Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2104.14389 · Physical Review Research

Partitioning dysprosium's electronic spin to reveal entanglement in nonclassical states

Tanish Satoor, Aurélien Fabre, Jean-Baptiste Bouhiron, Alexandre Evrard, Raphael Lopes, Sylvain Nascimbène

Published Oct 1, 2021• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum spins of mesoscopic size are a well-studied playground for engineering nonclassical states. If the spin represents the collective state of an ensemble of qubits, its nonclassical behavior is linked to entanglement between the qubits. In this paper, we report on an experimental study of entanglement between two subsystems of dysprosium's electronic spin. Its ground state, of angular momentum $J=8$, can formally be viewed as a set of $2J$ qubits symmetric upon exchange. To access entanglement properties, we partition the spin by optically coupling it to an excited state ${J}^{\ensuremath{'}}=J\ensuremath{-}1$, which removes a pair of qubits in a state defined by the light polarization. Starting with the well-known W and squeezed states, we extract the concurrence of qubit pairs, which quantifies their nonclassical character. We also directly demonstrate entanglement between the 14- and 2-qubit subsystems via an increase in entropy upon partition. In a complementary set of experiments, we probe decoherence of a state prepared in the excited level ${J}^{\ensuremath{'}}=J+1$ and interpret spontaneous emission as a loss of a qubit pair in a random state. This allows us to contrast the robustness of nonclassical pairwise correlations of the W state with the fragility of the coherence involved in a Schr\"odinger cat state. Our findings open up the possibility to engineer novel types of entangled atomic ensembles, in which entanglement occurs within each atom's electronic spin as well as between different atoms. Qubit ensembles with large entanglement depth could then be realized with a few atoms only, facilitating the scaling up of quantum-enhanced sensors.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.3.043001

Related papers

Manipulating ultracold dysprosium’s atomic spin to encode quantum critical, entangled, and topological states of matter

Tanish Satoor

This thesis describes three studies using ultracold gases of bosonic dysprosium atoms. We encode quantum states of interest in the large electronic ground state spin J=8 of each atom. Narrow-line optical transitions are used to manipulate these states by creating strong spin-dependent tensor light shifts with negligible heating. Our detection scheme uses arbitrary spin rotations followed by measurement of projection probabilities with single magnetic sublevel resolution. Firstly, we study a transverse-field Ising model of quantum spin-1/2’s with infinite-range interactions. This model shows a paramagnetic to ferromagnetic quantum phase transition in the thermodynamic limit. Our experiment relies on the formal equivalence between the states of a spin J=8 and exchange-symmetric states of 2J=16 qubits in the sector of maximum total spin. We probe the thermodynamic and dynamical properties, revealing finite-size quantum critical behaviour around the transition point. We also directly test the fundamental link between symmetry breaking and the appearance of a finite order parameter. This is enabled by access to the collective observable defining the underlying Z2 symmetry. Secondly, we partition the electronic spin to reveal entanglement in nonclassical states. By optically coupling the ground level to an excited state J' = J-1, we remove a pair of encoded qubits in a state defined by the light polarisation. We probe the concurrence of qubit pairs extracted from W and squeezed states to quantify their nonclassical character. We directly demonstrate entanglement between the 14- and 2-qubit subsystems via an increase in entropy upon partition. In a complementary set of experiments, we probe the decoherence of a state prepared in the excited level J' = J + 1 and interpret spontaneous emission as a loss of a qubit pair in a random state. This allows us to contrast the robustness of nonclassical pairwise correlations of the W state with the fragility of the coherence of a Schrödinger cat state. Thirdly, we simulate a quantum Hall system by exploiting the electronic ground state spin as a discrete synthetic dimension, and optically coupling it to atomic motion along a second real dimension. This creates an artificial magnetic field, with the two coupled dimensions forming a Hall ribbon with sharp edges along the synthetic axis. We demonstrate that the large number of magnetic sublevels leads to distinct bulk and edge behaviours, and a Hall response characteristic of a non-trivial topology. We perform a preliminary investigation of the entanglement spectrum associated with a partition at the centre of the synthetic dimension, and we explain how future studies could directly implement the corresponding entanglement Hamiltonian. We conclude with a roadmap for extending the techniques presented in this thesis in order to realise many-body topological states.

