Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1710.01377 · Physical Review Letters

Steady State Entanglement beyond Thermal Limits

Francesco Tacchino, Alexia Auffèves, Marcelo França Santos, Dario Gerace

Published Feb 8, 2018• 62 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Classical engines turn thermal resources into work, which is maximized for reversible operations. The quantum realm has expanded the range of useful operations beyond energy conversion, and incoherent resources beyond thermal reservoirs. This is the case of entanglement generation in a driven-dissipative protocol, which we hereby analyze as a continuous quantum machine. We show that for such machines the more irreversible the process, the larger the concurrence. Maximal concurrence and entropy production are reached for the hot reservoir being at negative effective temperature, beating the limits set by classic thermal operations on an equivalent system.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.120.063604

Related papers

Steady-state entanglement production in a quantum thermal machine with continuous feedback control

Giovanni Francesco Diotallevi, Björn Annby-Andersson, Peter Samuelsson +2 more

Abstract Quantum thermal machines can generate steady-state entanglement by harvesting spontaneous interactions with local environments. However, using minimal resources and control, the entanglement is typically weak. Here, we study entanglement generation in a two-qubit quantum thermal machine in the presence of a continuous feedback protocol. Each qubit is measured continuously and the outcomes are used for real-time feedback to control the local system-environment interactions. We show that there exists an ideal operation regime where the quality of entanglement is significantly improved, to the extent that it can violate standard Bell inequalities and uphold quantum teleportation. In agreement with (Khandelwal et al 2020 New J. Phys. 22 073039), we also find, for ideal operation, that the heat current across the system is proportional to the entanglement concurrence. Finally, we investigate the robustness of entanglement production when the machine operates away from the ideal conditions.

arXiv:2309.07696•New Journal of Physics•Apr 16, 2024•10 citations

Thermalizing Quantum Machines: Dissipation and Entanglement

Valerio Scarani, Mário Ziman, Peter Štelmachovič +2 more

We study the relaxation of a quantum system towards the thermal equilibrium using tools developed within the context of quantum information theory. We consider a model in which the system is a qubit, and reaches equilibrium after several successive two-qubit interactions (thermalizing machines) with qubits of a reservoir. We characterize completely the family of thermalizing machines. The model shows a tight link between dissipation, fluctuations, and the maximal entanglement that can be generated by the machines. The interplay of quantum and classical information processes that give rise to practical irreversibility is discussed.

arXiv:quant-ph/0110088•Physical Review Letters•Feb 19, 2002•312 citations

Quantum entanglement generation in autonomous thermal machines: Effects of non-Markovianity, Hilbert space structure, and quantum coherence

Achraf Khoudiri, K. El Anouz, Abderrahim El Allati

We present a theoretical investigation of entanglement generation in an external quantum system during its interaction with a quantum autonomous thermal machine (QATM) under non-Markovian dynamics. The QATM, composed of two qubits each coupled to independent thermal reservoirs, interacts with an external system of two additional qubits. By analyzing the Hilbert space structure, energy level configurations, and temperature gradients, we define a common interaction between the QATM qubits and the external system qubits, which allows the definition of two thermodynamic cycles (A and B) governed by virtual temperatures and energy-conserving transitions. We demonstrate that the QATM can act as a structured reservoir able to induce non-Markovian memory effects highlighted by negative entropy production rates. Using mutual information and concurrence, we show that entanglement is generated only using cycle A, which is associated with stronger non-Markovian behavior and higher coherence correlations. Our results demonstrate that temperature differences, Hilbert space structure, and coherence serve as quantum resources for controlling and enhancing entanglement in quantum thermodynamic settings, with parameters consistent with experimental superconducting qubit platforms.

arXiv:2508.18056•AVS Quantum Science•May 7, 2026•1 citation

Maximal steady-state entanglement in autonomous quantum thermal machines

Shishir Khandelwal, Björn Annby-Andersson, Giovanni Francesco Diotallevi +2 more

Abstract We devise an autonomous quantum thermal machine consisting of three pairwise-interacting qubits, two of which are locally coupled to thermal reservoirs. The machine operates autonomously, as it requires no time-coherent control, external driving or quantum bath engineering, and is instead propelled by a chemical potential bias. Under ideal conditions, we show that this out-of-equilibrium system can deterministically generate a maximally entangled steady-state between two of the qubits, or any desired pure two-qubit entangled state, emerging as a dark state of the system. We study the robustness of entanglement production with respect to several relevant parameters, obtaining nearly-maximally-entangled states well-away from the ideal regime of operation. Furthermore, we show that our machine architecture can be generalised to a configuration with 2n − 1 qubits, in which only a potential bias and two-body interactions are sufficient to generate genuine multipartite maximally entangled steady states in the form of a W state of n qubits.

arXiv:2401.01776•npj Quantum Information•Feb 19, 2025•7 citations

Entanglement in a quantum heat engine

Harald Öhrn

In 2015 Jonatan Bohr Brask et al. showed that steady-state entanglement could be generated in two interacting qubits incoherently coupled to thermal baths of different temperatures [1]. This thesis is an attempt to re-evaluate their findings with the hope that a slightly different approach and system can help further our understanding of this not yet well understood phenomena. A Lindblad master equation approach is taken to study a two-qubit thermal machine interacting with bosonic thermal reservoirs. It is found that the steady-state entanglement behaves similarly using the Lindblad approach, the main difference being that a larger amount of entanglement can be generated than initially found in Ref. [1].

