Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0305137

An Explanation of Spin Based on Classical Mechanics and Electrodynamics

O. Chavoya-Aceves

Published May 23, 2003• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is proved that, according to Classical Mechanics and Electrodynamics, the trajectory of the center of mass of a neutral system of electrical charges can be deflected by an inhomogeneous magnetic field, even if its internal angular momentum is zero. This challenges the common view about the function of the Stern-Gerlach apparatus, as resolving the eigen-states of an intrinsic angular momentum. Doubts are cast also on the supposed failure of Schrodinger's theory to explain the properties of atoms in presence of magnetic fields without introducing spin variables.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0305137

Related papers

An Electrodynamic Theory of Spin

O. Chavoya-Aceves

We prove that according to classical mechanics the trajectory of the center of mass of a neutral system of electrical charges can be deflected by an inhomogeneous magnetic field, even if the internal angular momentum is zero. This challenges the common interpretation of the functioning of the Stern-Gerlach apparatus, as resolving the eigen-states of a mysterious strictly quantum two valued physical observable. Even more, the main evidence we have of the failure of Schr\\"odinger's theory to explain the properties of complex atoms without introducing spin variables is not reliable.

•May 23, 2003•0 citations

On the angular momentum of a system of quantum particles

O Chavoya-Aceves

The properties of angular momentum and its connection to magnetic moment are explored, based on a reconsideration of the Stern-Gerlach experiment and gauge invariance. The separation of angular momentum of a quantum system of particles into orbital angular momentum plus intrinsic angular momentum is reconsidered, within the limits of the Schrödinger theory. A proof is given that, for systems of more than two particles, unless all of them have the same mass, the possibility of having eigenvalues of the form $(n+1/2)\hbar$ is not excluded for the operators of angular momentum of the centre of mass and the internal angular momentum. \noindent\textbf{PACS: 03.65.Ta} angular momentum, magnetic moment, spin crisis

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Phenomenological Theory of the Stern-Gerlach Experiment

Sergey A. Rashkovskiy

Abstract We propose a phenomenological theory of spin behavior in a magnetic field, which explains from the point of view of classical physics the two-valued result of the Stern-Gerlach experiment. The behavior of the spin and intrinsic magnetic moment of an electron wave of an atom in an external magnetic field is considered. We show that in a weak magnetic field, the intrinsic magnetic moment of an electron wave is always oriented parallel to the magnetic field strength vector, while in a strong magnetic field, depending on the initial orientation of the intrinsic magnetic moment, two orientations are realized: either parallel or antiparallel to the magnetic field strength vector. Within the framework of classical electrodynamics, the calculation of the motion of an atomic beam in an inhomogeneous magnetic field is carried out, which reproduces the results of the Stern-Gerlach experiment.

•Oct 31, 2022•2 citations

Multielectronic Atom in Magnetic Field Revisited

O. Chavoya-Aceves

The motion of a multi-electronic atom in an external electro-magnetic field is reconsidered. We prove that according to classical mechanics and electrodynamics, the assumption that the interaction with the magnetic field is described by means of a potential energy is no valid, and the trajectory of the center of mass can be deflected by a magnetic field, even if the internal angular momentum is zero. The characteristic equation of the corresponding hamiltonian is not separable in three degrees of freedom for the hydrogen atom.

arXiv:quant-ph/0306191•Jun 27, 2003•1 citation

A New Interpretation of The Stern-Gerlach Experiment by Classical Physics

Zhonglin BO

A thorough motion investigation and analysis was conducted again for the original Stern-Gerlach Experiment(SGE). The analysis is still based on the assumption that the atom passing the SG apparatus is a micromagnet due to the spin of its electron, the atoms in the source beam are with an orientation distribution of its angular momentum vectors, while the spin micromagnet is in the precession induced by an inhomogeneous magnetic field. It is the precession that keeps the silver beam with narrower orientation distribution of its angular momentum vectors after passing through the inhomogeneous magnetic field. The motion relativity was introduced in the SGE between the SG apparatus and the silver source beam, which interpreted all the detection phenomena in the multi-stage SGE. The research provided a new and convincing interpretation to the SGE with full satisfaction based on the classical physics without any mysterious or counter intuitive concepts introduced compared to quantum physics.

