Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2602.15115 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Experimental characterization of the hierarchy of quantum correlations in top quark pairs

Yoav Afik, Regina Demina, Alan Herrera, Otto Hindrichs, Juan Ramón Muñoz de Nova, Baptiste Ravina

quant-phhep-exhep-phSubmitted Feb 16, 2026• Announced Feb 18, 2026• 1 citation• Revised May 27, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Feb 16, 2026v2 · May 27, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recent results from the Large Hadron Collider have demonstrated quantum entanglement of top quark-antiquark pairs using the spin degrees of freedom. Based on the doubly differential measurement of the spin density matrix of the top quark and antiquark performed by the CMS collaboration in the helicity and beam bases, we evaluate a set of quantum observables, including discord, steerability, Bell correlation, and magic. These observables allow for a quantitative characterization of the quantum correlations present in a top quark-antiquark system, thus enabling an interpretation of collider data in terms of quantum states and their properties. Discord is observed to be greater than zero with a significance of more than 5 standard deviations ($σ$) in several regions of phase space, some of which correspond to separable quantum states. Evidence for steerability is established for the first time in a high-energy system, with a significance of more than 3$σ$. No Bell correlation is observed within the currently probed phase space, in agreement with the theoretical prediction. These results experimentally corroborate the hierarchy of quantum correlations in top quarks with discord being the most basic form of quantum correlation, followed by entanglement, steerability, and Bell correlation. The significance of nonzero magic, which is a complementary observable to the quantum correlation hierarchy, is found to exceed 5$σ$ in several regions of phase space.

Journal reference
Phys. Rev. D 113, 096015 (2026)
DOI
10.1103/qqvz-87d2
Comments
11 pages, 4 figures

Related papers

Measurements of top quark properties in CMS: $t\bar{t}$ spin density matrix, quantum entanglement and quantum magic

E. Yazgan

Polarization and spin correlation measurements of top quark-antiquark ($t\bar{t}$) pairs provide tests of the standard model, but also new ways to test quantum mechanics with unstable particles at highest energies ever produced in a laboratory. Recent $t\bar{t}$ spin correlation measurements and the tests they enable, made with the CMS detector at the CERN LHC Run 2, are presented. The measurements summarized include the full spin density matrix measurement of top quark pairs using events with a single lepton and jets in the final state. Spin correlation measurements in specific phase space regions allow the observation of the entanglement phenomenon, and the measurement of quantum magic. From the measured spin correlation at the $t\bar{t}$ production threshold and high $t\bar{t}$ mass, entanglement is observed with a large fraction of the $t\bar{t}$ decays being spacelike separated. The observation of entanglement in $t\bar{t}$ events with two high transverse momentum leptons of opposite charge is also presented. Finally, the first TeV-scale experimental measurement of quantum magic, an important variable for the characterization of quantum states in quantum information science, is presented. These measurements provide one of the first connections between quantum information science and particle physics, and show the potential of collider experiments in the studies of the foundations of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2510.13743•European Physical Society Conference on High Energy Physics (EPS-HEP)•Jan 28, 2026•1 citation

Experimental probe of quantum coherence in top-quark pair production at the LHC

Saeed Haddadi, Majid Azizi, Artur Czerwinski +1 more

We investigate quantum coherence in the spin degrees of freedom of top--antitop pairs produced at the LHC using the $l_1$-norm of coherence in the helicity basis. Combining Standard Model predictions with the spin density matrix reconstructed from the CMS measurement of top-quark spin correlation coefficients, we study the dependence of coherence on the invariant mass $M_{t\bar t}$ and production angle. To quantify the experimental precision of the extracted coherence, we propagate the measured uncertainties and covariance matrix of the spin-correlation coefficients through a Monte Carlo procedure. We find a non-monotonic kinematic dependence: coherence is large near the production threshold, is reduced in the intermediate-mass region, and increases again in boosted central events. The theoretical predictions are in good agreement with the CMS determinations in all three kinematic regions. Moreover, the experimentally reconstructed coherence is nonzero with a significance exceeding $5σ$ in each region. In particular, in the intermediate-mass region, $400<M_{t\bar t}<600~\mathrm{GeV}$, we obtain $C_{l_1}=0.597\pm0.037$. This result is especially noteworthy because previous analyses of the same reconstructed top-quark spin density matrix found concurrence and negativity, both entanglement measures, to be consistent with zero, $0.00\pm0.02$, in this kinematic region. The persistence of sizable coherence where entanglement is not experimentally certified demonstrates that coherence provides complementary information on the off-diagonal helicity-interference structure of the top-quark spin density matrix. Our results establish quantum coherence as an experimentally accessible and statistically robust observable for probing the quantum structure of top-quark pair production at the LHC.

