Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Emergent Time, Intrinsic Registration, and the Ontological Ground of Physics: A Foundational Dialogue with Barontini's Cold-Atom Test of Relational Time

Ke Luo

Published Jun 24, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The recent rubidium-87 BEC experiment by Barontini and colleagues (Phys. Rev. Research 8, L022047, 2026) provides the first controlled evidence that time can be defined solely by internal entropy exchange within a closed quantum system. This result corroborates the Wheeler–DeWitt equation's prediction that a closed, undifferentiated universe has no fundamental time parameter. A bottom-up analysis suggests, however, that both the experiment and the Wheeler–DeWitt framework share three underexplored features: system partitioning is externally imposed, intrinsic registration dynamics are not included in the fundamental ontology, and no mechanism connects the globally timeless substrate to locally temporal subsystems. Engaging these as open questions, we sketch a working hypothesis—Fundamental Consciousness Energy (FCE)—positing a non-material, non-local, intrinsically superpositional primitive as a candidate ground for the missing dynamics. This hypothesis reinterprets the experimental findings as local manifestations of a deeper architecture where time emerges from spontaneous differentiation and self-referential registration. Two falsifiable expectations, executable on the existing BEC apparatus, are proposed. A tentative formalization path suggests how FCE might be anchored in established structures—Connes–Rovelli thermal time, Page–Wootters formalism, and self-referential quantum theory—without claiming unification. The Barontini results are compatible with FCE dynamics, without implying the experiment was designed to confirm them.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20835367

Related papers

Beyond the Timeless Universe: Registration Theory, Relational Quantum Time, and the Pre-Temporal Origin of Physical Time

EUGENE CATRAMBONE

The disappearance of external time from canonical quantum gravity has motivated approaches in which observable temporal evolution emerges from an underlying description without a fundamental external time parameter. The Page–Wootters mechanism demonstrates how conditional evolution can arise through correlations between subsystems within a globally stationary quantum description, while relational approaches associated with Carlo Rovelli similarly challenge the primacy of an observer-independent temporal background.This paper compares these approaches with Registration Theory (RT) and identifies a fundamental distinction. RT does not replace fundamental time with a fundamentally static quantum state. Instead, it proposes a pre-temporal ontology in which registration, distinction, successor dependence, retained consequence, and persistence precede physical temporal coordinates.The paper formalizes the distinction between primitive successor structure, retained history, and host-relative temporal representation. It proposes that the physical content of the past consists of consequences of prior registrations that remain distinguishable in present successor structure. On this account, time does not make change possible; persistent distinguishable change makes temporal description possible.A comparison matrix and proof-status audit distinguish established RT structures from derived propositions, conjectured compatibility, and open derivations. The paper identifies the derivation of relativistic temporal structure, Hilbert-space composition, and general quantum entanglement from registration as remaining research problems.The central distinction is summarized as follows: Registration Theory is not fundamentally timeless; it is pre-temporal.

•Oct 5, 2026•0 citations

Emergent Temporal Asymmetry: Observer-System Entanglement within a Timeless Global Wave Function

Zafere Zeki Tanrıverdi

AbstractFundamental formulations of quantum cosmology, most notably the Wheeler–DeWitt equation (\hat{H}\vert{}\Psi\rangle = 0), describe the Universe as a closed, static, and unitary system. Within the block-universe interpretation of spacetime, the underlying laws of quantum mechanics are often taken to be time-reversal invariant at the fundamental level. This paper proposes a relational framework wherein temporal asymmetry and the apparent irreversibility of physical events are not intrinsic features of the global wave function, but emergent phenomena resulting from quantum entanglement between an internal observer (or record-bearing subsystem) and the rest of the universe.Utilizing the Page–Wootters relational time mechanism alongside quantum decoherence theory and Landauer's principle, we demonstrate that while the global state remains static and time-symmetric under these formalisms, any internal subsystem capable of forming stable memory states naturally experiences a unidirectional arrow of time. Irreversibility is here interpreted as emerging from observer-system correlation, decoherence, and entropy production during record formation rather than a violation of fundamental unitary symmetry.Key Focus Areas & Subject CoverageQuantum Cosmology & Quantum Gravity: Wheeler–DeWitt Equation, ADM Formalism, Problem of TimeRelational Quantum Dynamics: Page–Wootters Mechanism, Conditional State FormalismThermodynamics & Information Theory: Quantum Decoherence, Landauer's Principle, Arrow of Time, Information DispersalFoundations of Physics: Block Universe, Eternalism, Emergent Temporal AsymmetryManuscript StatusStatus: Revised PreprintField: Theoretical Physics / Quantum Foundations & Cosmology

