Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1708.07673 · Physical Review Letters

Dipolar Bose Supersolid Stripes

Raúl Bombín, Jordi Boronat, Ferran Mazzanti

Published Dec 20, 2017• 70 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the superfluid properties of a system of fully polarized dipolar bosons moving in the XY plane. We focus on the general case where the polarization field forms an arbitrary angle α with respect to the Z axis, while the system is still stable. We use the diffusion Monte Carlo and the path integral ground state methods to evaluate the one-body density matrix and the superfluid fractions in the region of the phase diagram where the system forms stripes. Despite its oscillatory behavior, the presence of a finite large-distance asymptotic value in the s-wave component of the one-body density matrix indicates the existence of a Bose condensate. The superfluid fraction along the stripes direction is always close to 1, while in the Y direction decreases to a small value that is nevertheless different from zero. These two facts confirm that the stripe phase of the dipolar Bose system is a clear candidate for an intrinsic supersolid without the presence of defects as described by the Andreev-Lifshitz mechanism.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.119.250402

Related papers

Phase diagram of dipolar bosons in two dimensions with tilted polarization

A. Macia, Jordi Boronat, Ferran Mazzanti

We analyze the ground state of a system of dipolar bosons moving in the $XY$ plane and such that their dipolar moments are all aligned in a fixed direction in space. We focus on the general case where the polarization field forms a generic angle $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ with respect to the $Z$ axis. We use the path-integral ground-state method to analyze the static properties of the system as both $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ and the density $n$ vary over a wide range where the system is stable. We use the maximum of the static structure function as an order parameter to characterize the different phases and the transition lines among them. We find that, in addition to a superfluid gas and a solid phase, the system reaches a stripe phase at large tilting angles that is entirely induced by the anisotropic character of the interaction. We also show that the quantum phase transition from the gas to the stripe phase is of second order and report approximate values for the critical exponents.

arXiv:1407.6960•Physical Review A•Dec 1, 2014•32 citations

Density-wave-type supersolid of two-dimensional tilted dipolar bosons

A. N. Aleksandrova, I. L. Kurbakov, Aleksey K. Fedorov +1 more

We predict a stable density-wave-type supersolid phase of a dilute gas of tilted dipolar bosons in a two-dimensional (2D) geometry. This many-body phase is manifested by the formation of the stripe pattern and elasticity coexisting together with the Bose-Einstein condensation and superfluidity at zero temperature. With the increasing of the tilting angle the type of the gas-supersolid transition changes from the first order to the second-order one despite the 2D character of the system, whereas the anisotropy and many-body stabilizing interactions play crucial roles. Our approach is based on the numerical analysis of the phase diagram using the simulated annealing method for a free-energy functional. The predicted supersolid effect can be realized in a variety of experimental setups ranging from excitons in heterostructures to cold atoms and polar molecules in optical potentials.

arXiv:2312.01716•Physical Review A•Jun 24, 2024•8 citations

Supersolid dipolar phases in planar geometry: Effects of tilted polarization

Daniel Lima, Matheus Grossklags, Vinicius Zampronio +2 more

The behavior of dipolar Bose-Einstein condensates in planar geometries is investigated, focusing on the effects of the polarization orientation. While perpendicular polarization produces a phase diagram with hexagonal, stripes, and honeycomb phases ending at a single critical point, the presence of an in-plane polarization component transforms the critical point into three critical lines, separating two phases at a time and changing radically the appearance of the phase diagram. All transition lines contain first- and second-order regions, while the phase diagram itself shows a resemblance with those displayed by quasi-one-dimensional dipolar systems. Finally, we investigate the effect of introducing an in-plane polarization on the structural properties of the phases and determine the superfluid fraction. Our results show that this process induces an axial deformation on the hexagonal and honeycomb phases, resulting in an anisotropic behavior in the long distance properties of the system like superfluidity. We expect that the rich phenomenology observed provides motivation for new experiments and theoretical works.

arXiv:2501.09641•Physical Review A•Jun 9, 2025•6 citations

Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition in two-dimensional dipolar stripes

