Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0011103 · Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields

Approximate decoherence of histories and ’t Hooft’s deterministic quantum theory

J. J. Halliwell

Published Mar 23, 2001• 25 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the decoherent histories approach to quantum theory, sets of histories are said to be decoherent when the decoherence functional, measuring interference between pairs of histories, is exactly diagonal. In realistic situations, however, only approximate diagonality is ever achieved, raising the question of what approximate decoherence actually means and how it is related to exact decoherence. This paper explores the possibility that an exactly decoherent set of histories may be constructed from an approximate set by small distortions of the operators characterizing the histories. In particular, for the case of histories of positions and momenta, this is achieved by doubling the set of operators and then finding, among this enlarged set, new position and momentum operators that commute, and so decohere exactly, and which are ``close'' to the original operators. Two derivations are given: one in terms of the decoherence functional, the second in terms of Wigner functions. The enlarged, exactly decoherent theory has the same classical dynamics as the original one, and coincides with the so-called deterministic quantum theories of the type recently studied by 't Hooft. These results suggest that the comparison of standard and deterministic quantum theories may provide an alternative method of characterizing emergent classicality. A side product is the surprising result that histories of momenta in the quantum Brownian motion model (for the free particle in the high-temperature limit) are exactly decoherent.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.63.085013

Related papers

Quantum mechanics of history: The decoherence functional in quantum mechanics

Fay Dowker B, J. J. Halliwell

We study a formulation of quantum mechanics in which the central notion is that of a quantum-mechanical history---a sequence of events at a succession of times. The primary aim is to identify sets of ``decoherent'' (or ``consistent'') histories for the system. These are quantum-mechanical histories suffering negligible interference with each other, and, therefore, to which probabilities may be assigned. These histories may be found for a given system using the so-called decoherence functional. When the decoherence functional is exactly diagonal, probabilities may be assigned to the histories, and all probability sum rules are satisfied exactly. We propose a condition for approximate decoherence, and argue that it implies that most probability sum rules will be satisfied to approximately the same degree. We also derive an inequality bounding the size of the off-diagonal terms of the decoherence functional. We calculate the decoherence functional for some simple one-dimensional systems, with a variety of initial states. For these systems, we explore the extent to which decoherence is produced using two different types of coarse graining. The first type of coarse graining involves imprecise specification of the particle's position. The second involves coupling the particle to a thermal bath of harmonic oscillators and ignoring the details of the bath (the Caldeira-Leggett model). We argue that both types of coarse graining are necessary in general. We explicitly exhibit the degree of decoherence as a function of the temperature of the bath, and of the width to within which the particle's position is specified. We study the diagonal elements of the decoherence functional, representing the probabilities for the possible histories of the system. To the extent that the histories decohere, we show that the probability distributions are peaked about the classical histories of the system, with the distribution of their initial positions and momenta given by a smeared version of the Wigner function. We discuss this result in connection with earlier uses of the Wigner function in this context. We find that there is a certain amount of tension between the demands of decoherence and peaking about classical paths.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Aug 15, 1992•205 citations

Quantum-mechanical histories and the uncertainty principle. II. Fluctuations about classical predictability

J. J. Halliwell

This paper is concerned with two questions in the decoherent histories approach to quantum mechanics: the emergence of approximate classical predictability, and the fluctuations about it necessitated by the uncertainty principle. It is in part a continuation of an earlier paper on the uncertainty principle for quantum-mechanical histories. We consider histories characterized by position samplings at n moments of time. This includes the case of position sampling continuous in time in the limit n\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}. We use this to construct a probability distribution on the value of (discrete approximations to) the field equations, F=mx\ifmmode\ddot\else\textasciidieresis\fi{}+V'(x), at n-2 times. We find that it is peaked around F=0; thus classical correlations are exhibited. We show that the width of the peak \ensuremath{\Delta}F is largely independent of the initial state. We show that the uncertainty principle takes the form 2${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}^{2}$(\ensuremath{\Delta}F${)}^{2}$\ensuremath{\ge}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Elzxh}}}^{2}$/${\mathit{t}}^{2}$, where \ensuremath{\sigma} is the width of the position samplings, and t is the time scale between projections. We determine the modifications to this result when the system is coupled to a thermal environment, thus obtaining a measure of the comparative sizes of quantum and thermal fluctuations. We show that the thermal fluctuations become comparable to the quantum fluctuations under the same conditions that decoherence effects come into play, in agreement with earlier work. We also study an alternative measure of classical correlations, namely, the conditional probability of finding a sequence of position samplings, given that particular initial phase space data have occurred.We use these results to address the issue of the formal interpretation of the probabilities for sequences of position samplings in the decoherent histories approach to quantum mechanics. Under appropriate conditions, which we describe, they admit an interpretation as a statistical ensemble of classical solutions, with the probability of each individual classical solution given by a smeared Wigner function of its initial data. We study the decoherence properties of histories characterized by the value of the field equations, F, at a sequence of times. We argue that they will be decoherent if their initial data are decoherent.

