Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1909.07403 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Theory of dipole insulators

Oleg Dubinkin, Julian May-Mann, Taylor L. Hughes

Published Mar 15, 2021• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Insulating systems are characterized by their insensitivity to twisted boundary conditions as quantified by the charge stiffness and charge localization length. The latter quantity was shown to be related to the expectation value of the many-body position operator and serves as a universal criterion to distinguish between metals and insulators. In this work we extend these concepts to a new class of quantum systems having conserved charge and dipole moments. We refine the concept of a charge insulator by introducing notions of multipolar insulators, e.g., a charge insulator could be a dipole insulator or dipole metal. We develop a universal criterion to distinguish between these phases by extending the concept of charge stiffness and localization to analogous versions for multipole moments but with our focus on dipoles. We are able to relate the dipole localization scale to the expectation value of a recently introduced many-body quadrupole operator. This refined structure allows for the identification of phase transitions where charge remains localized but, e.g., dipoles delocalize. We illustrate the proposed criterion using several exactly solvable models that exemplify these concepts and discuss a possible realization in cold-atom systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.103.125129

Related papers

Many-body electric multipole operators in extended systems

William A. Wheeler, Lucas K. Wagner, Taylor L. Hughes

The quantum mechanical position operators, and their products, are not well-defined in systems obeying periodic boundary conditions. Here we extend the work of Resta [Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 1800 (1998)], who developed a formalism to calculate the electronic polarization as an expectation value of a many-body operator, to include higher multipole moments, e.g., quadrupole and octupole. We define $n\mathrm{th}$-order multipole operators whose expectation values can be used to calculate the $n\mathrm{th}$ multipole moment when all of the lower moments are vanishing (modulo a quantum). We show that changes in our operators are tied to flows of $n\ensuremath{-}1\mathrm{st}$ multipole currents, and encode the adiabatic evolution of the system in the presence of an $n\ensuremath{-}1\mathrm{st}$ gradient of the electric field. Finally, we test our operators on a set of tight-binding models to show that they correctly determine the phase diagrams of topological quadrupole and octupole models, capture an adiabatic quadrupole pump, and distinguish a bulk quadrupole moment from other mechanisms that generate corner charges.

arXiv:1812.06990•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 20, 2019•143 citations

Electric multipole moments and higher-order topological phases in crystalline insulators and superconductors

Wladimir A. Benalcazar

This dissertation discusses extensions of the theory of polarization in crystalline insulators. The notion that electronic wave functions of energy bands in crystalline insulators have Berry phases associated with the positions of electronic charge is at the basis of our understanding of topological band theory. We show, by using the Berry phase formulation and generalizations of it, as well as by exact diagonalization of tight-binding models, that crystalline insulators can generate charge and polarization patterns compatible with the notion of quadrupole and octupole electric moments. In the presence of certain symmetries, these moments are quantized, and their boundary signatures fractionalized. These higher multipole moments then correspond to new symmetry-protected topological phases (SPTs). A salient signature of these SPTs is the existence of zero-dimensional, corner-localized mid-gap energy states. We then study topological crystalline superconductors, in which these zero-dimensional mid-gap states amount to the existence of Majorana bound states (MBS). We thoroughly classify these systems when rotational group symmetries are enforced, and investigate the existence of zero-dimensional MBS trapped at topological defects in these crystals. The finding of these higher multipole moments or generalizations of them to other platforms constitute a new paradigm for the realization of symmetry protected topological phases.

•Jul 6, 2018•0 citations

Topological dipole conserving insulators and multipolar responses

Julian May-Mann, Taylor L. Hughes

Higher order topological insulators (HOTIs) are a novel form of insulating quantum matter, which are characterized by having gapped boundaries that are separated by gapless corner or hinge states. Recently, it has been proposed that the essential features of a large class of HOTIs are captured by topological multipolar response theories. In this paper, we show that these multipolar responses can be realized in interacting lattice models, which conserve both charge and dipole. In this paper we study several models in both the strongly interacting and mean field limits. In two dimensions we consider a ring-exchange model which exhibits a quadrupole response, and can be tuned to a ${C}_{4}$ symmetric higher order topological phase with half-integer quadrupole moment, as well as half-integer corner charges. We then extend this model to develop an analytic description of adiabatic dipole pumping in an interacting lattice model. The quadrupole moment changes during this pumping process, and if the process is periodic we show the total change in the quadrupole moment is quantized as an integer. We also consider two interacting three-dimensional ($3\mathrm{D}$) lattice models with chiral hinge modes. We show that the chiral hinge modes are heralds of a recently proposed ``dipolar Chern-Simons'' response, which is related to the quadrupole response by dimensional reduction. Interestingly, we find that in the mean field limit both the two-dimensional and $3\mathrm{D}$ interacting models we consider here are equivalent to known models of noninteracting HOTIs (or boundary obstructed versions). The self-consistent mean field theory treatment provides insight into the connection between free-fermion (mean field) theories having vanishing polarization and interacting models where dipole moments are microscopically conserved.

arXiv:2103.00008•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 18, 2021•11 citations