Raúl Bombín, Ferran Mazzanti, Jordi Boronat

A two-dimensional quantum system of dipoles, with a polarization angle not perpendicular to the plane, shows a transition from a gas to a stripe phase. We have studied the thermal properties of these two phases using the path-integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) method. By simulating the thermal density matrix, PIMC provides exact results for magnitudes of interest such as the superfluid fraction and the one-body density matrix. As it is well known, in two dimensions the superfluid-to-normal phase transition follows the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) scenario. Our results show that both the anisotropic gas and the stripe phases follow the BKT scaling laws. At fixed density and increasing the tilting angle, the transition temperature decreases in going from the gas to the stripe phase. Superfluidity in the perpendicular direction to the stripes is rather small close to the critical temperature but it becomes larger at lower temperatures, mainly close to the transition to the gas. Our results are in qualitative agreement with the supersolidity observed recently in a quasi-one-dimensional array of dipolar droplets.

arXiv:1912.04279•Physical Review A•Dec 5, 2019•24 citations

Ultracold Bose and Fermi dipolar gases : a quantum Monte Carlo study

Raúl Bombín

The object of study of this thesis are dipolar systems in the quantum degenerate regime. In general, dealing with many-body systems and evaluating their properties requires to deal with the the Schrödinger equation. In the present study we employ different Monte Carlo methods that allow to find numerical solutions to it by employing a set of stochastic techniques. The simplest one that we introduce corresponds to the Variational Monte Carlo (VMC) method, that despite its simplicity, allows to obtain variational solutions to the many-body problem. A more accurate description is provided by Diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC), that provides exact solutions for the ground state of the system when dealing with bosons. We continue presenting two methods that rely on the Feynman's path integral formalism of quantum mechanics: Path Integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) and Path Integral Ground State (PIGS), that provide exact solutions for the bosonic problem at finite and zero temperature respectively. In order to work with fermionic systems, as we do in chapter 4 of this thesis, the DMC algorithm has to be modified with the Fixed-Node (FN) approximation, what alows to avoid the sign problem. Doing so, the results obtained with DMC correspond to variational upper bounds to the energy. In chapter 3 we study the superfluid properties of a system of dipolar bosons that are fully polarized and in which the atoms are restricted to move in the plane. We also consider that all the dipolar moments form a certain tilting angle with the axis perpendicular to the plane, what allows to introduce anisotropy in the system. The phase diagram at zero temperature of this system reveals the existence of three different phases: gas, stripe and solid. Here we focus on the characterization of the superfluid properties across that phase diagram. Our calculations allow to address the question of whether the stripe phase of this system could be a candidate for the supersolid, a system that simultaneously exhibit spatial long-range order and superfluidity. By the employment of DMC and PIGS, we report finite supefluid and condensate fractions, both in the gas and the stripe phases. Then, the study is completed by performing finite temperature calculations, where the use of PIMC allows to characterize the BKT transition and to report the critical temperature at which it occurs in the different phases. Finally, by direct comparison with the predictions of the Luttinger Liquid theory, we explicitly show that the stripe phase can not be described as an ensemble of 1D isolated systems. In chapter 4, we study the fermionic dipolar system in two dimensions, focusing in the case in which all dipoles are polarized along the direction, that in this case is chosen to be the one perpendicular to the plane containing their movement. We compute the equation of state of the system in a wide range of interaction parameters. In the low density regime, the comparison of our results for the dipolar model with those of a hard-disks one allows to determine the regime of universality. On the other hand, at higher densities ( and before crystallization), we discuss the issue of itinerant ferromagnetism, that is, the possibility of having a polarized phase as the ground state of the