International Journal of Physics•Oct 18, 2023•1 citation

Spin Quantization in a Classical Model

David Lloyd Selke

The origins of quantum theory lie in a failure to explain certain phenomena using classical theory. But despite its adoption, quantum theory abounds with concepts described as “weird” or “spooky.” Even Feynman said that no one understands quantum theory. We revisit the Stern-Gerlach experiment that gave rise to the concept of spin and its quantization from a classical point of view. We present a simplified model of the classical electron which has two stable states which separate into two beams in the presence of an inhomogenous magnetic field.

European Journal of Applied Physics•Feb 6, 2021•0 citations
It is proved that, according to Classical Mechanics and Electrodynamics, the trajectory of the center of mass of a neutral system of electrical charges can be deflected by an inhomogeneous magnetic field, even if its internal angular momentum is zero. This challenges the common view about the function of the Stern-Gerlach apparatus, as resolving the eigen-states of an intrinsic angular momentum. Doubts are cast also on the supposed failure of Schrodinger's theory to explain the properties of atoms in presence of magnetic fields without introducing spin variables.
We prove that according to classical mechanics the trajectory of the center of mass of a neutral system of electrical charges can be deflected by an inhomogeneous magnetic field, even if the internal angular momentum is zero. This challenges the common interpretation of the functioning of the Stern-Gerlach apparatus, as resolving the eigen-states of a mysterious strictly quantum two valued physical observable. Even more, the main evidence we have of the failure of Schr\\"odinger's theory to explain the properties of complex atoms without introducing spin variables is not reliable.
The properties of angular momentum and its connection to magnetic moment are explored, based on a reconsideration of the Stern-Gerlach experiment and gauge invariance. The separation of angular momentum of a quantum system of particles into orbital angular momentum plus intrinsic angular momentum is reconsidered, within the limits of the Schrödinger theory. A proof is given that, for systems of more than two particles, unless all of them have the same mass, the possibility of having eigenvalues of the form (n+1/2)ℏ(n+1/2)\hbar(n+1/2)ℏ is not excluded for the operators of angular momentum of the centre of mass and the internal angular momentum. \noindent\textbf{PACS: 03.65.Ta} angular momentum, magnetic moment, spin crisis
Abstract We propose a phenomenological theory of spin behavior in a magnetic field, which explains from the point of view of classical physics the two-valued result of the Stern-Gerlach experiment. The behavior of the spin and intrinsic magnetic moment of an electron wave of an atom in an external magnetic field is considered. We show that in a weak magnetic field, the intrinsic magnetic moment of an electron wave is always oriented parallel to the magnetic field strength vector, while in a strong magnetic field, depending on the initial orientation of the intrinsic magnetic moment, two orientations are realized: either parallel or antiparallel to the magnetic field strength vector. Within the framework of classical electrodynamics, the calculation of the motion of an atomic beam in an inhomogeneous magnetic field is carried out, which reproduces the results of the Stern-Gerlach experiment.
The motion of a multi-electronic atom in an external electro-magnetic field is reconsidered. We prove that according to classical mechanics and electrodynamics, the assumption that the interaction with the magnetic field is described by means of a potential energy is no valid, and the trajectory of the center of mass can be deflected by a magnetic field, even if the internal angular momentum is zero. The characteristic equation of the corresponding hamiltonian is not separable in three degrees of freedom for the hydrogen atom.
A thorough motion investigation and analysis was conducted again for the original Stern-Gerlach Experiment(SGE). The analysis is still based on the assumption that the atom passing the SG apparatus is a micromagnet due to the spin of its electron, the atoms in the source beam are with an orientation distribution of its angular momentum vectors, while the spin micromagnet is in the precession induced by an inhomogeneous magnetic field. It is the precession that keeps the silver beam with narrower orientation distribution of its angular momentum vectors after passing through the inhomogeneous magnetic field. The motion relativity was introduced in the SGE between the SG apparatus and the silver source beam, which interpreted all the detection phenomena in the multi-stage SGE. The research provided a new and convincing interpretation to the SGE with full satisfaction based on the classical physics without any mysterious or counter intuitive concepts introduced compared to quantum physics.
The origins of quantum theory lie in a failure to explain certain phenomena using classical theory. But despite its adoption, quantum theory abounds with concepts described as “weird” or “spooky.” Even Feynman said that no one understands quantum theory. We revisit the Stern-Gerlach experiment that gave rise to the concept of spin and its quantization from a classical point of view. We present a simplified model of the classical electron which has two stable states which separate into two beams in the presence of an inhomogenous magnetic field.