Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2509.07745 · Physical Review Research

Testing the problem of time with cold atoms

Giovanni Barontini

Published Apr 29, 2026• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We realize a cold-atom system to quantitatively test relational constructions of time. A well-isolated atomic Bose-Einstein condensate evolves in a conservative trap that is partitioned by a thin optical barrier into an observed and unobserved sector, with negligible dissipation on the experimental timescale. Motivated by relational-time approaches discussed in the Wheeler-DeWitt framework, we ask whether the dynamics of the observed sector can be ordered using only internal degrees of freedom. To this end, we construct an entropic time from an experimentally defined coarse-grained entropy and demonstrate that it can robustly order the events in the observed sector across repeated cycles of expansion and recollapse. We finally derive an effective Schrödinger equation parametrized by this internal time and show that it is able to reproduce the measured evolution. These results establish a controlled experimental setting in which relational-time constructions can be quantitatively tested.

DOI
10.1103/1h9j-df4k

Related papers

Entropic Time from Coarse-Graining: A Testable Prediction in Quantum Error Correction

F.G.A., van den Berg

Description: This paper introduces a thermodynamic time parameter τ = ∫C dt, where C[ρ,𝒜] quantifies the information accessibility of quantum state ρ within observable set 𝒜. We prove that entropy decrease with respect to τ is equivalent to information recovery from inaccessible degrees of freedom—a process realizable in quantum error correction (QEC) cycles. The framework predicts a measurable signature: QEC should exhibit 10-15% fidelity enhancement relative to standard quantum dynamics, arising from negative coarse-graining rates (dC/dt < 0) during syndrome measurement. The time-dependent field C(t) can be reconstructed from fidelity data via C(t) = -(1/Γ) d ln F(t)/dt, providing a falsifiable experimental observable. We present a detailed experimental protocol for trapped-ion systems, achievable with current technology. Statistical discrimination criteria distinguish this effect from conventional mechanisms (non-Markovian baths, leakage errors, SPAM errors, dynamical decoupling). The combined statistical power enables rigorous falsification. This work establishes quantum error correction as a testbed for emergent time dynamics and provides concrete predictions testable with current trapped-ion quantum computing platforms. Key contributions: Theoretical framework linking coarse-graining to emergent time Quantitative prediction: 10-15% fidelity enhancement in QEC Experimental protocol for trapped-ion systems Falsification criteria distinguishing from alternative mechanisms Document type: Preprint / Working Paper Date: December 2025

•Nov 15, 2025•0 citations

Investigating the emergence of time in stationary states with trapped ions

Serge Massar, Philippe Spindel, A. F. Varón +1 more

Even though quantum systems in energy eigenstates do not evolve in time, they can exhibit correlations between internal degrees of freedom in such a way that one of the internal degrees of freedom behaves like a clock variable, and thereby defines an internal time, that parametrizes the evolution of the other degrees of freedom. This situation is of great interest in quantum cosmology where the invariance under reparametrization of time implies that the temporal coordinate dissapears and is replaced by the Wheeler-DeWitt constraint. Here we show that the emergent character of an internal time variable can be investigated experimentally using the exquisite control now available on moderate-size quantum systems. We describe in detail how to implement such an experimental demonstration using the spin and motional degrees of freedom of a single trapped ion.

arXiv:1410.6683•Physical Review A•Sep 21, 2015•10 citations

Relational Emergent Time for Quantum System: A Multi-Observer, Gravitational, and Cosmological Framework

Amir Hossein Ghasemi

We present a relational framework in which temporal structure is not fundamental but emerges from correlations within a globally stationary quantum state. Each subsystem includes an internal clock, and conditional states evolve effectively with respect to these internal readings. The construction naturally extends to relativistic motion, gravitational redshift, and cosmological expansion, leading to a unified emergent-time functional valid across diverse physical regimes. The theory reproduces classical time dilation, predicts correlation-dependent deviations from standard evolution, and suggests that non-interacting or massless particles exhibit negligible internal time. These consequences open directions for conceptual and experimental investigations in the foundations of temporal physics, from multi-clock quantum systems to precision metrology and cosmological settings. In particular, the framework suggests measurable deviation from standard quantum evolution for highly entangled systems and predicts negligible internal time for massless particles.

