Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1506.03638 · New Journal of Physics

Exploring complete positivity in hierarchy equations of motion

Björn Witt, Łukasz Rudnicki, Yoshitaka Tanimura, Florian Mintert

Published Jan 9, 2017• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We derive a purely algebraic framework for the identification of hierarchy equations of motion that induce completely positive dynamics and demonstrate the applicability of our approach with several examples. We find bounds on the violation of complete positivity for microscopically derived hierarchy equations of motion and construct well-behaved phenomenological models with strongly non-Markovian revivals of quantum coherence.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/19/1/013007

Related papers

Complete positivity of non-Markovian quantum dynamics

Björn Witt

The hierarchy equations of motion provide an elegant formalism for the description of non-Markovian quantum dynamics, which has successfully been applied to a broad variety of physical problems ranging from light-harvesting complexes to resonant tunnelling junctions. When these equations are derived from microscopic models of system and environment, then they typically expand to an infinite series of coupled differential equations. The truncation of this series is accompanied by an approximation of the dynamics and can give rise to a violation of complete positivity. The goal of this thesis is to investigate under what conditions a set of hierarchy equations of motion induces completely positive dynamics. Such conditions are in particular crucial for a phenomenological understanding of the equations of motion. Several approaches to this problem are proposed and compared for classical systems before a generalisation to quantum mechanical problems is carried out. The main result is a concise set of operator inequalities that are sufficient for complete positivity and that can be implemented efficiently in terms of a semi-definite program. The applicability of this technique is demonstrated by various explicit examples. For truncated hierarchy equations for which a violation of complete positivity is inevitable the framework is extended such that the degree of this violation can be estimated and the validity of the truncation can be gauged. In particular in the presence of initial system-environment correlations a dynamical process can also be considered physically reasonable, when the time evolution is not completely positive and it is shown how hierarchy equations that describe such scenarios can be identified. Eventually, the framework is altered such that it gives rise to conditions on hierarchy equations that are sufficient not only for completely positive but even Markovian dynamics.

•Aug 1, 2016•0 citations

Quantum Semi-Markov Processes

Heinz‐Peter Breuer, Bassano Vacchini

We construct a large class of non-Markovian master equations that describe the dynamics of open quantum systems featuring strong memory effects, which relies on a quantum generalization of the concept of classical semi-Markov processes. General conditions for the complete positivity of the corresponding quantum dynamical maps are formulated. The resulting non-Markovian quantum processes allow the treatment of a variety of physical systems, as is illustrated by means of various examples and applications, including quantum optical systems and models of quantum transport.

arXiv:0809.1501•Physical Review Letters•Oct 2, 2008•126 citations

Generalized Master Equations Leading to Completely Positive Dynamics

Bassano Vacchini

We provide a general construction of quantum generalized master equations with a memory kernel leading to well-defined, that is, completely positive and trace-preserving, time evolutions. The approach builds on an operator generalization of memory kernels appearing in the description of non-Markovian classical processes and puts into evidence the nonuniqueness of the relationship arising due to the typical quantum issue of operator ordering. The approach provides a physical interpretation of the structure of the kernels, and its connection with the classical viewpoint allows for a trajectory description of the dynamics. Previous apparently unrelated results are now connected in a unified framework, which further allows us to phenomenologically construct a large class of non-Markovian evolutions taking as the starting point collections of time-dependent maps and instantaneous transformations describing the microscopic interaction dynamics.

arXiv:1611.01150•Physical Review Letters•Nov 30, 2016•74 citations

Recovering Complete Positivity of Non-Markovian Quantum Dynamics with Choi-Proximity Regularization

Antonio D’Abbruzzo, Donato Farina, Vittorio Giovannetti

A relevant problem in the theory of open quantum systems is the lack of complete positivity of dynamical maps obtained after weak-coupling approximations, a famous example being the Redfield master equation. A number of approaches exist to recover well-defined evolutions under additional Markovian assumptions, but much less is known beyond this regime. Here, we propose a numerical method to cure the complete-positivity violation issue while preserving the non-Markovian features of an arbitrary original dynamical map. The idea is to replace its unphysical Choi operator with its closest physical one, mimicking recent work on quantum process tomography. We also show that the regularized dynamics is more accurate in terms of reproducing the exact dynamics, which allows us to heuristically push the utilization of these master equations in moderate coupling regimes, where the loss of positivity can have a relevant impact. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2309.16320•Physical Review X•Jul 17, 2024•8 citations

