Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1410.6683 · Physical Review A

Investigating the emergence of time in stationary states with trapped ions

Serge Massar, Philippe Spindel, A. F. Varón, Christof Wunderlich

Published Sep 21, 2015• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Even though quantum systems in energy eigenstates do not evolve in time, they can exhibit correlations between internal degrees of freedom in such a way that one of the internal degrees of freedom behaves like a clock variable, and thereby defines an internal time, that parametrizes the evolution of the other degrees of freedom. This situation is of great interest in quantum cosmology where the invariance under reparametrization of time implies that the temporal coordinate dissapears and is replaced by the Wheeler-DeWitt constraint. Here we show that the emergent character of an internal time variable can be investigated experimentally using the exquisite control now available on moderate-size quantum systems. We describe in detail how to implement such an experimental demonstration using the spin and motional degrees of freedom of a single trapped ion.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.92.030102

Related papers

Interpretation of time-reparametrization-invariant quantum mechanics: An exactly soluble model

Ian D. Lawrie, Richard J. Epp

The classical and quantum dynamics of simple time-reparametrization-invariant models containing two degrees of freedom are studied in detail. Elimination of one ``clock'' variable through the Hamiltonian constraint leads to a description of time evolution for the remaining variable which is essentially equivalent to the standard quantum mechanics of an unconstrained system. In contrast with a similar proposal of Rovelli, evolution is with respect to a geometrical proper time, and the Heisenberg equation of motion is exact. The physical phase space contains no coordinate associated with the eliminated ``clock'' variable. Therefore, time evolution is not with respect to the observable readings of a physical clock. Rather, the eliminated variable can be construed as intrinsic to a particular observer, and, hence, as unobservable, in principle, by this observer. The possibility of a ``test clock,'' which would reveal time evolution while contributing negligibly to the Hamiltonian constraint, is examined, and found to be viable in the semiclassical limit of large quantum numbers. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

arXiv:gr-qc/9509047•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jun 15, 1996•11 citations

Testing the problem of time with cold atoms

Giovanni Barontini

We realize a cold-atom system to quantitatively test relational constructions of time. A well-isolated atomic Bose-Einstein condensate evolves in a conservative trap that is partitioned by a thin optical barrier into an observed and unobserved sector, with negligible dissipation on the experimental timescale. Motivated by relational-time approaches discussed in the Wheeler-DeWitt framework, we ask whether the dynamics of the observed sector can be ordered using only internal degrees of freedom. To this end, we construct an entropic time from an experimentally defined coarse-grained entropy and demonstrate that it can robustly order the events in the observed sector across repeated cycles of expansion and recollapse. We finally derive an effective Schrödinger equation parametrized by this internal time and show that it is able to reproduce the measured evolution. These results establish a controlled experimental setting in which relational-time constructions can be quantitatively tested.

arXiv:2509.07745•Physical Review Research•Apr 29, 2026•8 citations

Relational Emergent Time for Quantum System: A Multi-Observer, Gravitational, and Cosmological Framework

Amir Hossein Ghasemi

We present a relational framework in which temporal structure is not fundamental but emerges from correlations within a globally stationary quantum state. Each subsystem includes an internal clock, and conditional states evolve effectively with respect to these internal readings. The construction naturally extends to relativistic motion, gravitational redshift, and cosmological expansion, leading to a unified emergent-time functional valid across diverse physical regimes. The theory reproduces classical time dilation, predicts correlation-dependent deviations from standard evolution, and suggests that non-interacting or massless particles exhibit negligible internal time. These consequences open directions for conceptual and experimental investigations in the foundations of temporal physics, from multi-clock quantum systems to precision metrology and cosmological settings. In particular, the framework suggests measurable deviation from standard quantum evolution for highly entangled systems and predicts negligible internal time for massless particles.

quant-pharXiv:2512.15789•Dec 17, 2025•3 citations

Internal clock formulation of quantum mechanics

Przemysław Małkiewicz, Artur Miroszewski

The basic tenet of the present work is the assumption of the lack of external and fixed time in the Universe. This assumption is best embodied by general relativity, which replaces the fixed space-time structure with the gravitational field, which is subject to dynamics. The lack of time does not imply the lack of evolution but rather brings to the forefront the role of internal clocks which are some largely arbitrary internal degrees of freedom with respect to which the evolution of timeless systems can be described. We take this idea seriously and try to understand what it implies for quantum mechanics when the fixed external time is replaced by an arbitrary internal clock. We put the issue in a solid, mathematically rigorous framework. We find that the dynamical interpretation of a quantum state of a timeless system depends on the employed internal clock. In particular, we find that the continuous spectra of well-known dynamical observables like the position of a free particle on the real line may turn discrete if measured in unusual clocks. We discuss the meaning of our result for attempts at quantization of global gravitational degrees of freedom.

