Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0207101

Ambiguities in the derivation of retrodictive probability

Kirkpatrick, K. A.

Published Jul 18, 2002• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The derivation of the quantum retrodictive probability formula involves an error, an ambiguity. The end result is correct because this error appears twice, in such a way as to cancel itself. In addition, however, the usual expression for the probability itself contains the same ambiguity; this may lead to errors in its application. A generally applicable method is given to avoid such ambiguities altogether.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0207101

Related papers

Quantum Retrodiction: Foundations and Controversies

Stephen Mark Barnett, John Jeffers, David Thomas Pegg

Prediction is the making of statements, usually probabilistic, about future events based on current information. Retrodiction is the making of statements about past events based on current information. We present the foundations of quantum retrodiction and highlight its intimate connection with the Bayesian interpretation of probability. The close link with Bayesian methods enables us to explore controversies and misunderstandings about retrodiction that have appeared in the literature. To be clear, quantum retrodiction is universally applicable and draws its validity directly from conventional predictive quantum theory coupled with Bayes’ theorem.

arXiv:2103.06074•Symmetry•Apr 2, 2021•23 citations

Retrodiction in quantum theory: I

Izawa Ken'ichi, Taniguchi Tomonori

We consider retrodictive aspects of quantum theory. As a first step, we adopt quantum mechanics of a single free particle in one-dimensional space. Under successive mearsurements of particle position and momentum as a wave packet, we derive estimation on retrodictive probability, which happens to coincide with the expression for predictive probability into the past.

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

Quantum theory of preparation and measurement

DAVID PEGG, STEPHEN BARNETT, John Jeffers

The conventional postulate for the probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics is asymmetric in preparation and measurement, making retrodiction reliant on inference by use of Bayes' theorem. Here, a more fundamental symmetric postulate is presented, from which both predictive and retrodictive probabilities emerge immediately, even where measurement devices more general than those usually considered are involved. It is shown that the new postulate is perfectly consistent with the conventional postulate.

arXiv:quant-ph/0207174•Journal of Modern Optics•Apr 1, 2002•44 citations

Retrodiction in quantum optics

David Thomas Pegg, Stephen Mark Barnett

The usual formalism of quantum mechanics is predictive with state vectors being assigned on the basis of past preparation procedures. The retrodictive formalism, in which some state vectors are assigned on the basis of future measurement results is less usual, although it has been known for some time. Although at first sight this formalism may appear to be anticausal and subject to paradoxes, if used carefully it still predicts the same measurable correlations as the more usual approach despite different assignments of state vectors to states in the interval between preparation and measurement of the system. Here we use a procedure which involves retrodiction to examine some quantum optical processes, including a recent state truncation process. The collapse of the state vector occurs at a different time from that for the usual approach underlining the difficulty in regarding the collapse as a real physical process.

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Aug 1, 1999•39 citations

Aspects of the Problem of Retrodiction

Bernard d’Espagnat

The problem of retrodiction is associated with basic questions, but for this very reason it is, unfortunately, quite difficult, even in classical physics. In quantum physics it is even more subtle. In quantum mechanics, a consistent definition of what is called a "system" leads to problems that do not exist in classical physics, and correspondingly the answers to the questions raised are less straightforward. This chapter discusses the conditions under which it is possible to speak of an "independent time evolution" of a system S and to study what kinds of predictions can legitimately be made when these conditions are fulfilled. It describes retroactive computation to investigate whether or not the assumed knowledge in question is really consistent with the standard quantum mechanical formalism. The concept of retrodiction is related to the notions of time reversal and of irreversibility. Both these notions play a central role in physics.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2018•0 citations

Classical three-box paradox

K A Kirkpatrick

A simple classical probabilistic system (a simple card game) classically exemplifies Aharonov and Vaidman's ‘three-box ‘paradox’’ (1991 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 24 2315 ), implying that the three-box example is neither quantal nor a paradox and leaving one with less difficulty to busy the interpreters of quantum mechanics. An ambiguity in the usual expression of the retrodiction formula is shown to have misled Albert et al (1985 Phys. Rev. Lett. 54 5) to a result not, in fact, ‘curious’; the discussion illustrates how to avoid this ambiguity.

arXiv:quant-ph/0207124•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Apr 14, 2003•37 citations
The derivation of the quantum retrodictive probability formula involves an error, an ambiguity. The end result is correct because this error appears twice, in such a way as to cancel itself. In addition, however, the usual expression for the probability itself contains the same ambiguity; this may lead to errors in its application. A generally applicable method is given to avoid such ambiguities altogether.
Prediction is the making of statements, usually probabilistic, about future events based on current information. Retrodiction is the making of statements about past events based on current information. We present the foundations of quantum retrodiction and highlight its intimate connection with the Bayesian interpretation of probability. The close link with Bayesian methods enables us to explore controversies and misunderstandings about retrodiction that have appeared in the literature. To be clear, quantum retrodiction is universally applicable and draws its validity directly from conventional predictive quantum theory coupled with Bayes’ theorem.
The conventional postulate for the probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics is asymmetric in preparation and measurement, making retrodiction reliant on inference by use of Bayes' theorem. Here, a more fundamental symmetric postulate is presented, from which both predictive and retrodictive probabilities emerge immediately, even where measurement devices more general than those usually considered are involved. It is shown that the new postulate is perfectly consistent with the conventional postulate.
The usual formalism of quantum mechanics is predictive with state vectors being assigned on the basis of past preparation procedures. The retrodictive formalism, in which some state vectors are assigned on the basis of future measurement results is less usual, although it has been known for some time. Although at first sight this formalism may appear to be anticausal and subject to paradoxes, if used carefully it still predicts the same measurable correlations as the more usual approach despite different assignments of state vectors to states in the interval between preparation and measurement of the system. Here we use a procedure which involves retrodiction to examine some quantum optical processes, including a recent state truncation process. The collapse of the state vector occurs at a different time from that for the usual approach underlining the difficulty in regarding the collapse as a real physical process.
The problem of retrodiction is associated with basic questions, but for this very reason it is, unfortunately, quite difficult, even in classical physics. In quantum physics it is even more subtle. In quantum mechanics, a consistent definition of what is called a "system" leads to problems that do not exist in classical physics, and correspondingly the answers to the questions raised are less straightforward. This chapter discusses the conditions under which it is possible to speak of an "independent time evolution" of a system S and to study what kinds of predictions can legitimately be made when these conditions are fulfilled. It describes retroactive computation to investigate whether or not the assumed knowledge in question is really consistent with the standard quantum mechanical formalism. The concept of retrodiction is related to the notions of time reversal and of irreversibility. Both these notions play a central role in physics.
A simple classical probabilistic system (a simple card game) classically exemplifies Aharonov and Vaidman's ‘three-box ‘paradox’’ (1991 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 24 2315 ), implying that the three-box example is neither quantal nor a paradox and leaving one with less difficulty to busy the interpreters of quantum mechanics. An ambiguity in the usual expression of the retrodiction formula is shown to have misled Albert et al (1985 Phys. Rev. Lett. 54 5) to a result not, in fact, ‘curious’; the discussion illustrates how to avoid this ambiguity.