Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2505.04538 · Physical Review Letters

Clock Precision beyond the Standard Quantum Limit at 10 − 18 Level

Yutong Yang, Maya Miklos, Yee Ming Tso, Stella Kraus, Joonseok Hur, Jun Ye

Published Nov 7, 2025• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Optical atomic clocks with unrivaled precision and accuracy have advanced the frontier of precision measurement science and opened new avenues for exploring fundamental physics. A fundamental limitation on clock precision is the standard quantum limit (SQL), which stems from the uncorrelated projection noise of each atom. State-of-the-art optical lattice clocks interrogate large ensembles to minimize the SQL, but density-dependent frequency shifts pose challenges to scaling the atom number. The SQL can be surpassed, however, by leveraging entanglement, though it remains an open problem to achieve quantum advantage from spin squeezing at state-of-the-art stability levels. Here, we demonstrate clock performance beyond the SQL, achieving a fractional frequency precision of 1.1×10^{-18} for a single spin-squeezed clock. With cavity-based quantum nondemolition measurements, we prepare two spin-squeezed ensembles of ∼30 000 strontium atoms confined in a two-dimensional optical lattice. A synchronous clock comparison with an interrogation time of 61 ms achieves a metrological improvement of 2.0(2) dB beyond the SQL, after correcting for state preparation and measurement errors. These results establish the most precise entanglement-enhanced clock to date and offer a powerful platform for exploring the interplay of gravity and quantum entanglement.

DOI
10.1103/6v93-whwq

Related papers

Direct comparison of two spin squeezed optical clocks below the quantum projection noise limit

John Martin Robinson, Maya Miklos, Yee Ming Tso +5 more

Building scalable quantum systems that demonstrate genuine performance enhancement based on entanglement is a major scientific goal for fields including computing, networking, simulations, and metrology. The tremendous challenge arises from the fragility of entanglement in increasingly larger sized quantum systems. Optical atomic clocks utilizing a large number of atoms have pushed the frontier of measurement science, building on precise engineering of quantum states and control of atomic interactions. However, today's state-of-the-art optical atomic clocks are limited by the quantum projection noise (QPN) defined by many uncorrelated atoms. Pioneering work on producing spin squeezed states of atoms has shown a path towards integrating entanglement into the best performing clocks. However, to directly demonstrate advantage of quantum entanglement in a working clock we must prevent backaction effects that degrade quantum coherence and introduce uncontrolled perturbations, as well as minimize the influence of technical noise arising from the interrogating clock laser. Here we present a new optical clock platform integrated with collective strong-coupling cavity QED for quantum non-demolition (QND) measurement. Optimizing the competition between spin measurement precision and loss of coherence, we measure a Wineland parameter of -1.8(7) dB for 1.9x10$^4$ atoms, thus verifying the presence of entanglement. Furthermore, a moving lattice allows the cavity to individually address two independent sub-ensembles, enabling us to spin squeeze two clock ensembles successively and compare their performance. This differential comparison between the two squeezed clocks directly verifies enhanced clock stability of 2.0(3) dB below QPN, and 0.6(3) dB above the standard quantum limit (SQL), at the measurement precision level of 10$^{-17}$, without subtracting any technical noise contributions.

arXiv:2211.08621•Nov 16, 2022•5 citations

Quantum enhanced metrology in the optical lattice clock

Chi Shu

High-bandwidth, high-stability clocks offer unique chances to study fundamental physics beyond simple metrology. Today, the most stable clocks are optical lattice clocks and they can reach a fractional stability of 3.1 × 10^−18 at 1 s averaging time. Their applications are ranging from the redefinition of the SI time unit, the Second, to the possible detection of gravitational waves in space. The stability of optical lattice clocks is primarily limited by quantum projection noise and Dick noise. In this thesis, I present our effort in creating a platform for studying quantum enhanced metrology and its application towards optical lattice clocks. We demonstrated the laser cooling in an optical cavity with Raman-sideband cooling and achieved average vibration number of n = 0.2. We utilized cavity feedback squeezing to demonstrate unitary spin squeezing on magnetic sub-levels of 171Yb, achieving 6.5 dB quantum projection noise reduction over the standard quantum limit (SQL). With coherent optical state transfer by ultra stable laser pulses, we successfully transferred the spin squeezed state from magnetic sub-levels to the optical transition, and demonstrated quantum enhanced metrology in the optical lattice clock for the first time. We achieved 4.4 dB of metrological gain over the SQL, which corresponds to a reduction of the averaging time by a factor of 2.8 in clock operation. Furthermore, we studied quantum enhanced metrology with time-reversal-based protocols. We performed a signal amplification through time-reversed interaction protocol between the ground state magnetic sublevels of 171Yb, achieving the largest sensitivity improvement beyond SQL in any interferometers to date at 11.8dB. Besides that, we experimentally studied the connection between quantum information scrambling, by measuring out-of-time-order correlators (OTOCs), and quantum metrology, by measuring metrological gain. We found these values to agree with each other, and concluded that the time-reversal quantum metrology can saturate the attainable gain from the quantum information scrambling.