system. The repulsive Fermi polaron with dipolar interaction, that corresponds to the limit of ultralow concentration of impurities embebed in a fermionic bath is also studied. Here we determine the regime of universality for this problem and compute observables that allow to discuss the validity of the quasi-particle picture. In the last part of the thesis, the formation of ultra-dilute dipolar droplets is studied. Our results are in agreement with experimental measurements performed with dysprosium atoms. On the other hand, the evaluation of their differences with the prediction of the extended Gross-Pitaevskii equation makes it possible to determine the limits of the mean-field approach to this problem. El objeto de estudio de esta tesis son los sistemas dipolares en el régimen cuántico degenardo. Usualmente, tratar con sistemas de muchos cuerpos y para evaluar sus propiedades requiere ser capaz de resolver la ecuación de Schrödinger. En el presente estudio, empleamos diferentes métodos de Monte Carlo, que permiten encontrar soluciones numéricas de forma estocásticas. La primera y más simple de estas técnicas es el método Variational Monte Carlo (VMC), que da una solución variacional. Una mejora sobre lo anterior consiste en emplear el método Diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) que permite obtener soluciones exactas para el estado fundamental del sistema (cuando se estudian sistemas bosónicos). Continuamos presentando dos métodos que se basan en el formalismo Feynman de la mecánica cuántica: Path Integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) y Path Integral Ground State (PIGS), que proporcionan soluciones exactas para el problema bosónico a temperatura finita y en el límite de temperatura cero respectivamente. Para trabajar con sistemas fermionicos, como es el caso del capítulo 4 de esta tesis, el algoritmo DMC tiene que ser modificado según la prescripción Fixed-Node para evitar el problema del signo. Al hacerlo, los resultados obtenidos con DMC se corresponden a soluciones variacionales a la energía. En el capítulo 3 estudiamos las propiedades superfluidas de un sistema de bosones dipolares completamente polarizados y en el que el movimiento de los dipolos está restringido al plano. También consideramos que los momentos dipolares forman un cierto ángulo con el eje perpendicular al plano, lo que permite introducir anisotropía en el sistema. El diagrama de fases a temperatura cero de este sistema revela la existencia de tres fases diferentes: gas, stripe y sólido. Aquí nos centramos en la caracterización de las propiedades superfluidas en ese diagrama de fases. Nuestros cálculos permiten abordar la cuestión de si la fase stripe de este sistema podría ser un candidato para el supersólido: un sistema en el que dos simetrías U (1) se rompen simultáneamente, permitiendo al sistema exhibir orden espacial de largo alcance y a la vez ser superfluido. Mediante el empleo de DMC y PIGS, evaluamos la fracción superfluída y el condensado, tanto en las fases de gas como en el stripe. Este estudio se completa con la extensión a temperatura finita, donde el uso de PIMC permite caracterizar la transición superfluida y obtener la temperatura crítica a la que ésta ocurre en las fases gas y stripe. Finalmente, por comparación directa con las predicciones Líquido de Luttinger, mostramos explícitamente que la fase de stripe no puede describirse como un conjunto de sistemas 1D aislados. En el capítulo 4, estudiamos el sistema dipolar fermiónico en dos dimensiones, enfocándonos en el caso en que todos los dipolos están polarizados a lo largo de la dirección que es perpendicular al plano que contiene su movimiento. Calculamos la ecuación de estado del sistema en un amplio rango de parámetros de interacción: a baja densidad, la comparación de nuestro modelo dipolar con uno de discos duros permite determinar el régimen de universalidad, mientras que a densidades más altas (antes de la cristalización), discutimos la posibilidad de una fase polarizada como el estado fundamental del sistema (ferromagnetismo itinerante). El polaron fermiónico dipolar, correspondiente al límite de impurezas ultradiluídas en un baño fermiónico también es estudiado, determinando el régimen de universalidad y los límites de validez de la aproximación de quasi-partícula. En la última parte de la tesis, la formación de gotas dipolares ultradiluídas es estudiada. Nuestros resultados están en acuerdo con medidas experimentales con átomos de disprosio. Por otro lado, la evaluación de las diferencias entre éstos y la predicción dada por la ecuación de Gross-Pitaevskii extendida, permite evaluar los límites de la aproximación

