Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0206145 · Physical Review A

Relating the Lorentzian and exponential: Fermi’s approximation, the Fourier transform, and causality

Arno Böhm, Nathan L. Harshman, HERBERT WALTHER

Published Jul 25, 2002• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Fourier transform is often used to connect the Lorentzian energy distribution for resonance scattering to the exponential time dependence for decaying states. However, to apply the Fourier transform, one has to bend the rules of standard quantum mechanics; the Lorentzian energy distribution must be extended to the full real axis $\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\infty}<E<\ensuremath{\infty}$ instead of being bounded from below $0<~E<\ensuremath{\infty}$ (Fermi's approximation). Then the Fourier transform of the extended Lorentzian becomes the exponential, but only for times $t>~0,$ a time asymmetry which is in conflict with the unitary group time evolution of standard quantum mechanics. Extending the Fourier transform from distributions to generalized vectors, we are led to Gamow kets, which possess a Lorentzian energy distribution with $\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\infty}<E<\ensuremath{\infty}$ and have exponential time evolution for $t>~{t}_{0}=0$ only. This leads to probability predictions that do not violate causality.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.66.012107

Related papers

Resonance and decay phenomena lead to quantum mechanical time asymmetry

Arno Böhm, Hai Viet Bui

The states (Schrödinger picture) and observables (Heisenberg picture) in the standard quantum theory evolve symmetrically in time, given by the unitary group with time extending over − ∞ < t < + ∞ . This time evolution is a mathematical consequence of the Hilbert space boundary condition for the dynamical differential equations. However, this unitary group evolution violates causality. Moreover, it does not solve an old puzzle of Wigner: How does one describe excited states of atoms which decay exponentially, and how is their lifetime τ related to the Lorentzian width Γ? These question can be answered if one replaces the Hilbert space boundary condition by new, Hardy space boundary conditions. These Hardy space boundary conditions allow for a distinction between states (prepared by a preparation apparatus) and observables (detected by a registration apparatus). The new Hardy space quantum theory is time asymmetric, i.e, the time evolution is given by the semigroup with t 0 ≤ t < + ∞ , which predicts a finite "beginning of time" t 0 , where t 0 is the ensemble of time at which each individual system has been prepared. The Hardy space axiom also leads to the new prediction: the width Γ and the lifetime τ are exactly related by τ = ℏ/Γ .

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Apr 5, 2013•1 citation

Time asymmetric quantum theory and its applications in non-relativistic and relativistic quantum systems

Hai Viet Bui

The exact relation τ = ~/Γ between the width Γ of a resonance and the lifetime\nτ for a decay of this resonance could not be obtained in the conventional quantum\ntheory based on the Hilbert space as well as on the Schwartz space in which the spaces\nof the states and of the observables are described by the same space. Furthermore,\nboth dynamical evolution of the states (in Schrodinger picture) and observables (in\nHeisenberg picture) are symmetrically in time, given by an unitary group with time\nextending over −∞ < t < +∞. This time symmetric evolution is a mathematical\nconsequence of Von Neumann theorem for the dynamical differential equations,\nSchrodinger equation for the state or Heisenberg equation for the observable, under\neither the Hilbert space or Schwartz space boundary condition. However, this unitary\ngroup evolution violates causality. In order to get a quantum theory in which the\nexact relation and causality are obtained, one has to replace the Hilbert space or the\nSchwartz space boundary condition by a new boundary condition based on the Hardy\nspace axioms in which the space of the states and the space of the observables are\ndescribed by two distinguishable Hardy spaces. As a consequence of the new Hardy\nspace axiom, one obtains, instead of the time symmetric evolution for the states and\nthe observables, time asymmetrical evolutions for the states and observables which\nare described by two semi-groups. The time asymmetrical evolution predicts an finite\nbeginning of time t0(= 0) for quantum system which can be experimental observed\nby directly measuring the lifetime of the decaying state as the beginning of time of\nthe ensemble in scattering experiments. A resonance obeying the exponential time\nevolution can then be described by a Gamow vector, which is defined as superposition\nof the exact out-plane wave states with exact Breit-Wigner energy distribution.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Relativistic resonance and decay phenomena

Hai Viet Bui

The exact relation τ = ℏ/Γ between the width Γ of a resonance and the lifetime τ for the decay of this resonance could not be obtained in standard quantum theory based on the Hilbert space or Schwartz space axiom in non-relativistic physics as well as in the relativistic regime. In order to obtain the exact relation, one has to modify the Hilbert space axiom or the Schwartz space axiom and choose new boundary conditions based on the Hardy space axioms in which the space of the states and the space of the observables are described by two different Hardy spaces. As consequences of the new Hardy space axioms, one obtains, instead of the symmetric time evolution for the states and the observables, asymmetrical time evolutions for the states and observables which are described by two semi-groups. A relativistic resonance obeying the exponential time evolution can be described by a relativistic Gamow vector, which is defined as superposition of the exact out-plane wave states with a Breit-Wigner energy distribution of the width Γ.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Apr 13, 2015•0 citations

