Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:math-ph/0412023 · Physical Review Letters

Justification of c -Number Substitutions in Bosonic Hamiltonians

Élliott H. Lieb, Robert Seiringer, Jakob Yngvason

Published Mar 2, 2005• 85 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The validity of substituting a c-number z for the k=0 mode operator a(0) is established rigorously in full generality, thereby verifying one aspect of Bogoliubov's 1947 theory. This substitution not only yields the correct value of thermodynamic quantities such as the pressure or ground state energy, but also the value of |z|(2) that maximizes the partition function equals the true amount of condensation in the presence of a gauge-symmetry-breaking term. This point had previously been elusive.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.94.080401

Related papers

Exactness of the Bogoliubov approximation in random external potentials

Thomas Jaeck, Valentin Anatol'evich Zagrebnov

We investigate the validity of the Bogoliubov c-number approximation in the case of interacting Bose-gas in a homogeneous random media. To take into account the possible occurence of type III generalized Bose–Einstein condensation (i.e., the occurrence of condensation in an infinitesimal band of low kinetic energy modes without macroscopic occupation of any of them) we generalize the c-number substitution procedure to this band of modes with low momentum. We show that, as in the case of the one-mode condensation for translation-invariant interacting systems, this procedure has no effect on the exact value of the pressure in the thermodynamic limit, assuming that the c-numbers are chosen according to a suitable variational principle. We then discuss the relation between these c-numbers and the (total) density of the condensate.

arXiv:1010.0425•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 2010•5 citations

Spontaneous U(1) symmetry breaking and Bose–Einstein condensation

Qian Feng, HUANG HONG-BIN, Qi Guan-Xiao +1 more

Based on Bogoliubov's truncated Hamiltonian H B for a weakly interacting Bose system, and adding a U(1) symmetry breaking term V 1/2 (λ a 0 +λ * a 0 + ) to H B , we show by using the coherent state theory and the mean-field approximation rather than the c-number approximations, that the Bose–Einstein condensation(BEC) occurs if and only if the U(1) symmetry of the system is spontaneously broken. The real ground state energy and the justification of the Bogoliubov c-number substitution are given by solving the Schrödinger eigenvalue equation and using the self-consistent condition.

Chinese Physics•Jul 1, 2006•6 citations

Superfluidity III

N Angelescu, André F. Verbeure, Valentin Anatol'evich Zagrebnov

The theory of Bogoliubov contains the prescription of replacing the ground-state mode by a constant b. In a previous contribution, we showed that the Bogoliubov model was thermodynamically unstable. We stabilized this model by adding `forward scattering' terms. In this paper we exploit the fact that it is not compulsary to take b equal to . We show that if b = c the Bogoliubov theory does not have a satisfactory thermodynamics. We prove that it is possible to make a proper choice of the ground-state mode, i.e. b as a function of c, in order to obtain the correct excitation spectrum and thermodynamically a second-order phase transition, as is compulsory for a theory of superfluidity.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jul 21, 1997•9 citations

Equivalence of Bose-Einstein Condensation and Symmetry Breaking

András Sütö

Based on a classic paper by Ginibre [Commun. Math. Phys. 8, 26 (1968)] it is shown that, whenever Bogoliubov's approximation, that is, the replacement of a(0) and a*(0) by complex numbers in the Hamiltonian, asymptotically yields the right pressure, it also implies the asymptotic equality of |a(0)|(2)/V and a*(0)a(0)/V in symmetry breaking fields, irrespective of the existence or absence of Bose-Einstein condensation. Because the former was proved by Ginibre to hold for absolutely integrable superstable pair interactions, the latter is equally valid in this case. Apart from Ginibre's work, our proof uses only a simple convexity inequality due to Griffiths.

arXiv:math-ph/0412056•Physical Review Letters•Mar 2, 2005•30 citations

The Condensate Replaced by a Number: Bogoliubov's Substitution and Its Self-Priced Error Bar