arXiv:1706.00743•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Aug 7, 2017•17 citations

Clock Time in Quantum Cosmology

Marcello Rotondo, Yasusada Nambu

We consider the conditioning of the timeless solution to the Wheeler–DeWitt equation by a predefined matter clock state in the simple scenario of an FLRW universe. The resulting evolution of the geometrodynamical degree of freedom with respect to clock time is characterized by the “Berry connection” of the reduced geometrodynamical space, which relies on the coupling of the clock with the geometry. When the connection vanishes, the standard Schrödinger equation is obtained for the geometry with respect to clock time. When one considers environment-induced decoherence in the semiclassical limit, this condition is satisfied, and clock time coincides with cosmic time. Explicit results for the conditioned wave functions for minimal clocks made up of two quantum harmonic oscillator eigenstates are shown.

arXiv:1901.02767•Universe•Feb 22, 2019•11 citations

Particle creation and memory effects in a trapped ion quantum simulator

Matthias Wittemer

The fundamental laws of quantum mechanics are far from our everyday life experiences. However, they have been extremely successful in explaining observations in microscopic physical systems and are, already, harnessed for several applications. Moreover, in combination with relativistic considerations, basic phenomena from quantum mechanics are accredited a central role in the (macroscopic) evolution of our universe. In this thesis, we employ a trapped ion quantum simulator to experimentally investigate two fundamental quantum mechanical effects that have been extensively studied for many decades. In the first investigation, we implement non-adiabatic changes of the ions’ trapping potential in order to amplify quantum vacuum fluctuations. Following theoretical works by others, this mechanism can be interpreted as an analog to the creation of particles during cosmic inflation in the early universe. Such cosmological particles are considered as the seeds for the formation of the large-scale structures in our universe that we observe nowadays. In our analog quantum simulation, the creation of particles is evidenced by the detection of a squeezed state in the motion of the ions. A remarkable feature of this mechanism is the accompanying creation of quantum entanglement. In case of the cosmological particles, this entanglement spreads over large, cosmic distances. In the second investigation, we benchmark a theoretical concept in the framework of open quantum systems in a most basic system and under near-ideal conditions. In nature, any quantum system inevitably interacts with its environment and, thereby, needs ultimately to be considered an open system that can build up correlations and, even, entanglement with its environment. We implement a spin-1/2 system in the electronic degree of freedom of a single trapped ion, which we couple to a bosonic environment, formed by a motional degree of freedom of the ion. Further, we implement a tunable interaction between system and environment that, in turn, can lead to entanglement. By performing measurements on the open system only, we observe quantum non-Markovian behavior, which we quantify using a rigorously defined measure. Thereby, we reveal that the quantification of such quantum memory effects is fundamentally limited by fundamental quantum mechanical measurement uncertainties. The investigations presented in this thesis significantly expand the capabilities of our trapped ion platform to perform analog quantum simulations of fundamental quantum mechanical problems under near-ideal conditions, and enable future studies of increased complexity and under more realistic conditions.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations
Even though quantum systems in energy eigenstates do not evolve in time, they can exhibit correlations between internal degrees of freedom in such a way that one of the internal degrees of freedom behaves like a clock variable, and thereby defines an internal time, that parametrizes the evolution of the other degrees of freedom. This situation is of great interest in quantum cosmology where the invariance under reparametrization of time implies that the temporal coordinate dissapears and is replaced by the Wheeler-DeWitt constraint. Here we show that the emergent character of an internal time variable can be investigated experimentally using the exquisite control now available on moderate-size quantum systems. We describe in detail how to implement such an experimental demonstration using the spin and motional degrees of freedom of a single trapped ion.
The classical and quantum dynamics of simple time-reparametrization-invariant models containing two degrees of freedom are studied in detail. Elimination of one ``clock'' variable through the Hamiltonian constraint leads to a description of time evolution for the remaining variable which is essentially equivalent to the standard quantum mechanics of an unconstrained system. In contrast with a similar proposal of Rovelli, evolution is with respect to a geometrical proper time, and the Heisenberg equation of motion is exact. The physical phase space contains no coordinate associated with the eliminated ``clock'' variable. Therefore, time evolution is not with respect to the observable readings of a physical clock. Rather, the eliminated variable can be construed as intrinsic to a particular observer, and, hence, as unobservable, in principle, by this observer. The possibility of a ``test clock,'' which would reveal time evolution while contributing negligibly to the Hamiltonian constraint, is examined, and found to be viable in the semiclassical limit of large quantum numbers. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
