Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0609157 · Physical Review A

Information-theoretic significance of the Wigner distribution

B. Roy Frieden, Bernard H. Soffer

Published Nov 16, 2006• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A coarse-grained Wigner distribution ${p}_{W}(x,\ensuremath{\mu})$ obeying positivity derives out of information-theoretic considerations. Let $p(x,\ensuremath{\mu})$ be the unknown joint probability density function (PDF) on position and momentum fluctuations $x$, $\ensuremath{\mu}$ for a particle in a pure state $\ensuremath{\psi}(x)$. Suppose that the phase part $\ensuremath{\Psi}(x,z)$ of its Fourier transform ${T}_{F}[p(x,\ensuremath{\mu})]\ensuremath{\equiv}\ensuremath{\mid}G(x,z)\ensuremath{\mid}\mathrm{exp}[i\ensuremath{\Psi}(x,z)]$ is constructed as a hologram. (Such a hologram is often used in heterodyne interferometry.) Consider a particle randomly illuminating this phase hologram. Let its two position coordinates be measured. Require that the measurements contain an extreme amount of Fisher information about true position, through variation of the phase function $\ensuremath{\Psi}(x,z)$. The extremum solution gives an output PDF $p(x,\ensuremath{\mu})$ that is the convolution of the Wigner ${p}_{W}(x,\ensuremath{\mu})$ with an instrument function defining uncertainty in either position $x$ or momentum $\ensuremath{\mu}$. The convolution arises naturally out of the approach, and is one dimensional, in comparison with the ad hoc two-dimensional convolutions usually proposed for coarse graining purposes. The output obeys positivity, as required of a PDF, if the one-dimensional instrument function is sufficiently wide. The result holds for a large class of systems: those whose amplitudes $\ensuremath{\psi}(x)$ are the same at their boundaries [examples: states $\ensuremath{\psi}(x)$ with positive parity; with periodic boundary conditions; free particle trapped in a box].

DOI
10.1103/physreva.74.052108

Related papers

The Wigner representation of quantum mechanics

Valerian I. Tatarskii

Correct use of the Wigner representation of quantum mechanics, which is realized with joint distributions of quasiprobabilities in phase space, requires the use of certain specific rules and attention to a number of properties which distinguish the quasiprobability from a true probability. This paper is mainly concerned with these problems. In the Wigner representation the quantum Liouville equation appears instead of the Schroedinger equation. The solution may have no physical meaning unless it is subjected to a necessary and sufficient condition which selects an allowed class of distributions which describe quantum-mechanical pure states. This condition contains Planck's constant and imposes, besides the uncertainty relations, severe restrictions on the possible form of the Wigner function. When this condition is satisfied, one can reconstruct the wave function from the Wigner function. In the case of an oscillator, the quantization condition for the energies of the stationary states does not follow from the Liouville equation, but from this supplementary condition. Unlike the true probability density, any Wigner function (except Gaussian ones) of a pure state takes on negative values. Another important peculiarity is that the quasiprobability is not concentrated on certain hypersurfaces, but is smeared out over the entire phase space. These and other features considered in this paper should be kept in mind when using the Wigner representation in quantum-mechanical problems.

Soviet Physics Uspekhi•Apr 30, 1983•483 citations

Positive phase space distributions and uncertainty relations

J.G. Krüger

In contrast to a widespread belief, Wigner's theorem allows the construction of true joint probabilities in phase space for distributions describing the object system as well as for distributions depending on the measurement apparatus. The fundamental role of Heisenberg's uncertainty relations in Schroedinger form (including correlations) is pointed out for these two possible interpretations of joint probability distributions. Hence, in order that a multivariate normal probability distribution in phase space may correspond to a Wigner distribution of a pure or a mixed state, it is necessary and sufficient that Heisenberg's uncertainty relation in Schroedinger form should be satisfied.

•Jan 1, 1993•0 citations

Probabilistic aspects of the Wigner function

Constantin V. Usenko

The Wigner function of quantum systems is an effective instrument for constructing an approximate classical description of the systems for which the classical approximation is possible. In recent years, the Wigner function formalism has been applied as well to seek indications of specific quantum properties of quantum systems leading to the impossibility of constructing the classical approximation. Used most of all as such an indication is the existence of negative values in the Wigner function for specific states of the quantum system being studied. The existence of such values itself prejudices the probabilistic interpretation of the Wigner function, though for an arbitrary observable depending jointly on the coordinate and the momentum of the quantum system just the Wigner function provides an effective instrument for calculating the average value and the other statistical characteristics. In this paper, a probabilistic interpretation of the Wigner function based on coordinating a theoretical probabilistic definition of the probability density, with restrictions to a physically small domain of phase space due to the uncertainty principle, is proposed.

arXiv:quant-ph/0406238•Optics and Spectroscopy•Sep 1, 2005•3 citations

On the Wigner transforms of some simple systems and their semiclassical interpretation

M. Casas, H. Krivine, Joan Martorell

In quantum mechanics it is not possible to define a probability density for finding a particle at position r with momentum p. Nevertheless there is a function introduced by Wigner, which retains several significant features of the classical probability distribution. Using simple one-dimensional models the authors try to understand the very intricate structure of this function.

