Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Critical Rotation for the First Vortex in Trapped Condensates and Helium Buckets

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 12, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The first quantised vortex enters a rotating superfluid only above a critical angular velocity set by the container size and the vortex core size. This paper computes that threshold for a trapped rubidium-87 condensate and for a centimetre-scale helium-4 bucket, compares the two, and examines the shear associated with the single-vortex state against the torsion ceiling. The condensate threshold is 0.22 hertz, comfortably inside trap rotation capabilities, while the helium bucket threshold is 0.46 millihertz, a ratio between the thresholds of 4.90e+02 driven almost entirely by the container-size term. In both systems a single central vortex is a gentle flow state whose gradients are far below those of dense arrays and enormously below the fundamental ceiling; the threshold is a finite-size energetics result, not a bound effect. The calculation is performed from stated geometry, not measured.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24155373

Related papers

Quantised Vortex Densities in Rotating Condensates and the Shear Bound

William Alexander Aldred

A rotating superfluid mimics solid-body rotation through an array of quantised vortices whose areal density is fixed by the Feynman relation. This paper computes vortex densities, intervortex spacings and the associated gradient scales for rotating rubidium-87 condensates and rotating helium-4 across experimentally accessible rotation rates, and compares them with the shear ceiling from the spin-torsion bound. Rubidium-87 rotating at 10 hertz carries 2.74e+10 vortices per square metre with a spacing of 6.0 micrometres; helium-4 at 10 radians per second carries 2.01e+08 per square metre with a spacing of 70.60 micrometres. The largest gradient associated with the array, set by the inverse spacing, stands at a ratio of 1.23e-11 to the torsion ceiling. Vortex arrays therefore reproduce the kinematics of rotation at densities of circulation that remain vastly below any fundamental shear limit, and the practical ceiling on vortex density is set by core overlap and condensate depletion, not by the bound. This study is computed from stated assumptions, not measured.

•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

Landau Critical Velocities in Superfluid Helium and Condensates Compared with the Bound Velocity Scale

William Alexander Aldred

The Landau criterion sets the speed above which a superfluid flowing past an obstacle can create excitations and dissipate. This paper evaluates that critical velocity from the roton spectrum of helium-4 and from the phonon spectrum of dilute condensates, and compares both with the relativistic velocity scale that accompanies the density and shear bounds. For helium-4 the roton minimum yields a Landau velocity of 59.6 metres per second, a ratio of 1.99e-07 to the speed of light; for rubidium-87 at laboratory density the phonon critical velocity is 1.89 millimetres per second, a ratio of 6.30e-12. Measured critical velocities in channels fall below the helium Landau value because vortices nucleate first, which widens rather than narrows the gap to the bound scale. Superfluid dissipation therefore begins for reasons internal to the excitation spectrum, orders of magnitude before any bound-related velocity could be approached. The analysis is computed from published spectra, not measured here.

•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

Rotating trapped Bose-Einstein condensates

Alexander L. Fetter

Trapped Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) differ considerably from the standard textbook example of a uniform Bose gas. In an isotropic harmonic potential V(r) = ½Mω2 r 2, the single-particle ground state introduces a new intrinsic scale of length [the ground-state size d = √ℏ/(Mω)] and energy [the ground-state energy E 0 = $$ \frac{3} {2} $$ ℏω]. When the trap rotates at a low angular velocity, the behavior of a single vortex illustrates the crucial role of discrete quantized vorticity. For more rapid rotation, the condensate contains a vortex array. The resulting centrifugal forces expand the condensate radially and shrink it axially; thus, the condensate becomes effectively two dimensional. If the external rotation speed approaches the frequency of the radial harmonic confining potential, the condensate enters the “lowest-Landau-level” regime, and a simple description again becomes possible. Eventually, the system is predicted to make a quantum phase transition to a highly correlated state analogous to the fractional quantum Hall states of electrons in a strong magnetic field.

Laser Physics•Jan 1, 2008•152 citations

Rotating trapped Bose-Einstein condensates

Alexander L. Fetter, Rocio R. Jauregui, J. Récamier +1 more

I review free and trapped Bose‐Einstein condensates (BECs) [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. In an isotropic harmonic potential V(r) = 12Mω2r2, the single‐particle ground state introduces a new intrinsic scale of length [the ground‐state size d = ℏ/(Mω)] and energy [the ground‐state energy E0 = 32ℏω]. When the trap rotates [6, 7, 8], there is a critical angular velocity for the appearance of one or a few quantized vortices. For more rapid rotation [9, 10, 11, 12, 13] the condensate contains a vortex array. The resulting centrifugal forces expand the condensate radially and shrink it axially; thus the condensate becomes effectively two‐dimensional. If the external rotation speed approaches the frequency of the radial harmonic confining potential, the condensate enters the “lowest‐Landau‐level” regime, and a simple description again becomes possible [14, 15]. Eventually, the system is predicted to make a quantum phase transition to a highly correlated state analogous to the fractional quantum Hall states of electrons in a strong magnetic field [16, 17, 18, 19, 20].