Relativistic Gamow Vectors

Arno Böhm, Hani Kaldass, Sujeewa Wickramasekara +1 more

Gamow vectors in non-relativistic quantum mechanics are generalized eigenvectors (kets) of self-adjoint Hamiltonians with complex eigenvalues. Like the Dirac kets, they are mathematically well defined in the Rigged Hilbert Space. Gamow kets are derived from the resonance poles of the S-matrix. They have a Breit-Wigner energy distribution, an exponential decay law, and are members of a basis vector expansion whose truncation gives the finite dimensional effective theories with a complex Hamiltonian matrix. They also have an asymmetric time evolution described by a semigroup generated by the Hamiltonian, which expresses a fundamental quantum mechanical arrow of time. These Gamow kets are generalized to relativistic Gamow vectors by extrapolating from the Galilei group to the Poincare group. This leads to semigroup representations of the Poincare group which are characterized by spin j and complex invariant mass square. In these non-unitary representations the Lorentz subgroup is unitarily represented and the four-momenta are "minimally complex" in the sense that the four-velocity is real. The relativistic Gamow vectors have all the properties listed above for the non-relativistic Gamow vectors and are therefore ideally suited to describe relativistic resonances and quasistable particles.

arXiv:hep-th/9904072•Apr 9, 1999•2 citations

On the time-dependent analysis of Gamow decay

Detlef Dürr, Robert Grummt, Martin Kolb

Gamow's explanation of the exponential decay law uses complex "eigenvalues" and exponentially growing "eigenfunctions". This raises the question, how Gamow's description fits into the quantum mechanical description of nature, which is based on real eigenvalues and square integrable wave functions. Observing that the time evolution of any wave function is given by its expansion in generalized eigenfunctions, we shall answer this question in the most straightforward manner, which at the same time is accessible to graduate students and specialists. Moreover the presentation can well be used in physics lectures to students.

arXiv:1011.6084•European Journal of Physics•Jul 27, 2011•6 citations

Resonances, Gamow Vectors and Time Asymmetric Quantum Theory

Arno Böhm, Raymond Scurek, Sujeewa Wikramasekara

Decaying states can be represented by Gamow vectors with an exponential, asymmetric time evolution. This asymmetric evolution is a manifestation of irreversibility on the microphysical level. The Rigged Hilbert Space provides a mathematical theory.

