arXiv:2409.16457

Quantum Probability via the Method of Arbitrary Functions

Liam Bonds, Brooke Burson, Kade Cicchella, Benjamin H. Feintzeig, Lynnx, Alia Yusaini

Published Sep 24, 2024• 1 citation

Abstract

The goal of this paper is to apply the collection of mathematical tools known as the "method of arbitrary functions" to analyze how probability arises from quantum dynamics. We argue that in a toy model of quantum measurement the Born rule probabilities can be derived from the unitary Schrödinger dynamics when certain dynamical parameters are treated as themselves random variables with initial probability distributions. Specifically, we study the perturbed double well model, in which the perturbation is treated as a random variable, and we show that for arbitrary initial distributions within a certain class, the dynamics yields the Born rule probabilities in the joint limits given by long times and small values of Planck's constant (the classical limit). Our results establish the Born rule as a type of universal limiting behavior that is independent of the precise initial dynamical parameters.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.2409.16457

Related papers

Deriving Born Rule Probabilities via the Method of Arbitrary Functions

Kade Cicchella, Liam Bonds, Brooke Burson +3 more

The goal of this paper is to apply the collection of mathematical tools known as the method of arbitrary functions to analyze how the Born rule probabilities arise from quantum dynamics. We argue that in a toy model of quantum measurement the Born rule probabilities can be derived from the unitary Schrödinger dynamics when certain dynamical parameters are treated as random variables with initial probability distributions. Specifically, we study the perturbed double well model, in which the perturbation is treated as a random variable, and we show that for arbitrary initial distributions within a certain class, the dynamics yield the Born rule probabilities in the joint limits given by long times and small values of Planck’s constant (the classical limit). Our results establish the Born rule as a type of universal limiting behavior that is independent of the precise initial dynamical parameters. We suggest that this provides a proof of concept for an explanatory schema for the Born rule, relying only on Schrödinger dynamics, which could generate a full explanation when supplemented with further interpretive details.

Philosophy of PhysicsJan 1, 20250 citations

Is the Born rule a result of measurement noise?

Torres, Frank

The Born rule asserts the probability distribution of eigenstates observed in unbiased quantum measurements, but the reason it holds remains elusive. This manuscript discusses how the Born rule might be explained by Schrodinger equation dynamics, if a measurement comprises a system responding to random fluctuations until it is within an arbitrarily small tolerance of a measurement eigenstate. We describe the random walk dynamics that produce this behavior in terms of a class of time-dependent, stochastic unitary matrices U(t). We also discuss the class of stochastic potential energies in the Schrodinger equation that is equivalent to this class of unitary matrices. This analysis raises some questions worth considering, including how to determine if any measurements actually follow the predicted random walk mechanism and whether a reliable measurement apparatus could be designed that deviates from Born rule probabilities. Interestingly, if any measurements do follow this random walk mechanism, then exposing a quantum system to stochastic 'noise' is an intrinsic part of such a measurement, not merely an unwanted side effect. This characteristic would have implications for reducing noise in quantum sensing and quantum computing. This is a draft of a work in progress. Questions and suggestions are welcome.

arXiv:2407.03139Jul 3, 20240 citations

Measurement Dynamics in Classical and Quantum Physics

Alexey A. Kryukov

Abstract It was recently demonstrated that the Born rule for transition probabilities can be modeled using the linear Schrödinger equation with a Hamiltonian represented by a random matrix from the Gaussian unitary ensemble. The matrices representing the Hamiltonian at different time points throughout the observation period are assumed to be independent. Instead of suppressing superpositions, such Schrödinger evolution makes the state perform an isotropic random walk on the projective space of states. The relative frequency of reaching different eigenstates of an arbitrary observable in the random walk is shown to satisfy the Born rule. Here, we apply this methodology to investigate the behavior of a particle in the context of the double-slit experiment with measurement, offering new insights into its potential underlying mechanisms.

Journal of Physics Conference SeriesJun 1, 20250 citations

First-Principle Derivation of the Born Rule Without Collapse or Observers

Zhen Su

The Born rule stands as the fundamental probability postulate of quantum mechanics, yet its first-principle derivation remains a longstanding open problem. This paper presents a rigorous, collapse-free, and observer-independent derivation of the Born rule. Starting from four physically natural and minimal axioms—unitary dynamics, uniqueness of classical records, unitary invariance, and consistency with the classical limit and ergodicity—we uniquely deduce the Born rule from first principles. We prove that the Born rule is not an independent postulate, but a necessary mathematical consequence of the core axiomatic structure. Our approach is self-contained, assumption-free, and purely unitary, establishing that the Born rule is canonically determined by the fundamental mathematical and physical principles of quantum mechanics.

May 7, 20260 citations

Emergent quantum probability from full quantum dynamics and the role of energy conservation

Chen Wang, Jincheng Lu, Jianhua Jiang

Abstract We propose and study a toy model for the quantum measurements that yield the Born’s rule of quantum probability. In this model, the electrons interact with local photon modes and the photon modes are dissipatively coupled with local photon reservoirs. We treat the interactions of the electrons and photons with full quantum mechanical description, while the dissipative dynamics of the photon modes are treated via the Lindblad master equation. By assigning double quantum dots setup for the electrons coupling with local photons and photonic reservoirs, we show that the Born’s rule of quantum probability can emerge directly from microscopic quantum dynamics. We further discuss how the microscopic quantities such as the electron–photon coupling, detuning, and photon dissipation rate affect the quantum dynamics. Surprisingly, in the infinite long time measurement limit, the energy conservation already dictates the emergence of the Born’s rule of quantum probability. For finite-time measurement, the local photon dissipation rate determines the characteristic time-scale for the completion of the measurement, while other microscopic quantities affect the measurement dynamics. Therefore, in genuine measurements, the measured probability is determined by both the local devices and the quantum mechanical wavefunction.

arXiv:2306.00298New Journal of PhysicsOct 1, 20230 citations

Quantum State Reduction of General Initial States through Spontaneous Unitarity Violation

Aritro Mukherjee, Srinivas Gotur, Jelle Aalberts +3 more

The inability of Schrödinger's unitary time evolution to describe the measurement of a quantum state remains a central foundational problem. It was recently suggested that the unitarity of Schrödinger dynamics can be spontaneously broken, resulting in measurement as an emergent phenomenon in the thermodynamic limit. Here, we introduce a family of models for spontaneous unitarity violation that apply to generic initial superpositions over arbitrarily many states, using either single or multiple state-independent stochastic components. Crucially, we show that Born's probability rule emerges spontaneously in all cases.

arXiv:2301.03233EntropyJan 31, 20248 citations