Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:hep-th/9907059

The principle of symmetric bracket invariance as the origin of first and second quantization

Theodore Garavaglia, Steven Kenneth Kauffmann

Published Jul 8, 1999• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The principle of invariance of the c-number symmetric bracket is used to derive both the quantum operator commutator relation $[\hat q, \hat p]=i\hbar$ and the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. A c-number dynamical equation is found which leads to the second quantized field theory of bosons and fermions.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.hep-th/9907059

Related papers

Principle of Symmetric Bracket Invariance as the Origin of First and Second Quantization

Theodore Garavaglia, Steven Kenneth Kauffmann

International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Apr 1, 2002•0 citations

The Schrödinger equation written in the second quantization formalism: derivation from first principles

Olavo Leopoldino da Silva Filho, S S João Augusto, Marcello Caio Ramon e Barros Ferreira

Courses about Quantum Mechanics are generally developed at the level of the mathematical formalism, its syntactic level, seldom treating the interpretation of the theory, its semantic level. In the majority of cases, this first formal approach is not followed by any other course addressing the numerous interpretations of the theory. It has become apparent that this strategy leads to a deficit in the professional formation of the students, exceedingly driving them to technical areas of application of Quantum Mechanics. However, applications such as those on quantum computing and entanglement, as they become more and more encrusted in the deepest foundations of the theory, are asking more and more for the development of this kind of ability. In this paper we develop an approach to deal with second quantization in the realm of Quantum Mechanics. We show that the second quantization Schrodinger equation can be mathematically derived from a classical Hamiltonian written in the phase space $(Q,P)$, obtained by a canonical transformation upon the original phase space $(q,p)$, using an axiomatic quantization procedure developed elsewhere. We apply this quantization process to a bosonic system, modelled by the harmonic oscillator problem. We then make reverse engineering to show that Schwinger's second quantization approach to fermionic systems furnishes the path to derive a Schrodinger equation explicitly written in terms of the usual momenta and positions operators $(\hat{q},\hat{p})$ for such systems. Finally, we use these mathematical developments to address the commonly accepted statement that 'the spin has no classical analog'.

Revista do Professor de Física•Apr 17, 2021•0 citations

Quantization of Fields and Second Quantization

Avinash Sharma

Essential contents on quantization of fields and second quantization, which are necessary for undergraduate and graduate level, are presented in this chapter. An innovative approach is used for the presentations and the discussions on field quantization and second quantization for systems of Bosons and Fermions. The chapter covers field operators, the procedure of second quantization and its use for the Schrödinger equation for both Bosons and Fermions, matrix representation of Fermionic operators, number operators for both Bosons and Fermions, and systems of weakly interacting Bosons and Fermions. A good number of solved examples and unsolved exercises clarify the basic concepts behind quantization of fields and second quantization.

CRC Press eBooks•Jun 18, 2021•0 citations

The Theory of Quantized Fields. I

Julian Schwinger

The conventional correspondence basis for quantum dynamics is here replaced by a self-contained quantum dynamical principle from which the equations of motion and the commutation relations can be deduced. The theory is developed in terms of the model supplied by localizable fields. A short review is first presented of the general quantum-mechanical scheme of operators and eigenvectors, in which emphasis is placed on the differential characterization of representatives and transformation functions by means of infinitesimal unitary transformations. The fundamental dynamical principle is stated as a variational equation for the transformation function connecting eigenvectors associated with different spacelike surfaces, which describes the temporal development of the system. The generator of the infinitesimal transformation is the variation of the action integral operator, the spacetime volume integral of the invariant lagrange function operator. The invariance of the lagrange function preserves the form of the dynamical principle under coordinate transformations, with the exception of those transformations which include a reversal in the positive sense of time, where a separate discussion is necessary. It will be shown in Sec. III that the requirement of invariance under time reflection imposes a restriction upon the operator properties of fields, which is simply the connection between the spin and statistics of particles. For a given dynamical system, changes in the transformation function arise only from alterations of the eigenvectors associated with the two surfaces, as generated by operators constructed from field variables attached to those surfaces. This yields the operator principle of stationary action, from which the equations of motion are obtained. Commutation relations are derived from the generating operator associated with a given surface. In particular, canonical commutation relations are obtained for those field components that are not restricted by equations of constraint. The surface generating operator also leads to generalized Schr\"odinger equations for the representative of an arbitrary state. Action integral variations which correspond to changing the dynamical system are discussed briefly. A method for constructing the transformation function is described, in a form appropriate to an integral spin field, which involves solving Hamilton-Jacobi equations for ordered operators. In Sec. III, the exceptional nature of time reflection is indicated by the remark that the charge and the energy-momentum vector behave as a pseudoscalar and pseudovector, respectively, for time reflection transformations. This shows, incidentally, that positive and negative charge must occur symmetrically in a completely covariant theory. The contrast between the pseudo energy-momentum vector and the proper displacement vector then indicates that time reflection cannot be described within the unitary transformation framework. This appears most fundamentally in the basic dynamical principle. It is important to recognize here that the contributions to the lagrange function of half-integral spin fields behave like pseudoscalars with respect to time reflection. The non-unitary transformation required to represent time reflection is found to be the replacement of a state vector by its dual, or complex conjugate vector, together with the transposition of all operators. The fundamental dynamical principle is then invariant under time reflection if inverting the order of all operators in the lagrange function leaves an integral spin contribution unaltered, and reverses the sign of a half-integral spin contribution. This implies the essential commutativity, or anti-commutativity, of integral and half-integral field components, respectively, which is the connection between spin and statistics.