•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

Spin-squeezing-enhanced optical lattice clocks with 10 − 19 -level differential frequency stability at the averaging time of 1 s

Deshui Yu, Jia Zhang, Tongyan Xia +3 more

Many-body entangled states allow precision measurement beyond the standard quantum limit. Yet they have not been effectively exploited in optical lattice clocks except for proof-of-principle demonstrations. Under the current experimental conditions, taking into account the lattice perturbation, atom-atom interactions, and local oscillator noise, we theoretically evaluate the performance of spin-squeezing-based shallow-lattice Yb optical clocks. The numerical simulation shows that the stability of differential frequency comparison between two Yb ensembles in squeezed spin states potentially accesses the ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}19}$ level at the averaging time of 1 s. The resultant Wineland parameter may be as low as ${\ensuremath{\xi}}_{\text{W}}^{2}=0.027$, corresponding to a reduction of averaging time by a factor of 37, and is limited by the collision-induced degradation of spin squeezing. The metrological gain provided by spin squeezing opens up new opportunities for precision measurement and fundamental physics.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 2024•4 citations

Spin Squeezing-Enhanced Stability in an Optical Lattice Clock Comparison

Maya Miklos, Yee Ming Tso, John Martin Robinson +3 more

We perform a self-synchronous clock comparison between two spin-squeezed ensembles in a strontium optical lattice clock to directly measure 2.0(3) dB of metrological gain beyond quantum projection noise-limited operation, averaging down to the 10 − 17 level.

Quantum 2.0 Conference and Exhibition•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

High precision differential clock comparisons with a multiplexed optical lattice clock

Xin Zheng, Jonathan Dolde, Varun Lochab +3 more

Rapid progress in the precision and accuracy of optical atomic clocks over the last decade has advanced the frontiers of timekeeping, metrology, and quantum science. However, the stabilities of most optical clocks remain limited by the local oscillator rather than the atoms themselves, leaving room for further progress. Here we implement a "multiplexed" one-dimensional optical lattice clock, in which spatially-resolved, movable ensembles of ultra-cold strontium atoms are trapped in the same optical lattice, interrogated simultaneously by a shared clock laser, and read-out in parallel. By performing synchronized Ramsey interrogations of ensemble pairs we observe atom-atom coherence times up to 26 seconds, a 270-fold improvement over the atom-laser coherence time, demonstrate a relative stability of $9.7(4)\times10^{-18}/\sqrtτ$ (where $τ$ is the averaging time in seconds), and reach a fractional uncertainty of $8.9(3)\times 10^{-20}$ after 3.3 hours of averaging. These results demonstrate that applications requiring ultra-high-precision comparisons between optical atomic clocks need not be limited by the stability of the local oscillator. With multiple ensemble pairs, we realize a miniaturized clock network consisting of 6 atom ensembles, resulting in 15 unique pairwise clock comparisons with relative stabilities below $3\times10^{-17}/\sqrtτ$. Finally, we demonstrate the capability to simultaneously load spatially-resolved, heterogeneous ensemble pairs of all four stable isotopes of strontium in a lattice. The unique capabilities offered by this platform pave the way for future studies of precision isotope shift measurements, spatially resolved characterization of limiting clock systematics, development of clock-based gravitational wave and dark matter detectors, and novel tests of relativity including measurements of the gravitational redshift at sub-centimeter scales.

