Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1301.5269

The He II Theory Preserving the Symmetry of the Initial Hamiltonian of the System

I. M. Yurin

Published Jan 22, 2013• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The article suggests a method for the construction of the number of atoms preserving microscopic He II theory. The suggested theory can provide the ground state wave function (WF) as an expansion in series by small parameters. In addition, errors in the definition of the WFs of the excited states turn out to be vanishingly small while the system size increases. Predictions of the proposed theory and of the Bogoliubov theory are identical if helium occupies a simply connected volume. However, there are differences in the general case. These differences are due to the fact that the operator of the occupation number of the zero momentum state does not commute with the creation and annihilation operators of phonons. This contradicts the Bogoliubov assumption that the creation and annihilation operators of atoms in the zero momentum state can be replaced by a c-number. The latter, as is known, should commute with any operator. This should lead to a difference in the results of calculation of helium flow through the tunnel transition. Therefore, the suggested theory is not equivalent to Bogoliubov theory.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1301.5269

Related papers

Bogoliubov theory for a many-boson system

Gary S. Grest, A. K. Rajagopal

Presently there are two distinct classes of microscopic theories which describe a system of many identical spinless bosons. One is the Bogoliubov theory, which places special emphasis on the occupation of the zero-momentum state and as such depends explicitly on the number of particles in this state, ${N}_{0}$. The other depends on density fluctuations to describe the fluid. In this work, we derive a modified version of the Bogoliubov theory which results in a number-conserving Hamiltonian with no explicit dependence on ${N}_{0}$. The ground- and first-excited-state energies evaluated through second order in $\frac{1}{{N}^{\frac{1}{2}}}$ are equivalent to the results of a variational-perturbative procedure based on the method of correlated basis functions in the uniform limit.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Dec 1, 1975•2 citations

Degenerate Bose gas without anomalous averages

Viktor Borisovich Bobrov, S. A. Trigger, Pieter P. J. M. Schram

Theory of a weakly non-ideal Bose gas in the canonical ensemble is developed without assumption of the C-number representation of the creation and annihilation operators with zero momentum. Instead of this assumption, we use the assumption on the C-number nature of the density operator N 0 = a † 0 a 0 with zero momentum. It is shown that the pole of the "density-density" Green function (DDGF), as well as the pole of the single-particle Green function (SPGF), exactly coincide with the Bogoliubov phonon-roton spectrum of excitations for both assumptions. This spectrum, as is known confirmed by many neutron and x-ray experimental measurements of the dynamic structure factor in He II, is straightly related to the DDGF. At the same time, we show that in the other case under consideration, when neither N 0 nor a † 0 and a 0 are C-numbers, a gap can exist in SPGF. This gap in SPGF excitations is straightly related to the density of particles in the "condensate". Therefore, the spectra of excitations for the DDGF and SPGF in the last case under consideration are different, in contrast to the Bogoliubov-type theory where these spectra are identical.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Nov 1, 2016•1 citation

A Microscopic Theory of Superfluids. I: Quasi-Particles and the Extended Bogoliubov Transformation

Shuichiro Yamasaki

Creation and annihilation operators of quasi-particles are introduced into the description of a finite temperature system of degenerate bosons with the aid of a canonical transformation which generalizes the one due to Bogoliubov. A variational calculation taking into account the interaction between non-zero momentum particles shows that the quasi-particles are phonons in the long wave-length limit. The state of the system, which is approximated by the grand canonical ensemble of the quasi-particles, approaches the Hartree-Fock state when the condensate is depleted completely at the critical temperature.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Sep 1, 1984•3 citations

Superfluidity without a Bose condensate

S. I. Shevchenko

We have developed a microscopic theory of superfluidity in a two-dimensional, slightly nonideal Bose gas. The theory is rooted in the fact that a number of bosons are concentrated in the small momentum region at low temperatures when the interaction is weak, in spite of the fact that there is no Bose condensate in the two-dimensional case when T≠0. This fact lets us reduce the description of the system from one employing creation ak+ and annihilation ak operators for bosons to one based on combinations of these operators ρk and φk(ρk = S−1Σqaq+aq+k, φk· = −(i/ns) Σ(kq/k2 + l)aq+aq+k, where n is the boson density, and S is the area of the system). The description in terms of ρk and φk is simple because the hamiltonian is quadratic with respect to ρk and φk. The operators ρk and φk can also be used to express the occupation number Nk = ak+ak and current operators. We find the elementary excitation spectrum (which is identical to the Bogolyubov spectrum) and the momentum distribution of the bosons. We calculate the normal density due to thermal oscillations in the Bose gas and to interactions with impurity centers in the substrate.