Limitations of the Markovian approximation in the harmonic oscillator

Michele Coppola, Zoubair Daouma, Malte Henkel

The quantum fluctuation-dissipation theorem is a central ingredient in the construction of quantum dynamics of Brownian motion which necessarily is non-Markovian. Yet, often Markovian approximations to quantum dynamics are studied in the literature. In this work, we investigate the limitations of the Markovian approximation within two paradigmatic models describing a single damped harmonic oscillator. These models are governed by distinct quantum Langevin equations, although both are constructed to satisfy the same set of phenomenological criteria: the canonical commutation relations between position and momentum, the Kubo response relation, the virial theorem, and the equilibrium quantum variance. The limitations of the Markovian approximation are underscored by the classical limit, violations of the Ehrenfest theorem, the breakdown of complete and simple positivity in the reconstructed master equations, and anomalies in thermalisation behaviour. Further phenomenological differences between the two models are illustrated through their quantum relaxation dynamics and phase diagrams, derived from their reinterpretation as mean-field approximations of a many-body interacting magnet. Our analysis explicitly reveals intrinsic inconsistencies introduced by the Markovian approximation, emphasising the need for non-Markovian frameworks for a consistent description of open quantum dynamics.

arXiv:2305.06312•May 10, 2023•0 citations

Completely-positive non-signalling non-Markovian dynamics

Serhii Kryhin, Vivishek Sudhir

We define non-Markovian quantum dynamics as evolution in which the current state depends on all past states, and completely characterize its structure under the assumptions of complete positivity and non-signalling. The resulting continuous-time dynamics is an integro-differential equation that augments the Gorini-Kossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad equation with a memory integral, and is capable of describing the quantum state of systems exposed to noise with any integrable power spectral density with no further approximations. We then establish a formalism to evaluate multi-time correlations of measurement outcomes in this general setting, obviating the need for a regression theorem. As an application, we derive the emission spectrum of a driven two-level system coupled to a non-Markovian bath: the familiar Mollow triplet acquires a frequency-dependent linewidth that encodes the memory of the bath. Our work provides a rigorous yet transparent description of the quantum state of non-Markovian systems, opening the door for state estimation and state-based quantum control beyond the Markovian regime.