hep-phCross-listedarXiv:2602.21069•Feb 25, 2026

Entanglement and Bell nonlocality with bottom-quark pairs at hadron colliders

Y. Afik, Yevgeny Kats, Juan Ramón Muñoz de Nova +2 more

It has been shown that entanglement and Bell nonlocality, which are key concepts in quantum mechanics, can be probed in high-energy colliders via processes of fundamental particle scattering. In fact, the ATLAS and CMS Collaborations have measured entanglement using top-quark pairs produced in proton-proton collisions at the LHC. Recently, it was shown that spin correlations can be measured in pairs of bottom quarks at the LHC, despite the fact that bottom quarks, unlike top quarks, hadronize before decaying. Here, we demonstrate that quantum correlations can also be studied using bottom-quark pairs, and analyze the feasibility of the observation of entanglement and Bell nonlocality in several collider experiments. Given the low mass of the bottom quark relative to typical energies accessible at the LHC, many of the bottom-quark pairs are in the ultrarelativistic regime, where they can exhibit strong spin entanglement. We find that entanglement of bottom-quark pairs may be measurable even with the LHC Run 2 data, especially with the CMS B parking dataset, while observation of Bell nonlocality may become feasible at the high-luminosity phase of the LHC.

arXiv:2406.04402•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•May 29, 2025•24 citations

Observation of quantum entanglement in top quark pairs at the ATLAS experiment

Baptiste Ravina

The ATLAS Collaboration has recently announced the first observation of quantum entanglement in top quark pair production at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). This work briefly reviews the experimental status of top quark pair spin correlations and highlights the distinctions between classical and quantum correlations. A proposed criterion for detecting spin entanglement in top quark pairs is outlined, along with the experimental strategy to observe this effect, culminating in the positive results of the ATLAS measurement.

arXiv:2410.04590•Annual Conference on Large Hadron Collider Physics (LHCP)•Dec 20, 2024•1 citation

Quantumness of top quark pairs produced at LHC within SMEFT framework

Amir Subba, Yu Shi

Top and anti-top quark pair production at LHC provides a unique setting to probe non-classical correlations at the TeV scale. We study quantum information (QI) properties of the $t\bar{t}$ spin state in $pp$ collisions at $\sqrt{s}=13$ TeV within the Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT), focusing on dimension-6 operators that induce anomalous chromo- and weak dipole moments of the top quark within their current experimental bounds. The $t\bar{t}$ spin density matrix is reconstructed from the joint angular distribution of the final state charged leptons in the $k$-$r$-$n$ helicity basis. We analyze three complementary QI quantities: concurrence-based quantum entanglement (QE), geometric quantum discord (GQD), and the Bell parameter,across four $t\bar{t}$ invariant-mass bins. Within the Standard Model (SM), non-vanishing QE appears only near threshold ($m_{t\bar{t}}\lesssim 400$ GeV), while GQD remains nonzero across the full phase space, indicating persistent non-classical correlations even for separable states. Anomalous chromo-dipole interactions modify these observables primarily near threshold: $\hatμ_t$ induces asymmetric shifts, whereas $\hat{d}_t$ produces a mild symmetric response without Bell inequality violation. Among weak dipole operators, the CP-even coupling $C_2^V$ generates the largest deformation of the QI observables, while $ΔC_1^{A,V}$ leave them unchanged. These results demonstrate that QI observables derived from the $t\bar{t}$ spin density matrix provide a complementary probe of anomalous top-quark interactions with distinct sensitivity to CP-even and CP-odd operator structures.

arXiv:2605.12033•May 12, 2026•0 citations

Measuring quantum discord at the LHC

Tao Han, Matthew Low, Navin McGinnis +1 more

A bstract There has been an increasing interest in exploring quantities associated with quantum information at colliders. We perform a detailed analysis describing how to measure the quantum discord in the top anti-top quantum state at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). While for pure states, quantum discord, entanglement, and Bell nonlocality all probe the same correlations, for mixed states they probe different aspects of quantum correlations. The quantum discord, in particular, is interesting because it aims to encapsulate all correlations between systems that cannot have a classical origin. We employ two complementary approaches for the study of the top anti-top system, namely the decay method and the kinematic method. We highlight subtleties associated with measuring discord for reconstructed quantum states at colliders. Usually quantum discord is difficult to compute due to an extremization that must be performed. We show, however, that for the $$ t\overline{t} $$ t t ¯ system this extremization can be performed analytically and we provide closed-form formulas for the quantum discord. We demonstrate that with current LHC datasets, quantum discord can be observed at 3 . 6 – 5 . 7 σ , depending on the signal region, with the decay method and can be measured at a precision of 0 . 1 – 0 . 2% with the kinematic method. At the high luminosity LHC, the observation of quantum discord is expected to be > 5 σ using both the decay and kinematic methods and can be measured with a precision of 5% with the decay method and 0 . 05% with the kinematic method. Additionally, we identify the kinematic cuts at the LHC to isolate the $$ t\overline{t} $$ t t ¯ state that is separable but has non-zero discord. By systematically investigating quantum discord for the first time through a detailed collider analysis, this work expands the toolkit for quantum information studies in particle physics and lays the groundwork for deeper insights into the quantum properties in high-energy collisions.

