Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2209.03969 · Physical Review Letters

Quantum Discord and Steering in Top Quarks at the LHC

Y. Afik, Juan Ramón Muñoz de Nova

Published May 31, 2023• 100 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Top quarks have been recently shown to be a promising system to study quantum information at the highest-energy scale available. The current lines of research mostly discuss topics such as entanglement, Bell nonlocality or quantum tomography. Here, we provide the full picture of quantum correlations in top quarks by studying also quantum discord and steering. We find that both phenomena are present at the LHC. In particular, quantum discord in a separable quantum state is expected to be detected with high-statistical significance. Interestingly, due to the singular nature of the measurement process, quantum discord can be measured following its original definition, and the steering ellipsoid can be experimentally reconstructed, both highly demanding measurements in conventional setups. In contrast to entanglement, the asymmetric nature of quantum discord and steering can provide witnesses of CP-violating physics beyond the standard model.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.130.221801

Related papers

Measuring quantum discord at the LHC

Tao Han, Matthew Low, Navin McGinnis +1 more

A bstract There has been an increasing interest in exploring quantities associated with quantum information at colliders. We perform a detailed analysis describing how to measure the quantum discord in the top anti-top quantum state at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). While for pure states, quantum discord, entanglement, and Bell nonlocality all probe the same correlations, for mixed states they probe different aspects of quantum correlations. The quantum discord, in particular, is interesting because it aims to encapsulate all correlations between systems that cannot have a classical origin. We employ two complementary approaches for the study of the top anti-top system, namely the decay method and the kinematic method. We highlight subtleties associated with measuring discord for reconstructed quantum states at colliders. Usually quantum discord is difficult to compute due to an extremization that must be performed. We show, however, that for the $$ t\overline{t} $$ t t ¯ system this extremization can be performed analytically and we provide closed-form formulas for the quantum discord. We demonstrate that with current LHC datasets, quantum discord can be observed at 3 . 6 – 5 . 7 σ , depending on the signal region, with the decay method and can be measured at a precision of 0 . 1 – 0 . 2% with the kinematic method. At the high luminosity LHC, the observation of quantum discord is expected to be > 5 σ using both the decay and kinematic methods and can be measured with a precision of 5% with the decay method and 0 . 05% with the kinematic method. Additionally, we identify the kinematic cuts at the LHC to isolate the $$ t\overline{t} $$ t t ¯ state that is separable but has non-zero discord. By systematically investigating quantum discord for the first time through a detailed collider analysis, this work expands the toolkit for quantum information studies in particle physics and lays the groundwork for deeper insights into the quantum properties in high-energy collisions.

arXiv:2412.21158•Journal of High Energy Physics•May 9, 2025•27 citations

Entanglement and quantum tomography with top quarks at the LHC

Y. Afik, Juan Ramón Muñoz de Nova

Abstract Entanglement is a central subject in quantum mechanics. Due to its genuine relativistic behavior and fundamental nature, high-energy colliders are attractive systems for the experimental study of fundamental aspects of quantum mechanics. We propose the detection of entanglement between the spins of top–antitop–quark pairs at the LHC, representing the first proposal of entanglement detection in a pair of quarks, and also the entanglement observation at the highest energy scale so far. We show that entanglement can be observed by direct measurement of the angular separation between the leptons arising from the decay of the top–antitop pair. The detection can be achieved with high statistical significance, using the current data recorded during Run 2 at the LHC. In addition, we develop a simple protocol for the quantum tomography of the top–antitop pair. This experimental technique reconstructs the quantum state of the system, providing a new experimental tool to test theoretical predictions. Our work explicitly implements canonical experimental techniques in quantum information in a two-qubit high-energy system, paving the way to use high-energy colliders to also study quantum information aspects.

arXiv:2003.02280•The European Physical Journal Plus•Sep 3, 2021•173 citations

Experimental characterization of the hierarchy of quantum correlations in top quark pairs

Yoav Afik, Regina Demina, Alan Herrera +3 more

Recent results from the Large Hadron Collider have demonstrated quantum entanglement of top quark-antiquark pairs using the spin degrees of freedom. Based on the doubly differential measurement of the spin density matrix of the top quark and antiquark performed by the CMS collaboration in the helicity and beam bases, we evaluate a set of quantum observables, including discord, steerability, Bell correlation, and magic. These observables allow for a quantitative characterization of the quantum correlations present in a top quark-antiquark system, thus enabling an interpretation of collider data in terms of quantum states and their properties. Discord is observed to be greater than zero with a significance of more than 5 standard deviations ($σ$) in several regions of phase space, some of which correspond to separable quantum states. Evidence for steerability is established for the first time in a high-energy system, with a significance of more than 3$σ$. No Bell correlation is observed within the currently probed phase space, in agreement with the theoretical prediction. These results experimentally corroborate the hierarchy of quantum correlations in top quarks with discord being the most basic form of quantum correlation, followed by entanglement, steerability, and Bell correlation. The significance of nonzero magic, which is a complementary observable to the quantum correlation hierarchy, is found to exceed 5$σ$ in several regions of phase space.

