Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Double-Slit Experiment as an Inverse Problem: What Detection Records Can and Cannot Reveal

Kacheong Yeung, Lex Yeung

Published Nov 14, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A detector screen records where particles arrive, but it does not by itself determine the physical process that produced those arrivals. Using the double-slit experiment and related two-path interferometers, this paper treats that distinction as an inverse problem: what can a specified experimental record establish, and what additional observation or intervention would be needed to establish more? The analysis distinguishes representational nonuniqueness, exact observational equivalence, unstable structural inference, nuisance nonidentifiability, and protocol\-dependent discrimination. Examples include aperture diffraction, homometric masks, path markers, fluctuating phases, time\-ordered detections, and trial-matched phase references. A central model-specific result shows that even the complete ordered screen record can fail to distinguish marker attenuation from unresolved phase jitter, determining only a product of the two under the stated assumptions. Additional records or controlled interventions can sometimes break such equivalences, but only when the competing models predict different responses. The paper does not propose a new diffraction law or infer unobserved particle histories. Its purpose is operational: to identify what follows from a given detection record, what does not, and what new experiment could distinguish explanations that the existing record leaves equivalent.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24226079

Related papers

The Double-Slit Experiment Reinterpreted: Matter-Wave Propagation and the Physical Mechanism of Quantum Interference

YOUNG HO GOH

The double-slit experiment has stood for a century as the paradigmatic demonstration of quantum superposition: the standard interpretation holds that a particle passes through both slits simultaneously, existing in a superposition of two spatially separated states. This paper proposes a physically distinct alternative: the particle's matter wave — a real physical wave propagating through space in accordance with de Broglie's relation λ = h/p — passes through both slits, while the particle itself (matter) remains in an undetermined state until a constructive interference maximum is formed at the detection screen. The particle does not simultaneously occupy two locations; the wave does. This distinction eliminates the need for superposition as an ontological commitment while fully reproducing the observed interference pattern. We further show that the disappearance of the interference pattern upon which-path measurement is explained without invoking wavefunction collapse: the measurement interaction redirects the matter wave to a single-slit geometry, eliminating the two-wave interference condition. Three experimentally testable predictions distinguish this framework from the standard interpretation: (1) weak-measurement trajectory reconstruction should reveal single particle paths inconsistent with simultaneous two-slit passage; (2) diffraction fringe spacing should depend on the mass density of the slit material, because denser slit edges generate a steeper refractive-index gradient for the matter wave; (3) the fringe pattern should exhibit a density-dependent phase shift measurable with current matter-wave interferometry technology. This reinterpretation requires no new mathematical formalism — the Schrödinger equation and Born's rule are retained — but replaces the ontological claim of simultaneous multi-location existence with the physically consistent picture of matter-wave propagation through an undetermined-state particle.

•Apr 22, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Interference from a Single Physical History: A Single-History Record Framework for Slit Experiments

Tong Wang

Quantum interference is conventionally formulated using complex amplitudes associated with quantum alternatives or through Feynman’s path integral over possible trajectories. This article investigates a different ontology, the Single-History Record Framework (SHRF), in which a physical system has one realized history together with a record space of phase-carrying contributions associated with that history. Observable amplitudes are obtained through History-Record Summation (HRS). SHRF deliberately retains established quantum ingredients wherever possible, including complex-amplitude addition, the Born probability rule, propagation phases, and marker-state overlaps. These mathematical devices are used as predictive rules and do not imply that multiple physical histories, paths, or marker outcomes coexist.A preliminary model is developed in which rapidly varying regions of record space largely cancel while coherent record bands provide the dominant detector amplitude. For double-slit geometry, two aperture-selected bands give A(x)≈H_A (x)+H_B (x).With the established propagation phases H_A=Ce^(ikL_A ),H_B=Ce^(ikL_B ),SHRF recovers the textbook far-field fringe spacing Δx=λD/d.The same formal structure is applied to single-slit diffraction, multiple slits, which-path marking, partial distinguishability, and quantum-eraser subensembles. In particular, marker records modify the interference term through the standard overlap factor ⟨M_A∣M_B⟩,without requiring a physical superposition of marker records. The present model assumes rather than derives its phase law, record-space measure, and Born rule. It is therefore a recovery-oriented consistency construction and ontological reinterpretation, not an independent replacement for standard quantum mechanics.