arXiv:2412.21158•Journal of High Energy Physics•May 9, 2025•27 citations
Recent results from the Large Hadron Collider have demonstrated quantum entanglement of top quark-antiquark pairs using the spin degrees of freedom. Based on the doubly differential measurement of the spin density matrix of the top quark and antiquark performed by the CMS collaboration in the helicity and beam bases, we evaluate a set of quantum observables, including discord, steerability, Bell correlation, and magic. These observables allow for a quantitative characterization of the quantum correlations present in a top quark-antiquark system, thus enabling an interpretation of collider data in terms of quantum states and their properties. Discord is observed to be greater than zero with a significance of more than 5 standard deviations (σσσ) in several regions of phase space, some of which correspond to separable quantum states. Evidence for steerability is established for the first time in a high-energy system, with a significance of more than 3σσσ. No Bell correlation is observed within the currently probed phase space, in agreement with the theoretical prediction. These results experimentally corroborate the hierarchy of quantum correlations in top quarks with discord being the most basic form of quantum correlation, followed by entanglement, steerability, and Bell correlation. The significance of nonzero magic, which is a complementary observable to the quantum correlation hierarchy, is found to exceed 5σσσ in several regions of phase space.
Measurements of top quark properties in CMS: ttˉt\bar{t}ttˉ spin density matrix, quantum entanglement and quantum magic
Polarization and spin correlation measurements of top quark-antiquark (ttˉt\bar{t}ttˉ) pairs provide tests of the standard model, but also new ways to test quantum mechanics with unstable particles at highest energies ever produced in a laboratory. Recent ttˉt\bar{t}ttˉ spin correlation measurements and the tests they enable, made with the CMS detector at the CERN LHC Run 2, are presented. The measurements summarized include the full spin density matrix measurement of top quark pairs using events with a single lepton and jets in the final state. Spin correlation measurements in specific phase space regions allow the observation of the entanglement phenomenon, and the measurement of quantum magic. From the measured spin correlation at the ttˉt\bar{t}ttˉ production threshold and high ttˉt\bar{t}ttˉ mass, entanglement is observed with a large fraction of the ttˉt\bar{t}ttˉ decays being spacelike separated. The observation of entanglement in ttˉt\bar{t}ttˉ events with two high transverse momentum leptons of opposite charge is also presented. Finally, the first TeV-scale experimental measurement of quantum magic, an important variable for the characterization of quantum states in quantum information science, is presented. These measurements provide one of the first connections between quantum information science and particle physics, and show the potential of collider experiments in the studies of the foundations of quantum mechanics.
We investigate quantum coherence in the spin degrees of freedom of top--antitop pairs produced at the LHC using the l1l_1l1​-norm of coherence in the helicity basis. Combining Standard Model predictions with the spin density matrix reconstructed from the CMS measurement of top-quark spin correlation coefficients, we study the dependence of coherence on the invariant mass MttˉM_{t\bar t}Mttˉ​ and production angle. To quantify the experimental precision of the extracted coherence, we propagate the measured uncertainties and covariance matrix of the spin-correlation coefficients through a Monte Carlo procedure. We find a non-monotonic kinematic dependence: coherence is large near the production threshold, is reduced in the intermediate-mass region, and increases again in boosted central events. The theoretical predictions are in good agreement with the CMS determinations in all three kinematic regions. Moreover, the experimentally reconstructed coherence is nonzero with a significance exceeding 5σ5σ5σ in each region. In particular, in the intermediate-mass region, 400<Mttˉ<600 GeV400<M_{t\bar t}<600~\mathrm{GeV}400<Mttˉ​<600 GeV, we obtain Cl1=0.597±0.037C_{l_1}=0.597\pm0.037Cl1​​=0.597±0.037. This result is especially noteworthy because previous analyses of the same reconstructed top-quark spin density matrix found concurrence and negativity, both entanglement measures, to be consistent with zero, 0.00±0.020.00\pm0.020.00±0.02, in this kinematic region. The persistence of sizable coherence where entanglement is not experimentally certified demonstrates that coherence provides complementary information on the off-diagonal helicity-interference structure of the top-quark spin density matrix. Our results establish quantum coherence as an experimentally accessible and statistically robust observable for probing the quantum structure of top-quark pair production at the LHC.