Soviet Journal of Low Temperature Physics•Oct 1, 1983•1 citation

Quantum Mechanics of a Many-Boson System and the Representation of Canonical Variables

Hiroshi Ezawa

We present a method of treating the assembly of interacting bosons under Bose-Einstein condensation. Without applying the Bogoliubov approximation in which the creation and the annihilation operators of zero-momentum particles are replaced by a c number, we keep the quantum nature of these operators—thus the title, ``Quantum Mechanics.'' The method is a quantum mechanical adaptation of the theory of small oscillation. The oscillation means the fluctuation of the number of condensed particles. The interaction between particles determines the stability of this oscillation. When it is stable and its amplitude is not macroscopic, the Bogoliubov approximation is valid. In this way, our method provides a validity criterion for the Bogoliubov approximation as well as an estimation of the errors thereby committed. We have to note that the excitations associated with the fluctuation of condensed particles can never be obtained within that approximation. Our method is applied to the Huang model, the assembly of bosons interacting through a hard core plus weak attractive potential. Having found that, within the physically accessible range of the particle density, the above-mentioned oscillation is stable, we can conclude that Huang's treatment is well founded. We have discussed the mathematical background of our approximation by invoking the representation theory of canonical variables of an infinitely large system.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 1965•28 citations

Calculation of the wave functions of the ground and weakly excited states of helium II

Maksim Tomchenko

The wave functions of the ground (Ψ 0 ) and the first excited (Ψ k ) states of He II in the second-order approximation, i.e., up to the first two corrections to the corresponding solutions for a weakly nonideal Bose gas, are determined by the collective variable method, which was proposed by Bogolyubov and Zubarev and developed in the studies by Yukhnovskii and Vakarchuk. The functions Ψ 0 and Ψ k = ψ k Ψ 0 are determined as the eigenfunctions of the N -particle Schrödinger equation from a system of coupled equations for Ψ 0 , Ψ k , and the quasiparticle spectrum E ( k ) of helium II. The results consist in the following: (1) these equations are solved numerically for a higher order approximation compared with those investigated earlier (the first-order approximation), and (2) Ψ 0 and ψ k are derived from a model potential of interaction between He 4 atoms (rather than from the structure factor as earlier) in which the potential barrier is joined with the attractive potential found from experiment. The height V 0 of the potential barrier is a free parameter. Except for V 0 , the model does not have any free parameters or functions. The calculated values of the structure factor, the ground-state energy E 0 , and the quasiparticle spectrum E ( k ) of He II are in agreement with the experimental values for V 0 ≈ 100 K. The second-order correction to the logarithm of Ψ 0 significantly affects the value of E 0 and provides the asymptotics E ( k → 0) = ck , while the second-order correction to ψ k slightly affects the E ( k ). The second-order corrections to Ψ 0 and ψ k have a smaller effect on the results compared with the first-order corrections, whereby the theory is in agreement with experiment; therefore, one may assume that the truncated Ψ 0 and ψ k well describe the microstructure of He II. Thus, the series for Ψ 0 and Ψ k can be truncated in spite of the fact that the expansion parameter is not very small (∼1/2).