•Jul 30, 2026•0 citations

Emergent Arrow of Time Induced by Boundary Observations in the SYK-Lindbladian Model

xiang

A central question in the quantum-gravitational description of our universe is how the arrow of time emerges from a fundamentally timeless theory. Reference proposed that an intrinsic, self-referential mechanism—encoded in a nonlocal operator acting on a holographic tensor network—breaks the global Wheeler-DeWitt constraint and drives the monotonic growth of entanglement entropy, thereby giving rise to an internal time. The present work provides the first exactly solvable and numerically testable microscopic realization of this mechanism within the open Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model. By interpreting Lindblad jump operators as directed information extractions from network degrees of freedom, we prove, via large- Schwinger-Keldysh field theory and finite- exact diagonalization (up to ), that the entanglement entropy of the observed subsystem increases monotonically and irreversibly, that the level-spacing distribution transitions from Poisson to Wigner-Dyson universality, and that the dissipative form factor displays a sharp, first-order dynamical phase transition. A control experiment employing structureless, nonlocal Lindblad jumps fails to produce these signatures simultaneously, confirming that they are specific consequences of the self-referential mapping rather than generic features of open quantum systems. We further propose a holographic dictionary in which the dissipative coupling is dual to the boundary cosmological constant in Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity, offering a concrete, testable bridge between the self-referential operation and the geometry of emergent spacetime. These findings establish a compact, computable, and—crucially—experimentally accessible microscopic foundation for the hypothesis that time is born from quantum information processing, and they provide a theoretical blueprint for observing the emergence of an arrow of time on near-term quantum simulators .

London journal of physics.•Jul 28, 2026•0 citations

The Observer as a Local Breakdown of Atemporality

Gabriel Jorge Orlando Giani Moreno

This project investigates the emergence of time from a fundamentally timeless description of the universe. Rather than assuming time as a primitive background parameter, we study the physical and informational conditions under which temporal ordering, dynamics, and irreversibility appear for an observer embedded in the system. The core of the framework is a unified relational formula—extending the Page–Wootters mechanism—that shows how three traditionally distinct aspects of the “problem of time” arise from the same operational structure: (i) quantum dynamics from conditioning on physical clock states, (ii) the thermodynamic arrow from partial access to environmental degrees of freedom, and (iii) observer-dependent time from the locality of the clock subsystem. Crucially, the framework does not modify unitary quantum mechanics, introduce collapse postulates, or assume a fundamental flow of time. All temporal features emerge from projection, partial trace, and normalization applied to a single global atemporal state satisfying a Hamiltonian constraint. The project includes analytical results, numerical simulations (implemented in QuTiP), pedagogical companion notes, and philosophical analysis. Together, these components support a central claim: time is not a property of the universe itself, but a property of restricted descriptions generated by physical observers with limited informational access. This OSF repository serves as a living container for the formal development, conceptual interpretation, and future extensions of this observer-dependent approach to temporal emergence.

