Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2104.13861 · Annales Henri Poincaré

Another Proof of Born’s Rule on Arbitrary Cauchy Surfaces

Sascha Lill, Roderich Tumulka

Published Dec 6, 2021• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract In 2017, Lienert and Tumulka proved Born’s rule on arbitrary Cauchy surfaces in Minkowski space-time assuming Born’s rule and a corresponding collapse rule on horizontal surfaces relative to a fixed Lorentz frame, as well as a given unitary time evolution between any two Cauchy surfaces, satisfying that there is no interaction faster than light and no propagation faster than light. Here, we prove Born’s rule on arbitrary Cauchy surfaces from a different, but equally reasonable, set of assumptions. The conclusion is that if detectors are placed along any Cauchy surface $$\Sigma $$ Σ , then the observed particle configuration on $$\Sigma $$ Σ is a random variable with distribution density $$|\Psi _\Sigma |^2$$ | Ψ Σ | 2 , suitably understood. The main different assumption is that the Born and collapse rules hold on any spacelike hyperplane, i.e., at any time coordinate in any Lorentz frame. Heuristically, this follows if the dynamics of the detectors is Lorentz invariant.

DOI
10.1007/s00023-021-01130-4

Related papers

Comment on "Born's rule for arbitrary Cauchy surfaces"

Maik Reddiger, Bill Poirier

A recent article has treated the question of how to generalize the Born rule from non-relativistic quantum theory to curved spacetimes (Lienert and Tumulka, Lett. Math. Phys. 110, 753 (2019)). The supposed generalization originated in prior works on 'hypersurface Bohm-Dirac models' as well as approaches to relativistic quantum theory developed by Bohm and Hiley. In this comment, we raise three objections to the rule and the broader theory in which it is embedded. In particular, to address the underlying assertion that the Born rule is naturally formulated on a spacelike hypersurface, we provide an analytic example showing that a spacelike hypersurface need not remain spacelike under proper time evolution -- even in the absence of curvature. We finish by proposing an alternative `curved Born rule' for the one-body case, which overcomes these objections, and in this instance indeed generalizes the one Lienert and Tumulka attempted to justify. Our approach can be generalized to the many-body case, and we expect it to be also of relevance for the general case of a varying number of bodies.

•Dec 10, 2020•0 citations

First-Principle Derivation of the Born Rule Without Collapse or Observers

Zhen Su

The Born rule stands as the fundamental probability postulate of quantum mechanics, yet its first-principle derivation remains a longstanding open problem. This paper presents a rigorous, collapse-free, and observer-independent derivation of the Born rule. Starting from four physically natural and minimal axioms—unitary dynamics, uniqueness of classical records, unitary invariance, and consistency with the classical limit and ergodicity—we uniquely deduce the Born rule from first principles. We prove that the Born rule is not an independent postulate, but a necessary mathematical consequence of the core axiomatic structure. Our approach is self-contained, assumption-free, and purely unitary, establishing that the Born rule is canonically determined by the fundamental mathematical and physical principles of quantum mechanics.

•May 7, 2026•0 citations

The Born Rule from Configurational Stability: A Timeless Derivation

Ilja Schots

The Born rule, assigning probabilities via |ψ|², is traditionally introduced as an independent axiom of quantum mechanics. Despite its empirical success, its foundational origin remains unresolved. In this paper we derive the Born rule as a necessary consequence of configurational stability in a timeless, pre-metric configuration space. Physical states are described by field configurations Φ, weighted by a stability functional S[Φ]. Quantum states ψ arise as representational coordinates encoding relative stability rather than as ontological wave objects. We show that requiring: projective invariance, factorizability for independent subsystems, and classical additivity under phase degradation, uniquely selects the quadratic probability map |ψ|², without assuming Hilbert space structure, Gleason-type theorems, or temporal dynamics. Measurement is identified as a topological transition at a stability threshold Σ*, where the Hessian spectrum becomes marginally stable. This leads to a distinctive, non-analytic “kink” in decoherence behavior. Unlike stochastic collapse models, the framework predicts pure dephasing without energy injection, avoiding existing experimental heating constraints. The theory yields explicit, falsifiable experimental signatures, including structure-dependent decoherence effects in mesoscopic systems, accessible to current matter-wave interferometry and levitated nanosphere experiments. The framework is fully timeless at the fundamental level; laboratory time emerges only as an epistemic ordering parameter. This work is self-contained and does not rely on gravitational, cosmological, or dark-matter assumptions. Keywords quantum foundations; Born rule; measurement problem; decoherence; timeless physics; configuration space; stability theory; quantum-classical boundary