•Dec 13, 2019•2 citations

2D Dipolar Bosons with Non-zero Tilt Angles

Pengtao Shen, Khandker Quader

Recent experimental advances in creating stable dipolar systems, including polar molecules with large electric dipole moments, have led to vigorous theoretical activities. Here we discuss our work on homogeneous 2D dipolar bosons with dipoles oriented at an angle to the direction perpendicular to the confining 2D plane, i.e. for non-zero tilt angles. Using Bogoliubov-de Gennes equations, we obtain T=0 excitation spectrum of the dipolar Bose gas, and explore instabilities at varying tilt angle, density and dipolar coupling. We map out a phase diagram a function of tilt angle, dipole strength and density. We find the development of maxon-roton behavior leading to roton instabilities at large densities for small tilt angles, and at low densities for large tilt angles. The behavior is anisotropic in k-space; accordingly the roton instabilities occur in the k y direction, suggestive of inhomogeneity and stripe phase, with density mode becoming soft in the y direction. Our results compare favorably with existing Quantum Monte Carlo calculations for non-zero tilt angles.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2018•4 citations
We study the superfluid properties of a system of fully polarized dipolar bosons moving in the XY plane. We focus on the general case where the polarization field forms an arbitrary angle α with respect to the Z axis, while the system is still stable. We use the diffusion Monte Carlo and the path integral ground state methods to evaluate the one-body density matrix and the superfluid fractions in the region of the phase diagram where the system forms stripes. Despite its oscillatory behavior, the presence of a finite large-distance asymptotic value in the s-wave component of the one-body density matrix indicates the existence of a Bose condensate. The superfluid fraction along the stripes direction is always close to 1, while in the Y direction decreases to a small value that is nevertheless different from zero. These two facts confirm that the stripe phase of the dipolar Bose system is a clear candidate for an intrinsic supersolid without the presence of defects as described by the Andreev-Lifshitz mechanism.
We analyze the ground state of a system of dipolar bosons moving in the XYXYXY plane and such that their dipolar moments are all aligned in a fixed direction in space. We focus on the general case where the polarization field forms a generic angle $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ with respect to the ZZZ axis. We use the path-integral ground-state method to analyze the static properties of the system as both $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ and the density nnn vary over a wide range where the system is stable. We use the maximum of the static structure function as an order parameter to characterize the different phases and the transition lines among them. We find that, in addition to a superfluid gas and a solid phase, the system reaches a stripe phase at large tilting angles that is entirely induced by the anisotropic character of the interaction. We also show that the quantum phase transition from the gas to the stripe phase is of second order and report approximate values for the critical exponents.
We predict a stable density-wave-type supersolid phase of a dilute gas of tilted dipolar bosons in a two-dimensional (2D) geometry. This many-body phase is manifested by the formation of the stripe pattern and elasticity coexisting together with the Bose-Einstein condensation and superfluidity at zero temperature. With the increasing of the tilting angle the type of the gas-supersolid transition changes from the first order to the second-order one despite the 2D character of the system, whereas the anisotropy and many-body stabilizing interactions play crucial roles. Our approach is based on the numerical analysis of the phase diagram using the simulated annealing method for a free-energy functional. The predicted supersolid effect can be realized in a variety of experimental setups ranging from excitons in heterostructures to cold atoms and polar molecules in optical potentials.
The behavior of dipolar Bose-Einstein condensates in planar geometries is investigated, focusing on the effects of the polarization orientation. While perpendicular polarization produces a phase diagram with hexagonal, stripes, and honeycomb phases ending at a single critical point, the presence of an in-plane polarization component transforms the critical point into three critical lines, separating two phases at a time and changing radically the appearance of the phase diagram. All transition lines contain first- and second-order regions, while the phase diagram itself shows a resemblance with those displayed by quasi-one-dimensional dipolar systems. Finally, we investigate the effect of introducing an in-plane polarization on the structural properties of the phases and determine the superfluid fraction. Our results show that this process induces an axial deformation on the hexagonal and honeycomb phases, resulting in an anisotropic behavior in the long distance properties of the system like superfluidity. We expect that the rich phenomenology observed provides motivation for new experiments and theoretical works.
