Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0507175

Reply to "Comment on 'Measuring a Photonic Qubit without Destroying It'"

Geoff J. Pryde, Jeremy L. O’Brien, Andrew G. White, Stephen D. Bartlett, Timothy C. Ralph

Published Jul 19, 2005• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In our Letter we proposed a scheme for nondeterministic quantum nondemolition (QND) measurement of the polarization of a single photon--a photonic qubit--using linear optics and photodetection. The scheme works with nonunit probability, but success is heralded by the detection of a single photon in the meter output. We provided an experimental demonstration of this scheme and introduced three universally applicable fidelity measures--the measurement fidelity F_M, the quantum state preparation fidelity F_QSP, and the QND fidelity F_QND--to quantify its performance. The claim of Kok and Munro in their Comment [quant-ph/0406120] is that one of our fidelity measures F_M is not appropriate because it relies on coincidence measurements. We show why this claim is wrong from both a fundamental and an operational perspective.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0507175

Related papers

Comment on “Measuring a Photonic Qubit without Destroying It”

Pieter Kok, William J. Munro

Recently, Pryde et al reported the demonstration of a quantum non-demolition scheme for single-photon polarization states with linear optics and projective measurements [Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 190402 (2004)]. Here, we argue that their interpretation of the experiment is inconsistent with the fidelity measure they use.

arXiv:quant-ph/0406120•Physical Review Letters•Jul 18, 2005•5 citations

Measuring a Photonic Qubit without Destroying It

Geoff J. Pryde, Jeremy L. O’Brien, Andrew G. White +2 more

Measuring the polarization of a single photon typically results in its destruction. We propose, demonstrate, and completely characterize a quantum nondemolition (QND) scheme for realizing such a measurement nondestructively. This scheme uses only linear optics and photodetection of ancillary modes to induce a strong nonlinearity at the single-photon level, nondeterministically. We vary this QND measurement continuously into the weak regime and use it to perform a nondestructive test of complementarity in quantum mechanics. Our scheme realizes the most advanced general measurement of a qubit to date: it is nondestructive, can be made in any basis, and with arbitrary strength.

arXiv:quant-ph/0312048•Physical Review Letters•May 12, 2004•127 citations

Interferometric Quantum-Nondemolition Single-Photon Detectors

Peter Kok, Hwang Lee, Jonathan P. Dowling

Two interferometric quantum-nondemolition (QND) devices have been proposed: (1) a polarization-independent device and (2) a polarization-preserving device. The prolarization-independent device works on an input state of up to two photons, whereas the polarization-preserving device works on a superposition of vacuum and single- photon states. The overall function of the device would be to probabilistically generate a unique detector output only when its input electromagnetic mode was populated by a single photon, in which case its output mode would also be populated by a single photon. Like other QND devices, the proposed devices are potentially useful for a variety of applications, including such areas of NASA interest as quantum computing, quantum communication, detection of gravity waves, as well as pedagogical demonstrations of the quantum nature of light. Many protocols in quantum computation and quantum communication require the possibility of detecting a photon without destroying it. The only prior single- photon-detecting QND device is based on quantum electrodynamics in a resonant cavity and, as such, it depends on the photon frequency. Moreover, the prior device can distinguish only between one photon and no photon. The proposed interferometric QND devices would not depend on frequency and could distinguish between (a) one photon and (b) zero or two photons. The first proposed device is depicted schematically in Figure 1. The input electromagnetic mode would be a superposition of a zero-, a one-, and a two-photon quantum state. The overall function of the device would be to probabilistically generate a unique detector output only when its input electromagnetic mode was populated by a single photon, in which case its output mode also would be populated by a single photon.

•Mar 1, 2007•0 citations

Single-photon quantum-nondemolition detectors constructed with linear optics and projective measurements

Pieter Kok, Hwang Lee, Jonathan P. Dowling

Optical quantum-nondemolition devices can provide essential tools for quantum information processing. Here, we describe several optical interferometers that signal the presence of a single photon in a particular input state without destroying it. We discuss both entanglement-assisted and nonentanglement-assisted interferometers, with ideal and realistic detectors. We found that the existing detectors with 88% quantum efficiency and single-photon resolution can yield output fidelities of up to 89%, depending on the input state. Furthermore, we construct expanded protocols to perform quantum-nondemolition detections of single photons that leave the polarization invariant. For detectors with 88% efficiency, we found polarization-preserving output fidelities of up to 98.5%.

arXiv:quant-ph/0202046•Physical Review A•Dec 30, 2002•178 citations

Implementing a single-photon quantum nondemolition device with only linear optics and projective measurements

Pieter Kok, Hwang Lee, Jonathan P. Dowling

In this Letter we describe an optical interferometer that signals the presence of a single photon in a particular input state (c0 |0> + c1 |1> + c2 |2>) without destroying it. The interferometer employs two auxiliary single-photon sources and three detectors. The ideal efficiency of this quantum nondemolition (QND) device is 1/7. Furthermore, the interferometer presented is in principle not bound to a specific frequency range.