It has been shown that entanglement and Bell nonlocality, which are key concepts in quantum mechanics, can be probed in high-energy colliders via processes of fundamental particle scattering. In fact, the ATLAS and CMS Collaborations have measured entanglement using top-quark pairs produced in proton-proton collisions at the LHC. Recently, it was shown that spin correlations can be measured in pairs of bottom quarks at the LHC, despite the fact that bottom quarks, unlike top quarks, hadronize before decaying. Here, we demonstrate that quantum correlations can also be studied using bottom-quark pairs, and analyze the feasibility of the observation of entanglement and Bell nonlocality in several collider experiments. Given the low mass of the bottom quark relative to typical energies accessible at the LHC, many of the bottom-quark pairs are in the ultrarelativistic regime, where they can exhibit strong spin entanglement. We find that entanglement of bottom-quark pairs may be measurable even with the LHC Run 2 data, especially with the CMS B parking dataset, while observation of Bell nonlocality may become feasible at the high-luminosity phase of the LHC.
The ATLAS Collaboration has recently announced the first observation of quantum entanglement in top quark pair production at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). This work briefly reviews the experimental status of top quark pair spin correlations and highlights the distinctions between classical and quantum correlations. A proposed criterion for detecting spin entanglement in top quark pairs is outlined, along with the experimental strategy to observe this effect, culminating in the positive results of the ATLAS measurement.
Top and anti-top quark pair production at LHC provides a unique setting to probe non-classical correlations at the TeV scale. We study quantum information (QI) properties of the ttˉt\bar{t}ttˉ spin state in pppppp collisions at s=13\sqrt{s}=13s​=13 TeV within the Standard Model Effective Field Theory (SMEFT), focusing on dimension-6 operators that induce anomalous chromo- and weak dipole moments of the top quark within their current experimental bounds. The ttˉt\bar{t}ttˉ spin density matrix is reconstructed from the joint angular distribution of the final state charged leptons in the kkk-rrr-nnn helicity basis. We analyze three complementary QI quantities: concurrence-based quantum entanglement (QE), geometric quantum discord (GQD), and the Bell parameter,across four ttˉt\bar{t}ttˉ invariant-mass bins. Within the Standard Model (SM), non-vanishing QE appears only near threshold (mttˉ≲400m_{t\bar{t}}\lesssim 400mttˉ​≲400 GeV), while GQD remains nonzero across the full phase space, indicating persistent non-classical correlations even for separable states. Anomalous chromo-dipole interactions modify these observables primarily near threshold: μ^t\hatμ_tμ^​t​ induces asymmetric shifts, whereas d^t\hat{d}_td^t​ produces a mild symmetric response without Bell inequality violation. Among weak dipole operators, the CP-even coupling C2VC_2^VC2V​ generates the largest deformation of the QI observables, while ΔC1A,VΔC_1^{A,V}ΔC1A,V​ leave them unchanged. These results demonstrate that QI observables derived from the ttˉt\bar{t}ttˉ spin density matrix provide a complementary probe of anomalous top-quark interactions with distinct sensitivity to CP-even and CP-odd operator structures.
A bstract There has been an increasing interest in exploring quantities associated with quantum information at colliders. We perform a detailed analysis describing how to measure the quantum discord in the top anti-top quantum state at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). While for pure states, quantum discord, entanglement, and Bell nonlocality all probe the same correlations, for mixed states they probe different aspects of quantum correlations. The quantum discord, in particular, is interesting because it aims to encapsulate all correlations between systems that cannot have a classical origin. We employ two complementary approaches for the study of the top anti-top system, namely the decay method and the kinematic method. We highlight subtleties associated with measuring discord for reconstructed quantum states at colliders. Usually quantum discord is difficult to compute due to an extremization that must be performed. We show, however, that for the tt‾ t\overline{t} tt t t ¯ system this extremization can be performed analytically and we provide closed-form formulas for the quantum discord. We demonstrate that with current LHC datasets, quantum discord can be observed at 3 . 6 – 5 . 7 σ , depending on the signal region, with the decay method and can be measured at a precision of 0 . 1 – 0 . 2% with the kinematic method. At the high luminosity LHC, the observation of quantum discord is expected to be > 5 σ using both the decay and kinematic methods and can be measured with a precision of 5% with the decay method and 0 . 05% with the kinematic method. Additionally, we identify the kinematic cuts at the LHC to isolate the tt‾ t\overline{t} tt t t ¯ state that is separable but has non-zero discord. By systematically investigating quantum discord for the first time through a detailed collider analysis, this work expands the toolkit for quantum information studies in particle physics and lays the groundwork for deeper insights into the quantum properties in high-energy collisions.