Physical Review•Jun 15, 1951•1,002 citations

The physical origin of Schrödinger equation

Xiao-Bo Yan

Abstract Quantum mechanics is one of the basic theories of modern physics. Here, the famous Schrödinger equation and the differential operators representing mechanical quantities in quantum mechanics are derived, just based on the principle that the translation invariance (symmetry) of a system in Hamiltonian mechanics should be preserved in quantum mechanics. Moreover, according to the form of the differential operators, the commutation relation in quantum mechanics between the generalized coordinate and the generalized momentum can be directly obtained. We believe that the results in this paper are very useful for understanding the physical origin of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2106.01312•European Journal of Physics•Apr 9, 2021•2 citations

Quantum dynamics

In this chapter, we derived some elements of quantum mechanics, which are essential for the further development of our theory: the momentum of a system of Fermions in the second quantization, the coordinate and momentum of a harmonic oscillator as a unique operator at two different moments of time, Boson and Fermion operator algebra, coherent states, the electron-field interaction, the quantization of the electromagnetic field, Boson and Fermion distributions, and densities of states in a degenerate, or a non-degenerate system of Fermions. Our starting point is the wave nature of a quantum particle, the Hamiltonian equations were obtained as group velocities in the two conjugate spaces of the wave, of the coordinates and of the momentum. In this way, the Schr¨odinger equation and the electron-field potential of interaction are obtained from quantum equations generated by the particle wave function.