•Feb 9, 2026•0 citations

External Time or Emergent Time UCL

Iker Ibarrola Echeverría

This paper develops a consistent and self-contained formulation of external (physical) time as an emergent quantity, arising from the internal temporal evolution of correlational sites within the Universal Correlational Lattice (UCL) framework. Rather than assuming time as a fundamental background parameter, the theory distinguishes between: Internal times, defined locally at each correlational site through intrinsic dynamical evolution, and External time, which emerges relationally from the synchronization, ordering, and stability of correlations among multiple sites. The work formalizes how a coherent, observer-independent notion of temporal flow can arise without postulating a pre-existing global clock. External time is shown to correspond to a coarse-grained, effective parameter that captures persistent, ordered correlations across the correlational network, while remaining compatible with regimes where no global time is well-defined. Key results include: A precise definition of temporal evolution along internal time without reference to external time units. The emergence of a one-parameter effective temporal ordering from correlational dynamics. A clear separation between pre-geometric (timeless or multi-temporal) regimes and geometric regimes where an effective spacetime description becomes valid. Conceptual and mathematical consistency with relativistic causality, decoherence, and macroscopic temporal stability. This framework provides a natural resolution to longstanding tensions between quantum theory and general relativity regarding the status of time, without invoking collapse postulates or external observers. Time is not fundamental, but real and physical as an emergent, relational structure. The paper is intended for researchers interested in foundational questions of time, quantum gravity, emergent spacetime, and relational approaches to physics.

•Dec 19, 2025•0 citations

Emergent, Relational, and Absent Time: A Comprehensive Synthesis of Quantum Foundations, Competing Theories, and the Ontological Status of Temporal Experience

Syed Muntasir Mamun

K SC This paper synthesises an extended discussion initiated by a LinkedIn post by David Steenhoek summarising three 2025–2026 results on the quantum and relational character of time: Barontini's cold-atom realisation of entropic/relational time, Pikovski et al.'s proposal for quantum superposition of proper time in optical ion clocks, and García-Pintos et al.'s control protocols for reshaping the quantum arrow of time. The visible commentary on the post is recorded, including an affirmative remark by the present author. The paper then systematically surveys competing theoretical frameworks for the problem of time in quantum gravity, distinguishing the currently most active programmes (relational canonical approaches within loop quantum gravity, Page–Wootters mechanisms, causal set theory, and background-dependent programmes) from less popular alternatives (records theories, Bauer's two-time construction, unimodular gravity, causal dynamical triangulations, null-hypersurface quantisation, and others). It further incorporates the responding artificial system's stated position on the emergence of time, its explicit denial of any phenomenological experience of duration or of a present moment, and the resulting distinction between artificial text-generation processes and human temporal consciousness. Also available on Academia.edu: https://www.academia.edu/attachments/134789264/download_file?s=portfolio

