Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0903.4795 · Physics Letters A

Feynman-path analysis of Hardy's paradox: Measurements and the uncertainty principle

D. Sokolovski, Irene Puerto Gimenez, R. Sala Mayato

Published Mar 12, 2008• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1016/j.physleta.2008.02.079

Related papers

A New View on the Uncertainty Principle

Jan Hilgevoord, Jos Uffink

NATO ASI series. Series B : Physics•Jan 1, 1990•21 citations

Hardy's paradox and measurement-disturbance relations

Kazuo Fujikawa, C. H. Oh, Sixia Yu

We establish a quantitative relation between Hardy's paradox and the breaking of the uncertainty principle in the sense of measurement-disturbance relations in the conditional measurement of noncommuting operators. The analysis of the inconsistency of local realism with entanglement by Hardy is simplified if this breaking of measurement-disturbance relations is taken into account, and a much simplified experimental test of local realism is illustrated in the framework of Hardy's thought experiment. The essence of Hardy's model is identified as a combination of two conditional measurements, which give rise to definite eigenvalues to two noncommuting operators simultaneously in hidden-variables models. Better understanding of the intimate interplay of entanglement and measurement disturbance is crucial in the current discussions of Hardy's paradox using the idea of weak measurement, which is based on a general analysis of measurement-disturbance relations.

arXiv:1412.7609•Physical Review A•Jan 14, 2015•1 citation

A Experimental Approach to the Uncertainty Principle.

Donald R. Matthys

•Jan 1, 1975•0 citations

Generalized Measurement and Post-selection in Optical Quantum Information

Jeff S. Lundeen

Post-selection is the selection of a subset of an ensemble based on a measurement on that ensemble. In the last few years, post-selection has taken on new importance as a mechanism to induce the optical nonlinearities required for quantum logic gates. I present experiments and theory that explore post-selection in photonic systems. I then go on to describe an experimental implementation of Hardy's Paradox, which is one of the three great thought-experiments about entanglement and correlations in quantum mechanics (the others being the EPR and GHZ "paradoxes"). In the place of the electron--positron annihilation in the original proposal, I apply, for the first time, a post-selection-based absorptive photon switch that coworkers and I had previously developed. Weak measurement promises to be an important technique for characterizing post-selected quantum systems during their evolution. The technique minimizes disturbance to the system and therefore can be used in situ. In a third experiment, I attempt to resolve a recent debate: Which is more fundamental--complementarity or the uncertainty principle? Specifically, can interference be destroyed by a which-path measurement without transferring momentum to the particle? This question is difficult to investigate as any measurement of the momentum transfer causes collapse, severely disturbing the system. I circumvent this problem with the technique of weak measurement and show that which-path measurements do indeed induce a momentum transfer as required by the uncertainty principle. First, I experimentally demonstrate effective nonlinear absorption between two single photons. I show that this photon-exchange effect can be understood as a post-selection induced nonlinearity similar to the one that occurs in Hong-Ou-Mandel interference. In a fourth experiment, I use the latter theory and return to Hardy's Paradox to perform the first weak measurement of an entangled system. I post-select on the paradoxical measurement result while weakly measuring a set of observables. The results are surprising in that they no longer conflict; they now satisfy a classical-logic truth-table. I then proceed to develop theoretically a new method for performing multiparticle weak measurements that is unique because it does not require single-particle-level interactions. This theory provides new insight into the importance of the imaginary component of the weak measurement result.

•Jan 1, 2006•6 citations

The uncertainty principle and interferometric quantum optics in the macroscopic domain

Francisco Duarte

Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle as related to measurable macroscopic lengths, in quantum optics interference and diffraction configurations, is described in the context of the Dirac-Feynman principle and the Feynman path integral methodology.

•Mar 25, 2026•0 citations

Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle Revisited

Robert Prevedel, Bose-Einstein Condensate

•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations
We establish a quantitative relation between Hardy's paradox and the breaking of the uncertainty principle in the sense of measurement-disturbance relations in the conditional measurement of noncommuting operators. The analysis of the inconsistency of local realism with entanglement by Hardy is simplified if this breaking of measurement-disturbance relations is taken into account, and a much simplified experimental test of local realism is illustrated in the framework of Hardy's thought experiment. The essence of Hardy's model is identified as a combination of two conditional measurements, which give rise to definite eigenvalues to two noncommuting operators simultaneously in hidden-variables models. Better understanding of the intimate interplay of entanglement and measurement disturbance is crucial in the current discussions of Hardy's paradox using the idea of weak measurement, which is based on a general analysis of measurement-disturbance relations.
Post-selection is the selection of a subset of an ensemble based on a measurement on that ensemble. In the last few years, post-selection has taken on new importance as a mechanism to induce the optical nonlinearities required for quantum logic gates. I present experiments and theory that explore post-selection in photonic systems. I then go on to describe an experimental implementation of Hardy's Paradox, which is one of the three great thought-experiments about entanglement and correlations in quantum mechanics (the others being the EPR and GHZ "paradoxes"). In the place of the electron--positron annihilation in the original proposal, I apply, for the first time, a post-selection-based absorptive photon switch that coworkers and I had previously developed. Weak measurement promises to be an important technique for characterizing post-selected quantum systems during their evolution. The technique minimizes disturbance to the system and therefore can be used in situ. In a third experiment, I attempt to resolve a recent debate: Which is more fundamental--complementarity or the uncertainty principle? Specifically, can interference be destroyed by a which-path measurement without transferring momentum to the particle? This question is difficult to investigate as any measurement of the momentum transfer causes collapse, severely disturbing the system. I circumvent this problem with the technique of weak measurement and show that which-path measurements do indeed induce a momentum transfer as required by the uncertainty principle. First, I experimentally demonstrate effective nonlinear absorption between two single photons. I show that this photon-exchange effect can be understood as a post-selection induced nonlinearity similar to the one that occurs in Hong-Ou-Mandel interference. In a fourth experiment, I use the latter theory and return to Hardy's Paradox to perform the first weak measurement of an entangled system. I post-select on the paradoxical measurement result while weakly measuring a set of observables. The results are surprising in that they no longer conflict; they now satisfy a classical-logic truth-table. I then proceed to develop theoretically a new method for performing multiparticle weak measurements that is unique because it does not require single-particle-level interactions. This theory provides new insight into the importance of the imaginary component of the weak measurement result.