Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2102.05734 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

What makes a particle detector click

Erickson Tjoa, Irene López-Gutiérrez, Allison Sachs, Eduardo Martín-Martínez

Published Jun 22, 2021• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We highlight fundamental differences in the models of light-matter interaction between the behavior of Fock state detection in free space versus optical cavities. To do so, we study the phenomenon of the resonance of detectors with Fock wave packets as a function of their degree of monochromaticity, the number of spatial dimensions, the linear or quadratic nature of the light-matter coupling, and the presence (or absence) of cavity walls in space. In doing so we show that intuition coming from quantum optics in cavities does not straightforwardly carry to the free-space case. For example, in ($3+1$) dimensions the detector response to a Fock wave packet will go to zero as the wave packet is made more and more monochromatic and in coincidence with the detector's resonant frequency. This is so even though the energy of the free-space wave packet goes to the expected finite value of $\ensuremath{\hbar}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}$ in the monochromatic limit. This is in contrast to the behavior of the light-matter interaction in a cavity (even a large one) where the probability of absorbing a Fock quantum is maximized when the quantum is more monochromatic at the detector's resonance frequency. We trace this crucial difference to the fact that monochromatic Fock states are not normalizable in the continuum; thus physical Fock states need to be constructed out of normalizable wave packets whose energy density goes to zero in the monochromatic limit as they get spatially delocalized.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.103.125021

Related papers

Spatial statistics of single-quantum detection

Jonathan Schonfeld

In a single-particle detection experiment, a wavefront impinges on a detector but observers only see a point response. The extent of the wavefront becomes evident only in statistical accumulation of many independent detections, with probability given by the Born rule. Drawing on concepts from quantum optics, we analyze a simple model to reverse-engineer how this behavior can come about in terms of wave mechanics alone without a measurement axiom. The model detector consists of many molecules, each of which can be resonantly excited by the incoming particle and then emit a detection signature (e.g., localized flash of light). Different molecules have different resonant energies because local conditions (proximity of other molecules, Doppler shifts, etc.) vary. The detector is thus a quasi-continuum, and the incoming particle preferentially excites the molecule that it matches most closely in energy. (In actuality, molecules can be so numerous that many could closely match the incoming particle in energy; but in that case only one will be the first, and there will be nothing left for the others by the time the first match resonates and then emits. The model does not explicitly take into account the temporal advance of the particle wave packet through the detector medium.) The excited molecule can emit a detection signature, but that process competes with fluctuation-driven dephasing. We estimate the probability that a given molecule is resonantly excited, and we also estimate the probability that a detection signature is produced before being overwhelmed by fluctuations in the detector medium. The product of these two probabilities is proportional to the absolute-square of the incoming wavefunction at the molecule in question, i.e. the Born rule. We discuss ways to probe these mechanisms experimentally, and check the model with numbers from a neutron interference experiment.

arXiv:1706.07788•Jun 20, 2017•0 citations

Spontaneous and stimulated emissions of a preformed quantum free-electron wave function

Yiming Pan, Avraham Gover

Do the prior history and the wave-packet size and form of a free electron have a physical effect in its interaction with light? Here we answer these fundamental questions on the interpretation of the electron quantum wave function by analyzing spontaneous and stimulated emissions of a quantum electron wave packet, interacting with a general, quantized radiation field. For coherent radiation (Glauber state), we confirm that stimulated emission and absorption of photons depends on the preinteraction-history-dependent size, exhibiting spectral cutoff when it exceeds the interacting radiation wavelength. Furthermore, stimulated emission of an optically modulated electron wave packet has a characteristic harmonic emission spectrum beyond the cutoff, which depends on the modulation features. In either case, there is no wave-packet-dependent radiation of the Fock state, and particularly the vacuum state spontaneous emission is wave-packet independent. The classical-to-quantum transition of radiation from the point-particle to the plane-wave limits, and the effects of wave-packet modulation indicate a way of measuring the wave-packet size of a single electron wave function, and suggest an alternative direction for exploring light-matter interaction.

arXiv:1805.08210•Physical Review A•May 7, 2019•65 citations

The Monochromatic Resonator and the Interaction Between Light and Matter Under the Assumption That Photons Follow Classical Trajectories

W. Tiefenbrunner

According to R. Feynman 1963-1965 [10], the interference pattern that appears on the observation screen in the double-slit experiment with light cannot be explained by classical physics. The detection probability is supposed to result from the superposition of all paths that the photon can take from the source to the detector, the light quantum is self-interfering. However, Jin et al. 2010 [11] showed that this is not necessarily the case. In their computer simulation, they assumed that the trajectory of a photon corresponds to that of a classical particle. Thus, the interference only occurs at the detector with the participation of several photons. Not every photon causes a detection.Tiefenbrunner 2024 [17] investigated the detector further and recognized that particle interference under this and some other conditions presupposes a monochromatic resonator (all permissible energy levels are integer (ℕ0) multiples of a basal energy unit ε, where ε is also referred to as the ‘colour’ of the resonator). A monochromatic two-state system, e.g. a molecule that can only exist in two energetic states (ground and excited) and can only absorb one quantum (with respect to one ‘colour’), is, however, not sufficient for this. This prompted an evaluation of the significance of the monochromatic resonator for the Boltzmann-factor and Planck's radiation law. It turns out that the Boltzmann-factor and thus also the radiation law require resonators and hence are incompatible with two-state systems. The radiation law is derived using a kinetic model for the interaction of light with matter and without a priori use of the Boltzmann-factor, whereby it is also assumed that photons follow classical trajectories.