William Alexander Aldred

In 1947 Nikolai Bogoliubov founded the microscopic theory of superfluidity on a single operation: the zero-momentum mode's operators a_0, a_0^\dagger are replaced by the c-number \sqrt{N_0}, particle-number conservation is broken by hand, the Hamiltonian becomes quadratic, and its diagonalization returns the phonon spectrum E(k) = \sqrt{\epsilon_k^2 + 2gn\epsilon_k} on which superfluidity's microscopic basis stands. The paper's own warrant for the replacement is a size argument — the commutator 1 is small compared with a_0, a_0^* themselves — and a size argument is a regime statement, not a derivation. This paper evaluates the substitution with the theory's own arithmetic on declared inputs: the same diagonalization returns a quantum depletion of 1.682088 percent of the gas outside the condensate at the mildest declared coupling, 4.757664 percent at the central inputs, and 13.456707 percent at the strongest — the substitution's self-evaluated error bar, printed by its own computation — while the c-number discards the condensate mode's number fluctuations (relative spread 0.003333 at the declared central size) and commutator (1/N_0 = 0.000111) by decree, and the discarded third- and fourth-order terms return at the relative scale \sqrt{\gamma} = 0.031623. The spectrum, the sound speed, and superfluidity's basis are the 1947 paper's derivations and stand entire. What is counted here is the derivation status of the step they stand on: 1 c-number substitution carrying the discarded terms it makes necessary, 0 derivations in 1947 of the substitution. Census headline, unchanged: NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL · producing-count 0.

•Nov 6, 2026•0 citations

Bose-Einstein condensation and symmetry breaking

András Sütö

Adding a gauge symmetry breaking field $\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\nu}\sqrt{V}({a}_{0}+{a}_{0}^{*})$ to the Hamiltonian of some simplified models of an interacting Bose gas we compute the condensate density and the symmetry breaking order parameter in the limit of infinite volume and prove Bogoliubov's asymptotic hypothesis ${\mathrm{lim}}_{V\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}}⟨{a}_{0}⟩∕\sqrt{V}=\mathrm{sgn}\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\nu}\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}{\mathrm{lim}}_{V\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}}\sqrt{⟨{a}_{0}^{*}{a}_{0}⟩∕V}$ where the averages are taken in the ground state or in thermal equilibrium states. Letting $\ensuremath{\nu}$ tend to zero in this equation we obtain that Bose-Einstein condensation occurs if and only if the gauge symmetry is spontaneously broken. The simplification consists in dropping the off-diagonal terms in the momentum representation of the pair interaction. The models include the mean field and the imperfect (Huang-Yang-Luttinger) Bose gas. An implication of the result is that the compressibility sum rule cannot hold true in the ground state of the one-dimensional mean-field Bose gas. Our method is based on a resolution of the Hamiltonian into a family of single-mode $(\mathbf{k}=0)$ Hamiltonians and on the analysis of the associated microcanonical ensembles.

