Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0307259 · Science

Radio-Frequency Spectroscopy of Ultracold Fermions

Subhadeep Gupta, Zoran Hadzibabic, Martin W. Zwierlein, Claudiu A. Stan, Kai Dieckmann, Christian H. Schunck, E. G. M. van Kempen, BOUDEWIJN J. VERHAAR, Wolfgang Ketterle

Published May 13, 2003• 293 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Radio-frequency techniques were used to study ultracold fermions. We observed the absence of mean-field "clock" shifts, the dominant source of systematic error in current atomic clocks based on bosonic atoms. This absence is a direct consequence of fermionic antisymmetry. Resonance shifts proportional to interaction strengths were observed in a three-level system. However, in the strongly interacting regime, these shifts became very small, reflecting the quantum unitarity limit and many-body effects. This insight into an interacting Fermi gas is relevant for the quest to observe superfluidity in this system.

DOI
10.1126/science.1085335

Related papers

Radio-frequency spectroscopy of ultracold atomic Fermigases; Radiofrequency spectroscopy of strongly interactingFermions

André Schirotzek

This thesis presents experiments investigating the phase diagram of ultracold atomic Fermi gases using radio-frequency spectroscopy. The tunability of many experimental parameters including the temperature, the interparticle interaction strength and the relative population of different Fermions allows to access very different physical regimes. Radio-frequency spectroscopy has been developed into an ideal tool to probe correlations between particles in these different phases. In particular, radio-frequency spectroscopy of highly population imbalanced atomic Fermi systems gives access to the impurity problem: A single Fermion, or Boson, immersed in a sea of Fermions constitutes a polaron, which can be described by Landau's Fermi liquid theory. A critical interaction strength can be identified separating the regime of a fermionic polaron and a bosonic polaron. Radio-frequency spectroscopy of the polarized superfluid phase allows an accurate measure of the superfluid gap [Delta] and allows to identify the importance of Hartree Mean-field energies. Furthermore, it is shown how these different physical regimes are connected.

•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Radio-frequency spectroscopy of atomic fermi gas

J. J. Kinnunen

This thesis studies radio-frequency spectroscopy of superfluid alkali Fermi gases. Radio-frequency and laser fields provide a coherent and well understood tool for manipulating atomic gases. However, new phenomena are expected and have already been seen experimentally when the alkali atoms become strongly interacting. Here we use a simple perturbative treatment of the atom-rf-field coupling for studying the spectroscopy of a strongly interacting gas. At ultracold temperatures fermionic atoms become paired in analogy to electrons in superconductors. The resulting binding energy, or the pairing gap, can be observed as a shift in the radio-frequency spectrum. With strong interactions, the fermions begin pairing already above the critical superfluid transition temperature. The radio-frequency spectroscopy grants a way to study these fluctuation effects quantitatively. The inhomogeneous trapping potential of the atom cloud also adds its own flavour, resulting in distinct mesoscopic effects in the radio-frequency spectra. Our theoretical models are in very good agreement with the experimental results. First order perturbation theory provides qualitatively correct lineshapes, and our generalised perturbative approach gives quantitatively correct magnitudes for the transfer rates. The inhomogeneity plays an important part also in more exotic systems in which the simple BCS-type pairing of atoms is prevented by polarising the gas. Superfluidity and phase separation in such spin-imbalanced gases has been experimentally observed. We have suggested the use of radio-frequency spectroscopy for observing exotic polarised superfluid states, present at the edges of the atom cloud.