arXiv:nucl-th/9902076•Revista Mexicana de Física•Feb 26, 1999•10 citations
The Fourier transform is often used to connect the Lorentzian energy distribution for resonance scattering to the exponential time dependence for decaying states. However, to apply the Fourier transform, one has to bend the rules of standard quantum mechanics; the Lorentzian energy distribution must be extended to the full real axis \ensuremath−\ensuremath∞<E<\ensuremath∞\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\infty}<E<\ensuremath{\infty}\ensuremath−\ensuremath∞<E<\ensuremath∞ instead of being bounded from below 0< E<\ensuremath∞0<~E<\ensuremath{\infty}0< E<\ensuremath∞ (Fermi's approximation). Then the Fourier transform of the extended Lorentzian becomes the exponential, but only for times t> 0,t>~0,t> 0, a time asymmetry which is in conflict with the unitary group time evolution of standard quantum mechanics. Extending the Fourier transform from distributions to generalized vectors, we are led to Gamow kets, which possess a Lorentzian energy distribution with \ensuremath−\ensuremath∞<E<\ensuremath∞\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\infty}<E<\ensuremath{\infty}\ensuremath−\ensuremath∞<E<\ensuremath∞ and have exponential time evolution for t> t0=0t>~{t}_{0}=0t> t0​=0 only. This leads to probability predictions that do not violate causality.
The states (Schrödinger picture) and observables (Heisenberg picture) in the standard quantum theory evolve symmetrically in time, given by the unitary group with time extending over − ∞ < t < + ∞ . This time evolution is a mathematical consequence of the Hilbert space boundary condition for the dynamical differential equations. However, this unitary group evolution violates causality. Moreover, it does not solve an old puzzle of Wigner: How does one describe excited states of atoms which decay exponentially, and how is their lifetime τ related to the Lorentzian width Γ? These question can be answered if one replaces the Hilbert space boundary condition by new, Hardy space boundary conditions. These Hardy space boundary conditions allow for a distinction between states (prepared by a preparation apparatus) and observables (detected by a registration apparatus). The new Hardy space quantum theory is time asymmetric, i.e, the time evolution is given by the semigroup with t 0 ≤ t < + ∞ , which predicts a finite "beginning of time" t 0 , where t 0 is the ensemble of time at which each individual system has been prepared. The Hardy space axiom also leads to the new prediction: the width Γ and the lifetime τ are exactly related by τ = ℏ/Γ .
The exact relation τ = ~/Γ between the width Γ of a resonance and the lifetime\nτ for a decay of this resonance could not be obtained in the conventional quantum\ntheory based on the Hilbert space as well as on the Schwartz space in which the spaces\nof the states and of the observables are described by the same space. Furthermore,\nboth dynamical evolution of the states (in Schrodinger picture) and observables (in\nHeisenberg picture) are symmetrically in time, given by an unitary group with time\nextending over −∞ < t < +∞. This time symmetric evolution is a mathematical\nconsequence of Von Neumann theorem for the dynamical differential equations,\nSchrodinger equation for the state or Heisenberg equation for the observable, under\neither the Hilbert space or Schwartz space boundary condition. However, this unitary\ngroup evolution violates causality. In order to get a quantum theory in which the\nexact relation and causality are obtained, one has to replace the Hilbert space or the\nSchwartz space boundary condition by a new boundary condition based on the Hardy\nspace axioms in which the space of the states and the space of the observables are\ndescribed by two distinguishable Hardy spaces. As a consequence of the new Hardy\nspace axiom, one obtains, instead of the time symmetric evolution for the states and\nthe observables, time asymmetrical evolutions for the states and observables which\nare described by two semi-groups. The time asymmetrical evolution predicts an finite\nbeginning of time t0(= 0) for quantum system which can be experimental observed\nby directly measuring the lifetime of the decaying state as the beginning of time of\nthe ensemble in scattering experiments. A resonance obeying the exponential time\nevolution can then be described by a Gamow vector, which is defined as superposition\nof the exact out-plane wave states with exact Breit-Wigner energy distribution.
The exact relation τ = ℏ/Γ between the width Γ of a resonance and the lifetime τ for the decay of this resonance could not be obtained in standard quantum theory based on the Hilbert space or Schwartz space axiom in non-relativistic physics as well as in the relativistic regime. In order to obtain the exact relation, one has to modify the Hilbert space axiom or the Schwartz space axiom and choose new boundary conditions based on the Hardy space axioms in which the space of the states and the space of the observables are described by two different Hardy spaces. As consequences of the new Hardy space axioms, one obtains, instead of the symmetric time evolution for the states and the observables, asymmetrical time evolutions for the states and observables which are described by two semi-groups. A relativistic resonance obeying the exponential time evolution can be described by a relativistic Gamow vector, which is defined as superposition of the exact out-plane wave states with a Breit-Wigner energy distribution of the width Γ.
Gamow vectors in non-relativistic quantum mechanics are generalized eigenvectors (kets) of self-adjoint Hamiltonians with complex eigenvalues. Like the Dirac kets, they are mathematically well defined in the Rigged Hilbert Space. Gamow kets are derived from the resonance poles of the S-matrix. They have a Breit-Wigner energy distribution, an exponential decay law, and are members of a basis vector expansion whose truncation gives the finite dimensional effective theories with a complex Hamiltonian matrix. They also have an asymmetric time evolution described by a semigroup generated by the Hamiltonian, which expresses a fundamental quantum mechanical arrow of time. These Gamow kets are generalized to relativistic Gamow vectors by extrapolating from the Galilei group to the Poincare group. This leads to semigroup representations of the Poincare group which are characterized by spin j and complex invariant mass square. In these non-unitary representations the Lorentz subgroup is unitarily represented and the four-momenta are "minimally complex" in the sense that the four-velocity is real. The relativistic Gamow vectors have all the properties listed above for the non-relativistic Gamow vectors and are therefore ideally suited to describe relativistic resonances and quasistable particles.
Gamow's explanation of the exponential decay law uses complex "eigenvalues" and exponentially growing "eigenfunctions". This raises the question, how Gamow's description fits into the quantum mechanical description of nature, which is based on real eigenvalues and square integrable wave functions. Observing that the time evolution of any wave function is given by its expansion in generalized eigenfunctions, we shall answer this question in the most straightforward manner, which at the same time is accessible to graduate students and specialists. Moreover the presentation can well be used in physics lectures to students.