Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0611071 · Physical Review A

Breakdown of the few-level approximation in collective systems

Martin Kiffner, Jörg Evers, Christoph H. Keitel

Published Jul 10, 2007• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The validity of the few-level approximation in dipole-dipole interacting collective systems is discussed. As an example system, we study the archetype case of two dipole-dipole interacting atoms, each modeled by two complete sets of angular momentum multiplets. We establish the breakdown of the few-level approximation by first proving the intuitive result that the dipole-dipole induced energy shifts between collective two-atom states depend on the length of the vector connecting the atoms, but not on its orientation, if complete and degenerate multiplets are considered. A careful analysis of our findings reveals that the simplification of the atomic level scheme by artificially omitting Zeeman sublevels in a few-level approximation generally leads to incorrect predictions. We find that this breakdown can be traced back to the dipole-dipole coupling of transitions with orthogonal dipole moments. Our interpretation enables us to identify special geometries in which partial few-level approximations to two- or three-level systems are valid.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.76.013807

Related papers

Breakdown of the few-level approximation in dipole-dipole interacting systems

Martin Kiffner, Jörg Evers, Christoph H. Keitel

The validity of the few-level approximation is investigated in a system of two dipole-dipole interacting four-level atoms. Each atom is modelled by two complete sets of angular momentum multiplets. We provide two independent arguments demonstrating that the few-level approximation in general leads to incorrect predictions if it is applied to the Zeeman sublevels of the atomic level scheme. First, we show that the artificial omission of sublevels generally leads to incorrect eigenenergies of the system. The second counterexample involves an external laser field and illustrates that the relevant states in each atom are not only determined by the laser field polarization, but also by the orientation of the atomic separation vector. As the physical origin of this outcome, we identify the dipole-dipole interaction between orthogonal dipole transitions of different atoms. Our interpretation enables us to identify conditions on the atomic level structure as well as special geometries in which (partial) few-level approximations are valid.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Jun 7, 2007•0 citations

Level-degeneracy effects in superradiance theory

A. Crubellier

Up to now, the problem of the influence of level degeneracy on superradiance has been neglected. We describe here a first approach to this problem, in the frame of "small system" quantum model, generalized to the case of a collection of atoms with two degenerate levels of angular momenta $j$ and ${j}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ connected by an electric or magnetic dipole transition. The differences between this case and the well-known case of two (nondegenerate) level atoms are of two types. The first type is due to the competition between different transitions sharing a common state: superradiant emission on a transition inhibits or initiates superradiance on transitions with smaller transition probability, depending upon which state, upper or lower, is the common one. This effect does not come from the equality of the different wavelengths and would also appear with the same states even if the degeneracy were removed; its qualitative influence on the features of the superradiant pulse can be easily estimated. The second type of differences is quite specific to level degeneracy and consists in interferences between the transitions of the collective system having the same frequency and polarization. In analogy with the description of collections of two-level atoms as spin-\textonehalf{} systems, a group-theoretical description of the considered collection of atoms is found suitable; the problem of the determination of a basis of collective states and its group-theoretical implications are discussed; in particular, it is found that the isotropic character of spontaneous emission allows us to use tensorial formalism and simplifies the formal description of the problem.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1977•22 citations

Collective coupling of driven multilevel atoms and its effect on four-wave mixing