•Aug 27, 2026•0 citations

Double-Slit Admissible Probability

Nenad Đukanović

This work presents a self-contained reconstruction of the double-slit experiment under the Đukanović Theory of Everything, the Quantum of the Fundamental Asymmetry, and Admissible Probability. It begins by retaining the complete ordinary-quantum two-path and path-marker mathematics: arbitrary path imbalance, mixed marker states, calibrated visibility, detector response, path distinguishability, complementarity, finite-sample inference, and operational identifiability. It then separates that operational layer from a second problem: what distinguishes reversible correlation, decoherence, or amplified evidence from the constitutive event by which one admissible possibility acquires fixed historical truth-status. The central record architecture consists of source authentication, quotient-stable record identity, temporal descendant continuity, and whole-domain non-recoverability within a declared Null-Speed-bounded audit domain. This packet can reject reversible or unauthenticated false positives and can conditionally certify persistent record-capable morphology. It does not derive an exact outcome selector, collapse rate, or microscopic execution law.

•Jul 30, 2026•0 citations

Can the double-slit experiment distinguish between quantum interpretations?

Ali Ayatollah Rafsanjani, MohammadJavad Kazemi, Alireza Bahrampour +1 more

Abstract Despite the astonishing successes of quantum mechanics, due to some fundamental problems such as the measurement problem and quantum arrival time problem, the predictions of the theory are in some cases not quite clear and unique. Especially, there are various predictions for the joint spatiotemporal distribution of particle detection events on a screen, which are derived from different formulations and interpretations of the quantum theory. Although the differences are typically small, we show that these predictions can be experimentally distinguished by a proposed unconventional double-slit configuration, which is realizable using present-day single-atom interferometry. This experiment would enrich our understanding of the foundations of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2301.02641•Communications Physics•Jul 31, 2023•15 citations

Detection statistics in a double-double-slit experiment

MohammadJavad Kazemi, Vahid Hosseinzadeh

In this paper, we analyze the statistics of detection data in a general double-double-slit experiment. The two particles are detected at random times which are not equal in general and because we do not have any constraint on the distances of left and right screens from their slits and the ratio they can be detected in completely different timescales. As the detection of the first particle leads to collapse of the wave function, there is no a straightforward and agreed-upon method to study this problem in the orthodox formalism which lacks a clear prediction of these random events and therefore the quantum state afterward. This is not the case in the Bohmian framework which we implement in this paper, and we can predict the system up to the end of experiment. The main result is the joint distribution of detection data including the arrival time and position of the particles on left and right screens. As one of the main consequences, we see that although the joint spatial distribution can be affected by a change to the relative location of screens, the marginals on each side remain intact, compatible with signal locality. At the end, we see how this result is very sensitive to quantum equilibrium conditions.

arXiv:2208.01325•Physical Review A•Jan 31, 2023•11 citations

Beyond “Duality”: A Counterfactual Model-Testing Perspective on Interpretative Schemes in the Single-Quantum Double-Slit Experiment

Marco Giliberti, Luisa Lovisetti

The single-quantum double-slit experiment is often taught through a compact narrative of localised detections, interference, and wave–particle duality that may conceal weak explanatory coordination. This qualitative-dominant mixed-methods study investigates how students and teachers distinguish description of the experimental outcome from recognition of its interpretative problem. The framework uses counterfactual model testing as an analytical lens for examining model–evidence coordination, together with epistemic framing, ontological flexibility, and multimodal representation. The study draws on 54 individually coded questionnaires from the “100 QM” course and six follow-up interviews. In this corpus, 48 participants (88.9%) adequately described the double-slit outcome, whereas 26 (48.1%) also articulated, in response to the questionnaire prompts, a specific explanatory tension or unresolved relation concerning the experimental outcome. Recurrent explanations invoked definite trajectories, literal wave–particle transformations, physicalised probability waves, appeals to self-interference, and anthropocentric observation. The findings indicate that descriptive familiarity and technical terminology do not by themselves ensure interpretative recognition. These findings reinforce the distinction between descriptive familiarity and interpretative understanding, showing that understanding the double-slit experiment involves not only descriptive adequacy, but also the recognition and examination of the explanatory tensions that emerge when proposed models are compared with the experimental evidence.

