Post-selection is the selection of a subset of an ensemble based on a measurement on that ensemble. In the last few years, post-selection has taken on new importance as a mechanism to induce the optical nonlinearities required for quantum logic gates. I present experiments and theory that explore post-selection in photonic systems. I then go on to describe an experimental implementation of Hardy's Paradox, which is one of the three great thought-experiments about entanglement and correlations in quantum mechanics (the others being the EPR and GHZ "paradoxes"). In the place of the electron--positron annihilation in the original proposal, I apply, for the first time, a post-selection-based absorptive photon switch that coworkers and I had previously developed. Weak measurement promises to be an important technique for characterizing post-selected quantum systems during their evolution. The technique minimizes disturbance to the system and therefore can be used in situ. In a third experiment, I attempt to resolve a recent debate: Which is more fundamental--complementarity or the uncertainty principle? Specifically, can interference be destroyed by a which-path measurement without transferring momentum to the particle? This question is difficult to investigate as any measurement of the momentum transfer causes collapse, severely disturbing the system. I circumvent this problem with the technique of weak measurement and show that which-path measurements do indeed induce a momentum transfer as required by the uncertainty principle. First, I experimentally demonstrate effective nonlinear absorption between two single photons. I show that this photon-exchange effect can be understood as a post-selection induced nonlinearity similar to the one that occurs in Hong-Ou-Mandel interference. In a fourth experiment, I use the latter theory and return to Hardy's Paradox to perform the first weak measurement of an entangled system. I post-select on the paradoxical measurement result while weakly measuring a set of observables. The results are surprising in that they no longer conflict; they now satisfy a classical-logic truth-table. I then proceed to develop theoretically a new method for performing multiparticle weak measurements that is unique because it does not require single-particle-level interactions. This theory provides new insight into the importance of the imaginary component of the weak measurement result.
Post-selection is the selection of a subset of an ensemble based on a measurement on that ensemble. In the last few years, post-selection has taken on new importance as a mechanism to induce the optical nonlinearities required for quantum logic gates. I present experiments and theory that explore post-selection in photonic systems. I then go on to describe an experimental implementation of Hardy's Paradox, which is one of the three great thought-experiments about entanglement and correlations in quantum mechanics (the others being the EPR and GHZ "paradoxes"). In the place of the electron--positron annihilation in the original proposal, I apply, for the first time, a post-selection-based absorptive photon switch that coworkers and I had previously developed. Weak measurement promises to be an important technique for characterizing post-selected quantum systems during their evolution. The technique minimizes disturbance to the system and therefore can be used in situ. In a third experiment, I attempt to resolve a recent debate: Which is more fundamental--complementarity or the uncertainty principle? Specifically, can interference be destroyed by a which-path measurement without transferring momentum to the particle? This question is difficult to investigate as any measurement of the momentum transfer causes collapse, severely disturbing the system. I circumvent this problem with the technique of weak measurement and show that which-path measurements do indeed induce a momentum transfer as required by the uncertainty principle. First, I experimentally demonstrate effective nonlinear absorption between two single photons. I show that this photon-exchange effect can be understood as a post-selection induced nonlinearity similar to the one that occurs in Hong-Ou-Mandel interference. In a fourth experiment, I use the latter theory and return to Hardy's Paradox to perform the first weak measurement of an entangled system. I post-select on the paradoxical measurement result while weakly measuring a set of observables. The results are surprising in that they no longer conflict; they now satisfy a classical-logic truth-table. I then proceed to develop theoretically a new method for performing multiparticle weak measurements that is unique because it does not require single-particle-level interactions. This theory provides new insight into the importance of the imaginary component of the weak measurement result.
This thesis presents the results of a series of four photonic experiments on the topic of quantum measurement. The first two experiments relate to quantum metrology, and the use of quantum states to increase the precision of measurements beyond what is possible with classical systems; first to detect and characterize decoherence, and then in the context of quantum imaging. The third experiment studies a fundamental question in quantum mechanics: "How much must a quantum system be disturbed by a measurement?". We use weak measurement to confirm a recent theoretical result, showing that if a particle's state is already sufficiently uncertain we can perform a measurement with very little disturbance -- contrary to common explanations of Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. The fourth experiment falls in the category of quantum computation. In quantum mechanics having multiple copies of an identical system allows us to extract more information than we can extract from a single copy (since quantum mechanics allows each system to be measured only once before collapsing). We present and experimentally implement a quantum algorithm to compress all of the "extractable information" present in an ensemble of identical copies of quantum bits into exponentially fewer quantum bits. The research presented here samples from a variety of topics in quantum information, showing in several contexts how fascinating quantum effects can be exploited to gain a "quantum enhancement".To enable these experiments two sources of entangled photons were built, and "hybrid" quantum systems (encoding information in multiple degrees of freedom of a photon) were used to implement quantum circuits. This thesis will present the details of one of these sources (a novel and practical source of entangled N00N states), which was used in a four-photon quantum metrology experiment. The other, more standard, source of polarization-entangled photon pairs will only briefly be reviewed to leave room for the discussion of hybrid quantum logic.