•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

Experiments with Degenerate Bose and Fermi Gases

Subhadeep Gupta

Two sets of studies are described in this thesis. In the first set, an atom interferometry technique was developed for the measurement of the fine structure constant using a BoseEinstein Condensate. In the second set, degenerate Fermi gases were prepared and their properties explored in a regime of strong interactions. We have developed an atom interferometer which is capable of measuring with high precision the “photon recoil frequency” (ωrec). ωrec corresponds to the kinetic energy of an atom recoiling due to absorption of a photon. ωrec can be used to determine the quantity h/matom and the fine structure constant, α. A preliminary measurement using a 23Na BoseEinstein Condensate yielded ωrec with a precision of 7 × 10−6 which deviated by 2 × 10−4 from the currently accepted value. Plausible upgrades to the apparatus should produce a precision of 10−9 which would bring within reach a measurement of h/matom and α in the 10−9 range. Such accuracy would be of considerable scientific and metrological import. A quantum degenerate gas of 6Li fermions was produced by sympathetic cooling with 23Na bosons in a two-species atom trapping apparatus. The cooling strategy was optimized to enable production of fermions with atom numbers up to 7 × 107 at half the Fermi temperature (TF ), or temperatures down to 0.05TF ∼ 100 nK with 3× 107 atoms. We can also produce degenerate Bose-Fermi mixtures with several million atoms in each species. We studied the behavior of mixtures of fermi gases in regimes of strong interactions near “Feshbach” resonances. A study of system stability enabled the experimental observation of two such Feshbach resonances. We carried out a theoretical study to interpret the observation (by many experimental groups) of hydrodynamic behavior of fermi gases during expansion out of an atom trap in a strongly-interacting regime. The study concluded that this behavior was not a qualitative signature of fermionic superfluidity and could arise from classical collisions. Finally, radio-frequency (RF) spectroscopy was used to probe interaction in 6Li. We demonstrated the absence of mean field “clock” shifts of RF transitions in a two-(spin)state fermion system. Using a three-state system, we measured the interaction strength between different spin states. The measurements near Feshbach resonances indicate a saturation of the interaction strength at a large negative value. This result is of relevance in the continuing quest for fermionic superfluidity in atomic gases. Thesis Supervisor: David E. Pritchard Title: Cecil and Ida Green Professor of Physics Thesis Supervisor: Wolfgang Ketterle Title: John D. MacArthur Professor of Physics

•Jan 1, 2003•3 citations

High-temperature pairing in a strongly interacting two-dimensional Fermi gas

Puneet A. Murthy, M. Neidig, Ralf Klemt +7 more

The nature of the normal phase of strongly correlated fermionic systems is an outstanding question in quantum many-body physics. We used spatially resolved radio-frequency spectroscopy to measure pairing energy of fermions across a wide range of temperatures and interaction strengths in a two-dimensional gas of ultracold fermionic atoms. We observed many-body pairing at temperatures far above the critical temperature for superfluidity. In the strongly interacting regime, the pairing energy in the normal phase considerably exceeds the intrinsic two-body binding energy of the system and shows a clear dependence on local density. This implies that pairing in this regime is driven by many-body correlations, rather than two-body physics. Our findings show that pairing correlations in strongly interacting two-dimensional fermionic systems are remarkably robust against thermal fluctuations.

arXiv:1705.10577•Science•Dec 21, 2017•51 citations

Interacting Ultracold Alkali Atomic Fermion Gases and Radio-Frequency Spectroscopy

Zhenhua Yu

The last chapter focuses on radio-frequency spectroscopy of multi component fermion gases. Rf experiments of 6Li and 40K are first reviewed. We show that rf experiments essentially measure spin correlation functions, and internal symmetries of the interparticle interactions constrain the rf spectrum through sum rules. We self-consistently generate the spin correlation functions for 6Li within Hartree-Fock-BCS approximation. Our calculation reproduces the mean field shift observed in experiments for normal gases, and confirms that a second peak detected at higher frequencies in the rf spectrum at sufficiently low temperatures arises from paired fermions. We define a mean frequency shift by the sum rules, and show that it is proportional to the square of BCS pairing gap. The discrepancy between the mean shift and the peak frequency shift observed in experiment for the condensed phase lies in the broad width of the rf spectrum function.

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Theory of radio frequency spectroscopy experiments in ultracold Fermi gases and their relation to photoemission in the cuprates

