Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2402.01218 · Quantum

Double or nothing: a Kolmogorov extension theorem for multitime (bi)probabilities in quantum mechanics

Davide Lonigro, Fattah Sakuldee, Łukasz Cywiński, Dariusz Chruściński, Piotr Szańkowski

Published Aug 27, 2024• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The multitime probability distributions obtained by repeatedly probing a quantum system via the measurement of an observable generally violate Kolmogorov's consistency property. Therefore, one cannot interpret such distributions as the result of the sampling of a single trajectory. We show that, nonetheless, they do result from the sampling of one pair of trajectories. In this sense, rather than give up on trajectories, quantum mechanics requires to double down on them. To this purpose, we prove a generalization of the Kolmogorov extension theorem that applies to families of complex-valued bi-probability distributions (that is, defined on pairs of elements of the original sample spaces), and we employ this result in the quantum mechanical scenario. We also discuss the relation of our results with the quantum comb formalism.

DOI
10.22331/q-2024-08-27-1447

Related papers

Phenomenological quantum mechanics: I. Phenomenology of quantum observables

Piotr Szańkowski, Davide Lonigro, Fattah Sakuldee +2 more

Abstract We propose an exercise in which one attempts to deduce the formalism of quantum mechanics solely from phenomenological observations. The only assumed inputs are obtained through sequential probing of quantum systems; no presuppositions about the underlying mathematical structures are permitted. We demonstrate that it is indeed possible to derive, on this basis, a complete and fully functional formalism rooted in the structures of Hilbert spaces. However, the resulting formalism—the bi -trajectory formalism—differs significantly from the standard state-focused formulation. In Part I of the paper, we analyze the outcomes of various experiments involving sequential measurements of quantum observables. These outcomes are quantitatively described by phenomenological multi-time probability distributions, estimated from experimental data. Our first conclusion is that the theory describing these experiments must be non-classical: the measured sequences cannot be interpreted as sampling of a uni -trajectory representing the system’s observable. The non-classical nature of the investigated systems manifests in a range of observed phenomena, including quantum interference, the quantum Zeno effect, and uncertainty relations between the measured observables.

arXiv:2410.14410•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Aug 10, 2026•2 citations

Operator Valued Measures in Quantum Mechanics: Finite and Infinite Processes

Paul A. Benioff

In this work, operator valued measures are used to study finite and infinite sequences of measurements. It is shown that to each such process qΔ there is uniquely associated a probability operator measure OqΔ which contains all the statistical properties of the process. In order to make this association for infinite processes, the operator valued equivalent of the Kolmogorov extension theorem is needed. This theorem is given and proved. It is then shown that for each qΔ and each set E of possible outcome sequences, there are two ways to find the probability that carrying out qΔ on a system in state ρ gives an outcome sequence φ in E. The usual method of repeating qΔ on ρ over and over again generates a sequence α of outcome sequences φ. The probability is obtained as the limit relative frequency that α(j) is in E, for j = 0, 1, …. The other, new, method is the repeated measurement of OEqΔ on ρ. The remarkable aspect of this equivalence is that the mathematical procedures of the usual method for determining if α(j) is in E or not `disappear' into the operators OEqΔ of the new method. This is discussed in some detail and examples are given.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 1972•28 citations

Kolmogorov extension theorem for (quantum) causal modelling and general probabilistic theories

Simon Milz, Fattah Sakuldee, Felix A. Pollock +1 more

In classical physics, the Kolmogorov extension theorem lays the foundation for the theory of stochastic processes. It has been known for a long time that, in its original form, this theorem does not hold in quantum mechanics. More generally, it does not hold in any theory of stochastic processes -- classical, quantum or beyond -- that does not just describe passive observations, but allows for active interventions. Such processes form the basis of the study of causal modelling across the sciences, including in the quantum domain. To date, these frameworks have lacked a conceptual underpinning similar to that provided by Kolmogorov’s theorem for classical stochastic processes. We prove a generalized extension theorem that applies to all theories of stochastic processes, putting them on equally firm mathematical ground as their classical counterpart. Additionally, we show that quantum causal modelling and quantum stochastic processes are equivalent. This provides the correct framework for the description of experiments involving continuous control, which play a crucial role in the development of quantum technologies. Furthermore, we show that the original extension theorem follows from the generalized one in the correct limit, and elucidate how a comprehensive understanding of general stochastic processes allows one to unambiguously define the distinction between those that are classical and those that are quantum.

