Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2008.04843

The pollen and the electron: a study in randomness

Priyanka Giri, Tejinder P. Singh

Published Aug 8, 2020• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The random motion of a pollen grain in a glass of water is only apparently so. It results from coarse-graining an underlying deterministic motion - that of the molecules of water colliding with the grain. Not observing degrees of freedom on smaller scales can make deterministic evolution appear indeterministic on larger scales. In this essay we attempt to make the case that quantum indeterminism arises in an analogous manner, from coarse-graining a deterministic (but non-unitary) evolution at the Planck scale. The underlying evolution is described by the theory of trace dynamics, which is a deterministic matrix dynamics from which quantum theory and its indeterminism are emergent. One consequence of the theory is the Karolyhazy uncertainty relation, which implies a universal upper bound to the speed of computing, as noted also by other researchers.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2008.04843

Related papers

Nature does not play Dice at the Planck scale

Tejinder P. Singh

We start from classical general relativity coupled to matter fields. Each configuration variable and its conjugate momentum, as also spacetime points are raised to the status of matrices [equivalently operators]. These matrices obey a deterministic Lagrangian dynamics at the Planck scale. By coarse-graining this matrix dynamics over time intervals much larger than Planck time, one derives quantum theory as a low energy emergent approximation. If a sufficiently large number of degrees of freedom get entangled, spontaneous localisation takes place, leading to the emergence of classical spacetime geometry and a classical universe. In our theory, dark energy is shown to be a large-scale quantum gravitational phenomenon. Quantum indeterminism is not fundamental, but results from our not probing physics at the Planck scale.

arXiv:2005.06427•International Journal of Modern Physics D•Jul 29, 2020•6 citations

Physics Diamond

James Reeves

The standard formulation of quantum mechanics combines deterministic unitary evolution with non-deterministic measurement postulates. Although operationally successful, this hybrid structure introduces internal tensions between continuity, probability, and physical law. In this work, we examine the standard postulates across five independent formalisms—the Schro¨dinger picture, the Heisenberg picture, the path integral formulation, the density matrix framework, and open-systems measurement theory. By identifying the load-bearing assumptions required to sustain intrinsic randomness, we reveal a deeper consistency condition implicit in all five approaches. When made explicit, this condition enforces a fully deterministic substrate underlying quantum evolution, with apparent stochasticity arising only from coarse-graining over unresolved degrees of freedom. No empirical predictions are altered. Instead, determinism emerges as the minimal completion of the standard formalism.

•Jun 10, 2026•0 citations

Fluid Clocks: Emergence of quantum theory from sub-quantum dynamics

Gerhard Grössing

It is argued that any operational measure of time is inseparably bound to the presence of a periodic process in some medium. Since, as first formulated by Einstein's (1905) equation for the energy, all "particles" (neutrons, electrons, photons, etc.) are each characterized by a specific "frequency", the inverse of this frequency is the smallest operational unit of time available in principle. With a corresponding "coarse graining" of an otherwise practically idealized, continuous time (i.e., with the latter then holding on time scales much larger than the coarse grained one), one can show that the basic features of quantum theory can be derived from a minimal set of assumptions. In particular, it is shown here how the Schroedinger equation can be derived from classical physics modified only by said assumption of a coarse grained time and the presence of so-called "zero-point fluctuations". The latter relate to the dynamics of a "fluid" vacuum, which is today known to be a far cry from just being "empty space". Consequently, it is shown that time and matter, when discussed from a physical point of view, must by necessity be considered in one common framework.

arXiv:quant-ph/0508079•Aug 9, 2005•1 citation

Deterministic Growth Dynamics of Causal Graphs IV: Derivation of Quantum Mechanics

Andrei Okhremenko

The present paper continues the DGDCG I–III programme by deriving quantum dynamics and Lorentz invariance from a single axiom — the Coverage Principle. A deterministic mechanism for the emergence of quantum uncertainty is proposed for the first time: it is interpreted as the operational ambiguity of coarse-graining at finite structural resolution r∗, rather than as fundamental stochasticity. On this basis, the uncertainty relation, the Born rule, unitary evolution, and the Schrödinger equation are rigorously derived. The Lorentzian signature (− + ++) and the group SO(3, 1) emerge as the unique structure compatible with the complex phase of the geometric action and the irreversibility of Frontier growth. All results follow from a variational principle without additional physical postulates.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Quasiclassical coarse graining and thermodynamic entropy

Murray Gell‐Mann, James B. Hartle

Our everyday descriptions of the universe are highly coarse grained, following only a tiny fraction of the variables necessary for a perfectly fine-grained description. Coarse graining in classical physics is made natural by our limited powers of observation and computation. But in the modern quantum mechanics of closed systems, some measure of coarse graining is inescapable because there are no nontrivial, probabilistic, fine-grained descriptions. This essay explores the consequences of that fact. Quantum theory allows for various coarse-grained descriptions, some of which are mutually incompatible. For most purposes, however, we are interested in the small subset of ``quasiclassical descriptions'' defined by ranges of values of averages over small volumes of densities of conserved quantities such as energy and momentum and approximately conserved quantities such as baryon number. The near-conservation of these quasiclassical quantities results in approximate decoherence, predictability, and local equilibrium, leading to closed sets of equations of motion. In any description, information is sacrificed through the coarse graining that yields decoherence and gives rise to probabilities for histories. In quasiclassical descriptions, further information is sacrificed in exhibiting the emergent regularities summarized by classical equations of motion. An appropriate entropy measures the loss of information. For a ``quasiclassical realm'' this is connected with the usual thermodynamic entropy as obtained from statistical mechanics. It was low for the initial state of our universe and has been increasing since.

arXiv:quant-ph/0609190•Physical Review A•Aug 20, 2007•97 citations

Emergence of Classical Properties from Quantum Theory

Masa‐aki Sakagami

We discuss how classical nature appears from quantum theory using two different points of view. The first employs a coarse-grained dynamics which is obtained by means of tracing over the environment. In this viewpoint, we focus on non-linear quantum systems and examine how this effects their decoherence. In the other viewpoint, we study a formalism which realizes decoherence without the partial trace. The roles of an infinite number of degrees of freedom on the issue are discussed.