Qijin Chen, Yan He, Chih-Chun Chien +1 more

In this paper we present an overview of radio frequency (RF) spectroscopy in the atomic Fermi superfluids. An ultimate goal is to suggest new directions in the cold gas research agenda from the condensed matter perspective.Our focus is on the experimental and theoretical literature of cold gases and photoemission spectroscopy of the cuprates particularly as it pertains to areas of overlap. This paper contains a systematic overview of the theory of RF spectroscopy, both momentum integrated and momentum resolved. We discuss the effects of traps, population imbalance, final state interactions over the entire range of temperatures and compare theory and experiment. We show that this broad range of phenomena can be accomodated within the BCS-Leggett description of BCS-BEC crossover and that this scheme also captures some of the central observations in photoemission experiments in the cuprates. In this last context, we note that the key themes which have emerged in cuprate photoemission studies involve characterization of the fermionic self energy, of the pseudogap and of the effects of superconducting coherence (in passing from above to below the superfluid transition temperature, $T_c$).These issues have a counterpart in the cold Fermi gases and it would be most useful in future to use these atomic systems to address these and the more sweeping question of how to describe that anomalous superfluid phase which forms in the presence of a normal state excitation gap.

arXiv:0810.1940•Reports on Progress in Physics•Oct 22, 2009•47 citations
Radio-frequency techniques were used to study ultracold fermions. We observed the absence of mean-field "clock" shifts, the dominant source of systematic error in current atomic clocks based on bosonic atoms. This absence is a direct consequence of fermionic antisymmetry. Resonance shifts proportional to interaction strengths were observed in a three-level system. However, in the strongly interacting regime, these shifts became very small, reflecting the quantum unitarity limit and many-body effects. This insight into an interacting Fermi gas is relevant for the quest to observe superfluidity in this system.
This thesis presents experiments investigating the phase diagram of ultracold atomic Fermi gases using radio-frequency spectroscopy. The tunability of many experimental parameters including the temperature, the interparticle interaction strength and the relative population of different Fermions allows to access very different physical regimes. Radio-frequency spectroscopy has been developed into an ideal tool to probe correlations between particles in these different phases. In particular, radio-frequency spectroscopy of highly population imbalanced atomic Fermi systems gives access to the impurity problem: A single Fermion, or Boson, immersed in a sea of Fermions constitutes a polaron, which can be described by Landau's Fermi liquid theory. A critical interaction strength can be identified separating the regime of a fermionic polaron and a bosonic polaron. Radio-frequency spectroscopy of the polarized superfluid phase allows an accurate measure of the superfluid gap [Delta] and allows to identify the importance of Hartree Mean-field energies. Furthermore, it is shown how these different physical regimes are connected.
This thesis studies radio-frequency spectroscopy of superfluid alkali Fermi gases. Radio-frequency and laser fields provide a coherent and well understood tool for manipulating atomic gases. However, new phenomena are expected and have already been seen experimentally when the alkali atoms become strongly interacting. Here we use a simple perturbative treatment of the atom-rf-field coupling for studying the spectroscopy of a strongly interacting gas. At ultracold temperatures fermionic atoms become paired in analogy to electrons in superconductors. The resulting binding energy, or the pairing gap, can be observed as a shift in the radio-frequency spectrum. With strong interactions, the fermions begin pairing already above the critical superfluid transition temperature. The radio-frequency spectroscopy grants a way to study these fluctuation effects quantitatively. The inhomogeneous trapping potential of the atom cloud also adds its own flavour, resulting in distinct mesoscopic effects in the radio-frequency spectra. Our theoretical models are in very good agreement with the experimental results. First order perturbation theory provides qualitatively correct lineshapes, and our generalised perturbative approach gives quantitatively correct magnitudes for the transfer rates. The inhomogeneity plays an important part also in more exotic systems in which the simple BCS-type pairing of atoms is prevented by polarising the gas. Superfluidity and phase separation in such spin-imbalanced gases has been experimentally observed. We have suggested the use of radio-frequency spectroscopy for observing exotic polarised superfluid states, present at the edges of the atom cloud.