•Oct 7, 2022•0 citations

Entanglement of Permutation Symmetric State

Duger Ulam-Orgikh, Masahiro Kitagawa

We consider an assembly of N indistinguishable two-level atoms, for which a concept of spin- squeezing and entanglement measures can be well defined. Permutation symmetry of such a state allows one to use an entanglement measure called the concurrence as the measures of pairwise and also N-partite entanglement. Dy using these measures, we show that negative pair-spin correlations of the state are quantum ones. It implies the quantumness of a spin-squeezing, which also pos­sesses pair-spin negative correlations. We also provide the entanglement measures of a macroscopic entangled state and an atomic Dicke state for super-radiant and spontaneous emissions.

Физик сэтгүүл•Mar 13, 2022•0 citations

Enhanced Magnetic Sensitivity with Non-Gaussian Quantum Fluctuations

Alexandre Evrard, Vasiliy Makhalov, Thomas Chalopin +4 more

The precision of a quantum sensor can overcome its classical counterpart when its constituents are entangled. In Gaussian squeezed states, quantum correlations lead to a reduction of the quantum projection noise below the shot noise limit. However, the most sensitive states involve complex non-Gaussian quantum fluctuations, making the required measurement protocol challenging. Here we measure the sensitivity of nonclassical states of the electronic spin J=8 of dysprosium atoms, created using light-induced nonlinear spin coupling. Magnetic sublevel resolution enables us to reach the optimal sensitivity of non-Gaussian (oversqueezed) states, well above the capability of squeezed states and about half the Heisenberg limit.

arXiv:1901.06282•Physical Review Letters•May 1, 2019•53 citations

Atomic entanglement and decoherence.

Claudiu Genes

The generation of entanglement in atomic systems plays a central topic in the fields of quantum information storage and processing. Moreover, a special category of entangled states of multi-atom ensembles, spin squeezed states, have been proven to lead to considerable improvement in the sensitivity of precision measurements compared to systems involving uncorrelated atoms. A treatment of entanglement in open systems is, however, incomplete without a precise description of the process of decoherence which necessarily accompanies it. The theory of entanglement and decoherence are the two main topics of this thesis. Methods are described for the generation of strong correlations in large atomic ensembles using either cavity quantum electrodynamics or measurement outcome conditioned quantum dynamics. Moreover, the description of loss of entanglement resulting from the coupling to a noise reservoir (electromagnetic vacuum) is explored. A spin squeezing parameter is used throughout this thesis as both a measure of entanglement strength and as an indication of the sensitivity improvement above the so-called standard quantum limit (sensitivity obtained with uncorrelated particles) in metrology. The first scheme considered consists of a single mode cavity field interacting with a collection of atoms for which spin squeezing is produced in both resonant and off-resonant regimes. In the resonant case, transfer of squeezing from a field state to the atoms is analyzed, while in the off-resonant regime squeezing is produced via an effective nonlinear interaction (one-axis twisting Hamiltonian). A second, more experimentally realistic case, is one involving the interaction of free space atoms with laser pulses; a projective measurement of a source field originating from atomic fluctuations provides a means of preparing atomic collective states such as spin squeezed and Schrodinger cat states. A new unravelling is proposed, that employs the detection of photon number in a single output channel and is capable of producing mesoscopic Schrodinger cat states in a single step. As a first step to understanding the role of cooperative decoherence, of importance in the case of dense pencil-shaped atomic ensembles, the collective spin decoherence of a two multilevel atom system is derived. This calculation is also relevant to entanglement loss for two qubits manipulated using with reading/writing pulses. Finally, a scheme is proposed in which arbitrarily strong entanglement can be produced in a four-wave mixing setup, where the preparation of the atoms in a dark state limits the decoherence to negligible values.