Progress of Theoretical Physics Supplement•Jan 1, 1994•5 citations
The random motion of a pollen grain in a glass of water is only apparently so. It results from coarse-graining an underlying deterministic motion - that of the molecules of water colliding with the grain. Not observing degrees of freedom on smaller scales can make deterministic evolution appear indeterministic on larger scales. In this essay we attempt to make the case that quantum indeterminism arises in an analogous manner, from coarse-graining a deterministic (but non-unitary) evolution at the Planck scale. The underlying evolution is described by the theory of trace dynamics, which is a deterministic matrix dynamics from which quantum theory and its indeterminism are emergent. One consequence of the theory is the Karolyhazy uncertainty relation, which implies a universal upper bound to the speed of computing, as noted also by other researchers.
We start from classical general relativity coupled to matter fields. Each configuration variable and its conjugate momentum, as also spacetime points are raised to the status of matrices [equivalently operators]. These matrices obey a deterministic Lagrangian dynamics at the Planck scale. By coarse-graining this matrix dynamics over time intervals much larger than Planck time, one derives quantum theory as a low energy emergent approximation. If a sufficiently large number of degrees of freedom get entangled, spontaneous localisation takes place, leading to the emergence of classical spacetime geometry and a classical universe. In our theory, dark energy is shown to be a large-scale quantum gravitational phenomenon. Quantum indeterminism is not fundamental, but results from our not probing physics at the Planck scale.
The standard formulation of quantum mechanics combines deterministic unitary evolution with non-deterministic measurement postulates. Although operationally successful, this hybrid structure introduces internal tensions between continuity, probability, and physical law. In this work, we examine the standard postulates across five independent formalisms—the Schro¨dinger picture, the Heisenberg picture, the path integral formulation, the density matrix framework, and open-systems measurement theory. By identifying the load-bearing assumptions required to sustain intrinsic randomness, we reveal a deeper consistency condition implicit in all five approaches. When made explicit, this condition enforces a fully deterministic substrate underlying quantum evolution, with apparent stochasticity arising only from coarse-graining over unresolved degrees of freedom. No empirical predictions are altered. Instead, determinism emerges as the minimal completion of the standard formalism.
It is argued that any operational measure of time is inseparably bound to the presence of a periodic process in some medium. Since, as first formulated by Einstein's (1905) equation for the energy, all "particles" (neutrons, electrons, photons, etc.) are each characterized by a specific "frequency", the inverse of this frequency is the smallest operational unit of time available in principle. With a corresponding "coarse graining" of an otherwise practically idealized, continuous time (i.e., with the latter then holding on time scales much larger than the coarse grained one), one can show that the basic features of quantum theory can be derived from a minimal set of assumptions. In particular, it is shown here how the Schroedinger equation can be derived from classical physics modified only by said assumption of a coarse grained time and the presence of so-called "zero-point fluctuations". The latter relate to the dynamics of a "fluid" vacuum, which is today known to be a far cry from just being "empty space". Consequently, it is shown that time and matter, when discussed from a physical point of view, must by necessity be considered in one common framework.
The present paper continues the DGDCG I–III programme by deriving quantum dynamics and Lorentz invariance from a single axiom — the Coverage Principle. A deterministic mechanism for the emergence of quantum uncertainty is proposed for the first time: it is interpreted as the operational ambiguity of coarse-graining at finite structural resolution r∗, rather than as fundamental stochasticity. On this basis, the uncertainty relation, the Born rule, unitary evolution, and the Schrödinger equation are rigorously derived. The Lorentzian signature (− + ++) and the group SO(3, 1) emerge as the unique structure compatible with the complex phase of the geometric action and the irreversibility of Frontier growth. All results follow from a variational principle without additional physical postulates.
Our everyday descriptions of the universe are highly coarse grained, following only a tiny fraction of the variables necessary for a perfectly fine-grained description. Coarse graining in classical physics is made natural by our limited powers of observation and computation. But in the modern quantum mechanics of closed systems, some measure of coarse graining is inescapable because there are no nontrivial, probabilistic, fine-grained descriptions. This essay explores the consequences of that fact. Quantum theory allows for various coarse-grained descriptions, some of which are mutually incompatible. For most purposes, however, we are interested in the small subset of ``quasiclassical descriptions'' defined by ranges of values of averages over small volumes of densities of conserved quantities such as energy and momentum and approximately conserved quantities such as baryon number. The near-conservation of these quasiclassical quantities results in approximate decoherence, predictability, and local equilibrium, leading to closed sets of equations of motion. In any description, information is sacrificed through the coarse graining that yields decoherence and gives rise to probabilities for histories. In quasiclassical descriptions, further information is sacrificed in exhibiting the emergent regularities summarized by classical equations of motion. An appropriate entropy measures the loss of information. For a ``quasiclassical realm'' this is connected with the usual thermodynamic entropy as obtained from statistical mechanics. It was low for the initial state of our universe and has been increasing since.