We realize a cold-atom system to quantitatively test relational constructions of time. A well-isolated atomic Bose-Einstein condensate evolves in a conservative trap that is partitioned by a thin optical barrier into an observed and unobserved sector, with negligible dissipation on the experimental timescale. Motivated by relational-time approaches discussed in the Wheeler-DeWitt framework, we ask whether the dynamics of the observed sector can be ordered using only internal degrees of freedom. To this end, we construct an entropic time from an experimentally defined coarse-grained entropy and demonstrate that it can robustly order the events in the observed sector across repeated cycles of expansion and recollapse. We finally derive an effective Schrödinger equation parametrized by this internal time and show that it is able to reproduce the measured evolution. These results establish a controlled experimental setting in which relational-time constructions can be quantitatively tested.
We present a relational framework in which temporal structure is not fundamental but emerges from correlations within a globally stationary quantum state. Each subsystem includes an internal clock, and conditional states evolve effectively with respect to these internal readings. The construction naturally extends to relativistic motion, gravitational redshift, and cosmological expansion, leading to a unified emergent-time functional valid across diverse physical regimes. The theory reproduces classical time dilation, predicts correlation-dependent deviations from standard evolution, and suggests that non-interacting or massless particles exhibit negligible internal time. These consequences open directions for conceptual and experimental investigations in the foundations of temporal physics, from multi-clock quantum systems to precision metrology and cosmological settings. In particular, the framework suggests measurable deviation from standard quantum evolution for highly entangled systems and predicts negligible internal time for massless particles.
The basic tenet of the present work is the assumption of the lack of external and fixed time in the Universe. This assumption is best embodied by general relativity, which replaces the fixed space-time structure with the gravitational field, which is subject to dynamics. The lack of time does not imply the lack of evolution but rather brings to the forefront the role of internal clocks which are some largely arbitrary internal degrees of freedom with respect to which the evolution of timeless systems can be described. We take this idea seriously and try to understand what it implies for quantum mechanics when the fixed external time is replaced by an arbitrary internal clock. We put the issue in a solid, mathematically rigorous framework. We find that the dynamical interpretation of a quantum state of a timeless system depends on the employed internal clock. In particular, we find that the continuous spectra of well-known dynamical observables like the position of a free particle on the real line may turn discrete if measured in unusual clocks. We discuss the meaning of our result for attempts at quantization of global gravitational degrees of freedom.
We consider the conditioning of the timeless solution to the Wheeler–DeWitt equation by a predefined matter clock state in the simple scenario of an FLRW universe. The resulting evolution of the geometrodynamical degree of freedom with respect to clock time is characterized by the “Berry connection” of the reduced geometrodynamical space, which relies on the coupling of the clock with the geometry. When the connection vanishes, the standard Schrödinger equation is obtained for the geometry with respect to clock time. When one considers environment-induced decoherence in the semiclassical limit, this condition is satisfied, and clock time coincides with cosmic time. Explicit results for the conditioned wave functions for minimal clocks made up of two quantum harmonic oscillator eigenstates are shown.
The fundamental laws of quantum mechanics are far from our everyday life experiences. However, they have been extremely successful in explaining observations in microscopic physical systems and are, already, harnessed for several applications. Moreover, in combination with relativistic considerations, basic phenomena from quantum mechanics are accredited a central role in the (macroscopic) evolution of our universe. In this thesis, we employ a trapped ion quantum simulator to experimentally investigate two fundamental quantum mechanical effects that have been extensively studied for many decades. In the first investigation, we implement non-adiabatic changes of the ions’ trapping potential in order to amplify quantum vacuum fluctuations. Following theoretical works by others, this mechanism can be interpreted as an analog to the creation of particles during cosmic inflation in the early universe. Such cosmological particles are considered as the seeds for the formation of the large-scale structures in our universe that we observe nowadays. In our analog quantum simulation, the creation of particles is evidenced by the detection of a squeezed state in the motion of the ions. A remarkable feature of this mechanism is the accompanying creation of quantum entanglement. In case of the cosmological particles, this entanglement spreads over large, cosmic distances. In the second investigation, we benchmark a theoretical concept in the framework of open quantum systems in a most basic system and under near-ideal conditions. In nature, any quantum system inevitably interacts with its environment and, thereby, needs ultimately to be considered an open system that can build up correlations and, even, entanglement with its environment. We implement a spin-1/2 system in the electronic degree of freedom of a single trapped ion, which we couple to a bosonic environment, formed by a motional degree of freedom of the ion. Further, we implement a tunable interaction between system and environment that, in turn, can lead to entanglement. By performing measurements on the open system only, we observe quantum non-Markovian behavior, which we quantify using a rigorously defined measure. Thereby, we reveal that the quantification of such quantum memory effects is fundamentally limited by fundamental quantum mechanical measurement uncertainties. The investigations presented in this thesis significantly expand the capabilities of our trapped ion platform to perform analog quantum simulations of fundamental quantum mechanical problems under near-ideal conditions, and enable future studies of increased complexity and under more realistic conditions.