Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Boston studies in the philosophy of science

The Controversy between Schrödinger and the Göttingen-Copenhagen Physicists in the 1950’s

Michel Bitbol

Published Jan 1, 1996• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/978-94-009-1772-9_1

Related papers

Animadversion on the Quantum Mechanics Annotation of the Copenhagen School in China During 1950s and 1970s

HU Hua-ka

The Copenhagen School that was represented by Bohr and Heisenberg made great contributions to the establishment of Quantum Mechanics. However, the annotation of Quantum Mechanics of the Copenhagen School aroused long-time controversy among many physicists, including Einstein. During 1950s and 1970s, a series of animadversion activities had been developed in China with a particular history background, and Bohr’s Principle of Complementarity and Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle had been repeatedly criticized. The animadversion affected Chinese people’s correct understanding of the Quantum Mechanical Viewpoints of the Copenhagen School, therefore it hampered the development of Quantum Mechanics in China. This article systematically investigates the historical process of the animadversion, analyzes the historical causes of the animadversion, and summarizes the characteristics of these activities.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Erwin Schrödinger’s Position in the Einstein-Bohr Debate

Ulrich Röseberg

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1992•1 citation

A Story Without an Ending: The Quantum Physics Controversy 1950–1970

Olival Freire

Science & Education•Aug 1, 2003•22 citations

Chaos and Indeterminism

Jesse Hobbs

Laplacean determinism remains a popular theory among philosophers and scientists alike, in spite of the fact that the Copenhagen Interpretation of quantum mechanics, with which it is inconsistent, has been around for more than fifty years. There are a number of reasons for its continuing popularity. One, recently articulated by Honderich, is that there are too many possible interpretations of quantum mechanics, and the subject is too controversial even among physicists to be an adequate basis for overturning determinism. Nevertheless, quantum mechanics is an enormously successful theory, considering the quantity and variety of its predictions which have been verified under conditions never dreamt of by its originators; and the Copenhagen Interpretation is the only widely accepted interpretation of it. Although a hidden variable theory consistent with the results of quantum mechanics is not impossible, one of its major advocates admits that it is highly speculative, and far from adequately developed. Yet such a theory would be needed to reconcile Laplacean determinism with quantum mechanics; most of the controversies alluded to by Honderich are irrelevant.

Canadian Journal of Philosophy•Jun 1, 1991•105 citations

Quantum Mechanics and Multi-World Interpretation—A Dialogue between a Cat and Everett

Tiantian Yang, Hailiang Che

Quantum mechanics is an important understanding of modern physics, and one of China’s first quantum experimental satellites is also launched in July of this year, but around the confusion about the interpretation of quantum philosophy, yet there has not a perfect answer today. “Schrodinger’s cat” is put forward by the Austrian physicist Schrodinger in 1935; it is a name for a quantum state, its production not only has its specific physical incentives, but also has the corresponding philosophical roots. Everett, the author of the “multi-world explanation”, explains that the explanation of “multi-world explanation” to the quantum philosophy from the point of view of Schrodinger’s cat in physics has not only helped us understand the nature of quantum mechanics, to solve the philosophical controversy that has revolved around quantum mechanics, but also deepened our understanding of multi-world interpretations where physics and philosophy blend. This article starts with the famous experiment Schrödinger’s Cat and then tells us two well-known answers to quantum mechanics in the history, that is the Copenhagen Interpretation and the Multi-World Interpretation. By comparing the differences between the two, it emphasis on the correctness of the “multi-world interpretation”. Then it can deepen our understanding of the concept of “Schrodinger’s Cat”, “Quantum Mechanics” and multi-world interpretations.

Open Journal of Social Sciences•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

Erwin Schrödinger And The Philosophy of The Physicists

Erhard Scheibe

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1992•0 citations
The Copenhagen School that was represented by Bohr and Heisenberg made great contributions to the establishment of Quantum Mechanics. However, the annotation of Quantum Mechanics of the Copenhagen School aroused long-time controversy among many physicists, including Einstein. During 1950s and 1970s, a series of animadversion activities had been developed in China with a particular history background, and Bohr’s Principle of Complementarity and Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle had been repeatedly criticized. The animadversion affected Chinese people’s correct understanding of the Quantum Mechanical Viewpoints of the Copenhagen School, therefore it hampered the development of Quantum Mechanics in China. This article systematically investigates the historical process of the animadversion, analyzes the historical causes of the animadversion, and summarizes the characteristics of these activities.
Laplacean determinism remains a popular theory among philosophers and scientists alike, in spite of the fact that the Copenhagen Interpretation of quantum mechanics, with which it is inconsistent, has been around for more than fifty years. There are a number of reasons for its continuing popularity. One, recently articulated by Honderich, is that there are too many possible interpretations of quantum mechanics, and the subject is too controversial even among physicists to be an adequate basis for overturning determinism. Nevertheless, quantum mechanics is an enormously successful theory, considering the quantity and variety of its predictions which have been verified under conditions never dreamt of by its originators; and the Copenhagen Interpretation is the only widely accepted interpretation of it. Although a hidden variable theory consistent with the results of quantum mechanics is not impossible, one of its major advocates admits that it is highly speculative, and far from adequately developed. Yet such a theory would be needed to reconcile Laplacean determinism with quantum mechanics; most of the controversies alluded to by Honderich are irrelevant.
Quantum mechanics is an important understanding of modern physics, and one of China’s first quantum experimental satellites is also launched in July of this year, but around the confusion about the interpretation of quantum philosophy, yet there has not a perfect answer today. “Schrodinger’s cat” is put forward by the Austrian physicist Schrodinger in 1935; it is a name for a quantum state, its production not only has its specific physical incentives, but also has the corresponding philosophical roots. Everett, the author of the “multi-world explanation”, explains that the explanation of “multi-world explanation” to the quantum philosophy from the point of view of Schrodinger’s cat in physics has not only helped us understand the nature of quantum mechanics, to solve the philosophical controversy that has revolved around quantum mechanics, but also deepened our understanding of multi-world interpretations where physics and philosophy blend. This article starts with the famous experiment Schrödinger’s Cat and then tells us two well-known answers to quantum mechanics in the history, that is the Copenhagen Interpretation and the Multi-World Interpretation. By comparing the differences between the two, it emphasis on the correctness of the “multi-world interpretation”. Then it can deepen our understanding of the concept of “Schrodinger’s Cat”, “Quantum Mechanics” and multi-world interpretations.