arXiv:1712.02589•Quantum•Apr 20, 2020•106 citations

Objectivity of classical quantum stochastic processes

Piotr Szańkowski, Łukasz Cywiński

We investigate what can be concluded about a quantum system when sequential quantum measurements of its observable – a prominent example of the so-called quantum stochastic process – fulfill the Kolmogorov consistency condition and thus appear to an observer as a sampling of a classical trajectory. We identify a set of physical conditions imposed on the system dynamics, that when satisfied, lead to the aforementioned trajectory interpretation of the measurement results. We then show that when another quantum system is coupled to the observable, the operator representing it can be replaced by external noise. Crucially, the realizations of this surrogate (classical) stochastic process follow the same trajectories as those measured by the observer. Therefore, it can be said that the trajectory interpretation suggested by the Kolmogorov consistent measurements also applies in contexts other than sequential measurements.

arXiv:2304.07110•Quantum•Jun 27, 2024•12 citations

Bohmian Trajectories Within Hilbert Space Based Quantum Mechanics. Solution of the Measurement Problem

Tulsi Dass

de Broglie-Bohm theory (dBBT), treating quantum particles as point objects moving along well defined (Bohmian) trajectories, offers an appealing solution of the measurement problem in quantum mechanics; it has, however, problems relating to spin, relativity and lack of proper integration with the Hilbert space based framework. In this work, we present a consistent formalism which has the traditional state-observable framework integrated with the desirable features of dBBT. We adopt ensemble interpretation for the Schrodinger wave function $ψ$. Given a Schrodinger wave function $ψ$, we use its value $ψ_0$ at some fixed time (say, $t = 0$) to define the probability measure $|ψ_0|^2 {\rm d}x$ on the system configuration space $M$ ($=\mathbb{R}^n$). On the resulting probability space $\mathcal{M}_0$, we introduce a stochastic process $ξ(t)$ corresponding to the Heisenberg position operator $X_H(t)$ such that, in the Heisenberg state $|ψ_h\rangle$ corresponding to $ψ_0$, the expectation value of $X_H(t)$ equals that of $ξ(t)$ in $\mathcal{M}_0$. This condition leads to the de Broglie-Bohm guidance equation for the sample paths of the process $ξ(t)$ which are, therefore, Bohmian trajectories supposedly representing time-evolutions of individual members of the $ψ_0$-ensemble. Stochastic processes and Bohmian trajectories corresponding to observables with discrete eigenvalues (in particular spin) are treated by extending the configuration space to the spectral space of the commutative algebra obtained by adding appropriate discrete observables to the position observables. Pauli's equation is treated as an example. A straightforward derivation of von Neumann's projection rule employing the Schrodinger-Bohm evolution of individual systems along their Bohmian trajectories is given. Some comments on the potential application of the formalism developed here to quantum mechanics of the universe are included.

quant-pharXiv:2512.07007•International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Dec 9, 2025•0 citations

Coherence and correlations in multitime quantum measurements of stochastic quantum trajectories

Vladimir Chernyak, František Šanda, Shaul Mukamel

Quantum effects on multitime distributions and correlation functions of single objects, stemming from both the dynamics and repeated measurements, are calculated for a driven harmonic system using a superoperator generating functional formalism. Marked differences between multipoint observables associated with classical and quantum measurements are identified. The effects of quantum collapse and measurement resolution are discussed.

