We point out an error in recent work by Pao, Wu, and Yip [Phys. Rev. B 73, 132506 (2006)], that stems from their use of a necessary but not sufficient condition [positive compressibility (magnetic susceptibility) and superfluid stiffness] for the stability of the ground state of a polarized Fermi gas. As a result, for a range of detunings their proposed ground-state solution is a local maximum rather than a minimum of the ground state energy, which thereby invalidates their proposed phase diagram for resonantly interacting fermions under an imposed population difference.
In a recent Comment, Perali, Pieri, and Strinati [Phys. Rev. B 68, 066501 (2003)] came forward with a correction to the work of Soares et al. [Phys. Rev. B 65, 174506 (2002)], in the sense that they correctly found no nonpairing region in the density vs coupling diagram of the two-dimensional attractive Hubbard model for a d-wave symmetry for the order parameter. But, the BCS-Bose-Einstein crossover diagram also changes, a point missed by Perali, Pieri, and Strinati in their Comment. Furthermore, they use an analytical treatment of the gap equation to find the order parameter as C function of interaction strength, namely, $\ensuremath{\Delta}/4t$ vs
V/4t. We point out that this treatment is not completely correct for the evaluation of the chemical potential, $\ensuremath{\mu}/4t$ vs
V/4t, when we include the Debye frequency, ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{D}/4t,$ and their cutoff frequency, ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{o}.$ As a consequence, the phase diagram, namely, n vs
V/4t, strongly depends on the value of ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{D}/4t,$ i.e., for small values of ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{D}/4t$ the phase diagram moves to higher values of
V/4t.The work by Soares et al. [Phys. Rev. B 65, 174506 (2002)] investigates the BCS to Bose-Einstein crossover for d-wave pairing in the two-dimensional attractive Hubbard model. Contrary to their claims, we found that a nonpairing region does not exist in the density vs coupling phase diagram. The gap parameter at
T=0, as obtained by solving analytically as well as numerically the BCS equations, is in fact finite for any nonzero density and coupling, even in the weak-coupling regime.
We discuss the BCS-BEC crossover in a degenerate Fermi gas of two hyperfine states interacting close to a Feshbach resonance. We show that, by including fluctuation contributions to the free energy similar to that considered by Nozières and Schmitt-Rink, the character of the superfluid phase transition continuously changes from the BCS-type to the BEC-type, as the threshold of the quasimolecular band is lowered. In the BEC regime, the superfluid phase transition is interpreted in terms of molecules associated with both the Feshbach resonance and Cooper pairing.