Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:nucl-th/0110061 · Physical Review C

Novel methods for determining effective interactions for the nuclear shell model

H. Mueller, J. Piekarewicz, James R. Shepard

Published Aug 29, 2002• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The contractor renormalization (CORE) method is applied in combination with modern effective-theory techniques to the nuclear many-body problem. A one-dimensional---yet ``realistic''---nucleon-nucleon potential is introduced to test these novel ideas. It is found that the magnitude of ``model-space'' (CORE) corrections diminishes considerably when an effective potential that eliminates the hard-momentum components of the potential is first introduced. As a result, accurate predictions for the ground-state energy of the three-body system are made with relatively little computational effort when both techniques are used in a complementary fashion.

DOI
10.1103/physrevc.66.024324

Related papers

The Canonical Nuclear Many-Body Problem as a Rigorous Effective Theory

W. C. Haxton, C.-L. Song

The shell model is the standard tool for addressing the canonical nuclear many-body problem of nonrelativistic nucleons interacting through a static potential. We discuss several of the uncontrolled approximations that are made in this model to motivate a different approach, one based on an exact solution of the Bloch-Horowitz equation. We argue that the necessary self-consistent solutions of this equation can be obtained efficiently by a Green's function expansion based on the Lanczos algorithm. The resulting effective theory is carried out for the simplest nuclei, d and 3He, using realistic NN interactions such as the Argonne v18 and Reid93 potentials, in order to contrast the results with the shell model. We discuss the wave function normalization, the evolution of the wave function as the "shell model" space is varied, and the magnetic elastic effective operator. The numerical results show a simple renormalization group behavior that differs from effective field theory treatments of the two- and three-body problems. The likely origin of this scaling is discussed.

arXiv:nucl-th/9906082•Jun 27, 1999•6 citations

Unitary-Model-Operator Approach to Nuclear Many-Body Problem. I: --The Ground-State and One-Body Energies of 16O--

Kenji Suzuki, R. Okamoto

A theory is formulated to derive an effective interaction in nuclei in the framework of the unitarymodel-operator approach.A unitary operator is introduced to describe two-body correlations, and it is determined from the condition that the effective interaction should be decoupled between the lowmomentum model space and the high-momentum space.The unitary-transformed Hamiltonian is represented in a cluster expansion form.The one-and two-body cluster terms are mainly discussed.The theory is applied to the calculation of the energies of the ground-and one-body states with the Reid soft core potential.A large gain of the energy has been obtained for the ground state in comparison with the result of the usual G-matrix theory.As for the one-body energies obtained, agreement with the experimental values is fairly good.Although the discrepancies with the experiments still remain at the 1O~ 15 % level, the present approach shows to have some desirable features compared with the nuclear many-body theories proposed so far. § 1. IntroductionA fundamental problem in nuclear physics is to clarify the properties of nuclei in terms of the interaction among their constituent particles.Although there have been many theories or approaches, we have not yet reached the goal of reproducing successfully the experimental data.The investigation of nuclear properties, in the usual nonrelativistic approach, proceeds in two steps: The first one is to determine the interaction among nucleons, and the second is to solve the many-body SchrOdinger equation.Concerning the nucleon-nucleon force, it seems that the phenomenological potential, such as the Reid potential, would be incomplete and one should wait until quark dynamics, probably quantum chromodynamics (QCD), solves finally the problem o~ nuclear force.It is of no doubt that in order to fit the experiments we need more accurate knowledge on the nuclear force including the threebody force.However, if we want to reach the goal, we need also a good many-body theory.Regardless of the accuracy of the nuclear force, we shall not be able to solve the problem unless we have a way of constructing an accurate solution for a many-body system.We believe that many-body theory should share the responsibility for the discrepancy between theory and experiment.It will be sure that nuclear many-body theory is still to be improved.Among many theories for nuclear many-body problem, the most widely applied method is, needless to say, the linked-diagram perturbation theory.This approach may also be referred to as the folded-diagram theory based on the G-matrix interaction especially due 'to Brandow 1l and Kuo et al. 2l An outstanding problem in this approach is the convergence of the perturbation expansion.Since Schucan and Weidenmliller 3 ) pointed out the divergence of the perturbation expansion due to the presence of intruder states, this difficulty has long been a serious problem.Present status of this problem is