Many-body multipole index and bulk-boundary correspondence

Yasuhiro Tada, Masaki Oshikawa

We propose dipole and quadrupole indices for interacting insulators with point group symmetries. The proposed indices are defined in terms of many-body quantum multipole operators combined with the generator of the point group symmetry. Unlike the original multipole operators, these combined operators commute with the Hamiltonian under symmetry and therefore their eigenvalues are quantized. This enables a clear identification of nontrivial multipolar states. We calculate the multipole indices in representative models and show their effectiveness as order parameters. Furthermore, we demonstrate a bulk-boundary correspondence: a nonzero index implies the existence of edge/corner states under the point group symmetry.

arXiv:2302.00800•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 15, 2023•7 citations

Metal and Superfluid–Insulator Transitions

M. A. Contínentino

Conductivity and Charge Stiffness In this chapter, we will consider initially metal–insulator (MI) transitions which occur in pure systems without disorder. In the final section we consider a superfluid–insulator transition induced by some special type of disorder. We will show that the quantities which characterise the phase transitions in both problems obey similar scaling laws and are governed by similar exponents. Differently from the magnetic transitions treated before metal–insulator (MI) transitions have no obvious order parameter to distinguish the metallic from the insulating phase. This precludes a power expansion of the free energy in terms of a small quantity as for magnetic phase transitions. In spite of that, the concepts of phase transitions and critical phenomena turn out to be very useful to describe metal–insulator transitions. In case this problem is approached using the renormalisation group, the localisation transition is associated with an unstable fixed point and the flow of the RG equations to the different attractors is sufficient to distinguish the nature of the phases. Then, in general, we can associate a set of critical exponents with the MI transitions. Besides, these exponents are not independent but obey scaling relations. Since we are concerned with zero temperature instabilities, the quantum hyperscaling law, Eq. 1.18, plays a crucial role in this problem. We will distinguish here two different types of metal–insulator transitions. Those due to a competition between parameters of the relevant Hamiltonian and metal–insulator transitions arising by varying the number of electrons or chemical potential. An example of the former is the Mott transition due to the competition between kinetic energy and the local Coulomb repulsion as described by the half-filled band Hubbard model. The latter will be referred as density-driven metal– insulator transitions in analogy with the superfluid–insulator transition in bosonic systems with varying particle number (Fisher et al ., 1989). These two types of transitions may occur in the same system or Hamiltonian. They in general belong to different universality classes and consequently have different critical exponents.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

Quantum Mechanical Position Operator and Localization in Extended Systems

Armando A. Aligia, Gerardo Ortíz

We introduce a fundamental complex quantity, ${z}_{L}$, which allows us to discriminate between conducting and nonconducting thermodynamic phases in extended quantum systems. Its phase can be related to the expectation value of the position operator, while its modulus provides an appropriate definition of a localization length. The expressions are valid for any fractional particle filling. As an illustration we use ${z}_{L}$ to characterize insulator to ``superconducting'' and Mott transitions in one-dimensional lattice models with infinite on-site Coulomb repulsion at quarter filling.