•Dec 30, 2025•0 citations

Born's Rule W*(x,t)W(x,t) and Determinism

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In (1) it is argued that a quantum particle’s probability P(x,t) satisfies a Nelson stochastic equation: d/dt partial P(x,t) + d/dx partial (b(x,t)P(x,t)) = D d/dx d/dx partial P. ((1)) where b(x,t) = hbar/m d/dx partial S(x,t) + 2D d/dx partial ln(R(x,t)) ((2)) with W(x,t)=wavefunction= R(x,t) exp(i S(x,t). Thus both a quantum wavefunction (satisfying the Schrodinger equation) and a separate P(x,t) are present. If P(x,0)= W*(x,0)W(x,0) ((3)), i.e. Born’s rule, then this rule holds for later times. It is, however, suggested in (1) that if P(x,0) not= W*(x,0)W(x,0) then the system may relax over time into a situation for which ((3)) holds. In this note, we argue that for a free particle moving with constant p in one direction, P(x,t)=constant, but there is an underlying two dimensional wavefunction exp(ipx). We ascribe this to two x-probability distributions associated with motion. In particular: v= (xfinal - xintial) / delta t. If xfinal and xinitial are both distributions such that on average v = constant, one needs to give a probability for both i.e. have two dimensions or an ordered pair. The two probability distributions, however, are not independent as they must describe a constant velocity i.e all points of space being the same. This leads to exp(ipx) such that exp(-ipx) exp(ipx) =1 . In other words, one may constrain two probability distributions to yield a deterministic type result for a single particle which appears as a probabilistic result for a steady stream.Born’s Rule automatically applies to a free particle and is not a “postulate” as argued in (1). The form exp(ipx) follows from the Lorentz invariant -Et+px we argue. We further argue that if one creates a linear superposition of exp(ipx)s i.e. W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) then Integral dx W*(x)W(x) is always linked to a steady stream probability picture ie. Sum over p a*(p)a(p) = 1. This is why given a p, one does not know its x point- it is associated with a steady stream. As a result, we argue that there is always a meaning for Born’s rule W*(x,t)W(x,t). As a result P(x,t=0) not= W*(x,t=0)W(x,t=0) must describe a probability which differs from the steady stream scenario linked with exp(ikpx).

•May 10, 2023•0 citations

The Born Rule from Gravitational Decoherence

Edmonds, Victor

We derive the Born rule (Pn=∣cn∣2) as a physical consequence of gravitational decoherence, without presupposing the probability rule of quantum mechanics. Working within standard quantum mechanics (unitary evolution, Hilbert space structure), we assume only that the system couples to a gravitational vacuum with spectral density S(ω)∝ω3e−ω/ωc via a quadrupolar interaction. The derivation establishes three key results: Quadratic Scaling: The energy radiated into the gravitational bath during decoherence is proportional to the square of the amplitude (∣cn∣2), reflecting the spin-2 structure of gravitational radiation. Operational Probability: By adopting a "Gravitational Darwinism" perspective, where probability is defined by the redundancy of environmental records, we recover the Born rule as the equation of state for a system in equilibrium with a spin-2 vacuum. The Equal Coupling Theorem: We prove that pointer states of the same total mass have equal gravitational coupling strength to within 10−30, ensuring the Born rule holds with extraordinary precision for macroscopic objects due to the Equivalence Principle. Experimental Connection: This framework predicts material-dependent decoherence rates for levitated nanospheres, specifically that diamond should heat ∼500× slower than silica of equal mass. This prediction provides a falsifiable test distinguishing this gravitational mechanism from mass-intrinsic collapse models.