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2008•78 citations

Quantum Turbulence: Vinen Vortex-Line Densities in Helium and Condensates Against the Shear Bound

William Alexander Aldred

A dense, random tangle of quantised vortices — quantum turbulence — is the most strongly sheared state a superfluid ordinarily reaches. This paper assembles representative vortex-line densities for helium-4 counterflow turbulence and for turbulent condensates, converts them to intervortex spacings and gradient scales, and compares the strongest case with the torsion shear ceiling. Strong helium counterflow reaches a line density of 1e+11 per square metre, corresponding to a spacing of 3.16 micrometres and a gradient ratio of 2.34e-11 to the ceiling; moderate counterflow gives a spacing of 31.6 micrometres. Even the turbulent state, in which the flow is nothing but vortex cores and their induced velocities, remains orders of magnitude below the fundamental shear scale, and its dynamics are governed by reconnections and Kelvin waves within classical-like cascade physics. The line densities are taken from the published turbulence record and converted here, not measured.

•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

Critical rotational speeds for superfluids in homogeneous traps

Michele Correggi, F. Pinsker, Nicolas Rougerie +1 more

We present an asymptotic analysis of the effects of rapid rotation on the ground state properties of a superfluid confined in a two-dimensional trap. The trapping potential is assumed to be radial and homogeneous of degree larger than two in addition to a quadratic term. Three critical rotational velocities are identified, marking, respectively, the first appearance of vortices, the creation of a “hole” of low density within a vortex lattice, and the emergence of a giant vortex state free of vortices in the bulk. These phenomena have previously been established rigorously for a “flat” trap with fixed boundary but the “soft” traps considered in the present paper exhibit some significant differences, in particular the giant vortex regime, that necessitate a new approach. These differences concern both the shape of the bulk profile and the size of vortices relative to the width of the annulus where the bulk of the superfluid resides. Close to the giant vortex transition the profile is of Thomas-Fermi type in “flat” traps, whereas it is gaussian for soft traps, and the “last” vortices to survive in the bulk before the giant vortex transition are small relative to the width of the annulus in the former case but of comparable size in the latter.