quant-pharXiv:2602.15115•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Feb 18, 2026•1 citation

Toponium effects on quantum steering and Bell nonlocality of top quarks

J. A. Aguilar-Saavedra, S. Rodríguez-Benítez

We investigate quantum steering and Bell nonlocality in top-quark pair production at the LHC near threshold. The toponium contribution strengthens the spin-singlet component and substantially enhances the entanglement between the two quark spins. With current LHC data, quantum steering appears observable with a statistical significance around $10σ$. For Bell nonlocality, the statistical significance can also be high close to threshold, reaching about $9σ$, although the feasibility of such a measurement will depend crucially on the control of systematic uncertainties.

hep-phCross-listedarXiv:2606.30768•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations

Quantum steering and discord in hyperon-antihyperon system in electron-positron annihilation

Sihao Wu, Chen Qian, Qun Wang +1 more

Hyperon-antihyperon pairs produced from electron-positron annihilations provide a promising platform for exploring quantum-information properties in particle physics. In this work, we analyze quantum steering and quantum discord in hyperon-antihyperon systems produced from e + e − annihilations, based on the X -shaped spin density matrix reconstructed via quantum state tomography. We show that the behaviors of these correlations differ from those observed in elementary particle-antiparticle systems such as top quarks and τ leptons, owing to the polarization effects specific to hyperon decays. From the results, we examine the hierarchy of quantum correlations in hyperon-antihyperon systems, Bell nonlocality ⊂ steering ⊂ entanglement ⊂ discord . We also discuss the role of experimental loopholes and the impact of quantum decoherence in collider-based studies of quantum correlations.

arXiv:2509.14990•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Mar 5, 2026•3 citations

Nonlocal advantage of quantum coherence in top quarks

Saurabh Rai, Jitendra Kumar

There is a growing interest in investigating top-quark systems using tools from quantum information theory. A key peculiarity of the top quark is that it decays before hadronization or spin decorrelation occurs, thereby preserving its spin information. This unique property enables direct access to spin correlations, making the top quark an ideal candidate for probing fundamental quantum correlations in high-energy physics processes. A wide range of concepts from quantum information theory, such as entanglement, Bell nonlocality, quantum steering, quantum discord, and fidelity, have been investigated in this context. Several of these measures have been employed as diagnostic tools to test the Standard Model and to search for possible signatures of physics beyond. However, the (NAQC) has remained largely unexplored in this context. In this work, we present a detailed investigation of the NAQC in top quark pair production. We employ two complementary NAQC measures based on the l 1 norm and the relative entropy of coherence. We also study the effect of angular averaging on these measures and assess the sensitivity of current LHC spin-correlation measurements to NAQC. Our findings reveal rich coherence structures and highlight NAQC as potentially a novel and complementary quantum signature in high-energy physics systems.