Education Sciences•Oct 17, 2026•0 citations
A detector screen records where particles arrive, but it does not by itself determine the physical process that produced those arrivals. Using the double-slit experiment and related two-path interferometers, this paper treats that distinction as an inverse problem: what can a specified experimental record establish, and what additional observation or intervention would be needed to establish more? The analysis distinguishes representational nonuniqueness, exact observational equivalence, unstable structural inference, nuisance nonidentifiability, and protocol-dependent discrimination. Examples include aperture diffraction, homometric masks, path markers, fluctuating phases, time-ordered detections, and trial-matched phase references. A central model-specific result shows that even the complete ordered screen record can fail to distinguish marker attenuation from unresolved phase jitter, determining only a product of the two under the stated assumptions. Additional records or controlled interventions can sometimes break such equivalences, but only when the competing models predict different responses. The paper does not propose a new diffraction law or infer unobserved particle histories. Its purpose is operational: to identify what follows from a given detection record, what does not, and what new experiment could distinguish explanations that the existing record leaves equivalent.
The double-slit experiment has stood for a century as the paradigmatic demonstration of quantum superposition: the standard interpretation holds that a particle passes through both slits simultaneously, existing in a superposition of two spatially separated states. This paper proposes a physically distinct alternative: the particle's matter wave — a real physical wave propagating through space in accordance with de Broglie's relation λ = h/p — passes through both slits, while the particle itself (matter) remains in an undetermined state until a constructive interference maximum is formed at the detection screen. The particle does not simultaneously occupy two locations; the wave does. This distinction eliminates the need for superposition as an ontological commitment while fully reproducing the observed interference pattern. We further show that the disappearance of the interference pattern upon which-path measurement is explained without invoking wavefunction collapse: the measurement interaction redirects the matter wave to a single-slit geometry, eliminating the two-wave interference condition. Three experimentally testable predictions distinguish this framework from the standard interpretation: (1) weak-measurement trajectory reconstruction should reveal single particle paths inconsistent with simultaneous two-slit passage; (2) diffraction fringe spacing should depend on the mass density of the slit material, because denser slit edges generate a steeper refractive-index gradient for the matter wave; (3) the fringe pattern should exhibit a density-dependent phase shift measurable with current matter-wave interferometry technology. This reinterpretation requires no new mathematical formalism — the Schrödinger equation and Born's rule are retained — but replaces the ontological claim of simultaneous multi-location existence with the physically consistent picture of matter-wave propagation through an undetermined-state particle.
Quantum interference is conventionally formulated using complex amplitudes associated with quantum alternatives or through Feynman’s path integral over possible trajectories. This article investigates a different ontology, the Single-History Record Framework (SHRF), in which a physical system has one realized history together with a record space of phase-carrying contributions associated with that history. Observable amplitudes are obtained through History-Record Summation (HRS). SHRF deliberately retains established quantum ingredients wherever possible, including complex-amplitude addition, the Born probability rule, propagation phases, and marker-state overlaps. These mathematical devices are used as predictive rules and do not imply that multiple physical histories, paths, or marker outcomes coexist.A preliminary model is developed in which rapidly varying regions of record space largely cancel while coherent record bands provide the dominant detector amplitude. For double-slit geometry, two aperture-selected bands give A(x)≈H_A (x)+H_B (x).With the established propagation phases H_A=Ce^(ikL_A ),H_B=Ce^(ikL_B ),SHRF recovers the textbook far-field fringe spacing Δx=λD/d.The same formal structure is applied to single-slit diffraction, multiple slits, which-path marking, partial distinguishability, and quantum-eraser subensembles. In particular, marker records modify the interference term through the standard overlap factor ⟨M_A∣M_B⟩,without requiring a physical superposition of marker records. The present model assumes rather than derives its phase law, record-space measure, and Born rule. It is therefore a recovery-oriented consistency construction and ontological reinterpretation, not an independent replacement for standard quantum mechanics.