arXiv:gr-qc/9307013•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Nov 15, 1993•49 citations

Decoherent Histories and the Emergent Classicality of Local Densities

J. J. Halliwell

In the context of the decoherent histories approach to quantum theory, it is shown that a class of macroscopic configurations consisting of histories of local densities (number, momentum, energy) exhibits negligible interference. This follows from the close connection of the local densities with the corresponding exactly conserved (and so exactly decoherent) quantities, and also from the observation that the eigenstates of local densities (averaged over a sufficiently large volume) remain approximate eigenstates under time evolution. The result is relevant to the derivation of hydrodynamic equations using the decoherent histories approach.

arXiv:quant-ph/9905094•Physical Review Letters•Sep 27, 1999•65 citations

Commuting position and momentum operators, exact decoherence, and emergent classicality

J. J. Halliwell

Inspired by an old idea of von Neumann, we seek a pair of commuting operators $X,\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}P$ which are, in a specific sense, ``close'' to the canonical noncommuting position and momentum operators $x,\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}p$. The construction of such operators is related to the problem of finding complete sets of orthonormal phase-space-localized states, a problem severely constrained by the Balian-Low theorem. Here these constraints are avoided by restricting attention to situations in which the density matrix is reasonably decohered (i.e., spread out in phase space). Commuting position and momentum operators are argued to be of use in discussions of emergent classicality from quantum mechanics. In particular, they may be used to give a discussion of the relationship between exact and approximate decoherence in the decoherent-histories approach to quantum theory.

arXiv:quant-ph/0507136•Physical Review A•Oct 20, 2005•6 citations

A Review of the Decoherent Histories Approach to Quantum Mechanicsa

J. J. Halliwell

I review the decoherent (or consistent) histories approach to quantum mechanics, due to Griffiths, to Gell-Mann and Hartle, and to Omnes. This is an approach to standard quantum theory specifically designed to apply to genuinely closed systems, up to and including the entire universe. It does not depend on an assumed separation of classical and quantum domains, on notions of measurement, or on collapse of the wave function. Its primary aim is to find sets of histories for closed systems exhibiting negligble interference, and therefore, to which probabilities may be assigned. Such sets of histories are called consistent or decoherent, and may be manipulated according to the rules of ordinary (Boolean) logic. The approach provides a framework from which one may predict the emergence of an approximately classical domain for macroscopic systems, together with the conventional Copenhagen quantum mechanics for microscropic subsystems. In the special case in which the total closed system naturally separates into a distinguished subsystem coupled to an environment, the decoherent histories approach is closed related to the quantum state diffusion approach of Gisin and Percival.

arXiv:gr-qc/9407040•Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences•Apr 1, 1995•109 citations

The form and interpretation of the decoherence functional

Henry Wilkes

In this thesis we will explore the development of a realist quantum theory based on the decoherence functional using the co-event interpretation of Quantum Measure Theory. The Sum-Over-Histories theory of quantum mechanics will provide the bedding for a Hilbert-space-free stochastic-like theory that can accommodate spacetime-like objects, and can therefore be applied to quantum gravity and cosmology, as well as give an alternative perspective on quantum phenomena. The primitive objects of the theory are histories, which give different accounts of a system’s evolution, and the decoherence functional, which sums the quantum interference between these histories. Quantum Measure Theory and Generalised Quantum Mechanics (a theory close to Decoherent Histories) then give alternative interpretations of the decoherence functional’s relation to reality. In these theories, the decoherence functional is mathematically constrained in analogue to probability measures. However, one of the conditions, called weak positivity, can be lost under composition of isolated systems. We will extend this composition argument to take the case for a stronger condition of strong positivity for decoherence functionals. The bulk of the report will then focus on the co-event interpretation of Quantum Measure Theory, where co-events give full accounts of which events do or do not occur for a given system. The quantum nature of reality is expressed through the breaking of classical logic within these co-event descriptions. We will focus on evolving co-event schemes, which dynamically construct co-events to describe the reality of an evolving system in tandem with its progression. The evolving co-event schemes will be shown to reproduce classical logic when they are applied to classical systems. Moreover, similar to classical stochastic theory, these schemes will be shown to be invariant under the inclusion or exclusion of non-interfering histories. We will also explore a number of outstanding problems for these schemes, and will propose some potential modifications.

