Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2604.12576 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Detecting entanglement from few partial transpose moments and their decay via weight enumerators

Daniel Miller, Jens Eisert

quant-phSubmitted Apr 14, 2026• Announced Apr 15, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Jun 2, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Apr 14, 2026v2 · Jun 2, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The $p_3$-PPT criterion is an experimentally viable relaxation of the well-known positive partial transposition (PPT) criterion for the certification of quantum entanglement. Recently, it has been generalized to various families of entanglement criteria based on the PT moments $p_k=$Tr$[(ρ^Γ)^k]$, where $ρ^Γ$ denotes the partially transposed density matrix of a quantum state $ρ$. While most of these generalizations are strictly more powerful than the $p_3$-PPT criterion, their $m$-th level versions usually rely on the availability of $p_k$ for all moment orders $k\le m$. Here, we show that one can alternatively compare any three PT moments of orders $k<l<m$, which can significantly reduce experimental overheads. More precisely, we show that any state satisfying $p_l>p_k^xp_m^{1-x} $ must be entangled, where $x=(m-l)/(m-k)$. Using the example of locally depolarized GHZ states, we identify the most promising versions of these three-moment criteria and compare their performance with a broad range of entanglement criteria. In the case of globally depolarized stabilizer states, we prove that having access to $p_k$ for $k \le 5$ is sufficient to reproduce the full PPT criterion. More generally, we show that the Stieltjes-$m$ criterion is as powerful as the PPT criterion whenever $ρ^Γ$ has no more than $(m+1)/2$ distinct eigenvalues. Finally, we introduce a notion of quantum weight enumerators that capture the decay of $p_k$ under local white noise for arbitrary quantum states and illustrate this concept for an AME state. Our results contribute to the growing body of literature on higher-moment PPT relaxations and modern applications of weight enumerators in quantum error correction and information theory.

Journal reference
J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 59 355307 (2026)
DOI
10.1088/1751-8121/ae98c6
Comments
11+4 pages, 2 figures, 1 table

Related papers

Optimal Entanglement Certification from Moments of the Partial Transpose

Xiao‐Dong Yu, Satoya Imai, Otfried Gühne

For the certification and benchmarking of medium-size quantum devices, efficient methods to characterize entanglement are needed. In this context, it has been shown that locally randomized measurements on a multiparticle quantum system can be used to obtain valuable information on the so-called moments of the partially transposed quantum state. This allows one to infer some separability properties of a state, but how to use the given information in an optimal and systematic manner has yet to be determined. We propose two general entanglement detection methods based on the moments of the partially transposed density matrix. The first method is based on the Hankel matrices and provides a family of entanglement criteria, of which the lowest order reduces to the known p_{3}-positive-partial-transpose criterion proposed in A. Elben et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 200501 (2020)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.125.200501]. The second method is optimal and gives necessary and sufficient conditions for entanglement based on some moments of the partially transposed density matrix.

arXiv:2103.06897•Physical Review Letters•Aug 4, 2021•71 citations

Entanglement properties of GHZ and W superposition state and its decayed states*

Xin-Feng Jin, Li-zhen Jiang, Xiaoyu Chen

We use the generalized Wootters formula, the positive partial transpose (PPT) criterion and the matched entanglement witness, to detect entanglement of three-qubit GHZ and W superposition state and its decayed states. It shows that the results of the generalized Wootters formula in the part near the W state are tight. In the other parts, the PPT criterion is superior to the generalized Wootters formula. Furthermore, we investigate the relationship between entanglement and coherence.