arXiv:1108.5429•Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 14, 2012•34 citations
The first quantised vortex enters a rotating superfluid only above a critical angular velocity set by the container size and the vortex core size. This paper computes that threshold for a trapped rubidium-87 condensate and for a centimetre-scale helium-4 bucket, compares the two, and examines the shear associated with the single-vortex state against the torsion ceiling. The condensate threshold is 0.22 hertz, comfortably inside trap rotation capabilities, while the helium bucket threshold is 0.46 millihertz, a ratio between the thresholds of 4.90e+02 driven almost entirely by the container-size term. In both systems a single central vortex is a gentle flow state whose gradients are far below those of dense arrays and enormously below the fundamental ceiling; the threshold is a finite-size energetics result, not a bound effect. The calculation is performed from stated geometry, not measured.
A rotating superfluid mimics solid-body rotation through an array of quantised vortices whose areal density is fixed by the Feynman relation. This paper computes vortex densities, intervortex spacings and the associated gradient scales for rotating rubidium-87 condensates and rotating helium-4 across experimentally accessible rotation rates, and compares them with the shear ceiling from the spin-torsion bound. Rubidium-87 rotating at 10 hertz carries 2.74e+10 vortices per square metre with a spacing of 6.0 micrometres; helium-4 at 10 radians per second carries 2.01e+08 per square metre with a spacing of 70.60 micrometres. The largest gradient associated with the array, set by the inverse spacing, stands at a ratio of 1.23e-11 to the torsion ceiling. Vortex arrays therefore reproduce the kinematics of rotation at densities of circulation that remain vastly below any fundamental shear limit, and the practical ceiling on vortex density is set by core overlap and condensate depletion, not by the bound. This study is computed from stated assumptions, not measured.
The Landau criterion sets the speed above which a superfluid flowing past an obstacle can create excitations and dissipate. This paper evaluates that critical velocity from the roton spectrum of helium-4 and from the phonon spectrum of dilute condensates, and compares both with the relativistic velocity scale that accompanies the density and shear bounds. For helium-4 the roton minimum yields a Landau velocity of 59.6 metres per second, a ratio of 1.99e-07 to the speed of light; for rubidium-87 at laboratory density the phonon critical velocity is 1.89 millimetres per second, a ratio of 6.30e-12. Measured critical velocities in channels fall below the helium Landau value because vortices nucleate first, which widens rather than narrows the gap to the bound scale. Superfluid dissipation therefore begins for reasons internal to the excitation spectrum, orders of magnitude before any bound-related velocity could be approached. The analysis is computed from published spectra, not measured here.
Trapped Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) differ considerably from the standard textbook example of a uniform Bose gas. In an isotropic harmonic potential V(r) = ½Mω2 r 2, the single-particle ground state introduces a new intrinsic scale of length [the ground-state size d = √ℏ/(Mω)] and energy [the ground-state energy E 0 = 32 \frac{3} {2} 23​ ℏω]. When the trap rotates at a low angular velocity, the behavior of a single vortex illustrates the crucial role of discrete quantized vorticity. For more rapid rotation, the condensate contains a vortex array. The resulting centrifugal forces expand the condensate radially and shrink it axially; thus, the condensate becomes effectively two dimensional. If the external rotation speed approaches the frequency of the radial harmonic confining potential, the condensate enters the “lowest-Landau-level” regime, and a simple description again becomes possible. Eventually, the system is predicted to make a quantum phase transition to a highly correlated state analogous to the fractional quantum Hall states of electrons in a strong magnetic field.
I review free and trapped Bose‐Einstein condensates (BECs) [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. In an isotropic harmonic potential V(r) = 12Mω2r2, the single‐particle ground state introduces a new intrinsic scale of length [the ground‐state size d = ℏ/(Mω)] and energy [the ground‐state energy E0 = 32ℏω]. When the trap rotates [6, 7, 8], there is a critical angular velocity for the appearance of one or a few quantized vortices. For more rapid rotation [9, 10, 11, 12, 13] the condensate contains a vortex array. The resulting centrifugal forces expand the condensate radially and shrink it axially; thus the condensate becomes effectively two‐dimensional. If the external rotation speed approaches the frequency of the radial harmonic confining potential, the condensate enters the “lowest‐Landau‐level” regime, and a simple description again becomes possible [14, 15]. Eventually, the system is predicted to make a quantum phase transition to a highly correlated state analogous to the fractional quantum Hall states of electrons in a strong magnetic field [16, 17, 18, 19, 20].
A dense, random tangle of quantised vortices — quantum turbulence — is the most strongly sheared state a superfluid ordinarily reaches. This paper assembles representative vortex-line densities for helium-4 counterflow turbulence and for turbulent condensates, converts them to intervortex spacings and gradient scales, and compares the strongest case with the torsion shear ceiling. Strong helium counterflow reaches a line density of 1e+11 per square metre, corresponding to a spacing of 3.16 micrometres and a gradient ratio of 2.34e-11 to the ceiling; moderate counterflow gives a spacing of 31.6 micrometres. Even the turbulent state, in which the flow is nothing but vortex cores and their induced velocities, remains orders of magnitude below the fundamental shear scale, and its dynamics are governed by reconnections and Kelvin waves within classical-like cascade physics. The line densities are taken from the published turbulence record and converted here, not measured.
We present an asymptotic analysis of the effects of rapid rotation on the ground state properties of a superfluid confined in a two-dimensional trap. The trapping potential is assumed to be radial and homogeneous of degree larger than two in addition to a quadratic term. Three critical rotational velocities are identified, marking, respectively, the first appearance of vortices, the creation of a “hole” of low density within a vortex lattice, and the emergence of a giant vortex state free of vortices in the bulk. These phenomena have previously been established rigorously for a “flat” trap with fixed boundary but the “soft” traps considered in the present paper exhibit some significant differences, in particular the giant vortex regime, that necessitate a new approach. These differences concern both the shape of the bulk profile and the size of vortices relative to the width of the annulus where the bulk of the superfluid resides. Close to the giant vortex transition the profile is of Thomas-Fermi type in “flat” traps, whereas it is gaussian for soft traps, and the “last” vortices to survive in the bulk before the giant vortex transition are small relative to the width of the annulus in the former case but of comparable size in the latter.