The ability to post-select the outcomes of an experiment is a useful theoretical concept and experimental tool. In the context of weak measurements, post-selection can lead to surprising results such as complex weak values outside the range of eigenvalues. Usually post-selection is realized by a projective measurement, which is hard to implement in ensemble systems such as NMR. We demonstrate the first experiment of a weak measurement with post-selection on an NMR quantum information processor. Our setup is used for measuring complex weak values and weak values outside the range of eigenvalues. The scheme for overcoming the problem of post-selection in an ensemble quantum computer is general and can be applied to any circuit-based implementation. This experiment paves the way for studying and exploiting post-selection and weak measurements in systems where projective measurements are hard to realize experimentally.
Weak value amplification (WVA) is a measurement technique in which the effect of a pre- and post-selected system on a weakly interacting probe is magnified. In this thesis, I present the first experimental observation of WVA of a single photon. We observed that a signal photon - sent through a polarization interferometer and post-selected by photodetection in the almost-dark port - can act like eight photons. The effect of this single photon is measured as a nonlinear phase shift on a separate laser beam. The interaction between the two is mediated by a sample of laser- cooled 85Rb atoms. Electromagnetically induced transparency (EIT) is used to enhance the nonlinearity and overcome resonant absorption. I believe this work to be the first demonstration of WVA where a deterministic interaction is used to entangle two distinct optical systems. In WVA, the amplification is contingent on discarding a large portion of the original data set. While amplification increases measurement sensitivity, discarding data worsens it. Questioning whether these competing effects conspire to improve or diminish measurement accuracy has resulted recently in controversy. I address this question by calculating the maximum amount of information achievable with the WVA technique. By comparing this information to that achievable by the standard technique, where no post-selection is employed, I show that the WVA technique can be advantageous under a certain class of noise models. Finally, I propose a way to optimally apply the WVA technique.
Weak measurement is a potentially powerful tool for studying post-selected quantum systems. The original approach to weak measurement requires a different von Neumann interaction between the quantum system and measurement pointer for weak values of every different observable. When studying weak values of properties of more than one particle, which is necessary for studying entanglement, these interactions can range from difficult to impossible to implement experimentally. For example, the measurement of properties on a pair of optical photons requires a strong Kerr-like nonlinearity at the two-photon level. In a recent work, we described a new method for extracting weak values of operators that can be expressed as products of two local, single-particle operators by studying the correlations in experimentally feasible local, single-particle measurements. In the present work, that theoretical approach is generalized so that weak values of products of N local, single-particle operators can be extracted from the correlations in N single-particle measurements.
By analysing the concept of contextuality (Bell–Kochen–Specker) in terms of pre- and post-selection, it is possible to assign definite values to observables in a new and surprising way. Physical reasons are presented for restrictions on these assignments. When measurements are performed which do not disturb the pre- and post-selection (i.e. weak measurements), then novel experimental aspects of contextuality can be demonstrated. We also prove that every PPS-paradox with definite predictions directly implies 'quantum contextuality' which is introduced as the analogue of contextuality at the level of quantum mechanics rather than at the level of hidden variable theories. Finally, we argue that certain results of these measurements (e.g. eccentric weak values outside the eigenvalue spectrum) cannot be explained by a 'classical-like' hidden variable theory.
Entanglement and nonlocality are studied in the framework of pre-/postselected ensembles with the aid of weak measurements and the two-state-vector formalism. In addition to the EPR–Bohm experiment, we revisit the Hardy and Cheshire Cat experiments, whose entangled pre- or postselected states give rise to curious phenomena. We then turn to even more peculiar phenomenon suggesting “emerging correlations” between independent preand postselected ensembles of particles. This can be viewed as a quantum violation of the classical “pigeonhole principle.” Introduction It is seldom acknowledged that seven years before the celebrated Bell paper [1], Bohm and Aharonov [2] published an analysis of the EPR paradox [3]. They suggested an experimental setup, based on Compton scattering, for testing nonlocal correlations between the polarizations of two annihilation photons. In 1964, Bell proposed his general inequality, thereby excluding local realism. During the same time, Aharonov et al. constructed the foundations of a time-symmetric formalism of quantum mechanics [4]. While Bell's proof utilizes entanglement to demonstrate nonlocal correlations,wewill describe inwhat follows the emergence of nonlocal correlations between product states. For this purpose, however, we shall invoke weak measurements of pre- and postselected ensembles. In classical mechanics, initial conditions of position and velocity for every particle fully determine the time evolution of the system. Therefore, trying to impose an additional final condition would lead either to redundancy or to inconsistency with the initial conditions. This is radically different in quantum mechanics. Because of the uncertainty principle, an initial state vector does not fully determine, in general, the outcome of a future measurement. However, adding a final (backward-evolving) state vector results in a more complete description of the quantum system in between these two boundary conditions, which has a bearing on the determination of measurement outcomes. The basis for this time-symmetric formulation of quantum mechanics was laid down by Aharonov, Bergman, and Lebowitz (ABL), who derived a symmetric probability rule concerning measurements performed on systems, while taking into account the final state of the system, in addition to the usual initial state [4].