Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2311.07253 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Machine learning the Kondo entanglement cloud from local measurements

Faluke Aikebaier, Teemu Ojanen, José Luis Lado

Published May 8, 2024• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A quantum coherent screening cloud around a magnetic impurity in metallic systems is the hallmark of the antiferromagnetic Kondo effect. Despite the central role of the Kondo effect in quantum materials, the structure of quantum correlations of the screening cloud has defied direct observations. In this work, we introduce a machine-learning algorithm that allows one to spatially map the entangled electronic modes in the vicinity of the impurity site from experimentally accessible data. We demonstrate that local correlators allow reconstruction of the local many-body correlation entropy in real space in a double Kondo system with overlapping entanglement clouds. Our machine-learning methodology allows bypassing the typical requirement of measuring long-range nonlocal correlators with conventional methods. We show that our machine-learning algorithm is transferable between different Kondo system sizes, and we show its robustness in the presence of noisy correlators. Our work establishes the potential machine-learning methods to map many-body entanglement from real-space measurements.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.109.195125

Related papers

Transfer learning of many-body electronic correlation entropy from local measurements

Faluke Aikebaier, Teemu Ojanen, José Luis Lado

Characterizing quantum correlations in many-body systems is essential for understanding emergent phenomena in quantum materials. The correlation entropy serves as a key metric for assessing the complexity of a quantum many-body state in interacting electronic systems. However, its determination requires the measurement of all single-particle correlators across a macroscopic sample, which can be impractical. Machine learning methods have been shown to enable the correlation entropy to be learned from a reduced set of measurements, yet these methods assume that the targeted system is contained in the set of training Hamiltonians. Here we show that a transfer learning strategy enables correlation entropy learning from a reduced set of measurements in variants of Hamiltonians never considered in the training set. We demonstrate this transfer learning methodology in a wide variety of interacting models, including local and nonlocal attractive and repulsive many-body interactions, long-range hopping, doping, magnetic field, and spin-orbit coupling. Furthermore, we show that this transfer learning methodology enables the detection of phases in quantum many-body systems beyond those present in the training set. Our results demonstrate that correlation entropy learning can be performed experimentally without requiring training in the experimentally realized Hamiltonian.

arXiv:2501.09505•Physical Review Applied•Oct 10, 2025•0 citations

Universal spatial correlations in the anisotropic Kondo screening cloud: Analytical insights and numerically exact results from a coherent state expansion

Serge Florens, Izak Snyman

We analyze the spatial correlation structure of the spin density of an electron gas in the vicinity of an antiferromagnetically coupled Kondo impurity. Our analysis extends to the regime of spin-anisotropic couplings, where there are no quantitative results for spatial correlations in the literature. We use an original and numerically exact method, based on a systematic coherent-state expansion of the ground state of the underlying spin-boson Hamiltonian. It has not yet been applied to the computation of observables that are specific to the fermionic Kondo model. We also present an important technical improvement to the method that obviates the need to discretize modes of the Fermi sea, and allows one to tackle the problem in the thermodynamic limit. As a result, one can obtain excellent spatial resolution over arbitrary length scales, for a relatively low computational cost, a feature that gives the method an advantage over popular techniques such as the numerical and density-matrix renormalization groups. We find that the anisotropic Kondo model shows rich universal scaling behavior in the spatial structure of the entanglement cloud. First, SU(2) spin-symmetry is dynamically restored in a finite domain in the parameter space in the vicinity of the isotropic line, as expected from poor man's scaling. More surprisingly, we are able to obtain in closed analytical form a set of different, yet universal, scaling curves for strong exchange asymmetry, which are parametrized by the longitudinal exchange coupling. Deep inside the cloud, i.e., for distances smaller than the Kondo length, the correlation between the electron spin density and the impurity spin oscillates between ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic values at the scale of the Fermi wavelength, an effect that is drastically enhanced at strongly anisotropic couplings. Our results also provide further numerical checks and alternative analytical approximations for the Kondo overlaps that were recently computed by Lukyanov, Saleur, Jacobsen, and Vasseur [Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 080601 (2015)].