arXiv:cond-mat/9810348•Physical Review Letters•Mar 22, 1999•101 citations
Insulating systems are characterized by their insensitivity to twisted boundary conditions as quantified by the charge stiffness and charge localization length. The latter quantity was shown to be related to the expectation value of the many-body position operator and serves as a universal criterion to distinguish between metals and insulators. In this work we extend these concepts to a new class of quantum systems having conserved charge and dipole moments. We refine the concept of a charge insulator by introducing notions of multipolar insulators, e.g., a charge insulator could be a dipole insulator or dipole metal. We develop a universal criterion to distinguish between these phases by extending the concept of charge stiffness and localization to analogous versions for multipole moments but with our focus on dipoles. We are able to relate the dipole localization scale to the expectation value of a recently introduced many-body quadrupole operator. This refined structure allows for the identification of phase transitions where charge remains localized but, e.g., dipoles delocalize. We illustrate the proposed criterion using several exactly solvable models that exemplify these concepts and discuss a possible realization in cold-atom systems.
The quantum mechanical position operators, and their products, are not well-defined in systems obeying periodic boundary conditions. Here we extend the work of Resta [Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 1800 (1998)], who developed a formalism to calculate the electronic polarization as an expectation value of a many-body operator, to include higher multipole moments, e.g., quadrupole and octupole. We define nthn\mathrm{th}nth-order multipole operators whose expectation values can be used to calculate the nthn\mathrm{th}nth multipole moment when all of the lower moments are vanishing (modulo a quantum). We show that changes in our operators are tied to flows of $n\ensuremath{-}1\mathrm{st}$ multipole currents, and encode the adiabatic evolution of the system in the presence of an $n\ensuremath{-}1\mathrm{st}$ gradient of the electric field. Finally, we test our operators on a set of tight-binding models to show that they correctly determine the phase diagrams of topological quadrupole and octupole models, capture an adiabatic quadrupole pump, and distinguish a bulk quadrupole moment from other mechanisms that generate corner charges.
This dissertation discusses extensions of the theory of polarization in crystalline insulators. The notion that electronic wave functions of energy bands in crystalline insulators have Berry phases associated with the positions of electronic charge is at the basis of our understanding of topological band theory. We show, by using the Berry phase formulation and generalizations of it, as well as by exact diagonalization of tight-binding models, that crystalline insulators can generate charge and polarization patterns compatible with the notion of quadrupole and octupole electric moments. In the presence of certain symmetries, these moments are quantized, and their boundary signatures fractionalized. These higher multipole moments then correspond to new symmetry-protected topological phases (SPTs). A salient signature of these SPTs is the existence of zero-dimensional, corner-localized mid-gap energy states. We then study topological crystalline superconductors, in which these zero-dimensional mid-gap states amount to the existence of Majorana bound states (MBS). We thoroughly classify these systems when rotational group symmetries are enforced, and investigate the existence of zero-dimensional MBS trapped at topological defects in these crystals. The finding of these higher multipole moments or generalizations of them to other platforms constitute a new paradigm for the realization of symmetry protected topological phases.
Higher order topological insulators (HOTIs) are a novel form of insulating quantum matter, which are characterized by having gapped boundaries that are separated by gapless corner or hinge states. Recently, it has been proposed that the essential features of a large class of HOTIs are captured by topological multipolar response theories. In this paper, we show that these multipolar responses can be realized in interacting lattice models, which conserve both charge and dipole. In this paper we study several models in both the strongly interacting and mean field limits. In two dimensions we consider a ring-exchange model which exhibits a quadrupole response, and can be tuned to a C4{C}_{4}C4​ symmetric higher order topological phase with half-integer quadrupole moment, as well as half-integer corner charges. We then extend this model to develop an analytic description of adiabatic dipole pumping in an interacting lattice model. The quadrupole moment changes during this pumping process, and if the process is periodic we show the total change in the quadrupole moment is quantized as an integer. We also consider two interacting three-dimensional (3D3\mathrm{D}3D) lattice models with chiral hinge modes. We show that the chiral hinge modes are heralds of a recently proposed ``dipolar Chern-Simons'' response, which is related to the quadrupole response by dimensional reduction. Interestingly, we find that in the mean field limit both the two-dimensional and 3D3\mathrm{D}3D interacting models we consider here are equivalent to known models of noninteracting HOTIs (or boundary obstructed versions). The self-consistent mean field theory treatment provides insight into the connection between free-fermion (mean field) theories having vanishing polarization and interacting models where dipole moments are microscopically conserved.
We propose dipole and quadrupole indices for interacting insulators with point group symmetries. The proposed indices are defined in terms of many-body quantum multipole operators combined with the generator of the point group symmetry. Unlike the original multipole operators, these combined operators commute with the Hamiltonian under symmetry and therefore their eigenvalues are quantized. This enables a clear identification of nontrivial multipolar states. We calculate the multipole indices in representative models and show their effectiveness as order parameters. Furthermore, we demonstrate a bulk-boundary correspondence: a nonzero index implies the existence of edge/corner states under the point group symmetry.
Conductivity and Charge Stiffness In this chapter, we will consider initially metal–insulator (MI) transitions which occur in pure systems without disorder. In the final section we consider a superfluid–insulator transition induced by some special type of disorder. We will show that the quantities which characterise the phase transitions in both problems obey similar scaling laws and are governed by similar exponents. Differently from the magnetic transitions treated before metal–insulator (MI) transitions have no obvious order parameter to distinguish the metallic from the insulating phase. This precludes a power expansion of the free energy in terms of a small quantity as for magnetic phase transitions. In spite of that, the concepts of phase transitions and critical phenomena turn out to be very useful to describe metal–insulator transitions. In case this problem is approached using the renormalisation group, the localisation transition is associated with an unstable fixed point and the flow of the RG equations to the different attractors is sufficient to distinguish the nature of the phases. Then, in general, we can associate a set of critical exponents with the MI transitions. Besides, these exponents are not independent but obey scaling relations. Since we are concerned with zero temperature instabilities, the quantum hyperscaling law, Eq. 1.18, plays a crucial role in this problem. We will distinguish here two different types of metal–insulator transitions. Those due to a competition between parameters of the relevant Hamiltonian and metal–insulator transitions arising by varying the number of electrons or chemical potential. An example of the former is the Mott transition due to the competition between kinetic energy and the local Coulomb repulsion as described by the half-filled band Hubbard model. The latter will be referred as density-driven metal– insulator transitions in analogy with the superfluid–insulator transition in bosonic systems with varying particle number (Fisher et al ., 1989). These two types of transitions may occur in the same system or Hamiltonian. They in general belong to different universality classes and consequently have different critical exponents.
We introduce a fundamental complex quantity, zL{z}_{L}zL​, which allows us to discriminate between conducting and nonconducting thermodynamic phases in extended quantum systems. Its phase can be related to the expectation value of the position operator, while its modulus provides an appropriate definition of a localization length. The expressions are valid for any fractional particle filling. As an illustration we use zL{z}_{L}zL​ to characterize insulator to ``superconducting'' and Mott transitions in one-dimensional lattice models with infinite on-site Coulomb repulsion at quarter filling.