•Feb 7, 2002•1 citation

High-fidelity Z -measurement error encoding of optical qubits

Jeremy L. O’Brien, Geoff J. Pryde, Andrew G. White +1 more

We demonstrate a quantum error correction scheme that protects against accidental measurement, using a parity encoding where the logical state of a single qubit is encoded into two physical qubits using a nondeterministic photonic controlled-NOT gate. For the single qubit input states $\ensuremath{\mid}0⟩$, $\ensuremath{\mid}1⟩$, $\ensuremath{\mid}0⟩\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}\ensuremath{\mid}1⟩$, and $\ensuremath{\mid}0⟩\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}i\ensuremath{\mid}1⟩$ our encoder produces the appropriate two-qubit encoded state with an average fidelity of $0.88\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.03$ and the single qubit decoded states have an average fidelity of $0.93\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.05$ with the original state. We are able to decode the two-qubit state (up to a bit flip) by performing a measurement on one of the qubits in the logical basis; we find that the 64 one-qubit decoded states arising from 16 real and imaginary single-qubit superposition inputs have an average fidelity of $0.96\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.03$.

arXiv:quant-ph/0408064•Physical Review A•Jun 9, 2005•25 citations
In our Letter we proposed a scheme for nondeterministic quantum nondemolition (QND) measurement of the polarization of a single photon--a photonic qubit--using linear optics and photodetection. The scheme works with nonunit probability, but success is heralded by the detection of a single photon in the meter output. We provided an experimental demonstration of this scheme and introduced three universally applicable fidelity measures--the measurement fidelity F_M, the quantum state preparation fidelity F_QSP, and the QND fidelity F_QND--to quantify its performance. The claim of Kok and Munro in their Comment [quant-ph/0406120] is that one of our fidelity measures F_M is not appropriate because it relies on coincidence measurements. We show why this claim is wrong from both a fundamental and an operational perspective.
Measuring the polarization of a single photon typically results in its destruction. We propose, demonstrate, and completely characterize a quantum nondemolition (QND) scheme for realizing such a measurement nondestructively. This scheme uses only linear optics and photodetection of ancillary modes to induce a strong nonlinearity at the single-photon level, nondeterministically. We vary this QND measurement continuously into the weak regime and use it to perform a nondestructive test of complementarity in quantum mechanics. Our scheme realizes the most advanced general measurement of a qubit to date: it is nondestructive, can be made in any basis, and with arbitrary strength.
Two interferometric quantum-nondemolition (QND) devices have been proposed: (1) a polarization-independent device and (2) a polarization-preserving device. The prolarization-independent device works on an input state of up to two photons, whereas the polarization-preserving device works on a superposition of vacuum and single- photon states. The overall function of the device would be to probabilistically generate a unique detector output only when its input electromagnetic mode was populated by a single photon, in which case its output mode would also be populated by a single photon. Like other QND devices, the proposed devices are potentially useful for a variety of applications, including such areas of NASA interest as quantum computing, quantum communication, detection of gravity waves, as well as pedagogical demonstrations of the quantum nature of light. Many protocols in quantum computation and quantum communication require the possibility of detecting a photon without destroying it. The only prior single- photon-detecting QND device is based on quantum electrodynamics in a resonant cavity and, as such, it depends on the photon frequency. Moreover, the prior device can distinguish only between one photon and no photon. The proposed interferometric QND devices would not depend on frequency and could distinguish between (a) one photon and (b) zero or two photons. The first proposed device is depicted schematically in Figure 1. The input electromagnetic mode would be a superposition of a zero-, a one-, and a two-photon quantum state. The overall function of the device would be to probabilistically generate a unique detector output only when its input electromagnetic mode was populated by a single photon, in which case its output mode also would be populated by a single photon.
Optical quantum-nondemolition devices can provide essential tools for quantum information processing. Here, we describe several optical interferometers that signal the presence of a single photon in a particular input state without destroying it. We discuss both entanglement-assisted and nonentanglement-assisted interferometers, with ideal and realistic detectors. We found that the existing detectors with 88% quantum efficiency and single-photon resolution can yield output fidelities of up to 89%, depending on the input state. Furthermore, we construct expanded protocols to perform quantum-nondemolition detections of single photons that leave the polarization invariant. For detectors with 88% efficiency, we found polarization-preserving output fidelities of up to 98.5%.
We demonstrate a quantum error correction scheme that protects against accidental measurement, using a parity encoding where the logical state of a single qubit is encoded into two physical qubits using a nondeterministic photonic controlled-NOT gate. For the single qubit input states $\ensuremath{\mid}0⟩$, $\ensuremath{\mid}1⟩$, $\ensuremath{\mid}0⟩\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}\ensuremath{\mid}1⟩$, and $\ensuremath{\mid}0⟩\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}i\ensuremath{\mid}1⟩$ our encoder produces the appropriate two-qubit encoded state with an average fidelity of $0.88\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.03$ and the single qubit decoded states have an average fidelity of $0.93\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.05$ with the original state. We are able to decode the two-qubit state (up to a bit flip) by performing a measurement on one of the qubits in the logical basis; we find that the 64 one-qubit decoded states arising from 16 real and imaginary single-qubit superposition inputs have an average fidelity of $0.96\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.03$.