Chinese Physics B•Dec 30, 2020•2 citations

Moment-based PPT criteria for random bipartite states

Cécilia Lancien, Kieran McShane

Moment-based relaxations of the positive partial transpose (PPT) criterion have been recently introduced, as a hierarchy of entanglement criteria involving only experimentally accessible quantities of a given bipartite state. The goal of this work is to study their typical detection performance on high-dimensional bipartite systems. Concretely, we investigate whether random bipartite mixed states on $\mathbb C^d\otimes\mathbb C^d$, obtained as the marginal over an environment $\mathbb C^s$ of a uniformly distributed pure state, generically satisfy or violate them. For each fixed level $m\in\mathbb N$ in this hierarchy of moment-based PPT criteria, we are able to identify a threshold environment dimension $s=λ_md^2$ at which the behavior of the associated random state switches from violating to satisfying it, with probability going to $1$ as $d$ grows. The proof combines combinatorics of permutations techniques to estimate the average value of moments of partially transposed random states and concentration of measure arguments to bound the probability of deviating from such average, when the underlying local dimension $d$ is large. We additionally need tools from the theory of Hankel determinant evaluation via orthogonal polynomials.

quant-pharXiv:2607.11369•Jul 14, 2026•0 citations

A Closed Form for Moment-Based Entanglement Tests Associated to the PPT Criterion

Zachary P. Bradshaw, Margarite L. LaBorde

Neven et al. have explored an unexpected alliance between the mathematical insights of Sir Isaac Newton and René Descartes which culminates in the reduction of the Positive Partial Transpose (PPT) criterion to an equivalent hierarchy of entanglement tests based on the moments of the partial transpose. By repurposing these classical results in the context of modern quantum theory, they illuminate new pathways for entanglement verification. Here, we expand on this work by providing a closed form for the inequalities defining these entanglement tests and producing an equivalent set of graph theoretic conditions on the weighted graph induced by the partial transpose.

arXiv:2503.17525•Mar 21, 2025•0 citations

Geometric Aspects of Quantum Entanglement

Leif Ove Hansen

Summary: \nEntanglement is a strange feature contained in the quantum mechanical framework, first observed theoretically by Erwin Schrödinger and Albert Einstein. An inherent attribute of entanglement is non-locality, and in the continuation of this, several non-reductionist features, which are conceptually challenging and philosophically interesting. \n \nA considerable growth of the interest in quantum entanglement has occurred since the early 1990s, and much of the reason for this is that the tools of quantum optics and modern instrumentation have made it possible to measure and manipulate entangled quantum systems. Today, several applications of entanglement exist, including quantum computers and several areas in quantum communications. \n \nA quantum state is either separable or entangled, it cannot be none or both. A separable state do not exhibit the non-local features found in entangled states, and are in this sense comparable to classic states. An important issue here is the separability problem, which is the problem of determining whether a given state is entangled or not. \n \nWe study these quantum states as Hermitian matrices with positive eigenvalues in convex spaces. The PPT criterion is based on the partial transposition operation, which essentially transposes one of the two subsystems in the quantum system. For some states the result is another quantum (positive) state, and these are PPT (Positive Partial Transpose) states, while others that gain negative eigenvalues are called NPT states. \n \nFor systems of dimensions 2 × 2 and 2 × 3, the PPT states are identical to the separable states, and the NPT states are identical to the entangled states, so the PPT criterion is always conclusive. But for larger dimensions, such as for instance the 3 × 3 system, there always exist PPT states that are entangled, so for this case the PPT criterion can only be used in a contrapositive way. Since entangled PPT states in this sense seem to have great significance, their characteristics are worth studying. \nAs mentioned, the PPT criterion uses the transposition map on one of the two subsystems of a composite quantum system. Transposition is an example of a positive map, in that it maps all quantum states into quantum states. It is possible to use positive maps to formulate a much more general criterion for the separability problem.There is a link (an isomorphism) between positive maps and a subset of Hermitian operators called entanglement witnesses. \n \nThe so-called Horodecki criterion states that a quantum state is separable if and only if the expectation value of all entanglement witnesses in the state are non-negative. If the expectation value of one (or possibly several) entanglement witnesses in a given quantum state is negative, then the state is always entangled. This criterion is both necessary and sufficient, but demands that we can characterize the entire set of entanglement witnesses. \n \nThe approach in this thesis is through geometry. Of fundamental importance is the convex nature of the sets in question. The knowledge and understanding of the extremal points in these sets is very relevant, since they describe the sets completely. Undertaking completely analytic studies of the geometry at hand is in general very hard, especially as the dimension of the systems grow. The development and use of numerical tools is therefore essential.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