•Mar 1, 2019•2 citations
In the decoherent histories approach to quantum theory, sets of histories are said to be decoherent when the decoherence functional, measuring interference between pairs of histories, is exactly diagonal. In realistic situations, however, only approximate diagonality is ever achieved, raising the question of what approximate decoherence actually means and how it is related to exact decoherence. This paper explores the possibility that an exactly decoherent set of histories may be constructed from an approximate set by small distortions of the operators characterizing the histories. In particular, for the case of histories of positions and momenta, this is achieved by doubling the set of operators and then finding, among this enlarged set, new position and momentum operators that commute, and so decohere exactly, and which are ``close'' to the original operators. Two derivations are given: one in terms of the decoherence functional, the second in terms of Wigner functions. The enlarged, exactly decoherent theory has the same classical dynamics as the original one, and coincides with the so-called deterministic quantum theories of the type recently studied by 't Hooft. These results suggest that the comparison of standard and deterministic quantum theories may provide an alternative method of characterizing emergent classicality. A side product is the surprising result that histories of momenta in the quantum Brownian motion model (for the free particle in the high-temperature limit) are exactly decoherent.
We study a formulation of quantum mechanics in which the central notion is that of a quantum-mechanical history---a sequence of events at a succession of times. The primary aim is to identify sets of ``decoherent'' (or ``consistent'') histories for the system. These are quantum-mechanical histories suffering negligible interference with each other, and, therefore, to which probabilities may be assigned. These histories may be found for a given system using the so-called decoherence functional. When the decoherence functional is exactly diagonal, probabilities may be assigned to the histories, and all probability sum rules are satisfied exactly. We propose a condition for approximate decoherence, and argue that it implies that most probability sum rules will be satisfied to approximately the same degree. We also derive an inequality bounding the size of the off-diagonal terms of the decoherence functional. We calculate the decoherence functional for some simple one-dimensional systems, with a variety of initial states. For these systems, we explore the extent to which decoherence is produced using two different types of coarse graining. The first type of coarse graining involves imprecise specification of the particle's position. The second involves coupling the particle to a thermal bath of harmonic oscillators and ignoring the details of the bath (the Caldeira-Leggett model). We argue that both types of coarse graining are necessary in general. We explicitly exhibit the degree of decoherence as a function of the temperature of the bath, and of the width to within which the particle's position is specified. We study the diagonal elements of the decoherence functional, representing the probabilities for the possible histories of the system. To the extent that the histories decohere, we show that the probability distributions are peaked about the classical histories of the system, with the distribution of their initial positions and momenta given by a smeared version of the Wigner function. We discuss this result in connection with earlier uses of the Wigner function in this context. We find that there is a certain amount of tension between the demands of decoherence and peaking about classical paths.
This paper is concerned with two questions in the decoherent histories approach to quantum mechanics: the emergence of approximate classical predictability, and the fluctuations about it necessitated by the uncertainty principle. It is in part a continuation of an earlier paper on the uncertainty principle for quantum-mechanical histories. We consider histories characterized by position samplings at n moments of time. This includes the case of position sampling continuous in time in the limit n\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}. We use this to construct a probability distribution on the value of (discrete approximations to) the field equations, F=mx\ifmmode\ddot\else\textasciidieresis\fi{}+V'(x), at n-2 times. We find that it is peaked around F=0; thus classical correlations are exhibited. We show that the width of the peak \ensuremath{\Delta}F is largely independent of the initial state. We show that the uncertainty principle takes the form 2${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}^{2}$(\ensuremath{\Delta}F)2{)}^{2})2\ensuremath{\ge}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Elzxh}}}^{2}$/t2{\mathit{t}}^{2}t2, where \ensuremath{\sigma} is the width of the position samplings, and t is the time scale between projections. We determine the modifications to this result when the system is coupled to a thermal environment, thus obtaining a measure of the comparative sizes of quantum and thermal fluctuations. We show that the thermal fluctuations become comparable to the quantum fluctuations under the same conditions that decoherence effects come into play, in agreement with earlier work. We also study an alternative measure of classical correlations, namely, the conditional probability of finding a sequence of position samplings, given that particular initial phase space data have occurred.We use these results to address the issue of the formal interpretation of the probabilities for sequences of position samplings in the decoherent histories approach to quantum mechanics. Under appropriate conditions, which we describe, they admit an interpretation as a statistical ensemble of classical solutions, with the probability of each individual classical solution given by a smeared Wigner function of its initial data. We study the decoherence properties of histories characterized by the value of the field equations, F, at a sequence of times. We argue that they will be decoherent if their initial data are decoherent.