European Journal of Physics•May 1, 1991•9 citations

Weyl and Wigner functions in an extended phase-space formalism

Spiros Chountasis, Apostol Vourdas

The Wigner function $W(x,p)$ is related to the Weyl function $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{W}(X,P)$ through a two-dimensional Fourier transform. Several properties for these functions are proved which lead naturally to an extended phase space $x\ensuremath{-}p\ensuremath{-}X\ensuremath{-}P.$ Uncertainty relations for $\ensuremath{\delta}x\ensuremath{\delta}P$ and for $\ensuremath{\delta}p\ensuremath{\delta}X$ are studied. They reduce to the usual uncertainty relation in the special case of pure states, but are different for mixed states. Thermal density matrices obey these uncertainty relations as equalities.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1998•37 citations

de Broglie’s wave hypothesis from Fisher information - eScholarship

B. Roy Frieden, Bernard H. Soffer

Seeking the unknown dynamics obeyed by a particle gives rise to the de Broglie wave representation, without the need for physical assumptions specific to quantum mechanics. The only required physical assumption is conservation of momentum μ. The particle, of mass m, moves through free space from an unknown source-plane position a to an unknown coordinate x in an aperture plane of unknown probability density pX(x), and then to an output plane of observed position y=a+z. There is no prior knowledge of the probability laws p(a,M),p(a) or p(M), with M the particle momentum at the source. It is desired to (i)optimally estimate a, in the sense of a maximum likelihood (ML) estimate. The estimate is further optimized, by minimizing its error through (ii) maximizing the Fisher information about a that is received at y. Forming the ML estimate requires (iii) estimation of the likelihood law pZ(z), which (iv) must obey positivity. The relation pZ(z)=|u(z)|*2≥0 satisfies this. The same u(z) conveniently defines the Fisher channel capacity, a concept central to the principle of Extreme physical information (EPI). Its output u(z) achieves aims (i)–(iv). The output is parametrized by a free parameter K. For a choice K=0, the result is u(z)=δ(z), indicating classical motion. Or, for a finite, empirical choice K=h¯(Planck’s constant), u(z) obeys the familiar de Broglie representation as the Fourier transform of the particle’s probability amplitude function P(μ) on momentum μ. For a definite momentum μ, u(z) becomes a sinusoid of wavelength λ= h¯/μ, the de Broglie result.

