Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1907.10464 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Collective modes in pumped unconventional superconductors with competing ground states

Marvin A. Müller, Pavel A. Volkov, Indranil Paul, Ilya Eremin

Published Oct 15, 2019• 24 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Motivated by the recent development of terahertz pump-probe experiments, we investigate the short-time dynamics in superconductors with multiple attractive pairing channels. Studying a single-band square lattice model with a spin-spin interaction as an example, we find the signatures of collective excitations of the pairing symmetries (known as Bardasis-Schrieffer modes) as well as the order parameter amplitude (Higgs mode) in the short-time dynamics of the spectral gap and quasiparticle distribution after an excitation by a pump pulse. We show that the polarization and intensity of the pulse can be used to control the symmetry of the nonequilibrium state as well as frequencies and relative intensities of the contributions of different collective modes. We find particularly strong signatures of the Bardasis-Schrieffer mode in the dynamics of the quasiparticle distribution function. Our work shows the potential of modern ultrafast experiments to address the collective excitations in unconventional superconductors and highlights the importance of subdominant interactions for the nonequilibrium dynamics in these systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.100.140501

Related papers

Novel Non–Equilibrium Dynamics in Superconductors: Induced Superconductivity and Higgs Modes

Nikolaj Bittner

This thesis reports on theoretical investigations of the ultrafast nonequilibrium dynamics in superconductors. In particular, two nonequilibrium scenarios are modeled by combining several analytical and numerical methods: transient superconducting phase transition and collective excitations of a superconducting condensate. In the first part of the thesis the possibility to induce singlet superconducting correlations far from equilibrium is explored by applying time-dependent Lanczos algorithm to the one-dimensional extended Hubbard model. Here, the system is driven into a nonequilibrium state by (i) interaction quench and (ii) quench by pulse. In both cases the buildup of the superconducting correlations is studied in view of several correlation functions. Moreover, a transient Meissner effect, which reflects fingerprints of the induced superconductivity, is observed in calculations of the important for experiments time-dependent optical conductivity. In addition, the differences between nonequilibrium dynamics of the extended Hubbard model initiated by interaction quench and by pulse quench are discussed in detail. The second part is devoted to the excitation of collective modes in a superconductor out of equilibrium. First of all, focus is given to the properties of collective modes close to equilibrium conditions, where a linearized response can be expected. Within the framework of the (Nambu-) matrix kinetic theory in the clean limit a comprehensive gauge-invariant description of the collective modes associated with phase fluctuations of the order parameter is analytically formulated for the generalized case of two- band superconducting systems. Particular emphasis is on the application to the recently discovered noncentrosymmetric superconductors. A detailed analysis of the collective modes includes specification of the gauge mode (common to all superconductors) and the Leggett mode (collective fluctuations of the interband phase difference), and investigation of their subtle interplay in view of validity of the charge conservation law and the participation in the Anderson-Higgs mechanism. Further, the nonequilibrium excitation of the superconducting gaps for the case of two-band superconductors with singlet pairing correlations is investigated in a view of optical pump-probe experiments. For this purpose a semi-numerical method based on the density- matrix theory is formulated. In this case additional amplitude (Higgs) modes were identified, which allow to directly detect the properties of the superconducting condensates as a function of time. Moreover, a new interplay between the phase (Leggett) and amplitude (Higgs) modes is studied in detail. In particular it was found that the nonadiabatic excitation process leads to strong coupling between both modes. Finally, based on calculations of the time-dependent optical conductivity the prediction is made that the coupled Higgs and Leggett modes can be clearly visible in the pump-probe absorption spectra.

