In this thesis I discuss the nature of ‘measurement’ in quantum theory. ‘Measurement’ is associated with several different processes: the gradual imprinting of information about one system onto another, which is well understood; the collapse of the wavefunction, which is ill-defined and troublesome; and finally, the means by which inferences about unknown experimental parameters are made. I present a theoretical extension to an experimental proposal from Leggett and Garg, who suggested that the quantum-or-classical reality of a macroscopic system may be probed with successive measurements arrayed in time. The extension allows for a finite level of imperfection in the protocol, and makes use of Leggett’s ‘null result’ measurement scheme. I present the results of an experiment conducted in Oxford that, up to certain loopholes, defies a non-quantum interpretation of the dynamics of phosphorous nuclei embedded in silicon. I also present the theory of statistical parameter estimation, and discover that a recent trend to employ time symmetric ‘postselected’ measurements offers no true advantage over standard methods. The technique, known as weak-value amplification, combines a weak transfer of quantum information from system to meter with conditional data rejection, to surprising effect. The Fisher information is a powerful tool for evaluating the performance of any parameter estimation model, and it reveals the technique to be worse than ordinary, preselected only measurements. That this is true despite the presence of noise (including magnetic field fluctuations causing deco- herence, poor resolution detection, and random displacements), casts serious doubt on the utility of the method.
In this thesis I discuss the nature of ‘measurement’ in quantum theory. ‘Measurement’ is associated with several different processes: the gradual imprinting of information about one system onto another, which is well understood; the collapse of the wavefunction, which is ill-defined and troublesome; and finally, the means by which inferences about unknown experimental parameters are made. I present a theoretical extension to an experimental proposal from Leggett and Garg, who suggested that the quantum-or-classical reality of a macroscopic system may be probed with successive measurements arrayed in time. The extension allows for a finite level of imperfection in the protocol, and makes use of Leggett’s ‘null result’ measurement scheme. I present the results of an experiment conducted in Oxford that, up to certain loopholes, defies a non-quantum interpretation of the dynamics of phosphorous nuclei embedded in silicon. I also present the theory of statistical parameter estimation, and discover that a recent trend to employ time symmetric ‘postselected’ measurements offers no true advantage over standard methods. The technique, known as weak-value amplification, combines a weak transfer of quantum information from system to meter with conditional data rejection, to surprising effect. The Fisher information is a powerful tool for evaluating the performance of any parameter estimation model, and it reveals the technique to be worse than ordinary, preselected only measurements. That this is true despite the presence of noise (including magnetic field fluctuations causing deco- herence, poor resolution detection, and random displacements), casts serious doubt on the utility of the method.
This is a theoretical thesis in the area of quantum measurement theory. Due to the extensive breadth of this field we choose to narrow our focus to examine a particular problem - the quantum Zeno effect (defined below). Quantum measurement theory is introduced in Chap. 1, using the terminology of effects and operations. This approach allows an operational definition of such terms as a state vector, an ensemble, and a measurement device (for instance), and a consideration of interactions between quantum systems and inaccurate measurement devices. We further introduce the quantum trajectories approach to consider the evolution of an individual quantum system subject to measurement. The quantum Zeno effect is introduced in Chap. 2. Any quantum treatment of a measurement interaction must consider the measurement backaction onto the measured system and this backaction will disrupt the free evolution of the system. The quantum Zeno effect occurs in the strong measurement limit where the measurement backaction totally freezes the evolution of the system, thus rendering the measurement useless. The effect is introduced via projective measurements of two level systems subject to measurement of level populations. At this stage we are able to discuss the main questions addressed by this thesis, and present its structure in Chap. 2. We then develop a new measurement model for the interaction between a system and a measurement device in Chap. 3. Our motivation in doing this is to better model the usual laboratory meter, and in our approach the meter dynamics are such that it relaxes towards an appropriate readout of the system parameter of interest. The irreducible quantum noise of the meter introduces fluctuations that drive the stochastic dynamical collapse of the system wavefunction. In our model, the measured system dynamics (if treated selectively) are described by a stochastic, nonlinear Schroedinger equation. A double well system subject to position measurement provides a natural first application for this model. This is done in Chap. 4 where we monitor the coherent tunnelling of a particle from one well to the other. The