arXiv:1507.04307•Physical Review B•Nov 4, 2015•24 citations

Electrical control of a Kondo spin screening cloud

Ngoc Han Tu, Dong-Hoon Kim, Kim, Minsoo L. +8 more

Quantitative analysis of quantum many-body systems, consisting of numerous itinerant electrons that interact with localized spins or electrons, is a long-standing issue. The Kondo cloud, a quantum many-body object of conduction electrons that screens a single localized spin, is the building block of such strongly correlated electronic systems. While quantitative analysis of the Kondo cloud associated with a single magnetic impurity is well established for uniform conduction electrons, the fundamental properties of a deformed Kondo cloud influenced by conduction electrons with a modulated density of states remain unsolved. Here we report engineering of the Kondo cloud deformation by confining a part of the cloud into a quantum box called the Kondo box that mimics realistic material systems. We demonstrate quantitative control of the Kondo cloud by developing a way of tuning quantum interference in the box and monitoring the Kondo entanglement. The temperature dependence of the entanglement reveals counterintuitively that the cloud shape is altered mainly outside the box although the quantum interference in the box is tuned. Our work provides a way to simulate various strongly correlated systems by integrating the Kondo cloud, which is not possible in the current theoretical framework.

arXiv:2404.11955•Apr 18, 2024•1 citation

Kondo screening cloud scaling: impurity entanglement and magnetization

Erik Schwartz Sørensen

Abstract The screening of an impurity spin in the Kondo model occurs over a characteristic length scale ξ K , that defines the size of the Kondo screening cloud or ‘mist’. The presence of such a length scale in experimental and numerical results is rather subtle. A consistent way to show the presence of the screening cloud is to demonstrate scaling in the spatial correlations in terms of the single variable, r / ξ K instead of the correlations depending on r and ξ K separately. Here we study the paradigmatic one channel Kondo model using a spin chain representation, with an impurity spin at one end of the chain coupled with a strength J K ′ . Using Fermi liquid theory combined with numerical results, we obtain new high precision estimates of the non-universal terms in the entanglement entropy which leads to a verification of the expected non-integer ground-state degeneracy, g. This then allows us to study the impurity contribution to the entanglement in detail. If the impurity coupling J K ′ is varied, a precise determination of ξ K can then be obtained. The length scale, ξ K , is then shown to characterize the scaling of both the uniform and alternating part of a measure of the magnetization of part of an odd length chain.

arXiv:2310.08547•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Jan 1, 2024•1 citation

Simulating realistic screening clouds around quantum impurities: Role of spatial anisotropy and disorder

Maxime Debertolis, Izak Snyman, Serge Florens

Dynamical quantum impurities in metals induce electronic correlations in real space that are difficult to simulate due to their multiscale nature, so that only $s\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{wave}$ scattering in clean metallic hosts has been investigated so far. However, screening clouds should show anisotropy due to lack of full rotational invariance in two- and three-dimensional lattices, while inherent disorder will also induce spatial inhomogeneities. To tackle these challenges, we present an efficient and robust algorithm based on the recursive generation of natural orbitals defined as eigenvectors of the truncated single-particle density matrix. This method provides well-converged many-body wave functions on lattices with up to tens of thousands of sites, bypassing some limitations of other approaches. The algorithm is put to the test by investigating the charge screening cloud around an interacting resonant level, both on clean and disordered lattices, achieving accurate spatial resolution from short to long distances. We thus demonstrate strong anisotropy of spatial correlations around an adatom in the half-filled square lattice. Taking advantage of the efficiency of the algorithm, we further compute the disorder-induced distribution of Kondo temperatures over several thousands of random realizations, at the same time gaining access to the full spatial profile of the screening cloud in each sample. While the charge screening cloud is typically shortened due to the polarization of the impurity by the disorder potential, we surprisingly find that rare disorder configurations preserve the long-range nature of Kondo correlations in the electronic bath.

arXiv:2203.13041•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 12, 2022•6 citations

