Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2510.17490

A Variance-Based Convergence Criterion in Neural Variational Monte Carlo for Quantum Systems

Shi, Huan-Chen, Er-Liang Cui, Dan Zhou

Published Oct 20, 2025• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The optimization of neural wave functions in variational Monte Carlo crucially relies on a robust convergence criterion. While the energy variance is theoretically a definitive measure, its practical application as a primary convergence criterion has been underexplored. In this work, we develop a lightweight, general-purpose solver that utilizes the energy variance as a convergence criterion. We apply it to several systems-including the harmonic oscillator, hydrogen atom, and charmonium hadron-for validating the variance as a reliable diagnostic, and using a empirical threshold $10^{-3}$ as the energy variance convergence values for performing rapid parameter scans to enable preliminary physical verification. To clarify the scope of our approach, we derive an inequality that delineates the limitations of variance-based optimization in nodal systems. Despite these limitations, the energy variance proves to be a highly valuable tool, guiding our solver to efficient and reliable results across a range of quantum problems.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2510.17490

Related papers

Variance extrapolation method for neural-network variational Monte Carlo

Weizhong Fu, Weiluo Ren, Ji Chen

Abstract Constructing more expressive ansatz has been a primary focus for quantum Monte Carlo, aimed at more accurate ab initio calculations. However, with more powerful ansatz, e.g. various recent developed models based on neural-network architectures, the training becomes more difficult and expensive, which may have a counterproductive effect on the accuracy of calculation. In this work, we propose to make use of the training data to perform empirical variance extrapolation when using neural-network ansatz in variational Monte Carlo. We show that this approach can speed up the convergence and surpass the ansatz limitation to obtain an improved estimation of the energy. Moreover, variance extrapolation greatly enhances the error cancellation capability, resulting in significantly improved relative energy outcomes, which are the keys to chemistry and physics problems.

arXiv:2308.02471•Machine Learning Science and Technology•Jan 17, 2024•13 citations

The Forgotten History of Wave Function Variance Optimization and its Relevance for Neural-Network VMC

Dario Bressanini

We revisit the almost century-old question of which functional of the local energy best optimizes a trial wave function, a problem of central importance in Variational Monte Carlo (VMC) and, more recently, in Neural-Network VMC (NN-VMC). While variance optimization dates back to the 1930s, the high statistical noise and heavy-tailed local energy distributions inherent to modern neural-network wave functions have renewed interest in this approach. We retrace its long and largely forgotten history here, showing its direct relevance to modern Neural Quantum States (NQS) frameworks. Minimizing the variance (an $L^2$ norm) implicitly assumes a Gaussian local energy distribution: an unjustified assumption. For Coulombic systems, the local energy distribution exhibits $E^{-4}$ power-law tails, causing the Central Limit Theorem to fail for the variance estimator. This instability can be mitigated by robust cost functions: the Mean Absolute Deviation (MAD, an $L^1$ norm), the Cauchy loss, or the $L_{-4}$ functional, which features a tail analytically designed to match the $E^{-4}$ exponent. We benchmark these functionals on $H_2^+$, an exactly solvable system at every internuclear distance, using the Guillemin-Zener wave function across the full potential energy curve. While energy minimization by construction yields the lowest energy, variance minimization is surpassed at every $R$ by alternative functionals: MAD proves superior in the bonding region, while $L_{-4}$ performs best in the dissociation regime.

quant-pharXiv:2609.08453•Sep 9, 2026•0 citations

Variational Principles in Quantum Monte Carlo: The Troubled Story of Variance Minimization

Alice Cuzzocrea, Anthony Scemama, Wim J. Briels +2 more

We investigate the use of different variational principles in quantum Monte Carlo, namely, energy and variance minimization, prompted by the interest in the robust and accurate estimation of electronic excited states. For two prototypical, challenging molecules, we readily reach the accuracy of the best available reference excitation energies using energy minimization in a state-specific or state-average fashion for states of different or equal symmetry, respectively. On the other hand, in variance minimization, where the use of suitable functionals is expected to target specific states regardless of the symmetry, we encounter severe problems for a variety of wave functions: as the variance converges, the energy drifts away from that of the selected state. This unexpected behavior is sometimes observed even when the target is the ground state and generally prevents the robust estimation of total and excitation energies. We analyze this problem using a very simple wave function and infer that the optimization finds little or no barrier to escape from a local minimum or local plateau, eventually converging to a lower-variance state instead of the target state. For the increasingly complex systems becoming in reach of quantum Monte Carlo simulations, variance minimization with current functionals appears to be an impractical route.

arXiv:2002.05951•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•May 17, 2020•42 citations

Taming the expressiveness of neural-network wave functions for robust convergence to quantum many-body states