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Jun 1, 1986•13 citations

Renormalization Group Equation for Low Momentum Effective Nuclear Interactions

S. K. Bogner, A. Schwenk, T.T.S. Kuo +1 more

We consider two nonperturbative methods originally used to derive shell model effective interactions in nuclei. These methods have been applied to the two nucleon sector to obtain an energy independent effective interaction V_{low k}, which preserves the low momentum half-on-shell T matrix and the deuteron pole, with a sharp cutoff imposed on all intermediate state momenta. We show that V_{low k} scales with the cutoff precisely as one expects from renormalization group arguments. This result is a step towards reformulating traditional model space many-body calculations in the language of effective field theories and the renormalization group. The numerical scaling properties of V_{low k} are observed to be in excellent agreement with our exact renormalization group equation.

arXiv:nucl-th/0111042•Nov 13, 2001•66 citations

Applications of the Similarity Renormalization Group to the Nuclear Interaction

Eric Jurgenson

The Similarity Renormalization Group (SRG) is investigated as a powerful yet practical method to modify nuclear potentials so as to reduce computational requirements for calculations of observables. The key feature of SRG transformations that leads to computational benefits is the decoupling of low-energy nuclear physics from high-energy details of the inter-nucleon interaction. We examine decoupling quantitatively for two-body observables and few-body binding energies. The universal nature of this decoupling is illustrated and errors from suppressing high-momentum modes above the decoupling scale are shown to be perturbatively small. To explore the SRG evolution of many-body forces, we use as a laboratory a one-dimensional system of bosons with short-range repulsion and mid-range attraction, which emulates realistic nuclear forces. The free-space SRG is implemented for few-body systems in a symmetrized harmonic oscillator basis using a recursive construction analogous to no-core shell model implementations. Building on one-dimensional results we performed the first practical evolution of three-dimensional many-body forces within the No-Core Shell Model basis. Results for the 3H binding energy are consistent with previous calculations involving momentum-space evolution of only two-body forces, and validate expectations from calculations in the one-dimensional oscillator basis. When applied to 4He calculations, the two- and three-body oscillator matrix elements yield rapid convergence of the ground-state energy with a small net contribution of the induced four-body force. The radius of light nuclei is also explored in the three-dimensional basis.

arXiv:0912.2937•Dec 15, 2009•8 citations

Effective-interaction approach to the Fermi hard-sphere system

Angela Mecca, Alessandro Lovato, Omar Benhar A +1 more

The formalism based on correlated basis functions and the cluster-expansion technique has been recently employed to derive an effective interaction from a realistic nuclear Hamiltonian. To gauge the reliability of this scheme, we perform a systematic comparison between the results of its application to the Fermi hard-sphere system and the predictions obtained from low-density expansions, as well as from other many-body techniques. The analysis of a variety of properties, including the ground-state energy, the effective mass, and the momentum distribution, shows that the effective-interaction approach is quite accurate, thus suggesting that it may be employed to achieve a consistent description of the structure and dynamics of nuclear matter in the density region relevant to astrophysical applications.