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

Multiple amplitude modes in strongly coupled phonon-mediated superconductors

Yuta Murakami, Philipp Werner, Naoto Tsuji +1 more

We study collective amplitude modes of the superconducting order parameter in strongly coupled electron-phonon systems described by the Holstein model using the nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field theory with the self-consistent Migdal approximation as an impurity solver. The frequency of the Higgs amplitude mode is found to coincide with the superconducting gap even in the strongly coupled (beyond BCS) regime. Besides the Higgs mode, we find another collective mode involving the dynamics of both the phonons and the superconducting order parameter. The frequency of this mode, higher than twice the renormalized phonon frequency in the superconducting phase, is shown to reflect a strong electron-mediated phonon-phonon interaction. Both of collective modes are predicted to contribute to time-resolved photoemission spectra after a strong laser pump as vertex corrections to produce resonance peaks, which allows one to distinguish them from quasiparticle excitations.

arXiv:1511.06105•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 8, 2016•46 citations

Simulation of topological superconductors and their competing orders using photon-mediated interactions

Anjun Chu, Joyce Kwan, Eric Yilun Song +3 more

Realizing and controlling the unconventional pairing featured by topological superconductors remains a central challenge. We introduce a cavity QED quantum simulator that engineers competing chiral $p_x+ip_y$ and $d_{x^2-y^2}+id_{xy}$ orders by tailoring cavity-mediated couplings between atomic pseudospins that emulate momentum-dependent pairing channels. The desired spatially inhomogeneous cavity-mediated couplings can be engineered in a 2D optical lattice using incommensurate cavity-lattice wavelengths naturally occurring in cavity QED systems. This minimal and fully tunable platform enables controlled state preparation and continuous measurement of superconducting order parameters. To probe this competition, the platform enables selective excitation and direct time-domain detection of Bardasis-Schrieffer modes---collective excitations of the subdominant pairing channel. The same competing channel can have an even stronger impact out of equilibrium, where a sudden quench can drive its growth and abruptly reshape the dominant superconducting order, despite the stability of the dominant order in equilibrium. Together, these results establish cavity QED as a controlled setting for revealing hidden competing orders and exploring nonlinear dynamics of topological superconductivity that remain elusive in solid-state and ultracold-atom systems.

quant-pharXiv:2512.17889•Dec 22, 2025•0 citations

Charge and pairing dynamics in the attractive Hubbard model: Mode coupling and the validity of linear-response theory

Jörg Bünemann, G. Seibold

Pump-probe experiments have turned out as a powerful tool in order to study the dynamics of competing orders in a large variety of materials. The corresponding analysis of the data often relies on standard linear-response theory generalized to nonequilibrium situations. Here we examine the validity of such an approach for the charge and pairing response of systems with charge-density wave and (or) superconducting (SC) order. Our investigations are based on the attractive Hubbard model which we study within the time-dependent Hartree-Fock approximation. In particular, we calculate the quench and pump-probe dynamics for SC and charge order parameters in order to analyze the frequency spectra and the coupling of the probe field to the specific excitations. Our calculations reveal that the ``linear-response assumption'' is justified for small to moderate nonequilibrium situations (i.e., pump pulses) in the case of a purely charge-ordered ground state. However, the pump-probe dynamics on top of a superconducting ground state is determined by phase and amplitude modes which get coupled far from the equilibrium state indicating the failure of the linear-response assumption.

arXiv:1708.05984•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 26, 2017•7 citations

Coherent spectroscopy of collective excitations in superfluid helium far from equilibrium

Gabriel Voith, Alexander A. Milner, Michael J. Desrochers +2 more

Ultrafast dynamics of collective excitations in superfluids remains largely unexplored beyond the roton region of the Landau excitation spectrum, despite the importance of such dynamics for understanding nonequilibrium processes in these systems. Here, we employ ultrafast coherent control with sequences of femtosecond pulses to perform spectroscopy of multiple quasiparticles in superfluid helium far from equilibrium. By measuring the time-resolved optical birefringence, we track the nonequilibrium dynamics of quasiparticle pairs associated with rotons, maxons and the Pitaevskii plateau region. The spectral lineshape of the roton peak is explained by an ab initio theoretical analysis of the roton-roton interaction. We also reveal strong energy shifts and short lifetimes of both maxon and Pitaevskii-plateau pairs, as well as an influence of the quasiparticle effective mass on the phase of their coherent response to laser pulses. These results demonstrate the ability to extract previously inaccessible information about collective excitations in a strongly interacting quantum fluid by probing its nonequilibrium dynamics on picosecond and sub-picosecond timescales.