Dezhe Z. Jin

Neural networks are emerging as a powerful tool for determining the quantum states of interacting many-body fermionic systems. The standard approach trains a neural-network ansatz by minimizing the mean local energy estimated from Monte Carlo samples. However, this typically results in large sample-to-sample fluctuations in the estimated mean energy and thus slow convergence of the energy minimization. We propose that minimizing a logarithmically compressed variance of the local energies can dramatically improve convergence. Moreover, this loss function can be adapted to systematically obtain the energy spectrum across multiple runs. We demonstrate these ideas for spin-1/2 particles in a 2D harmonic trap with attractive Poschl-Teller interactions between opposite spins.

cond-mat.supr-conCross-listedarXiv:2603.15853•Mar 18, 2026•1 citation

Is Variational Monte Carlo Robust? Sharp Moment Thresholds and Heavy-tailed Stochastic Optimization

Philipp Grohs, Davide Nobile

Variational Monte Carlo (VMC) is a central algorithm in electronic structure theory and has gained renewed importance through modern neural-network ansätze such as FermiNet. At its core, VMC seeks ground states by minimizing the Rayleigh quotient by stochastic optimization. In this work, we show that the resulting stochastic optimization problem is intrinsically governed by the nodal geometry of the underlying wave function. More precisely, we establish that properties of the nodal set determine the integrability of the local energy and gradient estimators that drive VMC. For broad and practically relevant ansatz classes, including Slater-Jastrow wave functions with variable-exponent Slater-type orbitals, we prove that these estimators are generically heavy-tailed and fail to admit higher moments. At the same time, for general analytic ansätze, we prove weak moment bounds for the relevant estimators and identify precise low-moment regimes, showing how generic and degenerate nodal structures lead to different integrability thresholds. Building on this analysis, we introduce a new robust variant of VMC $\unicode{x2013}$ coined PS-Clip-VMC $\unicode{x2013}$ which is based on clipping both the local energies and the per-sample gradients. We prove that PS-Clip-VMC converges both in expectation and with high probability in the weak moment regime of VMC. The robustness of our method is confirmed experimentally by training FermiNet on atoms with up to 18 electrons.

arXiv:2606.26009•Jun 24, 2026•1 citation

Optimum and efficient sampling for variational quantum Monte Carlo

J. R. Trail, Ryo Maezono

Quantum mechanics for many-body systems may be reduced to the evaluation of integrals in 3N dimensions using Monte Carlo, providing the Quantum Monte Carlo ab initio methods. Here we limit ourselves to expectation values for trial wave functions, that is to variational quantum Monte Carlo. Almost all previous implementations employ samples distributed as the physical probability density of the trial wave function, and assume the central limit theorem to be valid. In this paper we provide an analysis of random error in estimation and optimization that leads naturally to new sampling strategies with improved computational and statistical properties. A rigorous lower limit to the random error is derived, and an efficient sampling strategy presented that significantly increases computational efficiency. In addition the infinite variance heavy tailed random errors of optimum parameters in conventional methods are replaced with a Normal random error, strengthening the theoretical basis of optimization. The method is applied to a number of first row systems and compared with previously published results.