Two sets of studies are described in this thesis. In the first set, an atom interferometry technique was developed for the measurement of the fine structure constant using a BoseEinstein Condensate. In the second set, degenerate Fermi gases were prepared and their properties explored in a regime of strong interactions. We have developed an atom interferometer which is capable of measuring with high precision the “photon recoil frequency” (ωrec). ωrec corresponds to the kinetic energy of an atom recoiling due to absorption of a photon. ωrec can be used to determine the quantity h/matom and the fine structure constant, α. A preliminary measurement using a 23Na BoseEinstein Condensate yielded ωrec with a precision of 7 × 10−6 which deviated by 2 × 10−4 from the currently accepted value. Plausible upgrades to the apparatus should produce a precision of 10−9 which would bring within reach a measurement of h/matom and α in the 10−9 range. Such accuracy would be of considerable scientific and metrological import. A quantum degenerate gas of 6Li fermions was produced by sympathetic cooling with 23Na bosons in a two-species atom trapping apparatus. The cooling strategy was optimized to enable production of fermions with atom numbers up to 7 × 107 at half the Fermi temperature (TF ), or temperatures down to 0.05TF ∼ 100 nK with 3× 107 atoms. We can also produce degenerate Bose-Fermi mixtures with several million atoms in each species. We studied the behavior of mixtures of fermi gases in regimes of strong interactions near “Feshbach” resonances. A study of system stability enabled the experimental observation of two such Feshbach resonances. We carried out a theoretical study to interpret the observation (by many experimental groups) of hydrodynamic behavior of fermi gases during expansion out of an atom trap in a strongly-interacting regime. The study concluded that this behavior was not a qualitative signature of fermionic superfluidity and could arise from classical collisions. Finally, radio-frequency (RF) spectroscopy was used to probe interaction in 6Li. We demonstrated the absence of mean field “clock” shifts of RF transitions in a two-(spin)state fermion system. Using a three-state system, we measured the interaction strength between different spin states. The measurements near Feshbach resonances indicate a saturation of the interaction strength at a large negative value. This result is of relevance in the continuing quest for fermionic superfluidity in atomic gases. Thesis Supervisor: David E. Pritchard Title: Cecil and Ida Green Professor of Physics Thesis Supervisor: Wolfgang Ketterle Title: John D. MacArthur Professor of Physics
The nature of the normal phase of strongly correlated fermionic systems is an outstanding question in quantum many-body physics. We used spatially resolved radio-frequency spectroscopy to measure pairing energy of fermions across a wide range of temperatures and interaction strengths in a two-dimensional gas of ultracold fermionic atoms. We observed many-body pairing at temperatures far above the critical temperature for superfluidity. In the strongly interacting regime, the pairing energy in the normal phase considerably exceeds the intrinsic two-body binding energy of the system and shows a clear dependence on local density. This implies that pairing in this regime is driven by many-body correlations, rather than two-body physics. Our findings show that pairing correlations in strongly interacting two-dimensional fermionic systems are remarkably robust against thermal fluctuations.
The last chapter focuses on radio-frequency spectroscopy of multi component fermion gases. Rf experiments of 6Li and 40K are first reviewed. We show that rf experiments essentially measure spin correlation functions, and internal symmetries of the interparticle interactions constrain the rf spectrum through sum rules. We self-consistently generate the spin correlation functions for 6Li within Hartree-Fock-BCS approximation. Our calculation reproduces the mean field shift observed in experiments for normal gases, and confirms that a second peak detected at higher frequencies in the rf spectrum at sufficiently low temperatures arises from paired fermions. We define a mean frequency shift by the sum rules, and show that it is proportional to the square of BCS pairing gap. The discrepancy between the mean shift and the peak frequency shift observed in experiment for the condensed phase lies in the broad width of the rf spectrum function.
In this paper we present an overview of radio frequency (RF) spectroscopy in the atomic Fermi superfluids. An ultimate goal is to suggest new directions in the cold gas research agenda from the condensed matter perspective.Our focus is on the experimental and theoretical literature of cold gases and photoemission spectroscopy of the cuprates particularly as it pertains to areas of overlap. This paper contains a systematic overview of the theory of RF spectroscopy, both momentum integrated and momentum resolved. We discuss the effects of traps, population imbalance, final state interactions over the entire range of temperatures and compare theory and experiment. We show that this broad range of phenomena can be accomodated within the BCS-Leggett description of BCS-BEC crossover and that this scheme also captures some of the central observations in photoemission experiments in the cuprates. In this last context, we note that the key themes which have emerged in cuprate photoemission studies involve characterization of the fermionic self energy, of the pseudogap and of the effects of superconducting coherence (in passing from above to below the superfluid transition temperature, TcT_cTc​).These issues have a counterpart in the cold Fermi gases and it would be most useful in future to use these atomic systems to address these and the more sweeping question of how to describe that anomalous superfluid phase which forms in the presence of a normal state excitation gap.