arXiv:quant-ph/0206157

Once again on the `demythologizing' of the clock-in-the-box debate of Bohr and Einstein

Vladimir Hnizdo

Published Jun 21, 2002• 1 citation

Abstract

The reply of de la Torre, Daleo and Garcia-Mata [Eur. J. Phys. 23 (2002) L15-L16] to a criticism of their `demythologizing' analysis of the clock-in-the-box debate between Einstein and Bohr is commented on.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0206157

Related papers

On Bohr's response to the clock-in-the-box thought experiment of Einstein *

Vladimir Hnizdo

The recent analysis by de la Torre, Daleo and García-Mata of the reply of Bohr to the famous clock-in-the-box challenge of Einstein is criticized.

arXiv:quant-ph/0107028European Journal of PhysicsJun 14, 200211 citations

The photon-box Bohr-Einstein debate demythologized

A C de la Torre, Alejandro Daleo, Ignacio García-Mata

The legendary discussion between Einstein and Bohr concerning the photon-box experiment is critically analysed. It is shown that Einstein's argument is flawed while Bohr's reply is wrong.

European Journal of PhysicsMay 1, 200012 citations

The photon-box Bohr-Einstein debate demythologized. Reply to Comment *

A C de la Torre, Alejandro Daleo, Ignacio García-Mata

The arguments presented in the criticism of our work suffer from the same mistakes that we have denounced. That is, the confusion of quantum indeterminacies with experimental uncertainties. We mention another example of how this type of argument can lead to wrong results and we show other weaknesses of the debate.

European Journal of PhysicsJun 14, 20023 citations

The Photon-Box Bohr-Einstein Debate Demithologized

de la Torre, A. C., Alejandro Daleo, Ignacio García-Mata

The legendary discussion between Einstein and Bohr concerning the photon box experiment is critically analyzed. It is shown that Einstein's argument is flawed and Bohr's reply is wrong.

arXiv:quant-ph/9910040Oct 8, 19990 citations

Algunas observaciones sobre el debate Einstein-Bohr de la mecánica ondulatoria

Juan José Icaza Zabala

Jan 1, 19860 citations

DESMITIFICACIÓN DEL DEBATE SOBRE LA CAJA DE FOTONES ENTRE BOHR Y EINSTEIN

Alicia Torre, Alejandro Daleo, I. García Mata

La legendaria discusión entre Einstein y Bohr sobre el experimento de la caja de fotones es analizada críticamente. Se demuestra que el argumento de Einstein es erróneo y que la respuesta de Bohr es incorrecta.

ANALES AFAJul 23, 20130 citations