P. Yanes-Thomas, R. Gutiérrez-Jáuregui, Pablo Barberis-Blostein +3 more

Microscopic models based on multilevel atoms are central to optimizing nonlinear optical responses and the coherent control of light. These models are traditionally based on single-atom effects that are parametrically extrapolated to include collective effects, such as an enhanced response or propagation within atomic media. In this work, we present a systematic analysis of the cooperative effects arising in driven systems composed of multilevel atoms coupled via a common electromagnetic environment. The analysis is based on an interplay between dressed states induced by the driving field and photon exchanges, and collective decay channels. This theory is applied to the case of four-wave mixing induced by a pair of lasers acting on an atomic pair with internal levels in the diamond configuration. The effect of interatomic correlations and collective decay over the photons created in this nonlinear process is then explored. We identify three regions of operation: (i) laser-dominated, (ii) intermediate, and (iii) dipole-dominated. The dependence of single- and two-photon correlations is studied in detail for each region by varying atomic orientations and laser parameters consistent with current experiments involving atomic gases. Photonic correlation functions are shown to exhibit a transition from a Lorentz-like dependence on the two-photon detuning—with general features that can be obtained in an isolated atom scheme—to a two-peaked distribution when the dipole-dipole interactions become relevant. For weak Rabi frequencies whose value is smaller than the highest collective decay rate, the atoms are trapped inside their ground state as they approach each other. It is found that the anisotropy of the dipole-dipole interaction and its wave nature are essential to understand the behavior of the photon correlations. Signatures of these processes are identified for existing experimental realizations. The intuition obtained from this connection helps to uncover relevant parameters that could be exploited for quantum control protocols based on dispersive and dissipative cooperative effects in multilevel systems.

arXiv:2404.03615•Physical Review Research•Jan 8, 2025•3 citations

Breakdown of gauge invariance in ultrastrong-coupling cavity QED

Daniele De Bernardis, Philipp Pilar, Tuomas Jaako +2 more

We revisit the derivation of Rabi- and Dicke-type models, which are commonly used for the study of quantum light-matter interactions in cavity and circuit QED. We demonstrate that the validity of the two-level approximation, which is an essential step in this derivation, depends explicitly on the choice of gauge once the system enters the ultrastrong-coupling regime. In particular, while in the electric dipole gauge the two-level approximation can be performed as long as the Rabi frequency remains much smaller than the energies of all higher-lying levels, it can dramatically fail in the Coulomb gauge, even for systems with an extremely anharmonic spectrum. We extensively investigate this phenomenon both in the single-dipole (Rabi) and multidipole (Dicke) case, and consider the specific examples of dipoles confined by double-well and square-well potentials, and of circuit QED systems with flux qubits coupled to an LC resonator.

arXiv:1805.05339•Physical Review A•Nov 13, 2018•182 citations

Off-resonant transitions in the collective dynamics of multi-level atomic ensembles

Y. Miroshnychenko, Klaus Mølmer

We study the contributions of off-resonant transitions to the dynamics of a system of N multi-level atoms sharing one excitation and interacting with the quantized vector electromagnetic field. The rotating wave approximation significantly simplifies the derivation of the equations of motion describing the collective atomic dynamics, but it leads to an incorrect expression for the dispersive part of the atom–atom interaction terms. For the case of two-level atoms and a scalar electromagnetic field, it turns out that the atom–atom interaction can be recovered correctly if integrals over the photon mode frequencies are extended to incorporate negative values. We explicitly derive the atom–atom interaction for multi-level atoms, coupled to the full vector electromagnetic field, and we recover also in this general case the validity of the results obtained by the extension to negative frequencies of the formulas derived with the rotating wave approximation.

arXiv:1302.3036•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Nov 7, 2013•4 citations