In the context of the decoherent histories approach to quantum theory, it is shown that a class of macroscopic configurations consisting of histories of local densities (number, momentum, energy) exhibits negligible interference. This follows from the close connection of the local densities with the corresponding exactly conserved (and so exactly decoherent) quantities, and also from the observation that the eigenstates of local densities (averaged over a sufficiently large volume) remain approximate eigenstates under time evolution. The result is relevant to the derivation of hydrodynamic equations using the decoherent histories approach.
Inspired by an old idea of von Neumann, we seek a pair of commuting operators X,PX,\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}PX,P which are, in a specific sense, ``close'' to the canonical noncommuting position and momentum operators x,px,\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}px,p. The construction of such operators is related to the problem of finding complete sets of orthonormal phase-space-localized states, a problem severely constrained by the Balian-Low theorem. Here these constraints are avoided by restricting attention to situations in which the density matrix is reasonably decohered (i.e., spread out in phase space). Commuting position and momentum operators are argued to be of use in discussions of emergent classicality from quantum mechanics. In particular, they may be used to give a discussion of the relationship between exact and approximate decoherence in the decoherent-histories approach to quantum theory.
I review the decoherent (or consistent) histories approach to quantum mechanics, due to Griffiths, to Gell-Mann and Hartle, and to Omnes. This is an approach to standard quantum theory specifically designed to apply to genuinely closed systems, up to and including the entire universe. It does not depend on an assumed separation of classical and quantum domains, on notions of measurement, or on collapse of the wave function. Its primary aim is to find sets of histories for closed systems exhibiting negligble interference, and therefore, to which probabilities may be assigned. Such sets of histories are called consistent or decoherent, and may be manipulated according to the rules of ordinary (Boolean) logic. The approach provides a framework from which one may predict the emergence of an approximately classical domain for macroscopic systems, together with the conventional Copenhagen quantum mechanics for microscropic subsystems. In the special case in which the total closed system naturally separates into a distinguished subsystem coupled to an environment, the decoherent histories approach is closed related to the quantum state diffusion approach of Gisin and Percival.
In this thesis we will explore the development of a realist quantum theory based on the decoherence functional using the co-event interpretation of Quantum Measure Theory. The Sum-Over-Histories theory of quantum mechanics will provide the bedding for a Hilbert-space-free stochastic-like theory that can accommodate spacetime-like objects, and can therefore be applied to quantum gravity and cosmology, as well as give an alternative perspective on quantum phenomena. The primitive objects of the theory are histories, which give different accounts of a system’s evolution, and the decoherence functional, which sums the quantum interference between these histories. Quantum Measure Theory and Generalised Quantum Mechanics (a theory close to Decoherent Histories) then give alternative interpretations of the decoherence functional’s relation to reality. In these theories, the decoherence functional is mathematically constrained in analogue to probability measures. However, one of the conditions, called weak positivity, can be lost under composition of isolated systems. We will extend this composition argument to take the case for a stronger condition of strong positivity for decoherence functionals. The bulk of the report will then focus on the co-event interpretation of Quantum Measure Theory, where co-events give full accounts of which events do or do not occur for a given system. The quantum nature of reality is expressed through the breaking of classical logic within these co-event descriptions. We will focus on evolving co-event schemes, which dynamically construct co-events to describe the reality of an evolving system in tandem with its progression. The evolving co-event schemes will be shown to reproduce classical logic when they are applied to classical systems. Moreover, similar to classical stochastic theory, these schemes will be shown to be invariant under the inclusion or exclusion of non-interfering histories. We will also explore a number of outstanding problems for these schemes, and will propose some potential modifications.