cond-mat.otherCross-listedarXiv:2605.17835•May 19, 2026•0 citations

Transient dynamics of unconventional superconductors: d-wave symmetry and strong correlations

Francesco Peronaci

This thesis is about unconventional superconductors out of equilibrium. More precisely, it summarizes our theoretical efforts in addressing a few questions related to the real-time evolution in models displaying unconventional superconductivity. Apart from the purely theoretical interest, the motivation for these studies comes from the recent achievement in the field of ultrafast time-resolved spectroscopy on correlated materials, such as the high-temperature copper-oxide superconductors. The task of describing such systems in nonequilibrium is a very difficult one. In this thesis we attack the problem from two different points of view: • the anisotropic unconventional d-wave symmetry, • the strong electron-electron correlations. The thesis is organized as follows: The first part introduces the basic concepts which lay at the foundation of the work presented in the other two parts. In Chapter 1, the concept of unconventional superconductivity is briefly introduced. This mainly includes the high-temperature copper-oxide superconductors and their phenomenology: d-wave symmetry of the super- conducting gap and strong electron-electron interaction. Chapter 2 is devoted to a review of the recent experimental advances in the field of ultrafast spectroscopy of high temperature superconductors and correlated materials, with a particular focus on time- and angle- resolved photoemission spectroscopy. Finally, Chapter 3 is a short review of some works in the field of cold-atom Fermi gases. In the second part we address the physics of the d-wave superconductor after a sudden excitation. First, in Chapter 4 we introduce in some detail a model of mean-field superconductor with a d-wave symmetry. The principal feature of this model is the anisotropy of the gap and the nodal lines along which the gap vanishes. The results concerning the dynamics of the gap after a “quantum quench” are exposed in Chapter 5 where we compare our model to the s-wave superconductor. This comparison allows to identify the consequences of the unconventional symmetry. In Chapter 6 we discuss the spectral features of the transient nonequilibrium state of the d-wave superconductor. This is particularly important to move a first step towards photoemission experiments. In the third part we concentrate on the attractive Hubbard model as a prototype of strongly correlated superconductor. In Chapter 8 we discuss the superconducting state at equilibrium with the use of dynamical mean-field theory. In Chapter 9 we discuss the extension of this technique to systems out of equilibrium. In particular it is described the implementation in the superconducting phase. At the end of the thesis two appendices give some details of the calculations.