quant-pharXiv:2605.03197•May 6, 2026•0 citations
We derive a purely algebraic framework for the identification of hierarchy equations of motion that induce completely positive dynamics and demonstrate the applicability of our approach with several examples. We find bounds on the violation of complete positivity for microscopically derived hierarchy equations of motion and construct well-behaved phenomenological models with strongly non-Markovian revivals of quantum coherence.
The hierarchy equations of motion provide an elegant formalism for the description of non-Markovian quantum dynamics, which has successfully been applied to a broad variety of physical problems ranging from light-harvesting complexes to resonant tunnelling junctions. When these equations are derived from microscopic models of system and environment, then they typically expand to an infinite series of coupled differential equations. The truncation of this series is accompanied by an approximation of the dynamics and can give rise to a violation of complete positivity. The goal of this thesis is to investigate under what conditions a set of hierarchy equations of motion induces completely positive dynamics. Such conditions are in particular crucial for a phenomenological understanding of the equations of motion. Several approaches to this problem are proposed and compared for classical systems before a generalisation to quantum mechanical problems is carried out. The main result is a concise set of operator inequalities that are sufficient for complete positivity and that can be implemented efficiently in terms of a semi-definite program. The applicability of this technique is demonstrated by various explicit examples. For truncated hierarchy equations for which a violation of complete positivity is inevitable the framework is extended such that the degree of this violation can be estimated and the validity of the truncation can be gauged. In particular in the presence of initial system-environment correlations a dynamical process can also be considered physically reasonable, when the time evolution is not completely positive and it is shown how hierarchy equations that describe such scenarios can be identified. Eventually, the framework is altered such that it gives rise to conditions on hierarchy equations that are sufficient not only for completely positive but even Markovian dynamics.
We construct a large class of non-Markovian master equations that describe the dynamics of open quantum systems featuring strong memory effects, which relies on a quantum generalization of the concept of classical semi-Markov processes. General conditions for the complete positivity of the corresponding quantum dynamical maps are formulated. The resulting non-Markovian quantum processes allow the treatment of a variety of physical systems, as is illustrated by means of various examples and applications, including quantum optical systems and models of quantum transport.
We provide a general construction of quantum generalized master equations with a memory kernel leading to well-defined, that is, completely positive and trace-preserving, time evolutions. The approach builds on an operator generalization of memory kernels appearing in the description of non-Markovian classical processes and puts into evidence the nonuniqueness of the relationship arising due to the typical quantum issue of operator ordering. The approach provides a physical interpretation of the structure of the kernels, and its connection with the classical viewpoint allows for a trajectory description of the dynamics. Previous apparently unrelated results are now connected in a unified framework, which further allows us to phenomenologically construct a large class of non-Markovian evolutions taking as the starting point collections of time-dependent maps and instantaneous transformations describing the microscopic interaction dynamics.
A relevant problem in the theory of open quantum systems is the lack of complete positivity of dynamical maps obtained after weak-coupling approximations, a famous example being the Redfield master equation. A number of approaches exist to recover well-defined evolutions under additional Markovian assumptions, but much less is known beyond this regime. Here, we propose a numerical method to cure the complete-positivity violation issue while preserving the non-Markovian features of an arbitrary original dynamical map. The idea is to replace its unphysical Choi operator with its closest physical one, mimicking recent work on quantum process tomography. We also show that the regularized dynamics is more accurate in terms of reproducing the exact dynamics, which allows us to heuristically push the utilization of these master equations in moderate coupling regimes, where the loss of positivity can have a relevant impact. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
The quantum fluctuation-dissipation theorem is a central ingredient in the construction of quantum dynamics of Brownian motion which necessarily is non-Markovian. Yet, often Markovian approximations to quantum dynamics are studied in the literature. In this work, we investigate the limitations of the Markovian approximation within two paradigmatic models describing a single damped harmonic oscillator. These models are governed by distinct quantum Langevin equations, although both are constructed to satisfy the same set of phenomenological criteria: the canonical commutation relations between position and momentum, the Kubo response relation, the virial theorem, and the equilibrium quantum variance. The limitations of the Markovian approximation are underscored by the classical limit, violations of the Ehrenfest theorem, the breakdown of complete and simple positivity in the reconstructed master equations, and anomalies in thermalisation behaviour. Further phenomenological differences between the two models are illustrated through their quantum relaxation dynamics and phase diagrams, derived from their reinterpretation as mean-field approximations of a many-body interacting magnet. Our analysis explicitly reveals intrinsic inconsistencies introduced by the Markovian approximation, emphasising the need for non-Markovian frameworks for a consistent description of open quantum dynamics.
We define non-Markovian quantum dynamics as evolution in which the current state depends on all past states, and completely characterize its structure under the assumptions of complete positivity and non-signalling. The resulting continuous-time dynamics is an integro-differential equation that augments the Gorini-Kossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad equation with a memory integral, and is capable of describing the quantum state of systems exposed to noise with any integrable power spectral density with no further approximations. We then establish a formalism to evaluate multi-time correlations of measurement outcomes in this general setting, obviating the need for a regression theorem. As an application, we derive the emission spectrum of a driven two-level system coupled to a non-Markovian bath: the familiar Mollow triplet acquires a frequency-dependent linewidth that encodes the memory of the bath. Our work provides a rigorous yet transparent description of the quantum state of non-Markovian systems, opening the door for state estimation and state-based quantum control beyond the Markovian regime.