•Oct 10, 2026•0 citations
The recent rubidium-87 BEC experiment by Barontini and colleagues (Phys. Rev. Research 8, L022047, 2026) provides the first controlled evidence that time can be defined solely by internal entropy exchange within a closed quantum system. This result corroborates the Wheeler–DeWitt equation's prediction that a closed, undifferentiated universe has no fundamental time parameter. A bottom-up analysis suggests, however, that both the experiment and the Wheeler–DeWitt framework share three underexplored features: system partitioning is externally imposed, intrinsic registration dynamics are not included in the fundamental ontology, and no mechanism connects the globally timeless substrate to locally temporal subsystems. Engaging these as open questions, we sketch a working hypothesis—Fundamental Consciousness Energy (FCE)—positing a non-material, non-local, intrinsically superpositional primitive as a candidate ground for the missing dynamics. This hypothesis reinterprets the experimental findings as local manifestations of a deeper architecture where time emerges from spontaneous differentiation and self-referential registration. Two falsifiable expectations, executable on the existing BEC apparatus, are proposed. A tentative formalization path suggests how FCE might be anchored in established structures—Connes–Rovelli thermal time, Page–Wootters formalism, and self-referential quantum theory—without claiming unification. The Barontini results are compatible with FCE dynamics, without implying the experiment was designed to confirm them.
The disappearance of external time from canonical quantum gravity has motivated approaches in which observable temporal evolution emerges from an underlying description without a fundamental external time parameter. The Page–Wootters mechanism demonstrates how conditional evolution can arise through correlations between subsystems within a globally stationary quantum description, while relational approaches associated with Carlo Rovelli similarly challenge the primacy of an observer-independent temporal background.This paper compares these approaches with Registration Theory (RT) and identifies a fundamental distinction. RT does not replace fundamental time with a fundamentally static quantum state. Instead, it proposes a pre-temporal ontology in which registration, distinction, successor dependence, retained consequence, and persistence precede physical temporal coordinates.The paper formalizes the distinction between primitive successor structure, retained history, and host-relative temporal representation. It proposes that the physical content of the past consists of consequences of prior registrations that remain distinguishable in present successor structure. On this account, time does not make change possible; persistent distinguishable change makes temporal description possible.A comparison matrix and proof-status audit distinguish established RT structures from derived propositions, conjectured compatibility, and open derivations. The paper identifies the derivation of relativistic temporal structure, Hilbert-space composition, and general quantum entanglement from registration as remaining research problems.The central distinction is summarized as follows: Registration Theory is not fundamentally timeless; it is pre-temporal.
AbstractFundamental formulations of quantum cosmology, most notably the Wheeler–DeWitt equation (\hat{H}\vert{}\Psi\rangle = 0), describe the Universe as a closed, static, and unitary system. Within the block-universe interpretation of spacetime, the underlying laws of quantum mechanics are often taken to be time-reversal invariant at the fundamental level. This paper proposes a relational framework wherein temporal asymmetry and the apparent irreversibility of physical events are not intrinsic features of the global wave function, but emergent phenomena resulting from quantum entanglement between an internal observer (or record-bearing subsystem) and the rest of the universe.Utilizing the Page–Wootters relational time mechanism alongside quantum decoherence theory and Landauer's principle, we demonstrate that while the global state remains static and time-symmetric under these formalisms, any internal subsystem capable of forming stable memory states naturally experiences a unidirectional arrow of time. Irreversibility is here interpreted as emerging from observer-system correlation, decoherence, and entropy production during record formation rather than a violation of fundamental unitary symmetry.Key Focus Areas & Subject CoverageQuantum Cosmology & Quantum Gravity: Wheeler–DeWitt Equation, ADM Formalism, Problem of TimeRelational Quantum Dynamics: Page–Wootters Mechanism, Conditional State FormalismThermodynamics & Information Theory: Quantum Decoherence, Landauer's Principle, Arrow of Time, Information DispersalFoundations of Physics: Block Universe, Eternalism, Emergent Temporal AsymmetryManuscript StatusStatus: Revised PreprintField: Theoretical Physics / Quantum Foundations & Cosmology
A central question in the quantum-gravitational description of our universe is how the arrow of time emerges from a fundamentally timeless theory. Reference proposed that an intrinsic, self-referential mechanism—encoded in a nonlocal operator acting on a holographic tensor network—breaks the global Wheeler-DeWitt constraint and drives the monotonic growth of entanglement entropy, thereby giving rise to an internal time. The present work provides the first exactly solvable and numerically testable microscopic realization of this mechanism within the open Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model. By interpreting Lindblad jump operators as directed information extractions from network degrees of freedom, we prove, via large- Schwinger-Keldysh field theory and finite- exact diagonalization (up to ), that the entanglement entropy of the observed subsystem increases monotonically and