Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

Superfluidity III

N Angelescu, André F. Verbeure, Valentin Anatol'evich Zagrebnov

Published Jul 21, 1997• 9 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The theory of Bogoliubov contains the prescription of replacing the ground-state mode by a constant b. In a previous contribution, we showed that the Bogoliubov model was thermodynamically unstable. We stabilized this model by adding `forward scattering' terms. In this paper we exploit the fact that it is not compulsary to take b equal to . We show that if b = c the Bogoliubov theory does not have a satisfactory thermodynamics. We prove that it is possible to make a proper choice of the ground-state mode, i.e. b as a function of c, in order to obtain the correct excitation spectrum and thermodynamically a second-order phase transition, as is compulsory for a theory of superfluidity.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/30/14/006

Related papers

On Bogoliubov's model of superfluidity

N Angelescu, André F. Verbeure, Valentin Anatol'evich Zagrebnov

The authors point out that the conventional Bogoliubov model contains an attractive effective interaction, putting into question its stability. For positive chemical potentials they show instability, making the model unsuitable for explaining superfluidity from first principles. They present an extended model, yielding rigorously the relevant spectrum for superfluidity.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jun 21, 1992•32 citations

Stability and stabilization of unstable condensates

Doron Cohen

It is possible to condense a macroscopic number of bosons into a single mode. Adding interactions the question arises whether the condensate is stable. For repulsive interaction the answer is positive with regard to the ground-state, but what about a condensation in an excited mode? We discuss some results that have been obtained for a 2-mode bosonic Josephson junction, and for a 3-mode minimal-model of a superfluid circuit. Additionally we mention the possibility to stabilize an unstable condensate by introducing periodic or noisy driving into the system: this is due to the Kapitza and the Zeno effects.

arXiv:1510.02279•Physica Scripta•Oct 1, 2015•0 citations

The Condensate Replaced by a Number: Bogoliubov's Substitution and Its Self-Priced Error Bar

William Alexander Aldred

In 1947 Nikolai Bogoliubov founded the microscopic theory of superfluidity on a single operation: the zero-momentum mode's operators a_0, a_0^\dagger are replaced by the c-number \sqrt{N_0}, particle-number conservation is broken by hand, the Hamiltonian becomes quadratic, and its diagonalization returns the phonon spectrum E(k) = \sqrt{\epsilon_k^2 + 2gn\epsilon_k} on which superfluidity's microscopic basis stands. The paper's own warrant for the replacement is a size argument — the commutator 1 is small compared with a_0, a_0^* themselves — and a size argument is a regime statement, not a derivation. This paper evaluates the substitution with the theory's own arithmetic on declared inputs: the same diagonalization returns a quantum depletion of 1.682088 percent of the gas outside the condensate at the mildest declared coupling, 4.757664 percent at the central inputs, and 13.456707 percent at the strongest — the substitution's self-evaluated error bar, printed by its own computation — while the c-number discards the condensate mode's number fluctuations (relative spread 0.003333 at the declared central size) and commutator (1/N_0 = 0.000111) by decree, and the discarded third- and fourth-order terms return at the relative scale \sqrt{\gamma} = 0.031623. The spectrum, the sound speed, and superfluidity's basis are the 1947 paper's derivations and stand entire. What is counted here is the derivation status of the step they stand on: 1 c-number substitution carrying the discarded terms it makes necessary, 0 derivations in 1947 of the substitution. Census headline, unchanged: NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL · producing-count 0.

•Nov 6, 2026•0 citations

Theory of a Charged Bose Gas. II

Chia-Wei Woo, Shang-keng Ma

The simultaneous effects of the condensate and of the long-range nature of the interaction have made the high-density charged Bose gas an interesting theoretical problem. In this paper we present a straight-forward procedure which takes these effects into account. It is based on the perturbation theory in the Bogoliubov representation and the principle of the compensation of dangerous diagrams. Both the ground-state energy and the excitation spectrum are studied. Numerical results are given for the first two orders in ${{r}_{s}}^{\frac{3}{4}}$. The ground-state energy reduces to that calculated correctly by Brueckner, and earlier by Lee and Feenberg in a variational treatment. The excitation spectrum agrees with that calculated in our preceding paper using an entirely different method.

Physical Review•Jul 5, 1967•27 citations

Ground-state stability and excitation spectrum of a one-dimensional dipolar supersolid

Tobias Ilg, Hans Peter Büchler

We study the behavior of the excitation spectrum across the quantum phase transition from a superfluid to a supersolid phase of a dipolar Bose gas confined to a one-dimensional geometry. Including the leading beyond-mean-field effects within an effective Hamiltonian, the analysis is based on Bogoliubov theory with several order parameters accounting for the superfluid as well as solid structure. We find fast convergence of the ground-state energy in the supersolid with the number of order parameters and demonstrate a stable excitation spectrum with two Goldstone modes and an amplitude mode in the low-energy regime. Our results suggest that there exists an experimentally achievable parameter regime for dysprosium atoms, where the supersolid phase exhibits a stable excitation spectrum in the thermodynamic limit and the transition into the supersolid phase is of second order driven by the roton instability.