Unsupervised learning of effective quantum impurity models

Jonas B. Rigo, Andrew K. Mitchell

Generalized quantum impurity models—which feature a few localized and strongly correlated degrees of freedom coupled to itinerant conduction electrons—describe diverse physical systems, from magnetic moments in metals to nanoelectronics quantum devices such as quantum dots or single-molecule transistors. Correlated materials can also be understood as self-consistent impurity models through dynamical mean-field theory. Accurate simulation of such models is challenging, especially at low temperatures, due to many-body effects from electronic interactions, resulting in strong renormalization. In particular, the interplay between local impurity complexity and Kondo physics is highly nontrivial. A common approach, which we further develop in this work, is to consider instead a simpler effective impurity model that still captures the low-energy physics of interest. The mapping from a bare to an effective model is typically done perturbatively, but even this can be difficult for complex systems, and the resulting effective model parameters can nevertheless be quite inaccurate. Here we develop a nonperturbative, unsupervised machine learning approach to systematically obtain low-energy effective impurity-type models, based on the renormalization-group framework. The method is shown to be general and flexible, as well as accurate and systematically improvable. We benchmark the method against exact results for the Anderson impurity model, and we provide an outlook for more complex models beyond the reach of existing methods. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2401.13600•Physical Review Research•Oct 17, 2024•2 citations
A quantum coherent screening cloud around a magnetic impurity in metallic systems is the hallmark of the antiferromagnetic Kondo effect. Despite the central role of the Kondo effect in quantum materials, the structure of quantum correlations of the screening cloud has defied direct observations. In this work, we introduce a machine-learning algorithm that allows one to spatially map the entangled electronic modes in the vicinity of the impurity site from experimentally accessible data. We demonstrate that local correlators allow reconstruction of the local many-body correlation entropy in real space in a double Kondo system with overlapping entanglement clouds. Our machine-learning methodology allows bypassing the typical requirement of measuring long-range nonlocal correlators with conventional methods. We show that our machine-learning algorithm is transferable between different Kondo system sizes, and we show its robustness in the presence of noisy correlators. Our work establishes the potential machine-learning methods to map many-body entanglement from real-space measurements.
Characterizing quantum correlations in many-body systems is essential for understanding emergent phenomena in quantum materials. The correlation entropy serves as a key metric for assessing the complexity of a quantum many-body state in interacting electronic systems. However, its determination requires the measurement of all single-particle correlators across a macroscopic sample, which can be impractical. Machine learning methods have been shown to enable the correlation entropy to be learned from a reduced set of measurements, yet these methods assume that the targeted system is contained in the set of training Hamiltonians. Here we show that a transfer learning strategy enables correlation entropy learning from a reduced set of measurements in variants of Hamiltonians never considered in the training set. We demonstrate this transfer learning methodology in a wide variety of interacting models, including local and nonlocal attractive and repulsive many-body interactions, long-range hopping, doping, magnetic field, and spin-orbit coupling. Furthermore, we show that this transfer learning methodology enables the detection of phases in quantum many-body systems beyond those present in the training set. Our results demonstrate that correlation entropy learning can be performed experimentally without requiring training in the experimentally realized Hamiltonian.
We analyze the spatial correlation structure of the spin density of an electron gas in the vicinity of an antiferromagnetically coupled Kondo impurity. Our analysis extends to the regime of spin-anisotropic couplings, where there are no quantitative results for spatial correlations in the literature. We use an original and numerically exact method, based on a systematic coherent-state expansion of the ground state of the underlying spin-boson Hamiltonian. It has not yet been applied to the computation of observables that are specific to the fermionic Kondo model. We also present an important technical improvement to the method that obviates the need to discretize modes of the Fermi sea, and allows one to tackle the problem in the thermodynamic limit. As a result, one can obtain excellent spatial resolution over arbitrary length scales, for a relatively low computational cost, a feature that gives the method an advantage over popular techniques such as the numerical and density-matrix renormalization groups. We find that the anisotropic Kondo model shows rich universal scaling behavior in the spatial structure of the entanglement cloud. First, SU(2) spin-symmetry is dynamically restored in a finite domain in the parameter space in the vicinity of the isotropic line, as expected from poor man's scaling. More surprisingly, we are able to obtain in closed analytical form a set of different, yet universal, scaling curves for strong exchange asymmetry, which are parametrized by the longitudinal exchange coupling. Deep inside the cloud, i.e., for distances smaller than the Kondo length, the correlation between the electron spin density and the impurity spin oscillates between ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic values at the scale of the Fermi wavelength, an effect that is drastically enhanced at strongly anisotropic couplings. Our results also provide further numerical checks and alternative analytical approximations for the Kondo overlaps that were recently computed by Lukyanov, Saleur, Jacobsen, and Vasseur [Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 080601 (2015)].