This work presents a self-contained reconstruction of the double-slit experiment under the Đukanović Theory of Everything, the Quantum of the Fundamental Asymmetry, and Admissible Probability. It begins by retaining the complete ordinary-quantum two-path and path-marker mathematics: arbitrary path imbalance, mixed marker states, calibrated visibility, detector response, path distinguishability, complementarity, finite-sample inference, and operational identifiability. It then separates that operational layer from a second problem: what distinguishes reversible correlation, decoherence, or amplified evidence from the constitutive event by which one admissible possibility acquires fixed historical truth-status. The central record architecture consists of source authentication, quotient-stable record identity, temporal descendant continuity, and whole-domain non-recoverability within a declared Null-Speed-bounded audit domain. This packet can reject reversible or unauthenticated false positives and can conditionally certify persistent record-capable morphology. It does not derive an exact outcome selector, collapse rate, or microscopic execution law.
Abstract Despite the astonishing successes of quantum mechanics, due to some fundamental problems such as the measurement problem and quantum arrival time problem, the predictions of the theory are in some cases not quite clear and unique. Especially, there are various predictions for the joint spatiotemporal distribution of particle detection events on a screen, which are derived from different formulations and interpretations of the quantum theory. Although the differences are typically small, we show that these predictions can be experimentally distinguished by a proposed unconventional double-slit configuration, which is realizable using present-day single-atom interferometry. This experiment would enrich our understanding of the foundations of quantum mechanics.
In this paper, we analyze the statistics of detection data in a general double-double-slit experiment. The two particles are detected at random times which are not equal in general and because we do not have any constraint on the distances of left and right screens from their slits and the ratio they can be detected in completely different timescales. As the detection of the first particle leads to collapse of the wave function, there is no a straightforward and agreed-upon method to study this problem in the orthodox formalism which lacks a clear prediction of these random events and therefore the quantum state afterward. This is not the case in the Bohmian framework which we implement in this paper, and we can predict the system up to the end of experiment. The main result is the joint distribution of detection data including the arrival time and position of the particles on left and right screens. As one of the main consequences, we see that although the joint spatial distribution can be affected by a change to the relative location of screens, the marginals on each side remain intact, compatible with signal locality. At the end, we see how this result is very sensitive to quantum equilibrium conditions.
The single-quantum double-slit experiment is often taught through a compact narrative of localised detections, interference, and wave–particle duality that may conceal weak explanatory coordination. This qualitative-dominant mixed-methods study investigates how students and teachers distinguish description of the experimental outcome from recognition of its interpretative problem. The framework uses counterfactual model testing as an analytical lens for examining model–evidence coordination, together with epistemic framing, ontological flexibility, and multimodal representation. The study draws on 54 individually coded questionnaires from the “100 QM” course and six follow-up interviews. In this corpus, 48 participants (88.9%) adequately described the double-slit outcome, whereas 26 (48.1%) also articulated, in response to the questionnaire prompts, a specific explanatory tension or unresolved relation concerning the experimental outcome. Recurrent explanations invoked definite trajectories, literal wave–particle transformations, physicalised probability waves, appeals to self-interference, and anthropocentric observation. The findings indicate that descriptive familiarity and technical terminology do not by themselves ensure interpretative recognition. These findings reinforce the distinction between descriptive familiarity and interpretative understanding, showing that understanding the double-slit experiment involves not only descriptive adequacy, but also the recognition and examination of the explanatory tensions that emerge when proposed models are compared with the experimental evidence.