arXiv:2109.12237•Sep 24, 2021•5 citations

Improvement of an Atomic Clock using Squeezed Vacuum

I. Kruse, Karsten Lange, J. Peise +8 more

Since the pioneering work of Ramsey, atom interferometers are employed for precision metrology, in particular to measure time and to realize the second. In a classical interferometer, an ensemble of atoms is prepared in one of the two input states, whereas the second one is left empty. In this case, the vacuum noise restricts the precision of the interferometer to the standard quantum limit (SQL). Here, we propose and experimentally demonstrate a novel clock configuration that surpasses the SQL by squeezing the vacuum in the empty input state. We create a squeezed vacuum state containing an average of 0.75 atoms to improve the clock sensitivity of 10000 atoms by 2.05_{-0.37}^{+0.34} dB. The SQL poses a significant limitation for today's microwave fountain clocks, which serve as the main time reference. We evaluate the major technical limitations and challenges for devising a next generation of fountain clocks based on atomic squeezed vacuum.

arXiv:1605.07754•Physical Review Letters•Sep 28, 2016•133 citations
Optical atomic clocks with unrivaled precision and accuracy have advanced the frontier of precision measurement science and opened new avenues for exploring fundamental physics. A fundamental limitation on clock precision is the standard quantum limit (SQL), which stems from the uncorrelated projection noise of each atom. State-of-the-art optical lattice clocks interrogate large ensembles to minimize the SQL, but density-dependent frequency shifts pose challenges to scaling the atom number. The SQL can be surpassed, however, by leveraging entanglement, though it remains an open problem to achieve quantum advantage from spin squeezing at state-of-the-art stability levels. Here, we demonstrate clock performance beyond the SQL, achieving a fractional frequency precision of 1.1×10^{-18} for a single spin-squeezed clock. With cavity-based quantum nondemolition measurements, we prepare two spin-squeezed ensembles of ∼30 000 strontium atoms confined in a two-dimensional optical lattice. A synchronous clock comparison with an interrogation time of 61 ms achieves a metrological improvement of 2.0(2) dB beyond the SQL, after correcting for state preparation and measurement errors. These results establish the most precise entanglement-enhanced clock to date and offer a powerful platform for exploring the interplay of gravity and quantum entanglement.
Building scalable quantum systems that demonstrate genuine performance enhancement based on entanglement is a major scientific goal for fields including computing, networking, simulations, and metrology. The tremendous challenge arises from the fragility of entanglement in increasingly larger sized quantum systems. Optical atomic clocks utilizing a large number of atoms have pushed the frontier of measurement science, building on precise engineering of quantum states and control of atomic interactions. However, today's state-of-the-art optical atomic clocks are limited by the quantum projection noise (QPN) defined by many uncorrelated atoms. Pioneering work on producing spin squeezed states of atoms has shown a path towards integrating entanglement into the best performing clocks. However, to directly demonstrate advantage of quantum entanglement in a working clock we must prevent backaction effects that degrade quantum coherence and introduce uncontrolled perturbations, as well as minimize the influence of technical noise arising from the interrogating clock laser. Here we present a new optical clock platform integrated with collective strong-coupling cavity QED for quantum non-demolition (QND) measurement. Optimizing the competition between spin measurement precision and loss of coherence, we measure a Wineland parameter of -1.8(7) dB for 1.9x104^44 atoms, thus verifying the presence of entanglement. Furthermore, a moving lattice allows the cavity to individually address two independent sub-ensembles, enabling us to spin squeeze two clock ensembles successively and compare their performance. This differential comparison between the two squeezed clocks directly verifies enhanced clock stability of 2.0(3) dB below QPN, and 0.6(3) dB above the standard quantum limit (SQL), at the measurement precision level of 10−17^{-17}−17, without subtracting any technical noise contributions.
High-bandwidth, high-stability clocks offer unique chances to study fundamental physics beyond simple metrology. Today, the most stable clocks are optical lattice clocks and they can reach a fractional stability of 3.1 × 10^−18 at 1 s averaging time. Their applications are ranging from the redefinition of the SI time unit, the Second, to the possible detection of gravitational waves in space. The stability of optical lattice clocks is primarily limited by quantum projection noise and Dick noise. In this thesis, I present our effort in creating a platform for studying quantum enhanced metrology and its application towards optical lattice clocks. We demonstrated the laser cooling in an optical cavity with Raman-sideband cooling and achieved average vibration number of n = 0.2. We utilized cavity feedback squeezing