•Dec 13, 2025•0 citations

Deriving Born Rule Probabilities via the Method of Arbitrary Functions

Kade Cicchella, Liam Bonds, Brooke Burson +3 more

The goal of this paper is to apply the collection of mathematical tools known as the method of arbitrary functions to analyze how the Born rule probabilities arise from quantum dynamics. We argue that in a toy model of quantum measurement the Born rule probabilities can be derived from the unitary Schrödinger dynamics when certain dynamical parameters are treated as random variables with initial probability distributions. Specifically, we study the perturbed double well model, in which the perturbation is treated as a random variable, and we show that for arbitrary initial distributions within a certain class, the dynamics yield the Born rule probabilities in the joint limits given by long times and small values of Planck’s constant (the classical limit). Our results establish the Born rule as a type of universal limiting behavior that is independent of the precise initial dynamical parameters. We suggest that this provides a proof of concept for an explanatory schema for the Born rule, relying only on Schrödinger dynamics, which could generate a full explanation when supplemented with further interpretive details.

arXiv:2409.16457•Philosophy of Physics•Jan 1, 2025•4 citations
Abstract In 2017, Lienert and Tumulka proved Born’s rule on arbitrary Cauchy surfaces in Minkowski space-time assuming Born’s rule and a corresponding collapse rule on horizontal surfaces relative to a fixed Lorentz frame, as well as a given unitary time evolution between any two Cauchy surfaces, satisfying that there is no interaction faster than light and no propagation faster than light. Here, we prove Born’s rule on arbitrary Cauchy surfaces from a different, but equally reasonable, set of assumptions. The conclusion is that if detectors are placed along any Cauchy surface Σ\Sigma Σ Σ , then the observed particle configuration on Σ\Sigma Σ Σ is a random variable with distribution density ∣ΨΣ∣2|\Psi _\Sigma |^2∣ΨΣ​∣2 | Ψ Σ | 2 , suitably understood. The main different assumption is that the Born and collapse rules hold on any spacelike hyperplane, i.e., at any time coordinate in any Lorentz frame. Heuristically, this follows if the dynamics of the detectors is Lorentz invariant.
A recent article has treated the question of how to generalize the Born rule from non-relativistic quantum theory to curved spacetimes (Lienert and Tumulka, Lett. Math. Phys. 110, 753 (2019)). The supposed generalization originated in prior works on 'hypersurface Bohm-Dirac models' as well as approaches to relativistic quantum theory developed by Bohm and Hiley. In this comment, we raise three objections to the rule and the broader theory in which it is embedded. In particular, to address the underlying assertion that the Born rule is naturally formulated on a spacelike hypersurface, we provide an analytic example showing that a spacelike hypersurface need not remain spacelike under proper time evolution -- even in the absence of curvature. We finish by proposing an alternative `curved Born rule' for the one-body case, which overcomes these objections, and in this instance indeed generalizes the one Lienert and Tumulka attempted to justify. Our approach can be generalized to the many-body case, and we expect it to be also of relevance for the general case of a varying number of bodies.
The Born rule stands as the fundamental probability postulate of quantum mechanics, yet its first-principle derivation remains a longstanding open problem. This paper presents a rigorous, collapse-free, and observer-independent derivation of the Born rule. Starting from four physically natural and minimal axioms—unitary dynamics, uniqueness of classical records, unitary invariance, and consistency with the classical limit and ergodicity—we uniquely deduce the Born rule from first principles. We prove that the Born rule is not an independent postulate, but a necessary mathematical consequence of the core axiomatic structure. Our approach is self-contained, assumption-free, and purely unitary, establishing that the Born rule is canonically determined by the fundamental mathematical and physical principles of quantum mechanics.
The Born rule, assigning probabilities via |ψ|², is traditionally introduced as an independent axiom of quantum mechanics. Despite its empirical success, its foundational origin remains unresolved. In this paper we derive the Born rule as a necessary consequence of configurational stability in a timeless, pre-metric configuration space. Physical states are described by field configurations Φ, weighted by a stability functional S[Φ]. Quantum states ψ arise as representational coordinates encoding relative stability rather than as ontological wave objects. We show that requiring: projective invariance, factorizability for independent subsystems, and classical additivity under phase degradation, uniquely selects the quadratic probability map |ψ|², without assuming Hilbert space structure, Gleason-type theorems, or temporal dynamics. Measurement is identified as a topological transition at a stability threshold Σ*, where the Hessian spectrum becomes marginally stable. This leads to a distinctive, non-analytic “kink” in decoherence behavior. Unlike stochastic collapse models, the framework predicts pure dephasing without energy injection, avoiding existing experimental heating constraints. The theory yields explicit, falsifiable experimental signatures, including structure-dependent decoherence effects in mesoscopic systems, accessible to current matter-wave interferometry and levitated nanosphere experiments. The framework is fully timeless at the fundamental level; laboratory time emerges only as an epistemic ordering parameter. This work is self-contained and does not rely on gravitational, cosmological, or dark-matter assumptions. Keywords quantum foundations; Born rule; measurement problem; decoherence; timeless physics; configuration space; stability theory; quantum-classical boundary