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations
A coarse-grained Wigner distribution pW(x,\ensuremathμ){p}_{W}(x,\ensuremath{\mu})pW​(x,\ensuremathμ) obeying positivity derives out of information-theoretic considerations. Let p(x,\ensuremathμ)p(x,\ensuremath{\mu})p(x,\ensuremathμ) be the unknown joint probability density function (PDF) on position and momentum fluctuations xxx, \ensuremathμ\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremathμ for a particle in a pure state \ensuremathψ(x)\ensuremath{\psi}(x)\ensuremathψ(x). Suppose that the phase part \ensuremathΨ(x,z)\ensuremath{\Psi}(x,z)\ensuremathΨ(x,z) of its Fourier transform TF[p(x,\ensuremathμ)]\ensuremath≡\ensuremath∣G(x,z)\ensuremath∣exp[i\ensuremathΨ(x,z)]{T}_{F}[p(x,\ensuremath{\mu})]\ensuremath{\equiv}\ensuremath{\mid}G(x,z)\ensuremath{\mid}\mathrm{exp}[i\ensuremath{\Psi}(x,z)]TF​[p(x,\ensuremathμ)]\ensuremath≡\ensuremath∣G(x,z)\ensuremath∣exp[i\ensuremathΨ(x,z)] is constructed as a hologram. (Such a hologram is often used in heterodyne interferometry.) Consider a particle randomly illuminating this phase hologram. Let its two position coordinates be measured. Require that the measurements contain an extreme amount of Fisher information about true position, through variation of the phase function \ensuremathΨ(x,z)\ensuremath{\Psi}(x,z)\ensuremathΨ(x,z). The extremum solution gives an output PDF p(x,\ensuremathμ)p(x,\ensuremath{\mu})p(x,\ensuremathμ) that is the convolution of the Wigner pW(x,\ensuremathμ){p}_{W}(x,\ensuremath{\mu})pW​(x,\ensuremathμ) with an instrument function defining uncertainty in either position xxx or momentum \ensuremathμ\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremathμ. The convolution arises naturally out of the approach, and is one dimensional, in comparison with the ad hoc two-dimensional convolutions usually proposed for coarse graining purposes. The output obeys positivity, as required of a PDF, if the one-dimensional instrument function is sufficiently wide. The result holds for a large class of systems: those whose amplitudes \ensuremathψ(x)\ensuremath{\psi}(x)\ensuremathψ(x) are the same at their boundaries [examples: states \ensuremathψ(x)\ensuremath{\psi}(x)\ensuremathψ(x) with positive parity; with periodic boundary conditions; free particle trapped in a box].
Correct use of the Wigner representation of quantum mechanics, which is realized with joint distributions of quasiprobabilities in phase space, requires the use of certain specific rules and attention to a number of properties which distinguish the quasiprobability from a true probability. This paper is mainly concerned with these problems. In the Wigner representation the quantum Liouville equation appears instead of the Schroedinger equation. The solution may have no physical meaning unless it is subjected to a necessary and sufficient condition which selects an allowed class of distributions which describe quantum-mechanical pure states. This condition contains Planck's constant and imposes, besides the uncertainty relations, severe restrictions on the possible form of the Wigner function. When this condition is satisfied, one can reconstruct the wave function from the Wigner function. In the case of an oscillator, the quantization condition for the energies of the stationary states does not follow from the Liouville equation, but from this supplementary condition. Unlike the true probability density, any Wigner function (except Gaussian ones) of a pure state takes on negative values. Another important peculiarity is that the quasiprobability is not concentrated on certain hypersurfaces, but is smeared out over the entire phase space. These and other features considered in this paper should be kept in mind when using the Wigner representation in quantum-mechanical problems.
In contrast to a widespread belief, Wigner's theorem allows the construction of true joint probabilities in phase space for distributions describing the object system as well as for distributions depending on the measurement apparatus. The fundamental role of Heisenberg's uncertainty relations in Schroedinger form (including correlations) is pointed out for these two possible interpretations of joint probability distributions. Hence, in order that a multivariate normal probability distribution in phase space may correspond to a Wigner distribution of a pure or a mixed state, it is necessary and sufficient that Heisenberg's uncertainty relation in Schroedinger form should be satisfied.
The Wigner function of quantum systems is an effective instrument for constructing an approximate classical description of the systems for which the classical approximation is possible. In recent years, the Wigner function formalism has been applied as well to seek indications of specific quantum properties of quantum systems leading to the impossibility of constructing the classical approximation. Used most of all as such an indication is the existence of negative values in the Wigner function for specific states of the quantum system being studied. The existence of such values itself prejudices the probabilistic interpretation of the Wigner function, though for an arbitrary observable depending jointly on the coordinate and the momentum of the quantum system just the Wigner function provides an effective instrument for calculating the average value and the other statistical characteristics. In this paper, a probabilistic interpretation of the Wigner function based on coordinating a theoretical probabilistic definition of the probability density, with restrictions to a physically small domain of phase space due to the uncertainty principle, is proposed.
The Wigner function W(x,p)W(x,p)W(x,p) is related to the Weyl function $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{W}(X,P)$ through a two-dimensional Fourier transform. Several properties for these functions are proved which lead naturally to an extended phase space $x\ensuremath{-}p\ensuremath{-}X\ensuremath{-}P.$ Uncertainty relations for $\ensuremath{\delta}x\ensuremath{\delta}P$ and for $\ensuremath{\delta}p\ensuremath{\delta}X$ are studied. They reduce to the usual uncertainty relation in the special case of pure states, but are different for mixed states. Thermal density matrices obey these uncertainty relations as equalities.
Seeking the unknown dynamics obeyed by a particle gives rise to the de Broglie wave representation, without the need for physical assumptions specific to quantum mechanics. The only required physical assumption is conservation of momentum μ. The particle, of mass m, moves through free space from an unknown source-plane position a to an unknown coordinate x in an aperture plane of unknown probability density pX(x), and then to an output plane of observed position y=a+z. There is no prior knowledge of the probability laws p(a,M),p(a) or p(M), with M the particle momentum at the source. It is desired to (i)optimally estimate a, in the sense of a maximum likelihood (ML) estimate. The estimate is further optimized, by minimizing its error through (ii) maximizing the Fisher information about a that is received at y. Forming the ML estimate requires (iii) estimation of the likelihood law pZ(z), which (iv) must obey positivity. The relation pZ(z)=|u(z)|*2≥0 satisfies this. The same u(z) conveniently defines the Fisher channel capacity, a concept central to the principle of Extreme physical information (EPI). Its output u(z) achieves aims (i)–(iv). The output is parametrized by a free parameter K. For a choice K=0, the result is u(z)=δ(z), indicating classical motion. Or, for a finite, empirical choice K=h¯(Planck’s constant), u(z) obeys the familiar de Broglie representation as the Fourier transform of the particle’s probability amplitude function P(μ) on momentum μ. For a definite momentum μ, u(z) becomes a sinusoid of wavelength λ= h¯/μ, the de Broglie result.