•Feb 20, 2025•3 citations

Do we count indivisible photons or discrete quantum events experienced by detectors?

Chandrasekhar Roychoudhuri, Negussie Tirfessa

As low light detection technologies are advancing, novel experiments like single molecule spectroscopy, quantum computation, quantum encryption are proliferating. Quantum mechanical detectors can produce only discrete "clicks" at different rates based on the propagating field energy through them, irrespective of whether the photons are divisible or indivisible packets of energy. This is because electrons are quantized elementary particles and they are always bound in quantized energy levels in different quantum systems. Highly successful quantum formalism is not capable of providing the microscopic picture of the processes undergoing during QM interactions; that is left to human imaginations allowing for sustained controversies and mis-interpretations. This paper underscores the paradoxes that arise with the assumption that photons are indivisible elementary particles based on the obvious but generally ignored fact that EM fields do not operate on (interfere with) each other. Then we propose that atomic or molecular emissions emerge and propagate out as space and time finite classical wave packets. We also suggest experiments to validate that the amplitude of a photon wave packet can be split and combined by classical optical components using the specific example of an N-slit grating.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Oct 18, 2006•16 citations

Strong light-matter coupling: parametric interactions in a cavity and free-space

Igor B. Mekhov, V. S. Egorov, Victor Lebedev +3 more

We consider parametric interactions of laser pulses in a coherent macroscopic ensemble of resonant atoms, which are possible in the strong coupling regime of light-matter interaction. The spectrum condensation (lasing at collective vacuum Rabi sidebands) was studied in an active cavity configuration. Parametric interactions under the strong light-matter coupling were proved even in free space. In contrast to bichromatic beats in a cavity, they were shown to appear due to interference between polaritonic wave packets of different group velocities.

arXiv:quant-ph/0607033•Jul 5, 2006•1 citation

Cavity-assisted spontaneous emission as a single-photon source: Pulse shape and efficiency of one-photon Fock-state preparation

M. Khanbekyan, D.‐G. Welsch, C. Di Fidio +1 more

Within the framework of exact quantum electrodynamics in dispersing and absorbing media, we have studied the quantum state of the radiation emitted from an initially in the upper state, prepared two-level atom in a high-$\mathit{Q}$ cavity, including the regime where the emitted photon belongs to a wave packet that simultaneously covers the areas inside and outside the cavity. For both continuing atom-field interaction and short-term atom-field interaction, we have determined the spatiotemporal shape of the excited outgoing wave packet and calculated the efficiency of the wave packet to carry a one-photon Fock state. Furthermore, we have made contact with quantum noise theories where the intracavity field and the field outside the cavity are regarded as approximately representing independent degrees of freedom such that two separate Hilbert spaces can be introduced.