quant-pharXiv:2512.15789•Dec 17, 2025•3 citations

Emergent Time, Intrinsic Registration, and the Ontological Ground of Physics: A Foundational Dialogue with Barontini's Cold-Atom Test of Relational Time

Ke Luo

The recent rubidium-87 BEC experiment by Barontini and colleagues (Phys. Rev. Research 8, L022047, 2026) provides the first controlled evidence that time can be defined solely by internal entropy exchange within a closed quantum system. This result corroborates the Wheeler–DeWitt equation's prediction that a closed, undifferentiated universe has no fundamental time parameter. A bottom-up analysis suggests, however, that both the experiment and the Wheeler–DeWitt framework share three underexplored features: system partitioning is externally imposed, intrinsic registration dynamics are not included in the fundamental ontology, and no mechanism connects the globally timeless substrate to locally temporal subsystems. Engaging these as open questions, we sketch a working hypothesis—Fundamental Consciousness Energy (FCE)—positing a non-material, non-local, intrinsically superpositional primitive as a candidate ground for the missing dynamics. This hypothesis reinterprets the experimental findings as local manifestations of a deeper architecture where time emerges from spontaneous differentiation and self-referential registration. Two falsifiable expectations, executable on the existing BEC apparatus, are proposed. A tentative formalization path suggests how FCE might be anchored in established structures—Connes–Rovelli thermal time, Page–Wootters formalism, and self-referential quantum theory—without claiming unification. The Barontini results are compatible with FCE dynamics, without implying the experiment was designed to confirm them.

•Jun 24, 2026•0 citations

Tunneling Dynamics of a Bose-Einstein Condensate

Shreyas Potnis

The simplicity and versatility of ultra-cold atoms make it an ideal system for studying Quantum Mechanical phenomenon like tunneling. This thesis describes progress towards experimentally measuring the time spent by a tunneling particle in the classically forbidden region. A detailed analysis of the experimental requirements to measure the tunneling time is presented along with the experimental tools developed to meet these requirements. These include a thin \SI{1.3}{\micro m} optical tunnel barrier, a smooth atomic waveguide, and a Larmor clock to measure the tunneling time. Delta-kick cooling is used to achieve the extremely low temperatures required for the tunneling time experiments. A 2.4x reduction in the atomic velocity spread is demonstrated, reducing the rms velocity spread to \SI{0.46(5)}{mm/s}. This corresponds to cooling to an effective temperature of \SI{2.0(4)}{nK}. The thin optical barrier opens up the possibility to study the decay of quasi-bound condensates via tunneling. We develop a novel trapping configuration for this purpose, in which the barrier acts as one of the walls of the trap. Inter-atomic interactions strongly dictate the escape dynamics of the condensate out of this trap, giving rise to three distinct regimes--- classical over the barrier spilling, quantum tunneling driven by interactions, and decay dominated by background losses. We show that in the tunneling regime, the decay rate depends exponentially with the chemical potential of the condensate. Experimental results show good agreement with numerical solutions of the 3D Gross-Pitaevskii equation.

•Jun 1, 2016•1 citation

Time Without Time: A Dual Clock Interferometric Search for Operational Time Anomalies