•Oct 14, 2016•1 citation
Motivated by the recent development of terahertz pump-probe experiments, we investigate the short-time dynamics in superconductors with multiple attractive pairing channels. Studying a single-band square lattice model with a spin-spin interaction as an example, we find the signatures of collective excitations of the pairing symmetries (known as Bardasis-Schrieffer modes) as well as the order parameter amplitude (Higgs mode) in the short-time dynamics of the spectral gap and quasiparticle distribution after an excitation by a pump pulse. We show that the polarization and intensity of the pulse can be used to control the symmetry of the nonequilibrium state as well as frequencies and relative intensities of the contributions of different collective modes. We find particularly strong signatures of the Bardasis-Schrieffer mode in the dynamics of the quasiparticle distribution function. Our work shows the potential of modern ultrafast experiments to address the collective excitations in unconventional superconductors and highlights the importance of subdominant interactions for the nonequilibrium dynamics in these systems.
This thesis reports on theoretical investigations of the ultrafast nonequilibrium dynamics in superconductors. In particular, two nonequilibrium scenarios are modeled by combining several analytical and numerical methods: transient superconducting phase transition and collective excitations of a superconducting condensate. In the first part of the thesis the possibility to induce singlet superconducting correlations far from equilibrium is explored by applying time-dependent Lanczos algorithm to the one-dimensional extended Hubbard model. Here, the system is driven into a nonequilibrium state by (i) interaction quench and (ii) quench by pulse. In both cases the buildup of the superconducting correlations is studied in view of several correlation functions. Moreover, a transient Meissner effect, which reflects fingerprints of the induced superconductivity, is observed in calculations of the important for experiments time-dependent optical conductivity. In addition, the differences between nonequilibrium dynamics of the extended Hubbard model initiated by interaction quench and by pulse quench are discussed in detail. The second part is devoted to the excitation of collective modes in a superconductor out of equilibrium. First of all, focus is given to the properties of collective modes close to equilibrium conditions, where a linearized response can be expected. Within the framework of the (Nambu-) matrix kinetic theory in the clean limit a comprehensive gauge-invariant description of the collective modes associated with phase fluctuations of the order parameter is analytically formulated for the generalized case of two- band superconducting systems. Particular emphasis is on the application to the recently discovered noncentrosymmetric superconductors. A detailed analysis of the collective modes includes specification of the gauge mode (common to all superconductors) and the Leggett mode (collective fluctuations of the interband phase difference), and investigation of their subtle interplay in view of validity of the charge conservation law and the participation in the Anderson-Higgs mechanism. Further, the nonequilibrium excitation of the superconducting gaps for the case of two-band superconductors with singlet pairing correlations is investigated in a view of optical pump-probe experiments. For this purpose a semi-numerical method based on the density- matrix theory is formulated. In this case additional amplitude (Higgs) modes were identified, which allow to directly detect the properties of the superconducting condensates as a function of time. Moreover, a new interplay between the phase (Leggett) and amplitude (Higgs) modes is studied in detail. In particular it was found that the nonadiabatic excitation process leads to strong coupling between both modes. Finally, based on calculations of the time-dependent optical conductivity the prediction is made that the coupled Higgs and Leggett modes can be clearly visible in the pump-probe absorption spectra.
We study collective amplitude modes of the superconducting order parameter in strongly coupled electron-phonon systems described by the Holstein model using the nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field theory with the self-consistent Migdal approximation as an impurity solver. The frequency of the Higgs amplitude mode is found to coincide with the superconducting gap even in the strongly coupled (beyond BCS) regime. Besides the Higgs mode, we find another collective mode involving the dynamics of both the phonons and the superconducting order parameter. The frequency of this mode, higher than twice the renormalized phonon frequency in the superconducting phase, is shown to reflect a strong electron-mediated phonon-phonon interaction. Both of collective modes are predicted to contribute to time-resolved photoemission spectra after a strong laser pump as vertex corrections to produce resonance peaks, which allows one to distinguish them from quasiparticle excitations.
