Emergent, Relational, and Absent Time: A Comprehensive Synthesis of Quantum Foundations, Competing Theories, and the Ontological Status of Temporal Experience
K SC This paper synthesises an extended discussion initiated by a LinkedIn post by David Steenhoek summarising three 2025–2026 results on the quantum and relational character of time: Barontini's cold-atom realisation of entropic/relational time, Pikovski et al.'s proposal for quantum superposition of proper time in optical ion clocks, and García-Pintos et al.'s control protocols for reshaping the quantum arrow of time. The visible commentary on the post is recorded, including an affirmative remark by the present author. The paper then systematically surveys competing theoretical frameworks for the problem of time in quantum gravity, distinguishing the currently most active programmes (relational canonical approaches within loop quantum gravity, Page–Wootters mechanisms, causal set theory, and background-dependent programmes) from less popular alternatives (records theories, Bauer's two-time construction, unimodular gravity, causal dynamical triangulations, null-hypersurface quantisation, and others). It further incorporates the responding artificial system's stated position on the emergence of time, its explicit denial of any phenomenological experience of duration or of a present moment, and the resulting distinction between artificial text-generation processes and human temporal consciousness. Also available on Academia.edu: https://www.academia.edu/attachments/134789264/download_file?s=portfolio
K SC This paper synthesises an extended discussion initiated by a LinkedIn post by David Steenhoek summarising three 2025–2026 results on the quantum and relational character of time: Barontini's cold-atom realisation of entropic/relational time, Pikovski et al.'s proposal for quantum superposition of proper time in optical ion clocks, and García-Pintos et al.'s control protocols for reshaping the quantum arrow of time. The visible commentary on the post is recorded, including an affirmative remark by the present author. The paper then systematically surveys competing theoretical frameworks for the problem of time in quantum gravity, distinguishing the currently most active programmes (relational canonical approaches within loop quantum gravity, Page–Wootters mechanisms, causal set theory, and background-dependent programmes) from less popular alternatives (records theories, Bauer's two-time construction, unimodular gravity, causal dynamical triangulations, null-hypersurface quantisation, and others). It further incorporates the responding artificial system's stated position on the emergence of time, its explicit denial of any phenomenological experience of duration or of a present moment, and the resulting distinction between artificial text-generation processes and human temporal consciousness. Also available on Academia.edu: https://www.academia.edu/attachments/134789264/download_file?s=portfolio
This paper synthesises an extended discussion initiated by a LinkedIn post by David Steenhoek summarising three 2025–2026 results on the quantum and relational character of time: Barontini's cold-atom realisation of entropic/relational time, Pikovski et al.'s proposal for quantum superposition of proper time in optical ion clocks, and García-Pintos et al.'s control protocols for reshaping the quantum arrow of time. The visible commentary on the post is recorded, including an affirmative remark by the present author. The paper then systematically surveys competing theoretical frameworks for the problem of time in quantum gravity, distinguishing the currently most active programmes (relational canonical approaches within loop quantum gravity, Page–Wootters mechanisms, causal set theory, and background-dependent programmes) from less popular alternatives (records theories, Bauer's two-time construction, unimodular gravity, causal dynamical triangulations, null-hypersurface quantisation, and others). It further incorporates the responding artificial system's stated position on the emergence of time, its explicit denial of any phenomenological experience of duration or of a present moment, and the resulting distinction between artificial text-generation processes and human temporal consciousness. The synthesis leaves no element of the originating discussion unaddressed and situates the laboratory and theoretical results within the broader landscape of quantum-gravitational and foundational approaches to time. KSCCN synthesis, 10 October 2026. Dr. Syed Muntasir Mamun, ORCID 0000-0001-6845-2853. The views expressed are those of the author.
The problem of time in quantum gravity is often presented as a consequence of applying quantum theory to general relativity. These notes adopt a broader perspective. We first examine how time enters classical mechanics, relativity, quantum theory, and quantum field theory, distinguishing three principal aspects: causal order, temporal duration, and the present. This analysis shows that the conceptual difficulties associated with time do not arise only when gravity is quantised. Tensions between causal structure, clocks, observables, and measurement are already present in the theories from which quantum gravity is constructed. We then survey responses to the problem of time across the principal approaches to quantum gravity. These include canonical and Wheeler-DeWitt quantisation, path-integral and histories formulations, perturbative and background-dependent approaches, causal sets, and twistor theory. The programmes are compared according to whether they retain an external time, render time problematic through quantisation, or incorporate causal or temporal structure into their foundations. Particular emphasis is placed on questions arising from quantum foundations and relativistic quantum information. We conclude by examining linearised gravity and weak-gravity quantum systems. This regime shows that the problem of time is not confined to Planck-scale physics, but arises already in attempts to provide a predictive and operationally meaningful quantum description of spacetime near flat geometry.