arXiv:cond-mat/0412440•Physical Review A•Feb 7, 2005•16 citations
The validity of substituting a c-number z for the k=0 mode operator a(0) is established rigorously in full generality, thereby verifying one aspect of Bogoliubov's 1947 theory. This substitution not only yields the correct value of thermodynamic quantities such as the pressure or ground state energy, but also the value of |z|(2) that maximizes the partition function equals the true amount of condensation in the presence of a gauge-symmetry-breaking term. This point had previously been elusive.
We investigate the validity of the Bogoliubov c-number approximation in the case of interacting Bose-gas in a homogeneous random media. To take into account the possible occurence of type III generalized Bose–Einstein condensation (i.e., the occurrence of condensation in an infinitesimal band of low kinetic energy modes without macroscopic occupation of any of them) we generalize the c-number substitution procedure to this band of modes with low momentum. We show that, as in the case of the one-mode condensation for translation-invariant interacting systems, this procedure has no effect on the exact value of the pressure in the thermodynamic limit, assuming that the c-numbers are chosen according to a suitable variational principle. We then discuss the relation between these c-numbers and the (total) density of the condensate.
Based on Bogoliubov's truncated Hamiltonian H B for a weakly interacting Bose system, and adding a U(1) symmetry breaking term V 1/2 (λ a 0 +λ * a 0 + ) to H B , we show by using the coherent state theory and the mean-field approximation rather than the c-number approximations, that the Bose–Einstein condensation(BEC) occurs if and only if the U(1) symmetry of the system is spontaneously broken. The real ground state energy and the justification of the Bogoliubov c-number substitution are given by solving the Schrödinger eigenvalue equation and using the self-consistent condition.
The theory of Bogoliubov contains the prescription of replacing the ground-state mode by a constant b. In a previous contribution, we showed that the Bogoliubov model was thermodynamically unstable. We stabilized this model by adding `forward scattering' terms. In this paper we exploit the fact that it is not compulsary to take b equal to . We show that if b = c the Bogoliubov theory does not have a satisfactory thermodynamics. We prove that it is possible to make a proper choice of the ground-state mode, i.e. b as a function of c, in order to obtain the correct excitation spectrum and thermodynamically a second-order phase transition, as is compulsory for a theory of superfluidity.
Based on a classic paper by Ginibre [Commun. Math. Phys. 8, 26 (1968)] it is shown that, whenever Bogoliubov's approximation, that is, the replacement of a(0) and a*(0) by complex numbers in the Hamiltonian, asymptotically yields the right pressure, it also implies the asymptotic equality of |a(0)|(2)/V and a*(0)a(0)/V in symmetry breaking fields, irrespective of the existence or absence of Bose-Einstein condensation. Because the former was proved by Ginibre to hold for absolutely integrable superstable pair interactions, the latter is equally valid in this case. Apart from Ginibre's work, our proof uses only a simple convexity inequality due to Griffiths.
In 1947 Nikolai Bogoliubov founded the microscopic theory of superfluidity on a single operation: the zero-momentum mode's operators a_0, a_0^\dagger are replaced by the c-number \sqrt{N_0}, particle-number conservation is broken by hand, the Hamiltonian becomes quadratic, and its diagonalization returns the phonon spectrum E(k) = \sqrt{\epsilon_k^2 + 2gn\epsilon_k} on which superfluidity's microscopic basis stands. The paper's own warrant for the replacement is a size argument — the commutator 1 is small compared with a_0, a_0^* themselves — and a size argument is a regime statement, not a derivation. This paper evaluates the substitution with the theory's own arithmetic on declared inputs: the same diagonalization returns a quantum depletion of 1.682088 percent of the gas outside the condensate at the mildest declared coupling, 4.757664 percent at the central inputs, and 13.456707 percent at the strongest — the substitution's self-evaluated error bar, printed by its own computation — while the c-number discards the condensate mode's number fluctuations (relative spread 0.003333 at the declared central size) and commutator (1/N_0 = 0.000111) by decree, and the discarded third- and fourth-order terms return at the relative scale \sqrt{\gamma} = 0.031623. The spectrum, the sound speed, and superfluidity's basis are the 1947 paper's derivations and stand entire. What is counted here is the derivation status of the step they stand on: 1 c-number substitution carrying the discarded terms it makes necessary, 0 derivations in 1947 of the substitution. Census headline, unchanged: NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL · producing-count 0.
Adding a gauge symmetry breaking field $\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\nu}\sqrt{V}({a}_{0}+{a}_{0}^{*})$ to the Hamiltonian of some simplified models of an interacting Bose gas we compute the condensate density and the symmetry breaking order parameter in the limit of infinite volume and prove Bogoliubov's asymptotic hypothesis ${\mathrm{lim}}_{V\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}}⟨{a}_{0}⟩∕\sqrt{V}=\mathrm{sgn}\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\nu}\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}{\mathrm{lim}}_{V\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}}\sqrt{⟨{a}_{0}^{*}{a}_{0}⟩∕V}$ where the averages are taken in the ground state or in thermal equilibrium states. Letting $\ensuremath{\nu}$ tend to zero in this equation we obtain that Bose-Einstein condensation occurs if and only if the gauge symmetry is spontaneously broken. The simplification consists in dropping the off-diagonal terms in the momentum representation of the pair interaction. The models include the mean field and the imperfect (Huang-Yang-Luttinger) Bose gas. An implication of the result is that the compressibility sum rule cannot hold true in the ground state of the one-dimensional mean-field Bose gas. Our method is based on a resolution of the Hamiltonian into a family of single-mode (k=0)(\mathbf{k}=0)(k=0) Hamiltonians and on the analysis of the associated microcanonical ensembles.