A two-dimensional quantum system of dipoles, with a polarization angle not perpendicular to the plane, shows a transition from a gas to a stripe phase. We have studied the thermal properties of these two phases using the path-integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) method. By simulating the thermal density matrix, PIMC provides exact results for magnitudes of interest such as the superfluid fraction and the one-body density matrix. As it is well known, in two dimensions the superfluid-to-normal phase transition follows the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) scenario. Our results show that both the anisotropic gas and the stripe phases follow the BKT scaling laws. At fixed density and increasing the tilting angle, the transition temperature decreases in going from the gas to the stripe phase. Superfluidity in the perpendicular direction to the stripes is rather small close to the critical temperature but it becomes larger at lower temperatures, mainly close to the transition to the gas. Our results are in qualitative agreement with the supersolidity observed recently in a quasi-one-dimensional array of dipolar droplets.
The object of study of this thesis are dipolar systems in the quantum degenerate regime. In general, dealing with many-body systems and evaluating their properties requires to deal with the the Schrödinger equation. In the present study we employ different Monte Carlo methods that allow to find numerical solutions to it by employing a set of stochastic techniques. The simplest one that we introduce corresponds to the Variational Monte Carlo (VMC) method, that despite its simplicity, allows to obtain variational solutions to the many-body problem. A more accurate description is provided by Diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC), that provides exact solutions for the ground state of the system when dealing with bosons. We continue presenting two methods that rely on the Feynman's path integral formalism of quantum mechanics: Path Integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) and Path Integral Ground State (PIGS), that provide exact solutions for the bosonic problem at finite and zero temperature respectively. In order to work with fermionic systems, as we do in chapter 4 of this thesis, the DMC algorithm has to be modified with the Fixed-Node (FN) approximation, what alows to avoid the sign problem. Doing so, the results obtained with DMC correspond to variational upper bounds to the energy. In chapter 3 we study the superfluid properties of a system of dipolar bosons that are fully polarized and in which the atoms are restricted to move in the plane. We also consider that all the dipolar moments form a certain tilting angle with the axis perpendicular to the plane, what allows to introduce anisotropy in the system. The phase diagram at zero temperature of this system reveals the existence of three different phases: gas, stripe and solid. Here we focus on the characterization of the superfluid properties across that phase diagram. Our calculations allow to address the question of whether the stripe phase of this system could be a candidate for the supersolid, a system that simultaneously exhibit spatial long-range order and superfluidity. By the employment of DMC and PIGS, we report finite supefluid and condensate fractions, both in the gas and the stripe phases. Then, the study is completed by performing finite temperature calculations, where the use of PIMC allows to characterize the BKT transition and to report the critical temperature at which it occurs in the different phases. Finally, by direct comparison with the predictions of the Luttinger Liquid theory, we explicitly show that the stripe phase can not be described as an ensemble of 1D isolated systems. In chapter 4, we study the fermionic dipolar system in two dimensions, focusing in the case in which all dipoles are polarized along the direction, that in this case is chosen to be the one perpendicular to the plane containing their movement. We compute the equation of state of the system in a wide range of interaction parameters. In the low density regime, the comparison of our results for the dipolar model with those of a hard-disks one allows to determine the regime of universality. On the other hand, at higher densities ( and before crystallization), we discuss the issue of itinerant ferromagnetism, that is, the possibility of having a polarized phase as the ground state of the system. The repulsive Fermi polaron with dipolar interaction, that corresponds to the limit of ultralow concentration of impurities embebed in a fermionic bath is also studied. Here we determine the regime of universality for this problem and compute observables that allow to discuss the validity of the quasi-particle picture. In the last part of the thesis, the formation of ultra-dilute dipolar droplets is studied. Our results are in agreement with experimental measurements performed with dysprosium atoms. On the other hand, the evaluation of their