Realizing and controlling the unconventional pairing featured by topological superconductors remains a central challenge. We introduce a cavity QED quantum simulator that engineers competing chiral px+ipyp_x+ip_ypx​+ipy​ and dx2−y2+idxyd_{x^2-y^2}+id_{xy}dx2−y2​+idxy​ orders by tailoring cavity-mediated couplings between atomic pseudospins that emulate momentum-dependent pairing channels. The desired spatially inhomogeneous cavity-mediated couplings can be engineered in a 2D optical lattice using incommensurate cavity-lattice wavelengths naturally occurring in cavity QED systems. This minimal and fully tunable platform enables controlled state preparation and continuous measurement of superconducting order parameters. To probe this competition, the platform enables selective excitation and direct time-domain detection of Bardasis-Schrieffer modes---collective excitations of the subdominant pairing channel. The same competing channel can have an even stronger impact out of equilibrium, where a sudden quench can drive its growth and abruptly reshape the dominant superconducting order, despite the stability of the dominant order in equilibrium. Together, these results establish cavity QED as a controlled setting for revealing hidden competing orders and exploring nonlinear dynamics of topological superconductivity that remain elusive in solid-state and ultracold-atom systems.
Pump-probe experiments have turned out as a powerful tool in order to study the dynamics of competing orders in a large variety of materials. The corresponding analysis of the data often relies on standard linear-response theory generalized to nonequilibrium situations. Here we examine the validity of such an approach for the charge and pairing response of systems with charge-density wave and (or) superconducting (SC) order. Our investigations are based on the attractive Hubbard model which we study within the time-dependent Hartree-Fock approximation. In particular, we calculate the quench and pump-probe dynamics for SC and charge order parameters in order to analyze the frequency spectra and the coupling of the probe field to the specific excitations. Our calculations reveal that the ``linear-response assumption'' is justified for small to moderate nonequilibrium situations (i.e., pump pulses) in the case of a purely charge-ordered ground state. However, the pump-probe dynamics on top of a superconducting ground state is determined by phase and amplitude modes which get coupled far from the equilibrium state indicating the failure of the linear-response assumption.
Ultrafast dynamics of collective excitations in superfluids remains largely unexplored beyond the roton region of the Landau excitation spectrum, despite the importance of such dynamics for understanding nonequilibrium processes in these systems. Here, we employ ultrafast coherent control with sequences of femtosecond pulses to perform spectroscopy of multiple quasiparticles in superfluid helium far from equilibrium. By measuring the time-resolved optical birefringence, we track the nonequilibrium dynamics of quasiparticle pairs associated with rotons, maxons and the Pitaevskii plateau region. The spectral lineshape of the roton peak is explained by an ab initio theoretical analysis of the roton-roton interaction. We also reveal strong energy shifts and short lifetimes of both maxon and Pitaevskii-plateau pairs, as well as an influence of the quasiparticle effective mass on the phase of their coherent response to laser pulses. These results demonstrate the ability to extract previously inaccessible information about collective excitations in a strongly interacting quantum fluid by probing its nonequilibrium dynamics on picosecond and sub-picosecond timescales.
This thesis is about unconventional superconductors out of equilibrium. More precisely, it summarizes our theoretical efforts in addressing a few questions related to the real-time evolution in models displaying unconventional superconductivity. Apart from the purely theoretical interest, the motivation for these studies comes from the recent achievement in the field of ultrafast time-resolved spectroscopy on correlated materials, such as the high-temperature copper-oxide superconductors. The task of describing such systems in nonequilibrium is a very difficult one. In this thesis we attack the problem from two different points of view: • the anisotropic unconventional d-wave symmetry, • the strong electron-electron correlations. The thesis is organized as follows: The first part introduces the basic concepts which lay at the foundation of the work presented in the other two parts. In Chapter 1, the concept of unconventional superconductivity is briefly introduced. This mainly includes the high-temperature copper-oxide superconductors and their phenomenology: d-wave symmetry of the super- conducting gap and strong electron-electron interaction. Chapter 2 is devoted to a review of the recent experimental advances in the field of ultrafast spectroscopy of high temperature superconductors and correlated materials, with a particular focus on time- and angle- resolved photoemission spectroscopy. Finally, Chapter 3 is a short review of some works in the field of cold-atom Fermi gases. In the second part we address the physics of the d-wave superconductor after a sudden excitation. First, in Chapter 4 we introduce in some detail a model of mean-field superconductor with a d-wave symmetry. The principal feature of this model is the anisotropy of the gap and the nodal lines along which the gap vanishes. The results concerning the dynamics of the gap after a “quantum quench” are exposed in Chapter 5 where we compare our model to the s-wave superconductor. This comparison allows to identify the consequences of the unconventional symmetry. In Chapter 6 we discuss the spectral features of the transient nonequilibrium state of the d-wave superconductor. This is particularly important to move a first step towards photoemission experiments. In the third part we concentrate on the attractive Hubbard model as a prototype of strongly correlated superconductor. In Chapter 8 we discuss the superconducting state at equilibrium with the use of dynamical mean-field theory. In Chapter 9 we discuss the extension of this technique to systems out of equilibrium. In particular it is described the implementation in the superconducting phase. At the end of the thesis two appendices give some details of the calculations.