arXiv:2505.12004•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Dec 9, 2025•1 citation
Top quarks have been recently shown to be a promising system to study quantum information at the highest-energy scale available. The current lines of research mostly discuss topics such as entanglement, Bell nonlocality or quantum tomography. Here, we provide the full picture of quantum correlations in top quarks by studying also quantum discord and steering. We find that both phenomena are present at the LHC. In particular, quantum discord in a separable quantum state is expected to be detected with high-statistical significance. Interestingly, due to the singular nature of the measurement process, quantum discord can be measured following its original definition, and the steering ellipsoid can be experimentally reconstructed, both highly demanding measurements in conventional setups. In contrast to entanglement, the asymmetric nature of quantum discord and steering can provide witnesses of CP-violating physics beyond the standard model.
A bstract There has been an increasing interest in exploring quantities associated with quantum information at colliders. We perform a detailed analysis describing how to measure the quantum discord in the top anti-top quantum state at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). While for pure states, quantum discord, entanglement, and Bell nonlocality all probe the same correlations, for mixed states they probe different aspects of quantum correlations. The quantum discord, in particular, is interesting because it aims to encapsulate all correlations between systems that cannot have a classical origin. We employ two complementary approaches for the study of the top anti-top system, namely the decay method and the kinematic method. We highlight subtleties associated with measuring discord for reconstructed quantum states at colliders. Usually quantum discord is difficult to compute due to an extremization that must be performed. We show, however, that for the tt‾ t\overline{t} tt t t ¯ system this extremization can be performed analytically and we provide closed-form formulas for the quantum discord. We demonstrate that with current LHC datasets, quantum discord can be observed at 3 . 6 – 5 . 7 σ , depending on the signal region, with the decay method and can be measured at a precision of 0 . 1 – 0 . 2% with the kinematic method. At the high luminosity LHC, the observation of quantum discord is expected to be > 5 σ using both the decay and kinematic methods and can be measured with a precision of 5% with the decay method and 0 . 05% with the kinematic method. Additionally, we identify the kinematic cuts at the LHC to isolate the tt‾ t\overline{t} tt t t ¯ state that is separable but has non-zero discord. By systematically investigating quantum discord for the first time through a detailed collider analysis, this work expands the toolkit for quantum information studies in particle physics and lays the groundwork for deeper insights into the quantum properties in high-energy collisions.
Abstract Entanglement is a central subject in quantum mechanics. Due to its genuine relativistic behavior and fundamental nature, high-energy colliders are attractive systems for the experimental study of fundamental aspects of quantum mechanics. We propose the detection of entanglement between the spins of top–antitop–quark pairs at the LHC, representing the first proposal of entanglement detection in a pair of quarks, and also the entanglement observation at the highest energy scale so far. We show that entanglement can be observed by direct measurement of the angular separation between the leptons arising from the decay of the top–antitop pair. The detection can be achieved with high statistical significance, using the current data recorded during Run 2 at the LHC. In addition, we develop a simple protocol for the quantum tomography of the top–antitop pair. This experimental technique reconstructs the quantum state of the system, providing a new experimental tool to test theoretical predictions. Our work explicitly implements canonical experimental techniques in quantum information in a two-qubit high-energy system, paving the way to use high-energy colliders to also study quantum information aspects.
Recent results from the Large Hadron Collider have demonstrated quantum entanglement of top quark-antiquark pairs using the spin degrees of freedom. Based on the doubly differential measurement of the spin density matrix of the top quark and antiquark performed by the CMS collaboration in the helicity and beam bases, we evaluate a set of quantum observables, including discord, steerability, Bell correlation, and magic. These observables allow for a quantitative characterization of the quantum correlations present in a top quark-antiquark system, thus enabling an interpretation of collider data in terms of quantum states and their properties. Discord is observed to be greater than zero with a significance of more than 5 standard deviations (σσσ) in several regions of phase space, some of which correspond to separable quantum states. Evidence for steerability is established for the first time in a high-energy system, with a significance of more than 3σσσ. No Bell correlation is observed within the currently probed phase space, in agreement with the theoretical prediction. These results experimentally corroborate the hierarchy of quantum correlations in top quarks with discord being the most basic form of quantum correlation, followed by entanglement, steerability, and Bell correlation. The significance of nonzero magic, which is a complementary observable to the quantum correlation hierarchy, is found to exceed 5σσσ in several regions of phase space.
We investigate quantum steering and Bell nonlocality in top-quark pair production at the LHC near threshold. The toponium contribution strengthens the spin-singlet component and substantially enhances the entanglement between the two quark spins. With current LHC data, quantum steering appears observable with a statistical significance around 10σ10σ10σ. For Bell nonlocality, the statistical significance can also be high close to threshold, reaching about 9σ9σ9σ, although the feasibility of such a measurement will depend crucially on the control of systematic uncertainties.
Hyperon-antihyperon pairs produced from electron-positron annihilations provide a promising platform for exploring quantum-information properties in particle physics. In this work, we analyze quantum steering and quantum discord in hyperon-antihyperon systems produced from e + e − annihilations, based on the X -shaped spin density matrix reconstructed via quantum state tomography. We show that the behaviors of these correlations differ from those observed in elementary particle-antiparticle systems such as top quarks and τ leptons, owing to the polarization effects specific to hyperon decays. From the results, we examine the hierarchy of quantum correlations in hyperon-antihyperon systems, Bell nonlocality ⊂ steering ⊂ entanglement ⊂ discord . We also discuss the role of experimental loopholes and the impact of quantum decoherence in collider-based studies of quantum correlations.
There is a growing interest in investigating top-quark systems using tools from quantum information theory. A key peculiarity of the top quark is that it decays before hadronization or spin decorrelation occurs, thereby preserving its spin information. This unique property enables direct access to spin correlations, making the top quark an ideal candidate for probing fundamental quantum correlations in high-energy physics processes. A wide range of concepts from quantum information theory, such as entanglement, Bell nonlocality, quantum steering, quantum discord, and fidelity, have been investigated in this context. Several of these measures have been employed as diagnostic tools to test the Standard Model and to search for possible signatures of physics beyond. However, the (NAQC) has remained largely unexplored in this context. In this work, we present a detailed investigation of the NAQC in top quark pair production. We employ two complementary NAQC measures based on the l 1 norm and the relative entropy of coherence. We also study the effect of angular averaging on these measures and assess the sensitivity of current LHC spin-correlation measurements to NAQC. Our findings reveal rich coherence structures and highlight NAQC as potentially a novel and complementary quantum signature in high-energy physics systems.