•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

Quantum-enhanced sensing using non-classical spin states of a highly magnetic atom

Thomas Chalopin, Chayma Bouazza, Alexandre Evrard +5 more

Coherent superposition states of a mesoscopic quantum object play a major role in our understanding of the quantum to classical boundary, as well as in quantum-enhanced metrology and computing. However, their practical realization and manipulation remains challenging, requiring a high degree of control of the system and its coupling to the environment. Here, we use dysprosium atoms-the most magnetic element in its ground state-to realize coherent superpositions between electronic spin states of opposite orientation, with a mesoscopic spin size J = 8. We drive coherent spin states to quantum superpositions using non-linear light-spin interactions, observing a series of collapses and revivals of quantum coherence. These states feature highly non-classical behavior, with a sensitivity to magnetic fields enhanced by a factor 13.9(1.1) compared to coherent spin states-close to the Heisenberg limit 2J = 16-and an intrinsic fragility to environmental noise.

arXiv:1806.05495•Nature Communications•Nov 19, 2018•93 citations

Breaking Quantum Limits with Collective Cavity-QED: Generation of Spin Squeezed States via Quantum Non-Demolition Measurements

Zilong Chen

Large ensembles of uncorrelated atoms are extensively used as precise sensors of time, rotation, and gravity, and for tests of fundamental physics. The quantum nature of the sensors imposes a limit on their ultimate precision. Larger ensembles of N atoms can be used to average the quantum noise as 1/√N, a scaling known as the standard quantum limit. However, the ensemble size may be limited by technical constraints and/or atom-atom collisions -- a fundamental distinction from photon-based sensors. Learning to prepare entangled states of large ensembles with noise properties below the standard quantum limit will be key to extending both the precision and/or bandwidth of atomic sensors. More broadly, the generation and application of entanglement to solve problems is a core goal of quantum information science being pursued in both atomic and solid state systems.\nIn this thesis, we utilize the tools of cavity-QED to prepare entangled spin-squeezed states with 3.4(6) dB improvement in spectroscopic sensitivity over the standard quantum limit. The collective atomic spin is composed of the two-level clock states of 87Rb confined in a medium finesse F = 710 optical cavity. We employ cavity-aided quantum non-demolition measurements of the vacuum Rabi splitting to measure and subtract out the quantum projection noise of the collective spin state, preparing states with collective atomic spin projection noise 4.9(6) dB below the projection noise level. The conditionally reduced spin noise combined with the measured 1.5(3) dB reduction in the mean spin length implies a net 3.4(6) dB spectroscopic enhancement or conditional squeezing as defined by the Wineland criterion. Our method does not require single particle addressability and is applied to a spectroscopically large ensemble of N = 7 x 105 atoms using two collective population measurements, with the whole squeezing operation taking ~ 150 μs. The gain in sensitivity is spectroscopically equivalent to the enhancement obtained had we created > 105 pairs of maximally entangled qubits, demonstrating the power of a top-down approach for entangling large ensembles. The nondemolition probing of atomic populations via the vacuum Rabi splitting is also of broad interest for non-destructively reading out a wide variety of both atomic and solid state qubits.