to demonstrate unitary spin squeezing on magnetic sub-levels of 171Yb, achieving 6.5 dB quantum projection noise reduction over the standard quantum limit (SQL). With coherent optical state transfer by ultra stable laser pulses, we successfully transferred the spin squeezed state from magnetic sub-levels to the optical transition, and demonstrated quantum enhanced metrology in the optical lattice clock for the first time. We achieved 4.4 dB of metrological gain over the SQL, which corresponds to a reduction of the averaging time by a factor of 2.8 in clock operation. Furthermore, we studied quantum enhanced metrology with time-reversal-based protocols. We performed a signal amplification through time-reversed interaction protocol between the ground state magnetic sublevels of 171Yb, achieving the largest sensitivity improvement beyond SQL in any interferometers to date at 11.8dB. Besides that, we experimentally studied the connection between quantum information scrambling, by measuring out-of-time-order correlators (OTOCs), and quantum metrology, by measuring metrological gain. We found these values to agree with each other, and concluded that the time-reversal quantum metrology can saturate the attainable gain from the quantum information scrambling.
Many-body entangled states allow precision measurement beyond the standard quantum limit. Yet they have not been effectively exploited in optical lattice clocks except for proof-of-principle demonstrations. Under the current experimental conditions, taking into account the lattice perturbation, atom-atom interactions, and local oscillator noise, we theoretically evaluate the performance of spin-squeezing-based shallow-lattice Yb optical clocks. The numerical simulation shows that the stability of differential frequency comparison between two Yb ensembles in squeezed spin states potentially accesses the ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}19}$ level at the averaging time of 1 s. The resultant Wineland parameter may be as low as ${\ensuremath{\xi}}_{\text{W}}^{2}=0.027$, corresponding to a reduction of averaging time by a factor of 37, and is limited by the collision-induced degradation of spin squeezing. The metrological gain provided by spin squeezing opens up new opportunities for precision measurement and fundamental physics.
Rapid progress in the precision and accuracy of optical atomic clocks over the last decade has advanced the frontiers of timekeeping, metrology, and quantum science. However, the stabilities of most optical clocks remain limited by the local oscillator rather than the atoms themselves, leaving room for further progress. Here we implement a "multiplexed" one-dimensional optical lattice clock, in which spatially-resolved, movable ensembles of ultra-cold strontium atoms are trapped in the same optical lattice, interrogated simultaneously by a shared clock laser, and read-out in parallel. By performing synchronized Ramsey interrogations of ensemble pairs we observe atom-atom coherence times up to 26 seconds, a 270-fold improvement over the atom-laser coherence time, demonstrate a relative stability of 9.7(4)×10−18/τ9.7(4)\times10^{-18}/\sqrtτ9.7(4)×10−18/τ​ (where τττ is the averaging time in seconds), and reach a fractional uncertainty of 8.9(3)×10−208.9(3)\times 10^{-20}8.9(3)×10−20 after 3.3 hours of averaging. These results demonstrate that applications requiring ultra-high-precision comparisons between optical atomic clocks need not be limited by the stability of the local oscillator. With multiple ensemble pairs, we realize a miniaturized clock network consisting of 6 atom ensembles, resulting in 15 unique pairwise clock comparisons with relative stabilities below 3×10−17/τ3\times10^{-17}/\sqrtτ3×10−17/τ​. Finally, we demonstrate the capability to simultaneously load spatially-resolved, heterogeneous ensemble pairs of all four stable isotopes of strontium in a lattice. The unique capabilities offered by this platform pave the way for future studies of precision isotope shift measurements, spatially resolved characterization of limiting clock systematics, development of clock-based gravitational wave and dark matter detectors, and novel tests of relativity including measurements of the gravitational redshift at sub-centimeter scales.
Since the pioneering work of Ramsey, atom interferometers are employed for precision metrology, in particular to measure time and to realize the second. In a classical interferometer, an ensemble of atoms is prepared in one of the two input states, whereas the second one is left empty. In this case, the vacuum noise restricts the precision of the interferometer to the standard quantum limit (SQL). Here, we propose and experimentally demonstrate a novel clock configuration that surpasses the SQL by squeezing the vacuum in the empty input state. We create a squeezed vacuum state containing an average of 0.75 atoms to improve the clock sensitivity of 10000 atoms by 2.05_{-0.37}^{+0.34} dB. The SQL poses a significant limitation for today's microwave fountain clocks, which serve as the main time reference. We evaluate the major technical limitations and challenges for devising a next generation of fountain clocks based on atomic squeezed vacuum.