arXiv:0709.2998•Physical Review A•Jul 15, 2008•16 citations
We highlight fundamental differences in the models of light-matter interaction between the behavior of Fock state detection in free space versus optical cavities. To do so, we study the phenomenon of the resonance of detectors with Fock wave packets as a function of their degree of monochromaticity, the number of spatial dimensions, the linear or quadratic nature of the light-matter coupling, and the presence (or absence) of cavity walls in space. In doing so we show that intuition coming from quantum optics in cavities does not straightforwardly carry to the free-space case. For example, in (3+13+13+1) dimensions the detector response to a Fock wave packet will go to zero as the wave packet is made more and more monochromatic and in coincidence with the detector's resonant frequency. This is so even though the energy of the free-space wave packet goes to the expected finite value of \ensuremathℏ\ensuremathΩ\ensuremath{\hbar}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}\ensuremathℏ\ensuremathΩ in the monochromatic limit. This is in contrast to the behavior of the light-matter interaction in a cavity (even a large one) where the probability of absorbing a Fock quantum is maximized when the quantum is more monochromatic at the detector's resonance frequency. We trace this crucial difference to the fact that monochromatic Fock states are not normalizable in the continuum; thus physical Fock states need to be constructed out of normalizable wave packets whose energy density goes to zero in the monochromatic limit as they get spatially delocalized.
In a single-particle detection experiment, a wavefront impinges on a detector but observers only see a point response. The extent of the wavefront becomes evident only in statistical accumulation of many independent detections, with probability given by the Born rule. Drawing on concepts from quantum optics, we analyze a simple model to reverse-engineer how this behavior can come about in terms of wave mechanics alone without a measurement axiom. The model detector consists of many molecules, each of which can be resonantly excited by the incoming particle and then emit a detection signature (e.g., localized flash of light). Different molecules have different resonant energies because local conditions (proximity of other molecules, Doppler shifts, etc.) vary. The detector is thus a quasi-continuum, and the incoming particle preferentially excites the molecule that it matches most closely in energy. (In actuality, molecules can be so numerous that many could closely match the incoming particle in energy; but in that case only one will be the first, and there will be nothing left for the others by the time the first match resonates and then emits. The model does not explicitly take into account the temporal advance of the particle wave packet through the detector medium.) The excited molecule can emit a detection signature, but that process competes with fluctuation-driven dephasing. We estimate the probability that a given molecule is resonantly excited, and we also estimate the probability that a detection signature is produced before being overwhelmed by fluctuations in the detector medium. The product of these two probabilities is proportional to the absolute-square of the incoming wavefunction at the molecule in question, i.e. the Born rule. We discuss ways to probe these mechanisms experimentally, and check the model with numbers from a neutron interference experiment.
Do the prior history and the wave-packet size and form of a free electron have a physical effect in its interaction with light? Here we answer these fundamental questions on the interpretation of the electron quantum wave function by analyzing spontaneous and stimulated emissions of a quantum electron wave packet, interacting with a general, quantized radiation field. For coherent radiation (Glauber state), we confirm that stimulated emission and absorption of photons depends on the preinteraction-history-dependent size, exhibiting spectral cutoff when it exceeds the interacting radiation wavelength. Furthermore, stimulated emission of an optically modulated electron wave packet has a characteristic harmonic emission spectrum beyond the cutoff, which depends on the modulation features. In either case, there is no wave-packet-dependent radiation of the Fock state, and particularly the vacuum state spontaneous emission is wave-packet independent. The classical-to-quantum transition of radiation from the point-particle to the plane-wave limits, and the effects of wave-packet modulation indicate a way of measuring the wave-packet size of a single electron wave function, and suggest an alternative direction for exploring light-matter interaction.
According to R. Feynman 1963-1965 [10], the interference pattern that appears on the observation screen in the double-slit experiment with light cannot be explained by classical physics. The detection probability is supposed to result from the superposition of all paths that the photon can take from the source to the detector, the light quantum is self-interfering. However, Jin et al. 2010 [11] showed that this is not necessarily the case. In their computer simulation, they assumed that the trajectory of a photon corresponds to that of a classical particle. Thus, the interference only occurs at the detector with the participation of several photons. Not every photon causes a detection.Tiefenbrunner 2024 [17] investigated the detector further and recognized that particle interference under this and some other conditions presupposes a monochromatic resonator (all permissible energy levels are integer (ℕ0) multiples of a basal energy unit ε, where ε is also referred to as the ‘colour’ of the resonator). A monochromatic two-state system, e.g. a molecule that can only exist in two energetic states (ground and excited) and can only absorb one quantum (with respect to one ‘colour’), is, however, not sufficient for this. This prompted an evaluation of the significance of the monochromatic resonator for the Boltzmann-factor and Planck's radiation law. It turns out that the Boltzmann-factor and thus also the radiation law require resonators and hence are incompatible with two-state systems. The radiation law is derived using a kinetic model for the interaction of light with matter and without a priori use of the Boltzmann-factor, whereby it is also assumed that photons follow classical trajectories.
As low light detection technologies are advancing, novel experiments like single molecule spectroscopy, quantum computation, quantum encryption are proliferating. Quantum mechanical detectors can produce only discrete "clicks" at different rates based on the propagating field energy through them, irrespective of whether the photons are divisible or indivisible packets of energy. This is because electrons are quantized elementary particles and they are always bound in quantized energy levels in different quantum systems. Highly successful quantum formalism is not capable of providing the microscopic picture of the processes undergoing during QM interactions; that is left to human imaginations allowing for sustained controversies and mis-interpretations. This paper underscores the paradoxes that arise with the assumption that photons are indivisible elementary particles based on the obvious but generally ignored fact that EM fields do not operate on (interfere with) each other. Then we propose that atomic or molecular emissions emerge and propagate out as space and time finite classical wave packets. We also suggest experiments to validate that the amplitude of a photon wave packet can be split and combined by classical optical components using the specific example of an N-slit grating.
We consider parametric interactions of laser pulses in a coherent macroscopic ensemble of resonant atoms, which are possible in the strong coupling regime of light-matter interaction. The spectrum condensation (lasing at collective vacuum Rabi sidebands) was studied in an active cavity configuration. Parametric interactions under the strong light-matter coupling were proved even in free space. In contrast to bichromatic beats in a cavity, they were shown to appear due to interference between polaritonic wave packets of different group velocities.
Within the framework of exact quantum electrodynamics in dispersing and absorbing media, we have studied the quantum state of the radiation emitted from an initially in the upper state, prepared two-level atom in a high-Q\mathit{Q}Q cavity, including the regime where the emitted photon belongs to a wave packet that simultaneously covers the areas inside and outside the cavity. For both continuing atom-field interaction and short-term atom-field interaction, we have determined the spatiotemporal shape of the excited outgoing wave packet and calculated the efficiency of the wave packet to carry a one-photon Fock state. Furthermore, we have made contact with quantum noise theories where the intracavity field and the field outside the cavity are regarded as approximately representing independent degrees of freedom such that two separate Hilbert spaces can be introduced.