Simultaneous single-qubit driving of semiconductor spin qubits at the fault-tolerant threshold
William I. L. Lawrie, Maximilian Rimbach-Russ, F. van Riggelen, Nico W. Hendrickx, Sander L. de Snoo, Amir Sammak, Giordano Scappucci, Jonas Helsen, Menno Veldhorst
Practical Quantum computing hinges on the ability to control large numbers of qubits with high fidelity. Quantum dots define a promising platform due to their compatibility with semiconductor manufacturing. Moreover, high-fidelity operations above 99.9% have been realized with individual qubits, though their performance has been limited to 98.67% when driving two qubits simultaneously. Here we present single-qubit randomized benchmarking in a two-dimensional array of spin qubits, finding native gate fidelities as high as 99.992(1)%. Furthermore, we benchmark single qubit gate performance while simultaneously driving two and four qubits, utilizing a novel benchmarking technique called N-copy randomized benchmarking, designed for simple experimental implementation and accurate simultaneous gate fidelity estimation. We find two- and four-copy randomized benchmarking fidelities of 99.905(8)% and 99.34(4)% respectively, and that next-nearest neighbor pairs are highly robust to cross-talk errors. These characterizations of single-qubit gate quality are crucial for scaling up quantum information technology.
Practical Quantum computing hinges on the ability to control large numbers of qubits with high fidelity. Quantum dots define a promising platform due to their compatibility with semiconductor manufacturing. Moreover, high-fidelity operations above 99.9% have been realized with individual qubits, though their performance has been limited to 98.67% when driving two qubits simultaneously. Here we present single-qubit randomized benchmarking in a two-dimensional array of spin qubits, finding native gate fidelities as high as 99.992(1)%. Furthermore, we benchmark single qubit gate performance while simultaneously driving two and four qubits, utilizing a novel benchmarking technique called N-copy randomized benchmarking, designed for simple experimental implementation and accurate simultaneous gate fidelity estimation. We find two- and four-copy randomized benchmarking fidelities of 99.905(8)% and 99.34(4)% respectively, and that next-nearest neighbor pairs are highly robust to cross-talk errors. These characterizations of single-qubit gate quality are crucial for scaling up quantum information technology.
The promise of quantum information technology hinges on the ability to control large numbers of qubits with high-fidelity. Quantum dots define a promising platform due to their compatibility with semiconductor manufacturing. Moreover, high-fidelity operations above 99.9% have been realized with individual qubits, though their performance has been limited to 98.67% when driving two qubits simultaneously. Here we present single-qubit randomized benchmarking in a two-dimensional array of spin qubits, for one, two and four simultaneously driven qubits. We find that by carefully tuning the qubit parameters, we achieve native gate fidelities of 99.9899(4)%, 99.904(4)% and 99.00(4)% respectively. We also find that cross talk with next-nearest neighbor pairs induces errors that can be imperceptible within the error margin, indicating that cross talk can be highly local. These characterizations of the single-qubit gate quality and the ability to operate simultaneously are crucial aspects for scaling up germanium based quantum information technology.
Abstract Universal quantum computation will require qubit technology based on a scalable platform1, together with quantum error correction protocols that place strict limits on the maximum infidelities for one- and two-qubit gate operations2, 3. Although various qubit systems have shown high fidelities at the one-qubit level4–10, the only solid-state qubits manufactured using standard lithographic techniques that have demonstrated two-qubit fidelities near the fault-tolerance threshold6 have been in superconductor systems. Silicon-based quantum dot qubits are also amenable to large-scale fabrication and can achieve high single-qubit gate fidelities (exceeding 99.9 per cent) using isotopically enriched silicon11, 12. Two-qubit gates have now been demonstrated in a number of systems13–15, but as yet an accurate assessment of their fidelities using Clifford-based randomized benchmarking, which uses sequences of randomly chosen gates to measure the error, has not been achieved. Here, for qubits encoded on the electron spin states of gate-defined quantum dots, we demonstrate Bell state tomography with fidelities ranging from 80 to 89 per cent, and two-qubit randomized benchmarking with an average Clifford gate fidelity of 94.7 per cent and an average controlled-rotation fidelity of 98 per cent. These fidelities are found to be limited by the relatively long gate times used here compared with the decoherence times of the qubits. Silicon qubit designs employing fast gate operations with high Rabi frequencies16, 17, together with advanced pulsing techniques18, should therefore enable much higher fidelities in the near future.
Abstract Silicon spin qubits offer a promising path to scalable quantum computing due to their compatibility with industrial semiconductor manufacturing. A key requirement for scaling quantum processors is the ability to perform high-fidelity operations in parallel across many qubits. However, simultaneous control remains a major challenge in silicon devices, as fidelities typically degrade under parallel operation. Here we identify microwave-drive-induced a.c.-Stark shifts as the dominant source of this degradation in a five-qubit silicon spin array. We address this by introducing a scalable mitigation protocol based solely on pairwise phase calibrations. Using tailored control pulses on a shared control line, we achieve primitive X and Y gate fidelities well above 99.99% for each qubit individually, with some approaching 99.999%. Furthermore, these fidelities are preserved above 99.99% during simultaneous operation of up to three qubits. During parallel five-qubit operation, fidelities remain above the widely targeted fault-tolerant threshold of 99.9%. By maintaining high-fidelity control during simultaneous operation, shared qubit-control lines can support the development of large-scale semiconductor quantum processors.