advantage afforded by considering this system is that it displays differing regimes where the measurement observable (position) is approximated as possessing either, respectively, a continuous or a discrete eigenvalue structure. Thus, we use this one model to explore the quantum Zeno effect in both measurement regimes. The above treatment is of a theoretical measurement model. In Chap. 5 we turn to consider a recent experimental test of the quantum Zeno effect which examined the dynamics of a two level atom subject to pulsed measurements of atomic level populations. We treat a slightly modified experiment in a fully continuous measurement regime. By first unravelling the optical Bloch equations, and second, using the quantum trajectories approach we demonstrate the existence of certain measurement regimes where there is a quantum Zeno effect, and other regimes where no measurement of the atomic populations is being effected at all. Through these results we demonstrate the importance of making a full analysis of the system-detector interaction before any conclusions can be made. In the remainder of the thesis we propose further possible tests of the quantum Zeno effect. In Chap. 6 the evolution of a Rydberg atom exchanging one photon with a single cavity mode subject to measurement is examined. The measurement is made by monitoring the photon number occupancy of the cavity mode using a beam of Rydberg atoms configured so as to perform phase sensitive detection. In the limit of frequent monitoring we show that the free oscillation of the atomic inversion is disrupted, and the atom is trapped close to its initial state. This is the quantum Zeno effect. In Chap. 7 we realize the Zeno effect on two possible systems. We consider first, a two level Jaynes-Cumming atom interacting with a cavity mode, and second, two electromagnetic modes configured as a multi-level parametric frequency converter. These systems interact with another cavity mode via a quadratic coupling system based on four wave mixing, and constructed to be a quantum nondemolition measurement of the photon number. This mode is damped to the environment thus effecting a measurement of the system populations. Again we show that this interaction, can manifest the quantum Zeno effect. Our explicit modelling of the system-detector interaction enables us to show how the effect depends on the resolution time of the detector. Finally, we consider a proposed measurement of the square of the quadrature phase of an electromagnetic mode in Chap. 8. Here, a three mode interaction mediated by a second order nonlinear susceptibility is considered. One mode, the pump, is prepared in a feedback generated photon number state to give insight into the role of pump noise. The other two modes are treated as an angular momentum system, and we show that photon counting on the two mode rotation system effects the above mentioned measurement. In addition, this measurement provides a direct measure of the second order squeezing of the signal. With that we finish our investigation of the quantum Zeno effect using the techniques of quantum measurement theory. However, in the epilogue [Chap. 9] we note that no thesis in quantum measurement theory would be complete without some consideration of the ``meaning attributed to the theory. In the epilogue we take a novel historical approach and examine the method by which metaphysical theories are formed to draw conclusions regarding quantum metaphysics.
The quantum theory of measurement has been with us since quantum mechanics was invented. It has recently been invigorated, partly due to the increasing interest in quantum information science. In this partly pedagogical review I attempt to give a self-contained overview of non-relativistic quantum theory of measurement expressed in density matrix formalism. I will not dwell on the applications in quantum information theory; it is well covered by several books in that field. The focus is instead on applications to the theory of weak measurement, as developed by Aharonov and collaborators. Their development of weak measurement combined with what they call post-selection - judiciously choosing not only the initial state of a system (pre-selection) but also its final state - has received much attention recently. Not the least has it opened up new, fruitful experimental vistas, like novel approaches to amplification. But the approach has also attached to it some air of mystery. I will attempt to demystify it by showing that (almost) all results can be derived in a straight-forward way from conventional quantum mechanics. Among other things, I develop the formalism not only to first order but also to second order in the weak interaction responsible for the measurement. I apply it to the so called Leggett-Garg inequalities, also known as Bell inequalities in time. I also give an outline, even if rough, of some of the ingenious experiments that the work by Aharonov and collaborators has inspired. As an application of weak measurement, not related to the approach by Aharonov and collaborators, the formalism also allows me to derive the master equation for the density matrix of an open system in interaction with an environment. An issue that remains in the weak measurement plus post-selection approach is the interpretation of the so called weak value of an observable. Is it a bona fide property of the system considered? I have no definite answer to this question; I shall only exhibit the consequences of the proposed interpretation. Quanta 2013; 2: 18–49.