Abstract This article does not claim to present a successful theory of quantum gravity. Instead, it undertakes a systematic and self-aware survey of the research program aiming to derive both quantum mechanics and general relativity from a purely relational network, based on a set of minimal ontological postulates. The framework rests on three axioms: (1) physical reality consists of nodes without intrinsic properties and their symmetric relations; (2) the relation strengths are non-negative and symmetric, with the total information capacity conserved as an ensemble expectation; (3) local evolution is restricted to redistribution of relations within triads. We honestly display and rigorously distinguish the conceptual achievements from the essential obstacles of this framework. On the quantum side, we obtain solid conceptual progress: the Born rule, unitary evolution, and topological nonlocality of entanglement all emerge naturally as representation-theoretic consequences of the statistical description of a finite information capacity network. This strongly suggests that the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics may be a generic feature of the statistical representation of any complex informational system satisfying “finite information + local relational evolution.” On the gravitational side, however, we encounter chasms that current mathematical and conceptual tools cannot bridge. A central contribution of this article is to clearly label these obstacles as fundamental open scientific problems: the conflict between a positive-definite relational ontology and the target of pseudo-Riemannian signature (signature problem); the missing coarse-graining procedure from a discrete network to a smooth manifold (coarse-graining problem); and the disharmony between external algorithmic time and emergent physical time (time problem). We argue that these are not technical details unique to this framework, but core challenges that any “spacetime from relations” program must confront. The article positions itself as a “conceptual cartography”—it precisely delineates the known boundaries of this research program, exposes the fatal rift often bypassed in mainstream discourse, and transforms all unresolved issues into a formal invitation for future investigation.
We present a relational framework in which temporal structure is not fundamental but emerges from correlations within a globally stationary quantum state. Each subsystem includes an internal clock, and conditional states evolve effectively with respect to these internal readings. The construction naturally extends to relativistic motion, gravitational redshift, and cosmological expansion, leading to a unified emergent-time functional valid across diverse physical regimes. The theory reproduces classical time dilation, predicts correlation-dependent deviations from standard evolution, and suggests that non-interacting or massless particles exhibit negligible internal time. These consequences open directions for conceptual and experimental investigations in the foundations of temporal physics, from multi-clock quantum systems to precision metrology and cosmological settings. In particular, the framework suggests measurable deviation from standard quantum evolution for highly entangled systems and predicts negligible internal time for massless particles.
K SC This anatomical review examines Isabelle Bousquette's August 2026 Wall Street Journal article on enterprise quantum-computing expenditure, which reports that commercial users spent USD 300 million in 2025—surpassing the combined outlays of research laboratories and governments for the first time. Drawing on Boston Consulting Group survey data covering 275 large firms, the piece documents dual offensive (talent, use-case development, cloud experimentation) and defensive (post-quantum cryptography readiness) investment motives among firms such as HSBC, Allstate and EY. The review offers a generally affirmative appraisal of the article's empirical grounding and narrative clarity while identifying limitations in temporal specificity, sample breadth and technical depth. It situates the reported inflection within a comparative landscape of at least ten competing hardware and algorithmic paradigms (superconducting, trapped-ion, photonic, neutral-atom, silicon-spin, topological, annealing, hybrid quantum-classical, NISQ-era variational methods, and fault-tolerant surface-code architectures). Ontological and epistemological verticals are elaborated with reference to the evolving status of quantum resources, measurement, and knowledge production in commercial settings. Contemporary investment vectors—including record venture funding of approximately USD 3.9–12.6 billion in 2025, institutional private-equity participation, and sovereign co-investment—are synthesised. Also available on Academia.edu: https://www.academia.edu/attachments/133871908/download_file?s=portfolio
Because of the non-locality of quantum entanglement, realist approaches to completing quantum mechanics have implications for our conception of space. Quantum gravity also is expected to predict phenomena in which the locality of classical spacetime is modified or disordered. It is then possible that the right quantum theory of gravity will also be a completion of quantum mechanics in which the foundational puzzles in both are addressed together. I review here the results of a program, developed with Roberto Mangabeira Unger, Marina Cortes and other collaborators, which aims to do just that. The results so far include energetic causal set models, time asymmetric extensions of general relativity and relational hidden variables theories, including real ensemble approaches to quantum mechanics. These models share two assumptions: that physics is relational and that time and causality are fundamental.