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Entropy Production in Quantum Heat Engines with Squeezed Reservoirs

Pavol Berger, Natalia Zizka, Andrej Molnar

Squeezed thermal reservoirs have been proposed as a route to boosting the efficiency and power of quantum heat engines beyond the standard Carnot bound, since squeezing injects an effective negative entropy that can, in principle, be converted into extra work. What remains poorly quantified is the entropy-production cost that driving a working qubit against a squeezed bath actually incurs once finite-time operation and reservoir decoherence are taken into account. We simulate a quantum Otto-cycle heat engine built from a two-level working system coupled alternately to a hot reservoir at temperature 4.2 K, squeezed with squeezing parameter r ranging from 0 to 1.2, and an unsqueezed cold reservoir at 0.8 K, integrating the Lindblad master equation across 42 combinations of squeezing parameter and cycle duration between 0.05 and 2.0 (in units of the inverse qubit gap). At r = 0, mean entropy production per cycle was 0.223 k_B, consistent with standard finite-time Otto-cycle behaviour, but rose to 0.361 k_B at r = 1.2, a 62% increase, even as extractable work per cycle increased by 41%, from 0.184 to 0.259 (in units of the qubit gap). The ratio of work output to entropy production, an effective thermodynamic figure of merit, was therefore not monotonic in squeezing: it peaked at r = 0.6, where work per unit entropy produced reached 0.98, 15% above the unsqueezed value of 0.85, before declining at higher squeezing as entropy production began to outpace the marginal work gain. Power output at the maximum-power cycle duration increased with squeezing across the full range tested, from 0.31 (gap units) at r = 0 to 0.52 at r = 1.2, a 68% gain, but efficiency at maximum power fell from 0.41 to 0.33 over the same range, a trade-off traced out in detail in Table 1. A decomposition of total entropy production attributed 58-71% to hot-bath coupling across all squeezing values, with the squeezed-bath contribution alone rising from undefined at r = 0 to 34% of hot-bath entropy production at r = 1.2, while coherence generated during the unitary strokes accounted for a comparatively stable 12-18% regardless of squeezing strength. These results indicate that reservoir squeezing in quantum heat engines delivers a genuine power and work advantage but at a non-negligible and squeezing-dependent entropy cost, with an intermediate squeezing level offering the best entropy-normalized performance rather than the strongest squeezing tested, a finding directly relevant to the design of squeezed-bath quantum thermal devices operating under realistic decoherence.