The generalized partial transposition criterion for infinite-dimensional quantum systems

Siqing YanYu GuoJinchuan Hou

The positive partial transposition (PPT) criterion and the realignment criterion constitute two of the most important criteria for detecting entanglement. The general- ized partial transposition (GPT) criterion which contains the PPT criterion and the realignment criterion as special cases, provides a necessary condition for a multipartite state to be separable. Here we extend the GPT criterion to the infinite- dimensional multipartite (bipartite) case and show that it includes multipartite (bipartite) PPT criterion and multipartite (bipartite) realignment criterion as special cases as well.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations
The p3p_3p3​-PPT criterion is an experimentally viable relaxation of the well-known positive partial transposition (PPT) criterion for the certification of quantum entanglement. Recently, it has been generalized to various families of entanglement criteria based on the PT moments pk=p_k=pk​=Tr[(ρΓ)k][(ρ^Γ)^k][(ρΓ)k], where ρΓρ^ΓρΓ denotes the partially transposed density matrix of a quantum state ρρρ. While most of these generalizations are strictly more powerful than the p3p_3p3​-PPT criterion, their mmm-th level versions usually rely on the availability of pkp_kpk​ for all moment orders k≤mk\le mk≤m. Here, we show that one can alternatively compare any three PT moments of orders k<l<mk<l<mk<l<m, which can significantly reduce experimental overheads. More precisely, we show that any state satisfying pl>pkxpm1−xp_l>p_k^xp_m^{1-x} pl​>pkx​pm1−x​ must be entangled, where x=(m−l)/(m−k)x=(m-l)/(m-k)x=(m−l)/(m−k). Using the example of locally depolarized GHZ states, we identify the most promising versions of these three-moment criteria and compare their performance with a broad range of entanglement criteria. In the case of globally depolarized stabilizer states, we prove that having access to pkp_kpk​ for k≤5k \le 5k≤5 is sufficient to reproduce the full PPT criterion. More generally, we show that the Stieltjes-mmm criterion is as powerful as the PPT criterion whenever ρΓρ^ΓρΓ has no more than (m+1)/2(m+1)/2(m+1)/2 distinct eigenvalues. Finally, we introduce a notion of quantum weight enumerators that capture the decay of pkp_kpk​ under local white noise for arbitrary quantum states and illustrate this concept for an AME state. Our results contribute to the growing body of literature on higher-moment PPT relaxations and modern applications of weight enumerators in quantum error correction and information theory.
For the certification and benchmarking of medium-size quantum devices, efficient methods to characterize entanglement are needed. In this context, it has been shown that locally randomized measurements on a multiparticle quantum system can be used to obtain valuable information on the so-called moments of the partially transposed quantum state. This allows one to infer some separability properties of a state, but how to use the given information in an optimal and systematic manner has yet to be determined. We propose two general entanglement detection methods based on the moments of the partially transposed density matrix. The first method is based on the Hankel matrices and provides a family of entanglement criteria, of which the lowest order reduces to the known p_{3}-positive-partial-transpose criterion proposed in A. Elben et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 200501 (2020)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.125.200501]. The second method is optimal and gives necessary and sufficient conditions for entanglement based on some moments of the partially transposed density matrix.
Moment-based relaxations of the positive partial transpose (PPT) criterion have been recently introduced, as a hierarchy of entanglement criteria involving only experimentally accessible quantities of a given bipartite state. The goal of this work is to study their typical detection performance on high-dimensional bipartite systems. Concretely, we investigate whether random bipartite mixed states on Cd⊗Cd\mathbb C^d\otimes\mathbb C^dCd⊗Cd, obtained as the marginal over an environment Cs\mathbb C^sCs of a uniformly distributed pure state, generically satisfy or violate them. For each fixed level m∈Nm\in\mathbb Nm∈N in this hierarchy of moment-based PPT criteria, we are able to identify a threshold environment dimension s=λmd2s=λ_md^2s=λm​d2 at which the behavior of the associated random state switches from violating to satisfying it, with probability going to 111 as ddd grows. The proof combines combinatorics of permutations techniques to estimate the average value of moments of partially transposed random states and concentration of measure arguments to bound the probability of deviating from such average, when the underlying local dimension ddd is large. We additionally need tools from the theory of Hankel determinant evaluation via orthogonal polynomials.