differences with the prediction of the extended Gross-Pitaevskii equation makes it possible to determine the limits of the mean-field approach to this problem. El objeto de estudio de esta tesis son los sistemas dipolares en el régimen cuántico degenardo. Usualmente, tratar con sistemas de muchos cuerpos y para evaluar sus propiedades requiere ser capaz de resolver la ecuación de Schrödinger. En el presente estudio, empleamos diferentes métodos de Monte Carlo, que permiten encontrar soluciones numéricas de forma estocásticas. La primera y más simple de estas técnicas es el método Variational Monte Carlo (VMC), que da una solución variacional. Una mejora sobre lo anterior consiste en emplear el método Diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) que permite obtener soluciones exactas para el estado fundamental del sistema (cuando se estudian sistemas bosónicos). Continuamos presentando dos métodos que se basan en el formalismo Feynman de la mecánica cuántica: Path Integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) y Path Integral Ground State (PIGS), que proporcionan soluciones exactas para el problema bosónico a temperatura finita y en el límite de temperatura cero respectivamente. Para trabajar con sistemas fermionicos, como es el caso del capítulo 4 de esta tesis, el algoritmo DMC tiene que ser modificado según la prescripción Fixed-Node para evitar el problema del signo. Al hacerlo, los resultados obtenidos con DMC se corresponden a soluciones variacionales a la energía. En el capítulo 3 estudiamos las propiedades superfluidas de un sistema de bosones dipolares completamente polarizados y en el que el movimiento de los dipolos está restringido al plano. También consideramos que los momentos dipolares forman un cierto ángulo con el eje perpendicular al plano, lo que permite introducir anisotropía en el sistema. El diagrama de fases a temperatura cero de este sistema revela la existencia de tres fases diferentes: gas, stripe y sólido. Aquí nos centramos en la caracterización de las propiedades superfluidas en ese diagrama de fases. Nuestros cálculos permiten abordar la cuestión de si la fase stripe de este sistema podría ser un candidato para el supersólido: un sistema en el que dos simetrías U (1) se rompen simultáneamente, permitiendo al sistema exhibir orden espacial de largo alcance y a la vez ser superfluido. Mediante el empleo de DMC y PIGS, evaluamos la fracción superfluída y el condensado, tanto en las fases de gas como en el stripe. Este estudio se completa con la extensión a temperatura finita, donde el uso de PIMC permite caracterizar la transición superfluida y obtener la temperatura crítica a la que ésta ocurre en las fases gas y stripe. Finalmente, por comparación directa con las predicciones Líquido de Luttinger, mostramos explícitamente que la fase de stripe no puede describirse como un conjunto de sistemas 1D aislados. En el capítulo 4, estudiamos el sistema dipolar fermiónico en dos dimensiones, enfocándonos en el caso en que todos los dipolos están polarizados a lo largo de la dirección que es perpendicular al plano que contiene su movimiento. Calculamos la ecuación de estado del sistema en un amplio rango de parámetros de interacción: a baja densidad, la comparación de nuestro modelo dipolar con uno de discos duros permite determinar el régimen de universalidad, mientras que a densidades más altas (antes de la cristalización), discutimos la posibilidad de una fase polarizada como el estado fundamental del sistema (ferromagnetismo itinerante). El polaron fermiónico dipolar, correspondiente al límite de impurezas ultradiluídas en un baño fermiónico también es estudiado, determinando el régimen de universalidad y los límites de validez de la aproximación de quasi-partícula. En la última parte de la tesis, la formación de gotas dipolares ultradiluídas es estudiada. Nuestros resultados están en acuerdo con medidas experimentales con átomos de disprosio. Por otro lado, la evaluación de las diferencias entre éstos y la predicción dada por la ecuación de Gross-Pitaevskii extendida, permite evaluar los límites de la aproximación
Recent experimental advances in creating stable dipolar systems, including polar molecules with large electric dipole moments, have led to vigorous theoretical activities. Here we discuss our work on homogeneous 2D dipolar bosons with dipoles oriented at an angle to the direction perpendicular to the confining 2D plane, i.e. for non-zero tilt angles. Using Bogoliubov-de Gennes equations, we obtain T=0 excitation spectrum of the dipolar Bose gas, and explore instabilities at varying tilt angle, density and dipolar coupling. We map out a phase diagram a function of tilt angle, dipole strength and density. We find the development of maxon-roton behavior leading to roton instabilities at large densities for small tilt angles, and at low densities for large tilt angles. The behavior is anisotropic in k-space; accordingly the roton instabilities occur in the k y direction, suggestive of inhomogeneity and stripe phase, with density mode becoming soft in the y direction. Our results compare favorably with existing Quantum Monte Carlo calculations for non-zero tilt angles.