Quantitative analysis of quantum many-body systems, consisting of numerous itinerant electrons that interact with localized spins or electrons, is a long-standing issue. The Kondo cloud, a quantum many-body object of conduction electrons that screens a single localized spin, is the building block of such strongly correlated electronic systems. While quantitative analysis of the Kondo cloud associated with a single magnetic impurity is well established for uniform conduction electrons, the fundamental properties of a deformed Kondo cloud influenced by conduction electrons with a modulated density of states remain unsolved. Here we report engineering of the Kondo cloud deformation by confining a part of the cloud into a quantum box called the Kondo box that mimics realistic material systems. We demonstrate quantitative control of the Kondo cloud by developing a way of tuning quantum interference in the box and monitoring the Kondo entanglement. The temperature dependence of the entanglement reveals counterintuitively that the cloud shape is altered mainly outside the box although the quantum interference in the box is tuned. Our work provides a way to simulate various strongly correlated systems by integrating the Kondo cloud, which is not possible in the current theoretical framework.
Abstract The screening of an impurity spin in the Kondo model occurs over a characteristic length scale ξ K , that defines the size of the Kondo screening cloud or ‘mist’. The presence of such a length scale in experimental and numerical results is rather subtle. A consistent way to show the presence of the screening cloud is to demonstrate scaling in the spatial correlations in terms of the single variable, r / ξ K instead of the correlations depending on r and ξ K separately. Here we study the paradigmatic one channel Kondo model using a spin chain representation, with an impurity spin at one end of the chain coupled with a strength J K ′ . Using Fermi liquid theory combined with numerical results, we obtain new high precision estimates of the non-universal terms in the entanglement entropy which leads to a verification of the expected non-integer ground-state degeneracy, g. This then allows us to study the impurity contribution to the entanglement in detail. If the impurity coupling J K ′ is varied, a precise determination of ξ K can then be obtained. The length scale, ξ K , is then shown to characterize the scaling of both the uniform and alternating part of a measure of the magnetization of part of an odd length chain.
Dynamical quantum impurities in metals induce electronic correlations in real space that are difficult to simulate due to their multiscale nature, so that only $s\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{wave}$ scattering in clean metallic hosts has been investigated so far. However, screening clouds should show anisotropy due to lack of full rotational invariance in two- and three-dimensional lattices, while inherent disorder will also induce spatial inhomogeneities. To tackle these challenges, we present an efficient and robust algorithm based on the recursive generation of natural orbitals defined as eigenvectors of the truncated single-particle density matrix. This method provides well-converged many-body wave functions on lattices with up to tens of thousands of sites, bypassing some limitations of other approaches. The algorithm is put to the test by investigating the charge screening cloud around an interacting resonant level, both on clean and disordered lattices, achieving accurate spatial resolution from short to long distances. We thus demonstrate strong anisotropy of spatial correlations around an adatom in the half-filled square lattice. Taking advantage of the efficiency of the algorithm, we further compute the disorder-induced distribution of Kondo temperatures over several thousands of random realizations, at the same time gaining access to the full spatial profile of the screening cloud in each sample. While the charge screening cloud is typically shortened due to the polarization of the impurity by the disorder potential, we surprisingly find that rare disorder configurations preserve the long-range nature of Kondo correlations in the electronic bath.
Generalized quantum impurity models—which feature a few localized and strongly correlated degrees of freedom coupled to itinerant conduction electrons—describe diverse physical systems, from magnetic moments in metals to nanoelectronics quantum devices such as quantum dots or single-molecule transistors. Correlated materials can also be understood as self-consistent impurity models through dynamical mean-field theory. Accurate simulation of such models is challenging, especially at low temperatures, due to many-body effects from electronic interactions, resulting in strong renormalization. In particular, the interplay between local impurity complexity and Kondo physics is highly nontrivial. A common approach, which we further develop in this work, is to consider instead a simpler effective impurity model that still captures the low-energy physics of interest. The mapping from a bare to an effective model is typically done perturbatively, but even this can be difficult for complex systems, and the resulting effective model parameters can nevertheless be quite inaccurate. Here we develop a nonperturbative, unsupervised machine learning approach to systematically obtain low-energy effective impurity-type models, based on the renormalization-group framework. The method is shown to be general and flexible, as well as accurate and systematically improvable. We benchmark the method against exact results for the Anderson impurity model, and we provide an outlook for more complex models beyond the reach of existing methods. Published by the American Physical Society 2024