In (1) it is argued that a quantum particle’s probability P(x,t) satisfies a Nelson stochastic equation: d/dt partial P(x,t) + d/dx partial (b(x,t)P(x,t)) = D d/dx d/dx partial P. ((1)) where b(x,t) = hbar/m d/dx partial S(x,t) + 2D d/dx partial ln(R(x,t)) ((2)) with W(x,t)=wavefunction= R(x,t) exp(i S(x,t). Thus both a quantum wavefunction (satisfying the Schrodinger equation) and a separate P(x,t) are present. If P(x,0)= W*(x,0)W(x,0) ((3)), i.e. Born’s rule, then this rule holds for later times. It is, however, suggested in (1) that if P(x,0) not= W*(x,0)W(x,0) then the system may relax over time into a situation for which ((3)) holds. In this note, we argue that for a free particle moving with constant p in one direction, P(x,t)=constant, but there is an underlying two dimensional wavefunction exp(ipx). We ascribe this to two x-probability distributions associated with motion. In particular: v= (xfinal - xintial) / delta t. If xfinal and xinitial are both distributions such that on average v = constant, one needs to give a probability for both i.e. have two dimensions or an ordered pair. The two probability distributions, however, are not independent as they must describe a constant velocity i.e all points of space being the same. This leads to exp(ipx) such that exp(-ipx) exp(ipx) =1 . In other words, one may constrain two probability distributions to yield a deterministic type result for a single particle which appears as a probabilistic result for a steady stream.Born’s Rule automatically applies to a free particle and is not a “postulate” as argued in (1). The form exp(ipx) follows from the Lorentz invariant -Et+px we argue. We further argue that if one creates a linear superposition of exp(ipx)s i.e. W(x)=Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) then Integral dx W*(x)W(x) is always linked to a steady stream probability picture ie. Sum over p a*(p)a(p) = 1. This is why given a p, one does not know its x point- it is associated with a steady stream. As a result, we argue that there is always a meaning for Born’s rule W*(x,t)W(x,t). As a result P(x,t=0) not= W*(x,t=0)W(x,t=0) must describe a probability which differs from the steady stream scenario linked with exp(ikpx).
We derive the Born rule (Pn=∣cn∣2) as a physical consequence of gravitational decoherence, without presupposing the probability rule of quantum mechanics. Working within standard quantum mechanics (unitary evolution, Hilbert space structure), we assume only that the system couples to a gravitational vacuum with spectral density S(ω)∝ω3e−ω/ωc via a quadrupolar interaction. The derivation establishes three key results: Quadratic Scaling: The energy radiated into the gravitational bath during decoherence is proportional to the square of the amplitude (∣cn∣2), reflecting the spin-2 structure of gravitational radiation. Operational Probability: By adopting a "Gravitational Darwinism" perspective, where probability is defined by the redundancy of environmental records, we recover the Born rule as the equation of state for a system in equilibrium with a spin-2 vacuum. The Equal Coupling Theorem: We prove that pointer states of the same total mass have equal gravitational coupling strength to within 10−30, ensuring the Born rule holds with extraordinary precision for macroscopic objects due to the Equivalence Principle. Experimental Connection: This framework predicts material-dependent decoherence rates for levitated nanospheres, specifically that diamond should heat ∼500× slower than silica of equal mass. This prediction provides a falsifiable test distinguishing this gravitational mechanism from mass-intrinsic collapse models.
The goal of this paper is to apply the collection of mathematical tools known as the method of arbitrary functions to analyze how the Born rule probabilities arise from quantum dynamics. We argue that in a toy model of quantum measurement the Born rule probabilities can be derived from the unitary Schrödinger dynamics when certain dynamical parameters are treated as random variables with initial probability distributions. Specifically, we study the perturbed double well model, in which the perturbation is treated as a random variable, and we show that for arbitrary initial distributions within a certain class, the dynamics yield the Born rule probabilities in the joint limits given by long times and small values of Planck’s constant (the classical limit). Our results establish the Born rule as a type of universal limiting behavior that is independent of the precise initial dynamical parameters. We suggest that this provides a proof of concept for an explanatory schema for the Born rule, relying only on Schrödinger dynamics, which could generate a full explanation when supplemented with further interpretive details.