arXiv:2211.17178•Physical Review A•Jan 31, 2023•20 citations

Collective Excitation and Stability of Flowing Gapless Fermi Superfluids

Hiroki Yamamura, Daisuke Yamamoto

We study the collective excitation and stability of superfluid Fermi gases flowing with a constant velocity in three-dimensional free space. In particular, we investigate a possible gapless superfluid state induced by the superflow using the mean-field theory and the generalized random-phase approximation (GRPA). For weak attractive interactions, we find that the mean-field superfluid order parameter can take a nonzero value even after the superflow velocity exceeds the threshold for the onset of Bogoliubov quasiparticle excitations. Since the Cooper pairs are only partially broken by the quasiparticle excitations, a gapless superfluid state can be formed over a certain range of superflow velocity above the pair-breaking onset. In addition to the usual quasiparticle-pair continuum and the Anderson-Bogoliubov collective mode, the GRPA excitation spectrum of the gapless superfluid state has a quasiparticle-quasihole continuum and a second collective mode. We find that the long-wavelength excitations of the second collective mode eventually cause dynamical instability of the system when the superflow velocity increases. However, the gapless superfluid state still remains stable in a narrow but finite range of superflow velocity.

arXiv:1403.5621•Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Mar 19, 2015•6 citations
The theory of Bogoliubov contains the prescription of replacing the ground-state mode by a constant b. In a previous contribution, we showed that the Bogoliubov model was thermodynamically unstable. We stabilized this model by adding `forward scattering' terms. In this paper we exploit the fact that it is not compulsary to take b equal to . We show that if b = c the Bogoliubov theory does not have a satisfactory thermodynamics. We prove that it is possible to make a proper choice of the ground-state mode, i.e. b as a function of c, in order to obtain the correct excitation spectrum and thermodynamically a second-order phase transition, as is compulsory for a theory of superfluidity.
It is possible to condense a macroscopic number of bosons into a single mode. Adding interactions the question arises whether the condensate is stable. For repulsive interaction the answer is positive with regard to the ground-state, but what about a condensation in an excited mode? We discuss some results that have been obtained for a 2-mode bosonic Josephson junction, and for a 3-mode minimal-model of a superfluid circuit. Additionally we mention the possibility to stabilize an unstable condensate by introducing periodic or noisy driving into the system: this is due to the Kapitza and the Zeno effects.
In 1947 Nikolai Bogoliubov founded the microscopic theory of superfluidity on a single operation: the zero-momentum mode's operators a_0, a_0^\dagger are replaced by the c-number \sqrt{N_0}, particle-number conservation is broken by hand, the Hamiltonian becomes quadratic, and its diagonalization returns the phonon spectrum E(k) = \sqrt{\epsilon_k^2 + 2gn\epsilon_k} on which superfluidity's microscopic basis stands. The paper's own warrant for the replacement is a size argument — the commutator 1 is small compared with a_0, a_0^* themselves — and a size argument is a regime statement, not a derivation. This paper evaluates the substitution with the theory's own arithmetic on declared inputs: the same diagonalization returns a quantum depletion of 1.682088 percent of the gas outside the condensate at the mildest declared coupling, 4.757664 percent at the central inputs, and 13.456707 percent at the strongest — the substitution's self-evaluated error bar, printed by its own computation — while the c-number discards the condensate mode's number fluctuations (relative spread 0.003333 at the declared central size) and commutator (1/N_0 = 0.000111) by decree, and the discarded third- and fourth-order terms return at the relative scale \sqrt{\gamma} = 0.031623. The spectrum, the sound speed, and superfluidity's basis are the 1947 paper's derivations and stand entire. What is counted here is the derivation status of the step they stand on: 1 c-number substitution carrying the discarded terms it makes necessary, 0 derivations in 1947 of the substitution. Census headline, unchanged: NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL · producing-count 0.
The simultaneous effects of the condensate and of the long-range nature of the interaction have made the high-density charged Bose gas an interesting theoretical problem. In this paper we present a straight-forward procedure which takes these effects into account. It is based on the perturbation theory in the Bogoliubov representation and the principle of the compensation of dangerous diagrams. Both the ground-state energy and the excitation spectrum are studied. Numerical results are given for the first two orders in rs34{{r}_{s}}^{\frac{3}{4}}rs​43​. The ground-state energy reduces to that calculated correctly by Brueckner, and earlier by Lee and Feenberg in a variational treatment. The excitation spectrum agrees with that calculated in our preceding paper using an entirely different method.
We study the behavior of the excitation spectrum across the quantum phase transition from a superfluid to a supersolid phase of a dipolar Bose gas confined to a one-dimensional geometry. Including the leading beyond-mean-field effects within an effective Hamiltonian, the analysis is based on Bogoliubov theory with several order parameters accounting for the superfluid as well as solid structure. We find fast convergence of the ground-state energy in the supersolid with the number of order parameters and demonstrate a stable excitation spectrum with two Goldstone modes and an amplitude mode in the low-energy regime. Our results suggest that there exists an experimentally achievable parameter regime for dysprosium atoms, where the supersolid phase exhibits a stable excitation spectrum in the thermodynamic limit and the transition into the supersolid phase is of second order driven by the roton instability.
We study the collective excitation and stability of superfluid Fermi gases flowing with a constant velocity in three-dimensional free space. In particular, we investigate a possible gapless superfluid state induced by the superflow using the mean-field theory and the generalized random-phase approximation (GRPA). For weak attractive interactions, we find that the mean-field superfluid order parameter can take a nonzero value even after the superflow velocity exceeds the threshold for the onset of Bogoliubov quasiparticle excitations. Since the Cooper pairs are only partially broken by the quasiparticle excitations, a gapless superfluid state can be formed over a certain range of superflow velocity above the pair-breaking onset. In addition to the usual quasiparticle-pair continuum and the Anderson-Bogoliubov collective mode, the GRPA excitation spectrum of the gapless superfluid state has a quasiparticle-quasihole continuum and a second collective mode. We find that the long-wavelength excitations of the second collective mode eventually cause dynamical instability of the system when the superflow velocity increases. However, the gapless superfluid state still remains stable in a narrow but finite range of superflow velocity.