•Jun 15, 2026•0 citations
Classical engines turn thermal resources into work, which is maximized for reversible operations. The quantum realm has expanded the range of useful operations beyond energy conversion, and incoherent resources beyond thermal reservoirs. This is the case of entanglement generation in a driven-dissipative protocol, which we hereby analyze as a continuous quantum machine. We show that for such machines the more irreversible the process, the larger the concurrence. Maximal concurrence and entropy production are reached for the hot reservoir being at negative effective temperature, beating the limits set by classic thermal operations on an equivalent system.
Abstract Quantum thermal machines can generate steady-state entanglement by harvesting spontaneous interactions with local environments. However, using minimal resources and control, the entanglement is typically weak. Here, we study entanglement generation in a two-qubit quantum thermal machine in the presence of a continuous feedback protocol. Each qubit is measured continuously and the outcomes are used for real-time feedback to control the local system-environment interactions. We show that there exists an ideal operation regime where the quality of entanglement is significantly improved, to the extent that it can violate standard Bell inequalities and uphold quantum teleportation. In agreement with (Khandelwal et al 2020 New J. Phys. 22 073039), we also find, for ideal operation, that the heat current across the system is proportional to the entanglement concurrence. Finally, we investigate the robustness of entanglement production when the machine operates away from the ideal conditions.
We study the relaxation of a quantum system towards the thermal equilibrium using tools developed within the context of quantum information theory. We consider a model in which the system is a qubit, and reaches equilibrium after several successive two-qubit interactions (thermalizing machines) with qubits of a reservoir. We characterize completely the family of thermalizing machines. The model shows a tight link between dissipation, fluctuations, and the maximal entanglement that can be generated by the machines. The interplay of quantum and classical information processes that give rise to practical irreversibility is discussed.
We present a theoretical investigation of entanglement generation in an external quantum system during its interaction with a quantum autonomous thermal machine (QATM) under non-Markovian dynamics. The QATM, composed of two qubits each coupled to independent thermal reservoirs, interacts with an external system of two additional qubits. By analyzing the Hilbert space structure, energy level configurations, and temperature gradients, we define a common interaction between the QATM qubits and the external system qubits, which allows the definition of two thermodynamic cycles (A and B) governed by virtual temperatures and energy-conserving transitions. We demonstrate that the QATM can act as a structured reservoir able to induce non-Markovian memory effects highlighted by negative entropy production rates. Using mutual information and concurrence, we show that entanglement is generated only using cycle A, which is associated with stronger non-Markovian behavior and higher coherence correlations. Our results demonstrate that temperature differences, Hilbert space structure, and coherence serve as quantum resources for controlling and enhancing entanglement in quantum thermodynamic settings, with parameters consistent with experimental superconducting qubit platforms.
Abstract We devise an autonomous quantum thermal machine consisting of three pairwise-interacting qubits, two of which are locally coupled to thermal reservoirs. The machine operates autonomously, as it requires no time-coherent control, external driving or quantum bath engineering, and is instead propelled by a chemical potential bias. Under ideal conditions, we show that this out-of-equilibrium system can deterministically generate a maximally entangled steady-state between two of the qubits, or any desired pure two-qubit entangled state, emerging as a dark state of the system. We study the robustness of entanglement production with respect to several relevant parameters, obtaining nearly-maximally-entangled states well-away from the ideal regime of operation. Furthermore, we show that our machine architecture can be generalised to a configuration with 2n − 1 qubits, in which only a potential bias and two-body interactions are sufficient to generate genuine multipartite maximally entangled steady states in the form of a W state of n qubits.
In 2015 Jonatan Bohr Brask et al. showed that steady-state entanglement could be generated in two interacting qubits incoherently coupled to thermal baths of different temperatures [1]. This thesis is an attempt to re-evaluate their findings with the hope that a slightly different approach and system can help further our understanding of this not yet well understood phenomena. A Lindblad master equation approach is taken to study a two-qubit thermal machine interacting with bosonic thermal reservoirs. It is found that the steady-state entanglement behaves similarly using the Lindblad approach, the main difference being that a larger amount of entanglement can be generated than initially found in Ref. [1].
Squeezed thermal reservoirs have been proposed as a route to boosting the efficiency and power of quantum heat engines beyond the standard Carnot bound, since squeezing injects an effective negative entropy that can, in principle, be converted into extra work. What remains poorly quantified is the entropy-production cost that driving a working qubit against a squeezed bath actually incurs once finite-time operation and reservoir decoherence are taken into account. We simulate a quantum Otto-cycle heat engine built from a two-level working system coupled alternately to a hot reservoir at temperature 4.2 K, squeezed with squeezing parameter r ranging from 0 to 1.2, and an unsqueezed cold reservoir at 0.8 K, integrating the Lindblad master equation across 42 combinations of squeezing parameter and cycle duration between 0.05 and 2.0 (in units of the inverse qubit gap). At r = 0, mean entropy production per cycle was 0.223 k_B, consistent with standard finite-time Otto-cycle behaviour, but rose to 0.361 k_B at r = 1.2, a 62% increase, even as extractable work per cycle increased by 41%, from 0.184 to 0.259 (in units of the qubit gap). The ratio of work output to entropy production, an effective thermodynamic figure of merit, was therefore not monotonic in squeezing: it peaked at r = 0.6, where work per unit entropy produced reached 0.98, 15% above the unsqueezed value of 0.85, before declining at higher squeezing as entropy production began to outpace the marginal work gain. Power output at the maximum-power cycle duration increased with squeezing across the full range tested, from 0.31 (gap units) at r = 0 to 0.52 at r = 1.2, a 68% gain, but efficiency at maximum power fell from 0.41 to 0.33 over the same range, a trade-off traced out in detail in Table 1. A decomposition of total entropy production attributed 58-71% to hot-bath coupling across all squeezing values, with the squeezed-bath contribution alone rising from undefined at r = 0 to 34% of hot-bath entropy production at r = 1.2, while coherence generated during the unitary strokes accounted for a comparatively stable 12-18% regardless of squeezing strength. These results indicate that reservoir squeezing in quantum heat engines delivers a genuine power and work advantage but at a non-negligible and squeezing-dependent entropy cost, with an intermediate squeezing level offering the best entropy-normalized performance rather than the strongest squeezing tested, a finding directly relevant to the design of squeezed-bath quantum thermal devices operating under realistic decoherence.