arXiv:1410.8789•Physical Review C•Mar 24, 2015•9 citations

A phase-free quantum Monte Carlo method for the nuclear shell model

J. Bonnard, Olivier Juillet

The shell model provides a powerful framework for nuclear structure calculations. The nucleons beyond an inert magic core are confined in a valence shell and interact through an effective two-body potential generally determined from the G-matrix method. However, the applicability of the shell model remains limited by the exponential growth of the many-body space with the number of valence nucleons and with the size of the one-body space. The quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods may thus be considered as a potentially attractive alternative to the direct diagonalization of the Hamiltonian matrix. The many-body problem is indeed reduced to a set of stochastic one-body problems describing independent particles in a fluctuating external field. Up to date, the QMC approaches of the shell model lead to the ground-state and the thermodynamic properties, but a detailed spectroscopy of nuclei is not reachable. Furthermore, they suffer from a common pathology of fermionic QMC methods, namely the sign/phase problem, which strongly contaminates the convergence of the calculation. In this context, we will present a new QMC method, providing the "yrast spectroscopy" of nuclei, and in which the sign/phase problem is managed through the constrained path approximation that is widely used in the ab initio nuclear calculations and in condensed matter physics.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations
The contractor renormalization (CORE) method is applied in combination with modern effective-theory techniques to the nuclear many-body problem. A one-dimensional---yet realistic''---nucleon-nucleon potential is introduced to test these novel ideas. It is found that the magnitude of model-space'' (CORE) corrections diminishes considerably when an effective potential that eliminates the hard-momentum components of the potential is first introduced. As a result, accurate predictions for the ground-state energy of the three-body system are made with relatively little computational effort when both techniques are used in a complementary fashion.
The shell model is the standard tool for addressing the canonical nuclear many-body problem of nonrelativistic nucleons interacting through a static potential. We discuss several of the uncontrolled approximations that are made in this model to motivate a different approach, one based on an exact solution of the Bloch-Horowitz equation. We argue that the necessary self-consistent solutions of this equation can be obtained efficiently by a Green's function expansion based on the Lanczos algorithm. The resulting effective theory is carried out for the simplest nuclei, d and 3He, using realistic NN interactions such as the Argonne v18 and Reid93 potentials, in order to contrast the results with the shell model. We discuss the wave function normalization, the evolution of the wave function as the "shell model" space is varied, and the magnetic elastic effective operator. The numerical results show a simple renormalization group behavior that differs from effective field theory treatments of the two- and three-body problems. The likely origin of this scaling is discussed.
A theory is formulated to derive an effective interaction in nuclei in the framework of the unitarymodel-operator approach.A unitary operator is introduced to describe two-body correlations, and it is determined from the condition that the effective interaction should be decoupled between the lowmomentum model space and the high-momentum space.The unitary-transformed Hamiltonian is represented in a cluster expansion form.The one-and two-body cluster terms are mainly discussed.The theory is applied to the calculation of the energies of the ground-and one-body states with the Reid soft core potential.A large gain of the energy has been obtained for the ground state in comparison with the result of the usual G-matrix theory.As for the one-body energies obtained, agreement with the experimental values is fairly good.Although the discrepancies with the experiments still remain at the 1O~ 15 % level, the present approach shows to have some desirable features compared with the nuclear many-body theories proposed so far. § 1. IntroductionA fundamental problem in nuclear physics is to clarify the properties of nuclei in terms of the interaction among their constituent particles.Although there have been many theories or approaches, we have not yet reached the goal of reproducing successfully the experimental data.The investigation of nuclear properties, in the usual nonrelativistic approach, proceeds in two steps: The first one is to determine the interaction among nucleons, and the second is to solve the many-body SchrOdinger equation.Concerning the nucleon-nucleon force, it seems that the phenomenological potential, such as the Reid potential, would be incomplete and one should wait until quark dynamics, probably quantum chromodynamics (QCD), solves finally the problem o~ nuclear force.It is of no doubt that in order to fit the experiments we need more accurate knowledge on the nuclear force including the threebody force.However, if we want to reach the goal, we need also a good many-body theory.Regardless of the accuracy of the nuclear force, we shall not be able to solve the problem unless we have a way of constructing