI). By employing the Bayesian minimum mean square error criterion, which is always attainable by a different kind of spatial demultiplexing, we compare the effectiveness of HG-SPADE and DI and analyze how variations in the parameters of the prior PDF influence the conditions under which one method outperforms the other.

arXiv:2412.05245•APL Quantum•Oct 6, 2025•1 citation

Experimental subdiffraction source discrimination enabled by spatial demultiplexing and single-photon detectors

Luigi Santamaria Amato, Danilo Triggiani, Cosmo Lupo

We experimentally demonstrate a universal, parameter-independent test for asymmetric source discrimination below the diffraction limit. The test exploits spatial-mode demultiplexing (SPADE) and single-photon detection to discriminate the presence of a faint source in the vicinity of a brighter one. We develop a complete theory of the test in the presence of arbitrary modal crosstalk and show that the crosstalk-affected test retains a favorable error exponent over diffraction-limited direct imaging, provided that the crosstalk remains below a threshold $C_{\mathrm{max}}\simeq 1/9$. This establishes a quantitative condition under which the subdiffraction advantage of SPADE survives realistic imperfections. We experimentally test the scheme for a range of source separations and intensity ratios, without requiring prior knowledge of these parameters. The measured false-negative error rates are in good agreement with the theoretical model and systematically outperform direct imaging. These results demonstrate that SPADE provides a robust and experimentally accessible advantage for asymmetric subdiffraction hypothesis testing in the photon-starved regime, even in the presence of realistic modal crosstalk.

quant-pharXiv:2605.15929•Physical Review Letters•May 18, 2026•0 citations

Experimental Evidence-Based Sub-Rayleigh Source Discrimination

Saurabh U. Shringarpure, Yong Siah Teo, Hyunseok Jeong +5 more

We propose a Bayesian evidence-based inference framework based on relative belief ratios and apply it to discriminating between one and two incoherent optical point sources using spatial-mode demultiplexing (SPADE). Unlike the Helstrom measurement, SPADE require no collective detection and its optimal for asymptotically large samples. Our method avoids ad hoc statistical constructs and relies solely on the information contained in the data, with all assumptions entering only through the likelihood model and prior beliefs. Using experimental evidence, we demonstrate the superior resolving performance of SPADE over direct imaging from a new and extensible perspective; one that naturally generalizes to multiple sources and offers a practical robust approach to analyzing quantum-enhanced superresolution.

quant-pharXiv:2601.13972•Physical Review A•Jan 21, 2026•0 citations

Superresolving optical ruler based on spatial mode demultiplexing for systems evolving under Brownian motion

Konrad Schlichtholz

The development of super-resolution techniques, i.e., allowing for efficient resolution below the Rayleigh limit, became one of the important branches in contemporary optics and metrology. Recent findings show that perfect spatial mode demultiplexing (SPADE) into Hermite-Gauss modes followed by photon counting enables one to reach the quantum limit of precision in the task of estimation of separation between two weak stationary sources in the sub-Rayleigh regime. In order to check the limitations of the method, various imperfections such as misalignment or crosstalk between the modes were considered. Possible applications of the method in microscopy call for the adaptive measurement scheme, as the position of the measured system can evolve in time, causing non-negligible misalignment. In this paper, we examine the impact of Brownian motion of the center of the system of two weak incoherent sources on adaptive SPADE measurement precision limits. The analysis is carried out using Fisher information, from which the limit of precision can be obtained by Cramér-Rao bound. As a result, we find that Rayleigh's curse is present in such a scenario; however, SPADE measurement can outperform perfect direct imaging. What is more, a suitable adjustment of the measurement time between alignments allows measurement with near-optimal precision.

arXiv:2407.13723•Physics of Fluids•Feb 1, 2025•1 citation

Spatial-mode demultiplexing for enhanced intensity and distance measurement

Luigi Santamaria Amato, Deborah Katia Pallotti, Mario Siciliani de Cumis +2 more

Spatial-mode demultiplexing (SPADE) has recently been adopted to measure the separation in the transverse plane between two incoherent point-like sources with sub-wavelength separation. It has been argued that this approach may yield extraordinary performances in the photon-counting regime. Here, we explore SPADE as a tool for precision measurements in the regime of bright, incoherent sources. First we analyze the general problem of estimating the second moments of the source's intensity distribution, for an extended incoherent source of any shape. Our theory predicts a substantial improvement in signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of SPADE over direct imaging in the sub-wavelength regime. Second, we present an experimental application of SPADE to the case of two point-like, bright sources. We demonstrate the use of this setup for the estimation of the transverse separation and for the estimation of the relative intensity, confirming the expected improvement in SNR.