The weak-value amplification is extensively considered in precision metrology in order to achieve a higher sensitivity. Despite the practical benefits in amplifying small physical quantities, its metrological advantage still arouses a broad debate due to the low postselection probability of success. In this paper, by employing the quantum Fisher information metric, we show that the precision of estimating an unknown parameter can be improved by introducing a precoupling process with properly chosen interaction operators. We point out this result is credible for both real and imaginary weak values. By tracking the meter wave functions, we find this enhancement of estimation precision comes from a precoupling induced modulation of the meter wave function, thus the most sensitive regime with respect to the parameter is reached. In addition, the estimation error is investigated by considering the difference between the theoretical and estimated value. The analysis suggests that this kind of error can be effectively suppressed by averaging the estimations resulted from different initial meter states. These results are finally illustrated by an exact numerical simulation where the advantages of our proposal are displayed by the comparison to the standard weak-value amplification scheme.
A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it. – Max Planck, 1936 The only way quantum theory allows us to interact with quantum systems is via quantum processes. Thus, the only way we can extract information about the state of a quantum system is to apply some non-deterministic process and observe which of the branches happened. For that reason, many people refer to the act of applying certain quantum processes as measurement and sometimes even as observation . A consequence of this unfortunate terminology is that one of the most touted ‘strange’ features of quantum theory is often misleadingly described as follows: ‘The mere act of observing a quantum state changes it.’ ‘Misleading’, since the concept of measurement described in the previous paragraph is far from the passive concept of observation familiar from our macroscopic world, but is rather a non-trivial process that will almost always drastically affect the quantum state. So, the mysterious aspect of quantum theory is not that ‘observation’ alters the quantum state but, rather, that it is impossible, even in principle, to ‘observe’ a quantum system in the classical sense. Given this fundamental restriction on how we can extract information from a quantum system, what can we learn about that system by means of a quantum process? The answer is, in fact, very little! First, performing a particular measurement could, for the vast majority of quantum states, yield any outcome i with a non-zero probability. In that case, obtaining an outcome i doesn't tell us much about what the state of the system was. Second, we say ‘was’, because the measurement will moreover irreversibly change the state according to the outcome. So rather than revealing the state of a system, a quantum measurement typically erases that state from history! Nonetheless, these quantum measurements are crucial to quantum theory since they constitute the only interface between us, in our classical world, and the quantum world. The great insight of the quantum computing community is that the non-deterministic changes induced by these quantum measurements are not a nuisance, but rather an extremely useful resource.
In this article we present an experimental proposal for the estimation of an optomechanical parameter in the presence of noise. The estimation is based on the technique of weak-value amplification which can enlarge the radiation pressure effect of a single photon on a mechanical oscillator. In our setup we show that the weak-value amplification technique is preferable for the estimation over a method that relies on a strong measurement with postselection because the first method does not require a good prior knowledge of the parameter we wish to estimate, while both strategies reach the same level of precision from a Fisher information perspective. In the presence of strongly correlated noise, the weak-value amplification method is preferable, from a Fisher information perspective, than a standard measurement strategy that does not employ postselection and that is affected by the same type of noise.
While quantum measurement remains the central philosophical conundrum of quantum mechanics, it has recently grown into a respectable (read: experimental!) discipline as well. New perspectives on measurement have grown out of new technological possibilities, but also out of attempts to design systems for quantum information processing. I will present several examples of how our current ideas on quantum measurement go far beyond the usual textbook treatments, using examples from our entangled-photon and ultracold-atoms laboratories in Toronto. Topics will be drawn from weak measurement, 'interaction-free' measurement, Hardy's Paradox, measurement-induced quantum logic, and techniques for controlling and characterizing the coherence of quantum systems. The moral of the story will be that there are many different kinds of measurement strategies, with their own advantages and disadvantages; and that some things we have been taught not to even think about can actually be measured in a certain sense.