an accurate solution for a many-body system.We believe that many-body theory should share the responsibility for the discrepancy between theory and experiment.It will be sure that nuclear many-body theory is still to be improved.Among many theories for nuclear many-body problem, the most widely applied method is, needless to say, the linked-diagram perturbation theory.This approach may also be referred to as the folded-diagram theory based on the G-matrix interaction especially due 'to Brandow 1l and Kuo et al. 2l An outstanding problem in this approach is the convergence of the perturbation expansion.Since Schucan and Weidenmliller 3 ) pointed out the divergence of the perturbation expansion due to the presence of intruder states, this difficulty has long been a serious problem.Present status of this problem is
We consider two nonperturbative methods originally used to derive shell model effective interactions in nuclei. These methods have been applied to the two nucleon sector to obtain an energy independent effective interaction V_{low k}, which preserves the low momentum half-on-shell T matrix and the deuteron pole, with a sharp cutoff imposed on all intermediate state momenta. We show that V_{low k} scales with the cutoff precisely as one expects from renormalization group arguments. This result is a step towards reformulating traditional model space many-body calculations in the language of effective field theories and the renormalization group. The numerical scaling properties of V_{low k} are observed to be in excellent agreement with our exact renormalization group equation.
The Similarity Renormalization Group (SRG) is investigated as a powerful yet practical method to modify nuclear potentials so as to reduce computational requirements for calculations of observables. The key feature of SRG transformations that leads to computational benefits is the decoupling of low-energy nuclear physics from high-energy details of the inter-nucleon interaction. We examine decoupling quantitatively for two-body observables and few-body binding energies. The universal nature of this decoupling is illustrated and errors from suppressing high-momentum modes above the decoupling scale are shown to be perturbatively small. To explore the SRG evolution of many-body forces, we use as a laboratory a one-dimensional system of bosons with short-range repulsion and mid-range attraction, which emulates realistic nuclear forces. The free-space SRG is implemented for few-body systems in a symmetrized harmonic oscillator basis using a recursive construction analogous to no-core shell model implementations. Building on one-dimensional results we performed the first practical evolution of three-dimensional many-body forces within the No-Core Shell Model basis. Results for the 3H binding energy are consistent with previous calculations involving momentum-space evolution of only two-body forces, and validate expectations from calculations in the one-dimensional oscillator basis. When applied to 4He calculations, the two- and three-body oscillator matrix elements yield rapid convergence of the ground-state energy with a small net contribution of the induced four-body force. The radius of light nuclei is also explored in the three-dimensional basis.
The formalism based on correlated basis functions and the cluster-expansion technique has been recently employed to derive an effective interaction from a realistic nuclear Hamiltonian. To gauge the reliability of this scheme, we perform a systematic comparison between the results of its application to the Fermi hard-sphere system and the predictions obtained from low-density expansions, as well as from other many-body techniques. The analysis of a variety of properties, including the ground-state energy, the effective mass, and the momentum distribution, shows that the effective-interaction approach is quite accurate, thus suggesting that it may be employed to achieve a consistent description of the structure and dynamics of nuclear matter in the density region relevant to astrophysical applications.
The shell model provides a powerful framework for nuclear structure calculations. The nucleons beyond an inert magic core are confined in a valence shell and interact through an effective two-body potential generally determined from the G-matrix method. However, the applicability of the shell model remains limited by the exponential growth of the many-body space with the number of valence nucleons and with the size of the one-body space. The quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods may thus be considered as a potentially attractive alternative to the direct diagonalization of the Hamiltonian matrix. The many-body problem is indeed reduced to a set of stochastic one-body problems describing independent particles in a fluctuating external field. Up to date, the QMC approaches of the shell model lead to the ground-state and the thermodynamic properties, but a detailed spectroscopy of nuclei is not reachable. Furthermore, they suffer from a common pathology of fermionic QMC methods, namely the sign/phase problem, which strongly contaminates the convergence of the calculation. In this context, we will present a new QMC method, providing the "yrast spectroscopy" of nuclei, and in which the sign/phase problem is managed through the constrained path approximation that is widely used in the ab initio nuclear calculations and in condensed matter physics.