arXiv:2206.05246•Optics Express•Jun 5, 2023•25 citations
We study far-field discrimination between one and two incoherent point sources in the singular regime of weak and closely spaced emitters. Under ideal alignment, spatial-mode demultiplexing (SPADE) attains the quantum-optimal large-sample Stein exponent, but the finite-photon behavior near the one-source boundary and the effect of realistic imperfections remain less understood. Using singular learning theory, we analyze both the aligned and misaligned problems. In the aligned Gaussian case, for prior densities that are smooth and strictly positive in the physical (ε,s)(ε,s)(ε,s) coordinates near the singularity of the aligned model, direct imaging and SPADE share the same real log canonical threshold λ=1/2λ=1/2λ=1/2 but have different multiplicities, yielding distinct Bayes free-energy asymptotics. A fixed nonzero misalignment removes the exact support mismatch of ideal SPADE: locally, the fixed-offset binary-SPADE Kullback--Leibler function has the normal-crossing form K≍ε2s2K\asympε^2s^2K≍ε2s2, giving (λ,m)=(1/2,2)(λ,m)=(1/2,2)(λ,m)=(1/2,2) under the same prior class, as for direct imaging. The local separation scale nevertheless depends on the source-position convention. Moreover, full Hermite--Gaussian mode counting about an offset sorter axis has a reflection-induced KL-zero branch at s∗=2θs^\ast=2θs∗=2θ, where the two-source alternative becomes indistinguishable from the null. Pointwise finite-nnn binary-SPADE calculations exhibit the corresponding power collapse. These results identify measurement support, nuisance geometry, prior weighting, and identifiability as structural ingredients that must be tracked in finite-photon quantum discrimination.
We theoretically predict and experimentally demonstrate that a reduced spatial-mode demultiplexing (SPADE) measurement using only the two lowest-order Hermite-Gaussian modes exhibits remarkable robustness against background noise in discriminating between a single source and two incoherent point sources. We establish a theoretical framework incorporating uniform background noise and derive an analytical Chernoff exponent expression, showing that SPADE consistently outperforms direct imaging (DI) across all source separations. Experimental results confirm that SPADE-based hypothesis testing approaches the quantum limit even when the background-to-signal photon ratio per pixel is 0.11. This advantage stems from SPADE's ability to concentrate source information into minimal detection modes, reducing the cumulative background noise impact. Our findings provide a practical detection scheme for applications where background noise is inevitable, such as astronomical observations and quantum sensing.
We examine the problem of estimating the separation between two arbitrarily close incoherent point sources from a quantum Bayesian perspective—that is, assuming the availability of a prior probability distribution function (PDF) for the separation. In particular, we consider both non-displaced and displaced half-Gaussian prior PDFs to evaluate the performance of Hermite–Gauss spatial mode demultiplexing (HG-SPADE) and direct imaging (DI). By employing the Bayesian minimum mean square error criterion, which is always attainable by a different kind of spatial demultiplexing, we compare the effectiveness of HG-SPADE and DI and analyze how variations in the parameters of the prior PDF influence the conditions under which one method outperforms the other.
We experimentally demonstrate a universal, parameter-independent test for asymmetric source discrimination below the diffraction limit. The test exploits spatial-mode demultiplexing (SPADE) and single-photon detection to discriminate the presence of a faint source in the vicinity of a brighter one. We develop a complete theory of the test in the presence of arbitrary modal crosstalk and show that the crosstalk-affected test retains a favorable error exponent over diffraction-limited direct imaging, provided that the crosstalk remains below a threshold Cmax≃1/9C_{\mathrm{max}}\simeq 1/9Cmax​≃1/9. This establishes a quantitative condition under which the subdiffraction advantage of SPADE survives realistic imperfections. We experimentally test the scheme for a range of source separations and intensity ratios, without requiring prior knowledge of these parameters. The measured false-negative error rates are in good agreement with the theoretical model and systematically outperform direct imaging. These results demonstrate that SPADE provides a robust and experimentally accessible advantage for asymmetric subdiffraction hypothesis testing in the photon-starved regime, even in the presence of realistic modal crosstalk.
We propose a Bayesian evidence-based inference framework based on relative belief ratios and apply it to discriminating between one and two incoherent optical point sources using spatial-mode demultiplexing (SPADE). Unlike the Helstrom measurement, SPADE require no collective detection and its optimal for asymptotically large samples. Our method avoids ad hoc statistical constructs and relies solely on the information contained in the data, with all assumptions entering only through the likelihood model and prior beliefs. Using experimental evidence, we demonstrate the superior resolving performance of SPADE over direct imaging from a new and extensible perspective; one that naturally generalizes to multiple sources and offers a practical robust approach to analyzing quantum-enhanced superresolution.
The development of super-resolution techniques, i.e., allowing for efficient resolution below the Rayleigh limit, became one of the important branches in contemporary optics and metrology. Recent findings show that perfect spatial mode demultiplexing (SPADE) into Hermite-Gauss modes followed by photon counting enables one to reach the quantum limit of precision in the task of estimation of separation between two weak stationary sources in the sub-Rayleigh regime. In order to check the limitations of the method, various imperfections such as misalignment or crosstalk between the modes were considered. Possible applications of the method in microscopy call for the adaptive measurement scheme, as the position of the measured system can evolve in time, causing non-negligible misalignment. In this paper, we examine the impact of Brownian motion of the center of the system of two weak incoherent sources on adaptive SPADE measurement precision limits. The analysis is carried out using Fisher information, from which the limit of precision can be obtained by Cramér-Rao bound. As a result, we find that Rayleigh's curse is present in such a scenario; however, SPADE measurement can outperform perfect direct imaging. What is more, a suitable adjustment of the measurement time between alignments allows measurement with near-optimal precision.
Spatial-mode demultiplexing (SPADE) has recently been adopted to measure the separation in the transverse plane between two incoherent point-like sources with sub-wavelength separation. It has been argued that this approach may yield extraordinary performances in the photon-counting regime. Here, we explore SPADE as a tool for precision measurements in the regime of bright, incoherent sources. First we analyze the general problem of estimating the second moments of the source's intensity distribution, for an extended incoherent source of any shape. Our theory predicts a substantial improvement in signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of SPADE over direct imaging in the sub-wavelength regime. Second, we present an experimental application of SPADE to the case of two point-like, bright sources. We demonstrate the use of this setup for the estimation of the transverse separation and for the estimation of the relative intensity, confirming the expected improvement in SNR.