Polarization effects in radiation interaction with multilevel quantum systems

Alexander A. Apolonski, K. A. Nasyrov, Anatolii M. Shalagin

In recent years interest has significantly quickened in investigation of nonlinear optical and spectroscopic phenomena in such unique objects as Rydberg atoms (the atoms in the energy states near the ionization limit) and van der Waals complexes (dimers). These objects are characterized, in particular, by that their energy states are strongly degenerate due to a large value of angular (rotational) momentum. Here, the problem arises of adequate theoretical description of experimental results, especially when polarization peculiarities of nonlinear radiation processes are considered. The problem is caused by the existence of a huge number of quantum magnetic sublevels of energy states, which are, in the general case, coherently coupled to each other and take part in the radiation processes. Figure 1 gives a vivid presentation of the problem arising even in such a seemingly simple case when one need describe the radiation transitions caused by a strong monochromatic field between two energy levels with large values of the angular momentum J. If the field polarization is arbitrary, the whole set of the magnetic sublevels turn out to be coupled by radiative transitions. Formally, the problem becomes essentially multilevel. In this case not only the hope fades of solving it analytically using the traditional quantum-mechanical approach, but the problems of numerical solution grow abruptly with increasing quantum number J as well. On the other hand, as is often the case, every cloud has a silver lining. With large J we approach the situation when the rotational motion of particles can be described classically. It turns out that the transition from the quantum description of orientation states of the angular momentum to the classical one simplifies the problem radically: it reduces to the problem of radiation processes in the simplest model of nondegenerate states. In this case the rotational motion manifests itself in a dependence of the density matrix elements on orientation angles of the angular momentum as on a parameter.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Oct 21, 1998•0 citations
The validity of the few-level approximation in dipole-dipole interacting collective systems is discussed. As an example system, we study the archetype case of two dipole-dipole interacting atoms, each modeled by two complete sets of angular momentum multiplets. We establish the breakdown of the few-level approximation by first proving the intuitive result that the dipole-dipole induced energy shifts between collective two-atom states depend on the length of the vector connecting the atoms, but not on its orientation, if complete and degenerate multiplets are considered. A careful analysis of our findings reveals that the simplification of the atomic level scheme by artificially omitting Zeeman sublevels in a few-level approximation generally leads to incorrect predictions. We find that this breakdown can be traced back to the dipole-dipole coupling of transitions with orthogonal dipole moments. Our interpretation enables us to identify special geometries in which partial few-level approximations to two- or three-level systems are valid.
The validity of the few-level approximation is investigated in a system of two dipole-dipole interacting four-level atoms. Each atom is modelled by two complete sets of angular momentum multiplets. We provide two independent arguments demonstrating that the few-level approximation in general leads to incorrect predictions if it is applied to the Zeeman sublevels of the atomic level scheme. First, we show that the artificial omission of sublevels generally leads to incorrect eigenenergies of the system. The second counterexample involves an external laser field and illustrates that the relevant states in each atom are not only determined by the laser field polarization, but also by the orientation of the atomic separation vector. As the physical origin of this outcome, we identify the dipole-dipole interaction between orthogonal dipole transitions of different atoms. Our interpretation enables us to identify conditions on the atomic level structure as well as special geometries in which (partial) few-level approximations are valid.
Up to now, the problem of the influence of level degeneracy on superradiance has been neglected. We describe here a first approach to this problem, in the frame of "small system" quantum model, generalized to the case of a collection of atoms with two degenerate levels of angular momenta jjj and ${j}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ connected by an electric or magnetic dipole transition. The differences between this case and the well-known case of two (nondegenerate) level atoms are of two types. The first type is due to the competition between different transitions sharing a common state: superradiant emission on a transition inhibits or initiates superradiance on transitions with smaller transition probability, depending upon which state, upper or lower, is the common one. This effect does not come from the equality of the different wavelengths and would also appear with the same states even if the degeneracy were removed; its qualitative influence on the features of the superradiant pulse can be easily estimated. The second type of differences is quite specific to level degeneracy and consists in interferences between the transitions of the collective system having the same frequency and polarization. In analogy with the description of collections of two-level atoms as spin-\textonehalf{} systems, a group-theoretical description of the considered collection of atoms is found suitable; the problem of the determination of a basis of collective states and its group-theoretical implications are discussed; in particular, it is found that the isotropic character of spontaneous emission allows us to use tensorial formalism and simplifies the formal description of the problem.