•Jan 1, 2013•3 citations
Quantum spins of mesoscopic size are a well-studied playground for engineering nonclassical states. If the spin represents the collective state of an ensemble of qubits, its nonclassical behavior is linked to entanglement between the qubits. In this paper, we report on an experimental study of entanglement between two subsystems of dysprosium's electronic spin. Its ground state, of angular momentum J=8J=8J=8, can formally be viewed as a set of 2J2J2J qubits symmetric upon exchange. To access entanglement properties, we partition the spin by optically coupling it to an excited state J\ensuremath′=J\ensuremath−1{J}^{\ensuremath{'}}=J\ensuremath{-}1J\ensuremath′=J\ensuremath−1, which removes a pair of qubits in a state defined by the light polarization. Starting with the well-known W and squeezed states, we extract the concurrence of qubit pairs, which quantifies their nonclassical character. We also directly demonstrate entanglement between the 14- and 2-qubit subsystems via an increase in entropy upon partition. In a complementary set of experiments, we probe decoherence of a state prepared in the excited level J\ensuremath′=J+1{J}^{\ensuremath{'}}=J+1J\ensuremath′=J+1 and interpret spontaneous emission as a loss of a qubit pair in a random state. This allows us to contrast the robustness of nonclassical pairwise correlations of the W state with the fragility of the coherence involved in a Schr"odinger cat state. Our findings open up the possibility to engineer novel types of entangled atomic ensembles, in which entanglement occurs within each atom's electronic spin as well as between different atoms. Qubit ensembles with large entanglement depth could then be realized with a few atoms only, facilitating the scaling up of quantum-enhanced sensors.
This thesis describes three studies using ultracold gases of bosonic dysprosium atoms. We encode quantum states of interest in the large electronic ground state spin J=8 of each atom. Narrow-line optical transitions are used to manipulate these states by creating strong spin-dependent tensor light shifts with negligible heating. Our detection scheme uses arbitrary spin rotations followed by measurement of projection probabilities with single magnetic sublevel resolution. Firstly, we study a transverse-field Ising model of quantum spin-1/2’s with infinite-range interactions. This model shows a paramagnetic to ferromagnetic quantum phase transition in the thermodynamic limit. Our experiment relies on the formal equivalence between the states of a spin J=8 and exchange-symmetric states of 2J=16 qubits in the sector of maximum total spin. We probe the thermodynamic and dynamical properties, revealing finite-size quantum critical behaviour around the transition point. We also directly test the fundamental link between symmetry breaking and the appearance of a finite order parameter. This is enabled by access to the collective observable defining the underlying Z2 symmetry. Secondly, we partition the electronic spin to reveal entanglement in nonclassical states. By optically coupling the ground level to an excited state J' = J-1, we remove a pair of encoded qubits in a state defined by the light polarisation. We probe the concurrence of qubit pairs extracted from W and squeezed states to quantify their nonclassical character. We directly demonstrate entanglement between the 14- and 2-qubit subsystems via an increase in entropy upon partition. In a complementary set of experiments, we probe the decoherence of a state prepared in the excited level J' = J + 1 and interpret spontaneous emission as a loss of a qubit pair in a random state. This allows us to contrast the robustness of nonclassical pairwise correlations of the W state with the fragility of the coherence of a Schrödinger cat state. Thirdly, we simulate a quantum Hall system by exploiting the electronic ground state spin as a discrete synthetic dimension, and optically coupling it to atomic motion along a second real dimension. This creates an artificial magnetic field, with the two coupled dimensions forming a Hall ribbon with sharp edges along the synthetic axis. We demonstrate that the large number of magnetic sublevels leads to distinct bulk and edge behaviours, and a Hall response characteristic of a non-trivial topology. We perform a preliminary investigation of the entanglement spectrum associated with a partition at the centre of the synthetic dimension, and we explain how future studies could directly implement the corresponding entanglement Hamiltonian. We conclude with a roadmap for extending the techniques presented in this thesis in order to realise many-body topological states.
We consider an assembly of N indistinguishable two-level atoms, for which a concept of spin- squeezing and entanglement measures can be well defined. Permutation symmetry of such a state allows one to use an entanglement measure called the concurrence as the measures of pairwise and also N-partite entanglement. Dy using these measures, we show that negative pair-spin correlations of the state are quantum ones. It implies the quantumness of a spin-squeezing, which also pos­sesses pair-spin negative correlations. We also provide the entanglement measures of a macroscopic entangled state and an atomic Dicke state for super-radiant and spontaneous emissions.
The precision of a quantum sensor can overcome its classical counterpart when its constituents are entangled. In Gaussian squeezed states, quantum correlations lead to a reduction of the quantum projection noise below the shot noise limit. However, the most sensitive states involve complex non-Gaussian quantum fluctuations, making the required measurement protocol challenging. Here we measure the sensitivity of nonclassical states of the electronic spin J=8 of dysprosium atoms, created using light-induced nonlinear spin coupling. Magnetic sublevel resolution enables us to reach the optimal sensitivity of non-Gaussian (oversqueezed) states, well above the capability of squeezed states and about half the Heisenberg limit.