Neven et al. have explored an unexpected alliance between the mathematical insights of Sir Isaac Newton and René Descartes which culminates in the reduction of the Positive Partial Transpose (PPT) criterion to an equivalent hierarchy of entanglement tests based on the moments of the partial transpose. By repurposing these classical results in the context of modern quantum theory, they illuminate new pathways for entanglement verification. Here, we expand on this work by providing a closed form for the inequalities defining these entanglement tests and producing an equivalent set of graph theoretic conditions on the weighted graph induced by the partial transpose.
Summary: \nEntanglement is a strange feature contained in the quantum mechanical framework, first observed theoretically by Erwin Schrödinger and Albert Einstein. An inherent attribute of entanglement is non-locality, and in the continuation of this, several non-reductionist features, which are conceptually challenging and philosophically interesting. \n \nA considerable growth of the interest in quantum entanglement has occurred since the early 1990s, and much of the reason for this is that the tools of quantum optics and modern instrumentation have made it possible to measure and manipulate entangled quantum systems. Today, several applications of entanglement exist, including quantum computers and several areas in quantum communications. \n \nA quantum state is either separable or entangled, it cannot be none or both. A separable state do not exhibit the non-local features found in entangled states, and are in this sense comparable to classic states. An important issue here is the separability problem, which is the problem of determining whether a given state is entangled or not. \n \nWe study these quantum states as Hermitian matrices with positive eigenvalues in convex spaces. The PPT criterion is based on the partial transposition operation, which essentially transposes one of the two subsystems in the quantum system. For some states the result is another quantum (positive) state, and these are PPT (Positive Partial Transpose) states, while others that gain negative eigenvalues are called NPT states. \n \nFor systems of dimensions 2 × 2 and 2 × 3, the PPT states are identical to the separable states, and the NPT states are identical to the entangled states, so the PPT criterion is always conclusive. But for larger dimensions, such as for instance the 3 × 3 system, there always exist PPT states that are entangled, so for this case the PPT criterion can only be used in a contrapositive way. Since entangled PPT states in this sense seem to have great significance, their characteristics are worth studying. \nAs mentioned, the PPT criterion uses the transposition map on one of the two subsystems of a composite quantum system. Transposition is an example of a positive map, in that it maps all quantum states into quantum states. It is possible to use positive maps to formulate a much more general criterion for the separability problem.There is a link (an isomorphism) between positive maps and a subset of Hermitian operators called entanglement witnesses. \n \nThe so-called Horodecki criterion states that a quantum state is separable if and only if the expectation value of all entanglement witnesses in the state are non-negative. If the expectation value of one (or possibly several) entanglement witnesses in a given quantum state is negative, then the state is always entangled. This criterion is both necessary and sufficient, but demands that we can characterize the entire set of entanglement witnesses. \n \nThe approach in this thesis is through geometry. Of fundamental importance is the convex nature of the sets in question. The knowledge and understanding of the extremal points in these sets is very relevant, since they describe the sets completely. Undertaking completely analytic studies of the geometry at hand is in general very hard, especially as the dimension of the systems grow. The development and use of numerical tools is therefore essential.
The positive partial transposition (PPT) criterion and the realignment criterion constitute two of the most important criteria for detecting entanglement. The general- ized partial transposition (GPT) criterion which contains the PPT criterion and the realignment criterion as special cases, provides a necessary condition for a multipartite state to be separable. Here we extend the GPT criterion to the infinite- dimensional multipartite (bipartite) case and show that it includes multipartite (bipartite) PPT criterion and multipartite (bipartite) realignment criterion as special cases as well.