Microscopic models based on multilevel atoms are central to optimizing nonlinear optical responses and the coherent control of light. These models are traditionally based on single-atom effects that are parametrically extrapolated to include collective effects, such as an enhanced response or propagation within atomic media. In this work, we present a systematic analysis of the cooperative effects arising in driven systems composed of multilevel atoms coupled via a common electromagnetic environment. The analysis is based on an interplay between dressed states induced by the driving field and photon exchanges, and collective decay channels. This theory is applied to the case of four-wave mixing induced by a pair of lasers acting on an atomic pair with internal levels in the diamond configuration. The effect of interatomic correlations and collective decay over the photons created in this nonlinear process is then explored. We identify three regions of operation: (i) laser-dominated, (ii) intermediate, and (iii) dipole-dominated. The dependence of single- and two-photon correlations is studied in detail for each region by varying atomic orientations and laser parameters consistent with current experiments involving atomic gases. Photonic correlation functions are shown to exhibit a transition from a Lorentz-like dependence on the two-photon detuning—with general features that can be obtained in an isolated atom scheme—to a two-peaked distribution when the dipole-dipole interactions become relevant. For weak Rabi frequencies whose value is smaller than the highest collective decay rate, the atoms are trapped inside their ground state as they approach each other. It is found that the anisotropy of the dipole-dipole interaction and its wave nature are essential to understand the behavior of the photon correlations. Signatures of these processes are identified for existing experimental realizations. The intuition obtained from this connection helps to uncover relevant parameters that could be exploited for quantum control protocols based on dispersive and dissipative cooperative effects in multilevel systems.
We revisit the derivation of Rabi- and Dicke-type models, which are commonly used for the study of quantum light-matter interactions in cavity and circuit QED. We demonstrate that the validity of the two-level approximation, which is an essential step in this derivation, depends explicitly on the choice of gauge once the system enters the ultrastrong-coupling regime. In particular, while in the electric dipole gauge the two-level approximation can be performed as long as the Rabi frequency remains much smaller than the energies of all higher-lying levels, it can dramatically fail in the Coulomb gauge, even for systems with an extremely anharmonic spectrum. We extensively investigate this phenomenon both in the single-dipole (Rabi) and multidipole (Dicke) case, and consider the specific examples of dipoles confined by double-well and square-well potentials, and of circuit QED systems with flux qubits coupled to an LC resonator.
We study the contributions of off-resonant transitions to the dynamics of a system of N multi-level atoms sharing one excitation and interacting with the quantized vector electromagnetic field. The rotating wave approximation significantly simplifies the derivation of the equations of motion describing the collective atomic dynamics, but it leads to an incorrect expression for the dispersive part of the atom–atom interaction terms. For the case of two-level atoms and a scalar electromagnetic field, it turns out that the atom–atom interaction can be recovered correctly if integrals over the photon mode frequencies are extended to incorporate negative values. We explicitly derive the atom–atom interaction for multi-level atoms, coupled to the full vector electromagnetic field, and we recover also in this general case the validity of the results obtained by the extension to negative frequencies of the formulas derived with the rotating wave approximation.
In recent years interest has significantly quickened in investigation of nonlinear optical and spectroscopic phenomena in such unique objects as Rydberg atoms (the atoms in the energy states near the ionization limit) and van der Waals complexes (dimers). These objects are characterized, in particular, by that their energy states are strongly degenerate due to a large value of angular (rotational) momentum. Here, the problem arises of adequate theoretical description of experimental results, especially when polarization peculiarities of nonlinear radiation processes are considered. The problem is caused by the existence of a huge number of quantum magnetic sublevels of energy states, which are, in the general case, coherently coupled to each other and take part in the radiation processes. Figure 1 gives a vivid presentation of the problem arising even in such a seemingly simple case when one need describe the radiation transitions caused by a strong monochromatic field between two energy levels with large values of the angular momentum J. If the field polarization is arbitrary, the whole set of the magnetic sublevels turn out to be coupled by radiative transitions. Formally, the problem becomes essentially multilevel. In this case not only the hope fades of solving it analytically using the traditional quantum-mechanical approach, but the problems of numerical solution grow abruptly with increasing quantum number J as well. On the other hand, as is often the case, every cloud has a silver lining. With large J we approach the situation when the rotational motion of particles can be described classically. It turns out that the transition from the quantum description of orientation states of the angular momentum to the classical one simplifies the problem radically: it reduces to the problem of radiation processes in the simplest model of nondegenerate states. In this case the rotational motion manifests itself in a dependence of the density matrix elements on orientation angles of the angular momentum as on a parameter.