Norbert Levente Kis

Time is not a fundamental coordinate but a relation: all physical dynamics are defined on a timeless, global state space, and what we call “time” is the ordered relation between a chosen reference clock and the rest of the system. Formulate the above relational time postulate in an operationally minimal framework aligned with Wheeler–DeWitt constraint dynamics and the Page–Wootters construction, derive a concrete, testable prediction, when the same physical process is parametrized by two physically different “clocks” (e.g. an optical atomic clock and a mechanical phase clock), a small but measurable phase discrepancy can appear after all known effects are calibrated, if time is purely relational, propose a dual-clock interferometric experiment, and present an analytic sensitivity study. Our framework reproduces GR+QM in the ideal clock limit, yet allows for an operational deviation encoded by two dimensionless parameters. A null result yields new upper bounds across disparate frequency bands. A positive, replicated signal would provide the first operational evidence for “time without time”. This document is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. The specific measurement protocol described herein, the unique ϵ and χ parametrization, and the associated data analysis algorithms constitute intellectual property. Any experimental realization or software implementation of the mathematical model is subject to the prior written consent of the author.

•Feb 5, 2026•0 citations
We realize a cold-atom system to quantitatively test relational constructions of time. A well-isolated atomic Bose-Einstein condensate evolves in a conservative trap that is partitioned by a thin optical barrier into an observed and unobserved sector, with negligible dissipation on the experimental timescale. Motivated by relational-time approaches discussed in the Wheeler-DeWitt framework, we ask whether the dynamics of the observed sector can be ordered using only internal degrees of freedom. To this end, we construct an entropic time from an experimentally defined coarse-grained entropy and demonstrate that it can robustly order the events in the observed sector across repeated cycles of expansion and recollapse. We finally derive an effective Schrödinger equation parametrized by this internal time and show that it is able to reproduce the measured evolution. These results establish a controlled experimental setting in which relational-time constructions can be quantitatively tested.
Description: This paper introduces a thermodynamic time parameter τ = ∫C dt, where C[ρ,𝒜] quantifies the information accessibility of quantum state ρ within observable set 𝒜. We prove that entropy decrease with respect to τ is equivalent to information recovery from inaccessible degrees of freedom—a process realizable in quantum error correction (QEC) cycles. The framework predicts a measurable signature: QEC should exhibit 10-15% fidelity enhancement relative to standard quantum dynamics, arising from negative coarse-graining rates (dC/dt < 0) during syndrome measurement. The time-dependent field C(t) can be reconstructed from fidelity data via C(t) = -(1/Γ) d ln F(t)/dt, providing a falsifiable experimental observable. We present a detailed experimental protocol for trapped-ion systems, achievable with current technology. Statistical discrimination criteria distinguish this effect from conventional mechanisms (non-Markovian baths, leakage errors, SPAM errors, dynamical decoupling). The combined statistical power enables rigorous falsification. This work establishes quantum error correction as a testbed for emergent time dynamics and provides concrete predictions testable with current trapped-ion quantum computing platforms. Key contributions: Theoretical framework linking coarse-graining to emergent time Quantitative prediction: 10-15% fidelity enhancement in QEC Experimental protocol for trapped-ion systems Falsification criteria distinguishing from alternative mechanisms Document type: Preprint / Working Paper Date: December 2025
Even though quantum systems in energy eigenstates do not evolve in time, they can exhibit correlations between internal degrees of freedom in such a way that one of the internal degrees of freedom behaves like a clock variable, and thereby defines an internal time, that parametrizes the evolution of the other degrees of freedom. This situation is of great interest in quantum cosmology where the invariance under reparametrization of time implies that the temporal coordinate dissapears and is replaced by the Wheeler-DeWitt constraint. Here we show that the emergent character of an internal time variable can be investigated experimentally using the exquisite control now available on moderate-size quantum systems. We describe in detail how to implement such an experimental demonstration using the spin and motional degrees of freedom of a single trapped ion.