Abstract High-fidelity control of quantum bits is paramount for the reliable execution of quantum algorithms and for achieving fault tolerance—the ability to correct errors faster than they occur 1 . The central requirement for fault tolerance is expressed in terms of an error threshold. Whereas the actual threshold depends on many details, a common target is the approximately 1% error threshold of the well-known surface code 2,3 . Reaching two-qubit gate fidelities above 99% has been a long-standing major goal for semiconductor spin qubits. These qubits are promising for scaling, as they can leverage advanced semiconductor technology 4 . Here we report a spin-based quantum processor in silicon with single-qubit and two-qubit gate fidelities, all of which are above 99.5%, extracted from gate-set tomography. The average single-qubit gate fidelities remain above 99% when including crosstalk and idling errors on the neighbouring qubit. Using this high-fidelity gate set, we execute the demanding task of calculating molecular ground-state energies using a variational quantum eigensolver algorithm 5 . Having surpassed the 99% barrier for the two-qubit gate fidelity, semiconductor qubits are well positioned on the path to fault tolerance and to possible applications in the era of noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices.
In semiconductor single-spin qubits, high-fidelity quantum gates have been demonstrated; however, achieving consistent performance remains challenging due to variations in driven qubit coherence, which is less explored than free-evolution coherence such as T2∗. Here, we report single-qubit gate fidelities above 99.999%, achieved by dramatically extending the driven-spin coherence time and suppressing off-resonant driving effects that are detrimental to accurate fidelity benchmarking. We demonstrate that removing proximal reservoirs significantly enhances the spin-locking coherence time (T1ρ), a critical metric for qubits under microwave driving. Furthermore, we reveal that in typical spin qubit setups using parity readout and rectangular pulses, off-resonant excitation of neighboring qubits causes substantial benchmarking artifacts. By optimizing device conditions to mitigate microwave-induced degradation and implementing spectrally tailored pulse shaping, we achieve a π/2 gate fidelity of 99.99920(2)%, with remaining errors primarily limited by incoherent noise. These results showcase the mechanisms that bound fidelity benchmarking in state-of-the-art silicon spin qubits and provide practical guidelines for achieving and verifying high fidelities in these systems.
Electron spins trapped in quantum dots have recently proven to be a promising technology for the implementation of qubits, already demonstrating high fidelity single- and two-qubits gates. The next step towards fault-tolerant quantum computing is to increase the number of so-called spin qubits on the processor. However, this poses several challenges, one of which being how to implement single-qubit gates in multi-qubit systems, with high fidelity. This work focused on two aspects. The first one was to identify the physical phenomena and limitations that hinder the realisation of high fidelity single-qubit gates in multi-qubit environments. The second objective was to investigate, implement and optimise methods in order to minimise the impact of these perturbing phenomena. The identified perturbing effects include unwanted driving between a pulse and the neighbouring qubits, as well as frequency shifts induced by drive-spin coupling and non-ideal pulse in experimental setups. Crosstalk was addressed using pulse shaping (i.e. amplitude or phase modulation of the driving pulse to tailor its spectral characteristics and reduce the energy transmitted at unwanted frequencies). The performance of shapes taken from both NMR and signal processing literature was investigated, for various pulse parameters, through an extensive grid search. In addition, a frequency correction algorithm was devised: off-resonant drive frequencies are selected so that the shifted qubits are resonantly driven. It currently accounts for two phenomena: the AC Stark and Bloch-Siegert shifts. The algorithm furthermore tracks the changes caused by the time-dependent characteristics of the shaped pulses. The proposed frequency correction algorithm was shown to almost entirely negate the effects of the considered shifts, leading to unitary fidelity improvements by up to 55%. In addition, pulse shaping was demonstrated to noticeably improve the fidelity of simultaneous single-qubit rotations compared to unshaped driving. Rotations with fidelities as high as 99.98% were obtained for pi/2 rotations on two-qubits systems. Moreover, shapes whose Fourier transform is narrow and sharp, associated with low Rabi frequencies, were demonstrated to generally provide the highest fidelities of the tested configurations. Lastly, the trends and guidelines highlighted by these results were shown to scale to systems with larger numbers of qubits. The correction techniques investigated in this work have proven promising for the implementation of high fidelity single-qubit gates in multi-qubit systems. In particular, the guidelines for selecting a well-performing pulse shape should also be useful for the design of optimised driving schemes, regardless of the number of qubits involved. Additionally, the proposed frequency shift correction algorithm is expected to be able to handle arbitrary shifts, and so to be easily adaptable to use in experiments.