arXiv:1011.4344•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Nov 4, 2010•8 citations
The optimization of neural wave functions in variational Monte Carlo crucially relies on a robust convergence criterion. While the energy variance is theoretically a definitive measure, its practical application as a primary convergence criterion has been underexplored. In this work, we develop a lightweight, general-purpose solver that utilizes the energy variance as a convergence criterion. We apply it to several systems-including the harmonic oscillator, hydrogen atom, and charmonium hadron-for validating the variance as a reliable diagnostic, and using a empirical threshold 10−310^{-3}10−3 as the energy variance convergence values for performing rapid parameter scans to enable preliminary physical verification. To clarify the scope of our approach, we derive an inequality that delineates the limitations of variance-based optimization in nodal systems. Despite these limitations, the energy variance proves to be a highly valuable tool, guiding our solver to efficient and reliable results across a range of quantum problems.
Abstract Constructing more expressive ansatz has been a primary focus for quantum Monte Carlo, aimed at more accurate ab initio calculations. However, with more powerful ansatz, e.g. various recent developed models based on neural-network architectures, the training becomes more difficult and expensive, which may have a counterproductive effect on the accuracy of calculation. In this work, we propose to make use of the training data to perform empirical variance extrapolation when using neural-network ansatz in variational Monte Carlo. We show that this approach can speed up the convergence and surpass the ansatz limitation to obtain an improved estimation of the energy. Moreover, variance extrapolation greatly enhances the error cancellation capability, resulting in significantly improved relative energy outcomes, which are the keys to chemistry and physics problems.
We revisit the almost century-old question of which functional of the local energy best optimizes a trial wave function, a problem of central importance in Variational Monte Carlo (VMC) and, more recently, in Neural-Network VMC (NN-VMC). While variance optimization dates back to the 1930s, the high statistical noise and heavy-tailed local energy distributions inherent to modern neural-network wave functions have renewed interest in this approach. We retrace its long and largely forgotten history here, showing its direct relevance to modern Neural Quantum States (NQS) frameworks. Minimizing the variance (an L2L^2L2 norm) implicitly assumes a Gaussian local energy distribution: an unjustified assumption. For Coulombic systems, the local energy distribution exhibits E−4E^{-4}E−4 power-law tails, causing the Central Limit Theorem to fail for the variance estimator. This instability can be mitigated by robust cost functions: the Mean Absolute Deviation (MAD, an L1L^1L1 norm), the Cauchy loss, or the L−4L_{-4}L−4​ functional, which features a tail analytically designed to match the E−4E^{-4}E−4 exponent. We benchmark these functionals on H2+H_2^+H2+​, an exactly solvable system at every internuclear distance, using the Guillemin-Zener wave function across the full potential energy curve. While energy minimization by construction yields the lowest energy, variance minimization is surpassed at every RRR by alternative functionals: MAD proves superior in the bonding region, while L−4L_{-4}L−4​ performs best in the dissociation regime.
We investigate the use of different variational principles in quantum Monte Carlo, namely, energy and variance minimization, prompted by the interest in the robust and accurate estimation of electronic excited states. For two prototypical, challenging molecules, we readily reach the accuracy of the best available reference excitation energies using energy minimization in a state-specific or state-average fashion for states of different or equal symmetry, respectively. On the other hand, in variance minimization, where the use of suitable functionals is expected to target specific states regardless of the symmetry, we encounter severe problems for a variety of wave functions: as the variance converges, the energy drifts away from that of the selected state. This unexpected behavior is sometimes observed even when the target is the ground state and generally prevents the robust estimation of total and excitation energies. We analyze this problem using a very simple wave function and infer that the optimization finds little or no barrier to escape from a local minimum or local plateau, eventually converging to a lower-variance state instead of the target state. For the increasingly complex systems becoming in reach of quantum Monte Carlo simulations, variance minimization with current functionals appears to be an impractical route.
Neural networks are emerging as a powerful tool for determining the quantum states of interacting many-body fermionic systems. The standard approach trains a neural-network ansatz by minimizing the mean local energy estimated from Monte Carlo samples. However, this typically results in large sample-to-sample fluctuations in the estimated mean energy and thus slow convergence of the energy minimization. We propose that minimizing a logarithmically compressed variance of the local energies can dramatically improve convergence. Moreover, this loss function can be adapted to systematically obtain the energy spectrum across multiple runs. We demonstrate these ideas for spin-1/2 particles in a 2D harmonic trap with attractive Poschl-Teller interactions between opposite spins.
Variational Monte Carlo (VMC) is a central algorithm in electronic structure theory and has gained renewed importance through modern neural-network ansätze such as FermiNet. At its core, VMC seeks ground states by minimizing the Rayleigh quotient by stochastic optimization. In this work, we show that the resulting stochastic optimization problem is intrinsically governed by the nodal geometry of the underlying wave function. More precisely, we establish that properties of the nodal set determine the integrability of the local energy and gradient estimators that drive VMC. For broad and practically relevant ansatz classes, including Slater-Jastrow wave functions with variable-exponent Slater-type orbitals, we prove that these estimators are generically heavy-tailed and fail to admit higher moments. At the same time, for general analytic ansätze, we prove weak moment bounds for the relevant estimators and identify precise low-moment regimes, showing how generic and degenerate nodal structures lead to different integrability thresholds. Building on this analysis, we introduce a new robust variant of VMC $\unicode{x2013}$ coined PS-Clip-VMC $\unicode{x2013}$ which is based on clipping both the local energies and the per-sample gradients. We prove that PS-Clip-VMC converges both in expectation and with high probability in the weak moment regime of VMC. The robustness of our method is confirmed experimentally by training FermiNet on atoms with up to 18 electrons.
Quantum mechanics for many-body systems may be reduced to the evaluation of integrals in 3N dimensions using Monte Carlo, providing the Quantum Monte Carlo ab initio methods. Here we limit ourselves to expectation values for trial wave functions, that is to variational quantum Monte Carlo. Almost all previous implementations employ samples distributed as the physical probability density of the trial wave function, and assume the central limit theorem to be valid. In this paper we provide an analysis of random error in estimation and optimization that leads naturally to new sampling strategies with improved computational and statistical properties. A rigorous lower limit to the random error is derived, and an efficient sampling strategy presented that significantly increases computational efficiency. In addition the infinite variance heavy tailed random errors of optimum parameters in conventional methods are replaced with a Normal random error, strengthening the theoretical basis of optimization. The method is applied to a number of first row systems and compared with previously published results.