Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Basic equivalence between classical and quantum physics including probability aspects and nonphysics (further extended)

F Ghaboussi

Published Nov 14, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.13140/rg.2.2.10376.79364

Related papers

The wave-function is real but nonphysical: A view from counterfactual quantum cryptography

Akshata Shenoy H., R. Srikanth

Counterfactual quantum cryptography (CQC) is used here as a tool to assess the status of the quantum state: Is it real/ontic (an objective state of Nature) or epistemic (a state of the observer's knowledge)? In contrast to recent approaches to wave function ontology, that are based on realist models of quantum theory, here we recast the question as a problem of communication between a sender (Bob), who uses interaction-free measurements, and a receiver (Alice), who observes an interference pattern in a Mach-Zehnder set-up. An advantage of our approach is that it allows us to define the concept of "physical", apart from "real". In instances of counterfactual quantum communication, reality is ascribed to the interaction-freely measured wave function ($ψ$) because Alice deterministically infers Bob's measurement. On the other hand, $ψ$ does not correspond to the physical transmission of a particle because it produced no detection on Bob's apparatus. We therefore conclude that the wave function in this case (and by extension, generally) is real, but not physical. Characteristically for classical phenomena, the reality and physicality of objects are equivalent, whereas for quantum phenomena, the former is strictly weaker. As a concrete application of this idea, the nonphysical reality of the wavefunction is shown to be the basic nonclassical phenomenon that underlies the security of CQC.

arXiv:1311.7127•Nov 27, 2013•6 citations

Probability in Classical and Quantum Physics

Sachkov Vi

Studies in logic and the foundations of mathematics•Jan 1, 1982•1 citation

Decision Procedures in Quantum Mechanics

Paul A. Benioff

The results of an earlier paper on finite and infinite sequences of measurements are here extended to include decision procedures. It is shown that with each decision procedure Q there is uniquely associated a probability operator measure OQ, which gives the statistical properties of Q. None, some, or all of the paths of Q can be infinitely long. A result of this association is that there are two methods of measuring the probability that carrying out Q on a system in state ρ gives an outcome sequence in some set F. A remarkable aspect of this equivalence is that the purely physical operation of one method is equivalent to, or can replace, the physical operation and mathematical decision procedure of the other method.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jun 1, 1972•35 citations

From probabilities to quantum and classical mechanics

Lubomír Skála, V. Kapsa

Physica E Low-dimensional Systems and Nanostructures•Jul 2, 2005•9 citations

Geneza prawdopodobieństwa

Michał Heller

After briefly reviewing classical and quantum aspects of probability, basic concepts of the noncommutative calculus of probability (called also free calculus of probability) and its possible application to model the fundamental level of physics are presented. It is shown that the pair (M, *), where M is a (noncommutative) von Neumann algebra, and a state on it, is both a dynamical object and a probabilistic object. In this way, dynamics and probability can be unified in noncommutative geometry. Some philosophical consequences of such an approach are indicated.

Philosophical Problems in Science (Zagadnienia Filozoficzne w Nauce)•Jun 7, 2006•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics and Classical Probability Theory

Vladimir I. Man’ko

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1997•13 citations
Counterfactual quantum cryptography (CQC) is used here as a tool to assess the status of the quantum state: Is it real/ontic (an objective state of Nature) or epistemic (a state of the observer's knowledge)? In contrast to recent approaches to wave function ontology, that are based on realist models of quantum theory, here we recast the question as a problem of communication between a sender (Bob), who uses interaction-free measurements, and a receiver (Alice), who observes an interference pattern in a Mach-Zehnder set-up. An advantage of our approach is that it allows us to define the concept of "physical", apart from "real". In instances of counterfactual quantum communication, reality is ascribed to the interaction-freely measured wave function (ψψψ) because Alice deterministically infers Bob's measurement. On the other hand, ψψψ does not correspond to the physical transmission of a particle because it produced no detection on Bob's apparatus. We therefore conclude that the wave function in this case (and by extension, generally) is real, but not physical. Characteristically for classical phenomena, the reality and physicality of objects are equivalent, whereas for quantum phenomena, the former is strictly weaker. As a concrete application of this idea, the nonphysical reality of the wavefunction is shown to be the basic nonclassical phenomenon that underlies the security of CQC.
The results of an earlier paper on finite and infinite sequences of measurements are here extended to include decision procedures. It is shown that with each decision procedure Q there is uniquely associated a probability operator measure OQ, which gives the statistical properties of Q. None, some, or all of the paths of Q can be infinitely long. A result of this association is that there are two methods of measuring the probability that carrying out Q on a system in state ρ gives an outcome sequence in some set F. A remarkable aspect of this equivalence is that the purely physical operation of one method is equivalent to, or can replace, the physical operation and mathematical decision procedure of the other method.
After briefly reviewing classical and quantum aspects of probability, basic concepts of the noncommutative calculus of probability (called also free calculus of probability) and its possible application to model the fundamental level of physics are presented. It is shown that the pair (M, *), where M is a (noncommutative) von Neumann algebra, and a state on it, is both a dynamical object and a probabilistic object. In this way, dynamics and probability can be unified in noncommutative geometry. Some philosophical consequences of such an approach are indicated.