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 2006•3 citations
The article suggests a method for the construction of the number of atoms preserving microscopic He II theory. The suggested theory can provide the ground state wave function (WF) as an expansion in series by small parameters. In addition, errors in the definition of the WFs of the excited states turn out to be vanishingly small while the system size increases. Predictions of the proposed theory and of the Bogoliubov theory are identical if helium occupies a simply connected volume. However, there are differences in the general case. These differences are due to the fact that the operator of the occupation number of the zero momentum state does not commute with the creation and annihilation operators of phonons. This contradicts the Bogoliubov assumption that the creation and annihilation operators of atoms in the zero momentum state can be replaced by a c-number. The latter, as is known, should commute with any operator. This should lead to a difference in the results of calculation of helium flow through the tunnel transition. Therefore, the suggested theory is not equivalent to Bogoliubov theory.
Presently there are two distinct classes of microscopic theories which describe a system of many identical spinless bosons. One is the Bogoliubov theory, which places special emphasis on the occupation of the zero-momentum state and as such depends explicitly on the number of particles in this state, N0{N}_{0}N0​. The other depends on density fluctuations to describe the fluid. In this work, we derive a modified version of the Bogoliubov theory which results in a number-conserving Hamiltonian with no explicit dependence on N0{N}_{0}N0​. The ground- and first-excited-state energies evaluated through second order in 1N12\frac{1}{{N}^{\frac{1}{2}}}N21​1​ are equivalent to the results of a variational-perturbative procedure based on the method of correlated basis functions in the uniform limit.
Theory of a weakly non-ideal Bose gas in the canonical ensemble is developed without assumption of the C-number representation of the creation and annihilation operators with zero momentum. Instead of this assumption, we use the assumption on the C-number nature of the density operator N 0 = a † 0 a 0 with zero momentum. It is shown that the pole of the "density-density" Green function (DDGF), as well as the pole of the single-particle Green function (SPGF), exactly coincide with the Bogoliubov phonon-roton spectrum of excitations for both assumptions. This spectrum, as is known confirmed by many neutron and x-ray experimental measurements of the dynamic structure factor in He II, is straightly related to the DDGF. At the same time, we show that in the other case under consideration, when neither N 0 nor a † 0 and a 0 are C-numbers, a gap can exist in SPGF. This gap in SPGF excitations is straightly related to the density of particles in the "condensate". Therefore, the spectra of excitations for the DDGF and SPGF in the last case under consideration are different, in contrast to the Bogoliubov-type theory where these spectra are identical.
Creation and annihilation operators of quasi-particles are introduced into the description of a finite temperature system of degenerate bosons with the aid of a canonical transformation which generalizes the one due to Bogoliubov. A variational calculation taking into account the interaction between non-zero momentum particles shows that the quasi-particles are phonons in the long wave-length limit. The state of the system, which is approximated by the grand canonical ensemble of the quasi-particles, approaches the Hartree-Fock state when the condensate is depleted completely at the critical temperature.
We have developed a microscopic theory of superfluidity in a two-dimensional, slightly nonideal Bose gas. The theory is rooted in the fact that a number of bosons are concentrated in the small momentum region at low temperatures when the interaction is weak, in spite of the fact that there is no Bose condensate in the two-dimensional case when T≠0. This fact lets us reduce the description of the system from one employing creation ak+ and annihilation ak operators for bosons to one based on combinations of these operators ρk and φk(ρk = S−1Σqaq+aq+k, φk· = −(i/ns) Σ(kq/k2 + l)aq+aq+k, where n is the boson density, and S is the area of the system). The description in terms of ρk and φk is simple because the hamiltonian is quadratic with respect to ρk and φk. The operators ρk and φk can also be used to express the occupation number Nk = ak+ak and current operators. We find the elementary excitation spectrum (which is identical to the Bogolyubov spectrum) and the momentum distribution of the bosons. We calculate the normal density due to thermal oscillations in the Bose gas and to interactions with impurity centers in the substrate.
We present a method of treating the assembly of interacting bosons under Bose-Einstein condensation. Without applying the Bogoliubov approximation in which the creation and the annihilation operators of zero-momentum particles are replaced by a c number, we keep the quantum nature of these operators—thus the title, ``Quantum Mechanics.'' The method is a quantum mechanical adaptation of the theory of small oscillation. The oscillation means the fluctuation of the number of condensed particles. The interaction between particles determines the stability of this oscillation. When it is stable and its amplitude is not macroscopic, the Bogoliubov approximation is valid. In this way, our method provides a validity criterion for the Bogoliubov approximation as well as an estimation of the errors thereby committed. We have to note that the excitations associated with the fluctuation of condensed particles can never be obtained within that approximation. Our method is applied to the Huang model, the assembly of bosons interacting through a hard core plus weak attractive potential. Having found that, within the physically accessible range of the particle density, the above-mentioned oscillation is stable, we can conclude that Huang's treatment is well founded. We have discussed the mathematical background of our approximation by invoking the representation theory of canonical variables of an infinitely large system.
The wave functions of the ground (Ψ 0 ) and the first excited (Ψ k ) states of He II in the second-order approximation, i.e., up to the first two corrections to the corresponding solutions for a weakly nonideal Bose gas, are determined by the collective variable method, which was proposed by Bogolyubov and Zubarev and developed in the studies by Yukhnovskii and Vakarchuk. The functions Ψ 0 and Ψ k = ψ k Ψ 0 are determined as the eigenfunctions of the N -particle Schrödinger equation from a system of coupled equations for Ψ 0 , Ψ k , and the quasiparticle spectrum E ( k ) of helium II. The results consist in the following: (1) these equations are solved numerically for a higher order approximation compared with those investigated earlier (the first-order approximation), and (2) Ψ 0 and ψ k are derived from a model potential of interaction between He 4 atoms (rather than from the structure factor as earlier) in which the potential barrier is joined with the attractive potential found from experiment. The height V 0 of the potential barrier is a free parameter. Except for V 0 , the model does not have any free parameters or functions. The calculated values of the structure factor, the ground-state energy E 0 , and the quasiparticle spectrum E ( k ) of He II are in agreement with the experimental values for V 0 ≈ 100 K. The second-order correction to the logarithm of Ψ 0 significantly affects the value of E 0 and provides the asymptotics E ( k → 0) = ck , while the second-order correction to ψ k slightly affects the E ( k ). The second-order corrections to Ψ 0 and ψ k have a smaller effect on the results compared with the first-order corrections, whereby the theory is in agreement with experiment; therefore, one may assume that the truncated Ψ 0 and ψ k well describe the microstructure of He II. Thus, the series for Ψ 0 and Ψ k can be truncated in spite of the fact that the expansion parameter is not very small (∼1/2).