BENTHAM SCIENCE PUBLISHERS eBooks•Dec 17, 2014•0 citations
The principle of invariance of the c-number symmetric bracket is used to derive both the quantum operator commutator relation [q^,p^]=iℏ[\hat q, \hat p]=i\hbar[q^​,p^​]=iℏ and the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. A c-number dynamical equation is found which leads to the second quantized field theory of bosons and fermions.
Courses about Quantum Mechanics are generally developed at the level of the mathematical formalism, its syntactic level, seldom treating the interpretation of the theory, its semantic level. In the majority of cases, this first formal approach is not followed by any other course addressing the numerous interpretations of the theory. It has become apparent that this strategy leads to a deficit in the professional formation of the students, exceedingly driving them to technical areas of application of Quantum Mechanics. However, applications such as those on quantum computing and entanglement, as they become more and more encrusted in the deepest foundations of the theory, are asking more and more for the development of this kind of ability. In this paper we develop an approach to deal with second quantization in the realm of Quantum Mechanics. We show that the second quantization Schrodinger equation can be mathematically derived from a classical Hamiltonian written in the phase space (Q,P)(Q,P)(Q,P), obtained by a canonical transformation upon the original phase space (q,p)(q,p)(q,p), using an axiomatic quantization procedure developed elsewhere. We apply this quantization process to a bosonic system, modelled by the harmonic oscillator problem. We then make reverse engineering to show that Schwinger's second quantization approach to fermionic systems furnishes the path to derive a Schrodinger equation explicitly written in terms of the usual momenta and positions operators (q^,p^)(\hat{q},\hat{p})(q^​,p^​) for such systems. Finally, we use these mathematical developments to address the commonly accepted statement that 'the spin has no classical analog'.
Essential contents on quantization of fields and second quantization, which are necessary for undergraduate and graduate level, are presented in this chapter. An innovative approach is used for the presentations and the discussions on field quantization and second quantization for systems of Bosons and Fermions. The chapter covers field operators, the procedure of second quantization and its use for the Schrödinger equation for both Bosons and Fermions, matrix representation of Fermionic operators, number operators for both Bosons and Fermions, and systems of weakly interacting Bosons and Fermions. A good number of solved examples and unsolved exercises clarify the basic concepts behind quantization of fields and second quantization.
The conventional correspondence basis for quantum dynamics is here replaced by a self-contained quantum dynamical principle from which the equations of motion and the commutation relations can be deduced. The theory is developed in terms of the model supplied by localizable fields. A short review is first presented of the general quantum-mechanical scheme of operators and eigenvectors, in which emphasis is placed on the differential characterization of representatives and transformation functions by means of infinitesimal unitary transformations. The fundamental dynamical principle is stated as a variational equation for the transformation function connecting eigenvectors associated with different spacelike surfaces, which describes the temporal development of the system. The generator of the infinitesimal transformation is the variation of the action integral operator, the spacetime volume integral of the invariant lagrange function operator. The invariance of the lagrange function preserves the form of the dynamical principle under coordinate transformations, with the exception of those transformations which include a reversal in the positive sense of time, where a separate discussion is necessary. It will be shown in Sec. III that the requirement of invariance under time reflection imposes a restriction upon the operator properties of fields, which is simply the connection between the spin and statistics of particles. For a given dynamical system, changes in the transformation function arise only from alterations of the eigenvectors associated with the two surfaces, as generated by operators constructed from field variables attached to those surfaces. This yields the operator principle of stationary action, from which the equations of motion are obtained. Commutation relations are derived from the generating operator associated with a given surface. In particular, canonical commutation relations are obtained for those field components that are not restricted by equations of constraint. The surface generating operator also leads to generalized Schr\"odinger equations for the representative of an arbitrary state. Action integral variations which correspond to changing the dynamical system are discussed briefly. A method for constructing the transformation function is described, in a form appropriate to an integral spin field, which involves solving Hamilton-Jacobi equations for ordered operators. In Sec. III, the exceptional nature of time reflection is indicated by the remark that the charge and the energy-momentum vector behave as a pseudoscalar and pseudovector, respectively, for time reflection transformations. This shows, incidentally, that positive and negative charge must occur symmetrically in a completely covariant theory. The contrast between the pseudo energy-momentum vector and the proper displacement vector then indicates that time reflection cannot be described within the unitary transformation framework. This appears most fundamentally in the basic dynamical principle. It is important to recognize here that the contributions to the lagrange function of half-integral spin fields behave like pseudoscalars with respect to time reflection. The non-unitary transformation required to represent time reflection is found to be the replacement of a state vector by its dual, or complex conjugate vector, together with the transposition of all operators. The fundamental dynamical principle is then invariant under time reflection if inverting the order of all operators in the lagrange function leaves an integral spin contribution unaltered, and reverses the sign of a half-integral spin contribution. This implies the essential commutativity, or anti-commutativity, of integral and half-integral field components, respectively, which is the connection between spin and statistics.
Abstract Quantum mechanics is one of the basic theories of modern physics. Here, the famous Schrödinger equation and the differential operators representing mechanical quantities in quantum mechanics are derived, just based on the principle that the translation invariance (symmetry) of a system in Hamiltonian mechanics should be preserved in quantum mechanics. Moreover, according to the form of the differential operators, the commutation relation in quantum mechanics between the generalized coordinate and the generalized momentum can be directly obtained. We believe that the results in this paper are very useful for understanding the physical origin of quantum mechanics.
In this chapter, we derived some elements of quantum mechanics, which are essential for the further development of our theory: the momentum of a system of Fermions in the second quantization, the coordinate and momentum of a harmonic oscillator as a unique operator at two different moments of time, Boson and Fermion operator algebra, coherent states, the electron-field interaction, the quantization of the electromagnetic field, Boson and Fermion distributions, and densities of states in a degenerate, or a non-degenerate system of Fermions. Our starting point is the wave nature of a quantum particle, the Hamiltonian equations were obtained as group velocities in the two conjugate spaces of the wave, of the coordinates and of the momentum. In this way, the Schr¨odinger equation and the electron-field potential of interaction are obtained from quantum equations generated by the particle wave function.