We present a relational framework in which temporal structure is not fundamental but emerges from correlations within a globally stationary quantum state. Each subsystem includes an internal clock, and conditional states evolve effectively with respect to these internal readings. The construction naturally extends to relativistic motion, gravitational redshift, and cosmological expansion, leading to a unified emergent-time functional valid across diverse physical regimes. The theory reproduces classical time dilation, predicts correlation-dependent deviations from standard evolution, and suggests that non-interacting or massless particles exhibit negligible internal time. These consequences open directions for conceptual and experimental investigations in the foundations of temporal physics, from multi-clock quantum systems to precision metrology and cosmological settings. In particular, the framework suggests measurable deviation from standard quantum evolution for highly entangled systems and predicts negligible internal time for massless particles.
The recent rubidium-87 BEC experiment by Barontini and colleagues (Phys. Rev. Research 8, L022047, 2026) provides the first controlled evidence that time can be defined solely by internal entropy exchange within a closed quantum system. This result corroborates the Wheeler–DeWitt equation's prediction that a closed, undifferentiated universe has no fundamental time parameter. A bottom-up analysis suggests, however, that both the experiment and the Wheeler–DeWitt framework share three underexplored features: system partitioning is externally imposed, intrinsic registration dynamics are not included in the fundamental ontology, and no mechanism connects the globally timeless substrate to locally temporal subsystems. Engaging these as open questions, we sketch a working hypothesis—Fundamental Consciousness Energy (FCE)—positing a non-material, non-local, intrinsically superpositional primitive as a candidate ground for the missing dynamics. This hypothesis reinterprets the experimental findings as local manifestations of a deeper architecture where time emerges from spontaneous differentiation and self-referential registration. Two falsifiable expectations, executable on the existing BEC apparatus, are proposed. A tentative formalization path suggests how FCE might be anchored in established structures—Connes–Rovelli thermal time, Page–Wootters formalism, and self-referential quantum theory—without claiming unification. The Barontini results are compatible with FCE dynamics, without implying the experiment was designed to confirm them.
The simplicity and versatility of ultra-cold atoms make it an ideal system for studying Quantum Mechanical phenomenon like tunneling. This thesis describes progress towards experimentally measuring the time spent by a tunneling particle in the classically forbidden region. A detailed analysis of the experimental requirements to measure the tunneling time is presented along with the experimental tools developed to meet these requirements. These include a thin \SI{1.3}{\micro m} optical tunnel barrier, a smooth atomic waveguide, and a Larmor clock to measure the tunneling time. Delta-kick cooling is used to achieve the extremely low temperatures required for the tunneling time experiments. A 2.4x reduction in the atomic velocity spread is demonstrated, reducing the rms velocity spread to \SI{0.46(5)}{mm/s}. This corresponds to cooling to an effective temperature of \SI{2.0(4)}{nK}. The thin optical barrier opens up the possibility to study the decay of quasi-bound condensates via tunneling. We develop a novel trapping configuration for this purpose, in which the barrier acts as one of the walls of the trap. Inter-atomic interactions strongly dictate the escape dynamics of the condensate out of this trap, giving rise to three distinct regimes--- classical over the barrier spilling, quantum tunneling driven by interactions, and decay dominated by background losses. We show that in the tunneling regime, the decay rate depends exponentially with the chemical potential of the condensate. Experimental results show good agreement with numerical solutions of the 3D Gross-Pitaevskii equation.
Time is not a fundamental coordinate but a relation: all physical dynamics are defined on a timeless, global state space, and what we call “time” is the ordered relation between a chosen reference clock and the rest of the system. Formulate the above relational time postulate in an operationally minimal framework aligned with Wheeler–DeWitt constraint dynamics and the Page–Wootters construction, derive a concrete, testable prediction, when the same physical process is parametrized by two physically different “clocks” (e.g. an optical atomic clock and a mechanical phase clock), a small but measurable phase discrepancy can appear after all known effects are calibrated, if time is purely relational, propose a dual-clock interferometric experiment, and present an analytic sensitivity study. Our framework reproduces GR+QM in the ideal clock limit, yet allows for an operational deviation encoded by two dimensionless parameters. A null result yields new upper bounds across disparate frequency bands. A positive, replicated signal would provide the first operational evidence for “time without time”. This document is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. The specific measurement protocol described herein, the unique ϵ and χ parametrization, and the associated data analysis algorithms constitute intellectual property. Any experimental realization or software implementation of the mathematical model is subject to the prior written consent of the author.