The generation of entanglement in atomic systems plays a central topic in the fields of quantum information storage and processing. Moreover, a special category of entangled states of multi-atom ensembles, spin squeezed states, have been proven to lead to considerable improvement in the sensitivity of precision measurements compared to systems involving uncorrelated atoms. A treatment of entanglement in open systems is, however, incomplete without a precise description of the process of decoherence which necessarily accompanies it. The theory of entanglement and decoherence are the two main topics of this thesis. Methods are described for the generation of strong correlations in large atomic ensembles using either cavity quantum electrodynamics or measurement outcome conditioned quantum dynamics. Moreover, the description of loss of entanglement resulting from the coupling to a noise reservoir (electromagnetic vacuum) is explored. A spin squeezing parameter is used throughout this thesis as both a measure of entanglement strength and as an indication of the sensitivity improvement above the so-called standard quantum limit (sensitivity obtained with uncorrelated particles) in metrology. The first scheme considered consists of a single mode cavity field interacting with a collection of atoms for which spin squeezing is produced in both resonant and off-resonant regimes. In the resonant case, transfer of squeezing from a field state to the atoms is analyzed, while in the off-resonant regime squeezing is produced via an effective nonlinear interaction (one-axis twisting Hamiltonian). A second, more experimentally realistic case, is one involving the interaction of free space atoms with laser pulses; a projective measurement of a source field originating from atomic fluctuations provides a means of preparing atomic collective states such as spin squeezed and Schrodinger cat states. A new unravelling is proposed, that employs the detection of photon number in a single output channel and is capable of producing mesoscopic Schrodinger cat states in a single step. As a first step to understanding the role of cooperative decoherence, of importance in the case of dense pencil-shaped atomic ensembles, the collective spin decoherence of a two multilevel atom system is derived. This calculation is also relevant to entanglement loss for two qubits manipulated using with reading/writing pulses. Finally, a scheme is proposed in which arbitrarily strong entanglement can be produced in a four-wave mixing setup, where the preparation of the atoms in a dark state limits the decoherence to negligible values.
Coherent superposition states of a mesoscopic quantum object play a major role in our understanding of the quantum to classical boundary, as well as in quantum-enhanced metrology and computing. However, their practical realization and manipulation remains challenging, requiring a high degree of control of the system and its coupling to the environment. Here, we use dysprosium atoms-the most magnetic element in its ground state-to realize coherent superpositions between electronic spin states of opposite orientation, with a mesoscopic spin size J = 8. We drive coherent spin states to quantum superpositions using non-linear light-spin interactions, observing a series of collapses and revivals of quantum coherence. These states feature highly non-classical behavior, with a sensitivity to magnetic fields enhanced by a factor 13.9(1.1) compared to coherent spin states-close to the Heisenberg limit 2J = 16-and an intrinsic fragility to environmental noise.
Large ensembles of uncorrelated atoms are extensively used as precise sensors of time, rotation, and gravity, and for tests of fundamental physics. The quantum nature of the sensors imposes a limit on their ultimate precision. Larger ensembles of N atoms can be used to average the quantum noise as 1/√N, a scaling known as the standard quantum limit. However, the ensemble size may be limited by technical constraints and/or atom-atom collisions -- a fundamental distinction from photon-based sensors. Learning to prepare entangled states of large ensembles with noise properties below the standard quantum limit will be key to extending both the precision and/or bandwidth of atomic sensors. More broadly, the generation and application of entanglement to solve problems is a core goal of quantum information science being pursued in both atomic and solid state systems.\nIn this thesis, we utilize the tools of cavity-QED to prepare entangled spin-squeezed states with 3.4(6) dB improvement in spectroscopic sensitivity over the standard quantum limit. The collective atomic spin is composed of the two-level clock states of 87Rb confined in a medium finesse F = 710 optical cavity. We employ cavity-aided quantum non-demolition measurements of the vacuum Rabi splitting to measure and subtract out the quantum projection noise of the collective spin state, preparing states with collective atomic spin projection noise 4.9(6) dB below the projection noise level. The conditionally reduced spin noise combined with the measured 1.5(3) dB reduction in the mean spin length implies a net 3.4(6) dB spectroscopic enhancement or conditional squeezing as defined by the Wineland criterion. Our method does not require single particle addressability and is applied to a spectroscopically large ensemble of N = 7 x 105 atoms using two collective population measurements, with the whole squeezing operation taking ~ 150 μs. The gain in sensitivity is spectroscopically equivalent to the enhancement obtained had we created > 105 pairs of maximally entangled qubits, demonstrating the power of a top-down approach for entangling large ensembles. The nondemolition probing of atomic populations via the vacuum Rabi splitting is also of broad interest for non-destructively reading out a wide variety of both atomic and solid state qubits.