Physical Review E•Mar 15, 2006•12 citations
The multitime probability distributions obtained by repeatedly probing a quantum system via the measurement of an observable generally violate Kolmogorov's consistency property. Therefore, one cannot interpret such distributions as the result of the sampling of a single trajectory. We show that, nonetheless, they do result from the sampling of one pair of trajectories. In this sense, rather than give up on trajectories, quantum mechanics requires to double down on them. To this purpose, we prove a generalization of the Kolmogorov extension theorem that applies to families of complex-valued bi-probability distributions (that is, defined on pairs of elements of the original sample spaces), and we employ this result in the quantum mechanical scenario. We also discuss the relation of our results with the quantum comb formalism.
Abstract We propose an exercise in which one attempts to deduce the formalism of quantum mechanics solely from phenomenological observations. The only assumed inputs are obtained through sequential probing of quantum systems; no presuppositions about the underlying mathematical structures are permitted. We demonstrate that it is indeed possible to derive, on this basis, a complete and fully functional formalism rooted in the structures of Hilbert spaces. However, the resulting formalism—the bi -trajectory formalism—differs significantly from the standard state-focused formulation. In Part I of the paper, we analyze the outcomes of various experiments involving sequential measurements of quantum observables. These outcomes are quantitatively described by phenomenological multi-time probability distributions, estimated from experimental data. Our first conclusion is that the theory describing these experiments must be non-classical: the measured sequences cannot be interpreted as sampling of a uni -trajectory representing the system’s observable. The non-classical nature of the investigated systems manifests in a range of observed phenomena, including quantum interference, the quantum Zeno effect, and uncertainty relations between the measured observables.
In this work, operator valued measures are used to study finite and infinite sequences of measurements. It is shown that to each such process qΔ there is uniquely associated a probability operator measure OqΔ which contains all the statistical properties of the process. In order to make this association for infinite processes, the operator valued equivalent of the Kolmogorov extension theorem is needed. This theorem is given and proved. It is then shown that for each qΔ and each set E of possible outcome sequences, there are two ways to find the probability that carrying out qΔ on a system in state ρ gives an outcome sequence φ in E. The usual method of repeating qΔ on ρ over and over again generates a sequence α of outcome sequences φ. The probability is obtained as the limit relative frequency that α(j) is in E, for j = 0, 1, …. The other, new, method is the repeated measurement of OEqΔ on ρ. The remarkable aspect of this equivalence is that the mathematical procedures of the usual method for determining if α(j) is in E or not `disappear' into the operators OEqΔ of the new method. This is discussed in some detail and examples are given.
In classical physics, the Kolmogorov extension theorem lays the foundation for the theory of stochastic processes. It has been known for a long time that, in its original form, this theorem does not hold in quantum mechanics. More generally, it does not hold in any theory of stochastic processes -- classical, quantum or beyond -- that does not just describe passive observations, but allows for active interventions. Such processes form the basis of the study of causal modelling across the sciences, including in the quantum domain. To date, these frameworks have lacked a conceptual underpinning similar to that provided by Kolmogorov’s theorem for classical stochastic processes. We prove a generalized extension theorem that applies to all theories of stochastic processes, putting them on equally firm mathematical ground as their classical counterpart. Additionally, we show that quantum causal modelling and quantum stochastic processes are equivalent. This provides the correct framework for the description of experiments involving continuous control, which play a crucial role in the development of quantum technologies. Furthermore, we show that the original extension theorem follows from the generalized one in the correct limit, and elucidate how a comprehensive understanding of general stochastic processes allows one to unambiguously define the distinction between those that are classical and those that are quantum.
We investigate what can be concluded about a quantum system when sequential quantum measurements of its observable – a prominent example of the so-called quantum stochastic process – fulfill the Kolmogorov consistency condition and thus appear to an observer as a sampling of a classical trajectory. We identify a set of physical conditions imposed on the system dynamics, that when satisfied, lead to the aforementioned trajectory interpretation of the measurement results. We then show that when another quantum system is coupled to the observable, the operator representing it can be replaced by external noise. Crucially, the realizations of this surrogate (classical) stochastic process follow the same trajectories as those measured by the observer. Therefore, it can be said that the trajectory interpretation suggested by the Kolmogorov consistent measurements also applies in contexts other than sequential measurements.
de Broglie-Bohm theory (dBBT), treating quantum particles as point objects moving along well defined (Bohmian) trajectories, offers an appealing solution of the measurement problem in quantum mechanics; it has, however, problems relating to spin, relativity and lack of proper integration with the Hilbert space based framework. In this work, we present a consistent formalism which has the traditional state-observable framework integrated with the desirable features of dBBT. We adopt ensemble interpretation for the Schrodinger wave function ψψψ. Given a Schrodinger wave function ψψψ, we use its value ψ0ψ_0ψ0​ at some fixed time (say, t=0t = 0t=0) to define the probability measure ∣ψ0∣2dx|ψ_0|^2 {\rm d}x∣ψ0​∣2dx on the system configuration space MMM (=Rn=\mathbb{R}^n=Rn). On the resulting probability space M0\mathcal{M}_0M0​, we introduce a stochastic process ξ(t)ξ(t)ξ(t) corresponding to the Heisenberg position operator XH(t)X_H(t)XH​(t) such that, in the Heisenberg state ∣ψh⟩|ψ_h\rangle∣ψh​⟩ corresponding to ψ0ψ_0ψ0​, the expectation value of XH(t)X_H(t)XH​(t) equals that of ξ(t)ξ(t)ξ(t) in M0\mathcal{M}_0M0​. This condition leads to the de Broglie-Bohm guidance equation for the sample paths of the process ξ(t)ξ(t)ξ(t) which are, therefore, Bohmian trajectories supposedly representing time-evolutions of individual members of the ψ0ψ_0ψ0​-ensemble. Stochastic processes and Bohmian trajectories corresponding to observables with discrete eigenvalues (in particular spin) are treated by extending the configuration space to the spectral space of the commutative algebra obtained by adding appropriate discrete observables to the position observables. Pauli's equation is treated as an example. A straightforward derivation of von Neumann's projection rule employing the Schrodinger-Bohm evolution of individual systems along their Bohmian trajectories is given. Some comments on the potential application of the formalism developed here to quantum mechanics of the universe are included.