irreversibly, that the level-spacing distribution transitions from Poisson to Wigner-Dyson universality, and that the dissipative form factor displays a sharp, first-order dynamical phase transition. A control experiment employing structureless, nonlocal Lindblad jumps fails to produce these signatures simultaneously, confirming that they are specific consequences of the self-referential mapping rather than generic features of open quantum systems. We further propose a holographic dictionary in which the dissipative coupling is dual to the boundary cosmological constant in Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity, offering a concrete, testable bridge between the self-referential operation and the geometry of emergent spacetime. These findings establish a compact, computable, and—crucially—experimentally accessible microscopic foundation for the hypothesis that time is born from quantum information processing, and they provide a theoretical blueprint for observing the emergence of an arrow of time on near-term quantum simulators .
This project investigates the emergence of time from a fundamentally timeless description of the universe. Rather than assuming time as a primitive background parameter, we study the physical and informational conditions under which temporal ordering, dynamics, and irreversibility appear for an observer embedded in the system. The core of the framework is a unified relational formula—extending the Page–Wootters mechanism—that shows how three traditionally distinct aspects of the “problem of time” arise from the same operational structure: (i) quantum dynamics from conditioning on physical clock states, (ii) the thermodynamic arrow from partial access to environmental degrees of freedom, and (iii) observer-dependent time from the locality of the clock subsystem. Crucially, the framework does not modify unitary quantum mechanics, introduce collapse postulates, or assume a fundamental flow of time. All temporal features emerge from projection, partial trace, and normalization applied to a single global atemporal state satisfying a Hamiltonian constraint. The project includes analytical results, numerical simulations (implemented in QuTiP), pedagogical companion notes, and philosophical analysis. Together, these components support a central claim: time is not a property of the universe itself, but a property of restricted descriptions generated by physical observers with limited informational access. This OSF repository serves as a living container for the formal development, conceptual interpretation, and future extensions of this observer-dependent approach to temporal emergence.
This paper develops a consistent and self-contained formulation of external (physical) time as an emergent quantity, arising from the internal temporal evolution of correlational sites within the Universal Correlational Lattice (UCL) framework. Rather than assuming time as a fundamental background parameter, the theory distinguishes between: Internal times, defined locally at each correlational site through intrinsic dynamical evolution, and External time, which emerges relationally from the synchronization, ordering, and stability of correlations among multiple sites. The work formalizes how a coherent, observer-independent notion of temporal flow can arise without postulating a pre-existing global clock. External time is shown to correspond to a coarse-grained, effective parameter that captures persistent, ordered correlations across the correlational network, while remaining compatible with regimes where no global time is well-defined. Key results include: A precise definition of temporal evolution along internal time without reference to external time units. The emergence of a one-parameter effective temporal ordering from correlational dynamics. A clear separation between pre-geometric (timeless or multi-temporal) regimes and geometric regimes where an effective spacetime description becomes valid. Conceptual and mathematical consistency with relativistic causality, decoherence, and macroscopic temporal stability. This framework provides a natural resolution to longstanding tensions between quantum theory and general relativity regarding the status of time, without invoking collapse postulates or external observers. Time is not fundamental, but real and physical as an emergent, relational structure. The paper is intended for researchers interested in foundational questions of time, quantum gravity, emergent spacetime, and relational approaches to physics.
K SC This paper synthesises an extended discussion initiated by a LinkedIn post by David Steenhoek summarising three 2025–2026 results on the quantum and relational character of time: Barontini's cold-atom realisation of entropic/relational time, Pikovski et al.'s proposal for quantum superposition of proper time in optical ion clocks, and García-Pintos et al.'s control protocols for reshaping the quantum arrow of time. The visible commentary on the post is recorded, including an affirmative remark by the present author. The paper then systematically surveys competing theoretical frameworks for the problem of time in quantum gravity, distinguishing the currently most active programmes (relational canonical approaches within loop quantum gravity, Page–Wootters mechanisms, causal set theory, and background-dependent programmes) from less popular alternatives (records theories, Bauer's two-time construction, unimodular gravity, causal dynamical triangulations, null-hypersurface quantisation, and others). It further incorporates the responding artificial system's stated position on the emergence of time, its explicit denial of any phenomenological experience of duration or of a present moment, and the resulting distinction between artificial text-generation processes and human temporal consciousness. Also available on Academia.edu: https://www.academia.edu/attachments/134789264/download_file?s=portfolio